Why Wrestling Has A MAJOR Problem Right Now

AEW, WWE, NJPW: has pro wrestling reached critical mass?

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

There's a certain malaise in the air in wrestling right now.

Advertisement

WWE is WWE; the promotion mostly exists in a constant state of repetitive churn, with its rematch-heavy approach, and the drab, meandering approach Vince McMahon takes to booking has been brought into focus by the strange and possibly under-reported Roman Reigns story. His part-time schedule has compounded the stasis WWE finds itself in more often than not. WWE has long since evolved into a content factory, but in a post-Fiend world, it's barely even perversely entertaining. Since WrestleMania - the first night of which was incredible - WWE with the exception of the stellar Cody Rhodes Vs. Seth Rollins programme has failed to generate any buzz whatsoever. This is also a promotion that buried Sasha Banks and Naomi for letting the fans down and failing to appear as scheduled for a RAW main event, only to promote a tournament that then didn't end up happening. WWE summarily and unprofessionally failed to book the series of matches, as advertised, even though they had far more than eight hours to construct the brackets. The promotion just doesn't want to do anything, even if they've already committed to that thing.

AEW is in a lull.

Advertisement

Some of it is driven by misfortune, some of it is invited. Forbidden Door already feels like a convoluted, politicised compromise to get several wrestlers on the show between matches that have been announced and teased. This follows Double Or Nothing, a pay-per-view that also felt like an overlong compromise to keep the various stars happy. AEW remains the best promotion on the planet at its peak, but it feels overstuffed yet somehow weightless. The rate of excess is alarming, too.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

Remember the first Steel Cage match, between Cody and Wardlow, and how massive it felt?

Advertisement

It was the first time AEW had promoted that gimmick attraction, and it was built towards incredibly well. This week, Road Rager is essentially AEW Uncensored. Before Jeff Hardy's DUI arrest, AEW was cycling through ladder matches at a near one-per-month WWE-adjacent rate.

Impact Wrestling has effectively become the home of some excellent under-the-radar matches, but then, where can't you see great wrestling these days? For all its countless faults, even WWE has had a superb year in the ring in places. The Japanese landscape remains plagued by clap crowds, the "it is what it is" latitude extended towards which is harder to excuse now that fans have returned to arenas in the States for almost a full year. Dominion was a great one match show, but some of the dreck on that undercard indicated that NJPW can't rely on simply waiting for the noise to return. Gedo has peaked as a booker.

Advertisement

Ring Of Honor exists only to impose on AEW right now. Where the independent scene was once a thriving cult hotbed for discerning taste-making crowds, the place to watch the hottest new talent progress, AEW has seized this mantle, with its bold and revolutionary approach to debuting new acts with minimal TV experience. The scene remains in decent health, for completionists, but by the time a talent generates serious buzz, they've already appeared on Dynamite. As progressive and convenient as this directive is, it still de-incentivises catching up on the indies.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

PWG isn't what it was as a result. Its style has been subsumed by the mainstream, and its platform isn't as necessary as it once was for an emerging talent to make their name; by the time Daniel Garcia won the 2022 Battle of Los Angeles, he was already a Dynamite regular.

Advertisement

The problem is that this is just one of several things AEW seeks to accomplish; then again, is much of this actually a problem?

All of this can be interpreted as a euphoric net positive for the industry, at least as it relates to AEW. The company is a far-reaching fan service delivery system.

Advertisement

But the fact is that wrestling by its very format schedule is heavily, heavily reliant - perhaps even dependent - upon what's next. There is no off-season. Wrestling never stops, but must also incentivise the audience to keep watching every single week.

In a "post"-pandemic era of renewed competition, it feels as if wrestling has eaten itself in a mad rush to compete. On one side of the mainstream, at least. A strange schism has appeared between WWE and AEW.

Advertisement

WWE has realised that it needn't really do anything to remain #1. They have released countless talents, many of whom have subsequently signed to AEW and made little appreciable difference to company growth, which has happened, but wasn't driven by WWE ripping up its talent-hoarding philosophy. WWE is in a position where it can indulge itself, with minimal, repetitive and aimless content and an ingrained refusal to sign actual name wrestling talent.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)

Advertisement
WWE.com

This is how they've arrived at the risible NXT 2.0. They no longer have to try nor pretend to be something they simply don't want to be. They can just win with an overexposed skeleton crew without a World title as a narrative through line. SmackDown in particular has been piss-poor, zero effort sludge since Roman went on hiatus.

Advertisement

AEW meanwhile has tried everything to compete - almost to the point of parody. The promotion, and this is great but only to a point, has honed in on and struck off every last wish on the list. They've convinced CM Punk to return, Bryan Danielson to jump. The promotion's entire M.O. is to deliver everything WWE didn't want really fancy doing for much of the 21st century - stables, blood, surprise debuts! - but recently, it seems as though Tony Khan is trying too hard to make up for lost time. He is inundating his audience with so much ostensibly exciting stuff that it no longer scans as exciting.

In short, it's very easy to feel spoiled by wrestling in what is effectively the post-everything era.

Advertisement

In general, in a bygone era, there was far more room to dream. Prior to the Kenny Omega Vs. Kazuchika Okada series, it never once felt like wrestling had peaked in the ring. It does now. The wildest and most improbable fantasy booking imaginable has been realised with AEW signing CM Punk and Steve Austin returning to WWE for one more match. The once impossibly alluring notion of the "jump", the shock debut, has been thoroughly normalised.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

When NJPW's Will Ospreay turned up on AEW Dynamite, an absolutely unreal prospect in 2019, it just felt like the normal course of business.

Advertisement

In a senseless overload, Khan had already made parody the device by bringing in W. Morrissey, Big Damo and Jonnny Elite a month before the Forbidden Door pay-per-view. The timing was as preposterous as the notion that these three particular performers were truly worthy of the "Holy sh*t!" chant. The idea of an AEW/NJPW cross-promoted show was scintillating a year ago; now, the mere term 'Forbidden Door' has developed a familiarity incongruous to what it is meant to convey. The roster in general is overstuffed, so much so that Hangman Page's World title reign, the pivotal moment in the company's history, the moment everything built towards, was just another segment on the show. People clamoured for WarGames in the 2000s and early 2010s. Modern wrestling has already cannibalised the great lost gimmick match, the match we never thought we'd see again. What's left to look forward to?

All professional wrestling needs is a great story, a great source of conflict, and two performers gifted and creative enough to pull it off. WWE, a promotion buried ritually by the people who can still be arsed, did precisely this at Hell In A Cell - and despite a legendary, gutsy display on the part of the babyface, the heel was cheered for bringing out a table.

Advertisement

Still, there's no reason why, for example, a returning CM Punk and Kenny Omega can't tell a gripping, intriguing six month storyline using only the most basic elements: a grudge, a microphone, and two pairs of boots. The issue now is that AEW has made this sort of thing difficult for itself, or at least more difficult than it needs to be. The exhausting amount of good things has been normalised; a great programme is going to struggle without some violent shortcut or surprise angle or other.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

It felt, across 2018 and 2019, that wrestling was entering a new golden age. The in-ring standard had been redefined. Renewed competition reminded the fanbase of what wrestling should have always been. The thrill of Vince McMahon's weird self-imposed rules being broken was palpable.

Advertisement

Now, through sheer, undisciplined excess, it no longer feels that way. AEW being uneven shouldn't impact other promotions, but it does. AEW is a victim of its own success, and so is wrestling on the whole; because it is so phenomenal at its wide-ranging best, it effectively made other promotions redundant. There was no need for an ROH. Impact did nothing that AEW didn't do, and better. AEW took everything great about modern pro wrestling, tethered it to the best of what was once an unrecoverable past, and presented it in a brisk, appointment TV package. AEW became the new home of pro wrestling, its custodian almost, and now that it's in a lull, it feels like all wrestling is.

There's still good wrestling everywhere - STARDOM, DDT and Dragon Gate are doing much to energise their fanbases - but this was the case in 2004, which was the sh*ttest year in recorded history. We're nowhere near that point, but picture the eve of All Out 2022 and the dreamlike state fans were locked in.

Advertisement

Didn't you think it would be better by now?

Has wrestling eaten itself in a fit of greed having been starved for too long?

Advertisement