Wrestling's BIG DUMB IDIOTS Who Thought They Were COOL! ?

What does it mean to be cool in pro wrestling? These big dumb idiots thought they had the answer...

By Michael Hamflett /

There can’t be a single personality trait, attitude, vibe or skill as powerful in life as the ability to be cool.

Advertisement

You can’t teach it, because if you could, everybody would take the course, master it, and then it wouldn’t be “it” anymore.

There are no rules to being it, otherwise everybody would follow them, become it, and then it couldn’t be “it” ever again.

There’s no promise of being it forever, not warning if you’re no longer about to be it, otherwise everybody would figure it out and stop it being “it” forever.

And the biggest twist of all? The coolest people care the least about the fact that they are exponentially cooler than you or I could ever hope to be in our wildest dreams. Now apply that inordinately difficult set of circumstances to an uber-competitive locker room of an industry built on the ability to market yourself as the most appealing character in this or any world. And not always a particularly cool industry at that.

Being cool is a tool so few possess but so many pretend to. It defines lives and careers and transforms perceptions forever. It's little wonder you risk looking a big dumb idiot when you miss the mark.

Anyway, enough of looking in the mirror...

10. Logan Paul

Logan Paul knows how to thrive in this broken version of the world.

Advertisement

From courting controversy as a YouTube star just enough to pivot into multiple contact spots whilst also not-but-kind-of-definitely marketing his drinks to kids in order to create a have/have not culture amongst the purest in our society, he's never met a situation he couldn't monetise by hook or crook.

It's this attitude that brought him and WWE together, and enough big performances in big matches made his United States Championship victory a move that was smarter than it was stupid. He's filmed wherever he goes and the belt's there too. As it was at UFC 295 when he sat cageside shouting out Dominick (sic) Mysterio across the TKO divide. They're kindred spirits at the moment, and when the moment predictably went viral, Paul's position within the company was yet again vindicated.

He's entitled, he's a big dumb idiot, and he's athletic enough to achieve his goals. He's Shane McMahon before time noped him.

Speaking of which...

9. Shane McMahon

The "Shane McMahon: wrestler" character used to make so much sense.

Advertisement

Go back and look at when he first fluked his way to becoming European Champion at X-Pac's expense. A virtuoso pro wrestler had lost to the spoilt little rich kid with ample help from his heel friends, and was due an almighty battering in the rematch. That story was a trojan horse for Triple H turning on DX at WrestleMania XV, but 'The Money' took the promised beating all the same.

The win he got that night might have done something to his McMahonian Ego - he ended up retiring that title, and went on to fancy his chances against the likes of The Big Show and Kane in the years that followed. He did at least jump from high places, but even that was a case of diminishing returns after an insane SummerSlam 2000 original that holds up to this day.

Post-2016, the joke just wasn't funny anymore. McMahon had reason to think he was cool after the pop and buzz his return generated, but matches against The Undertaker and AJ Styles positioned the chancer as a man that could apparently subsume the skills of his opponent. It was neither believable nor entertaining, and the power apparently ran out in 2023 - McMahon couldn't copy The Miz' near-perfect injury record, blowing his quad on a leapfrog literally as Michael Cole was mid-sentence gushing about how he could still go.

8. Jimmy Uso

At last, an in-character one of these!

Advertisement

Jimmy Uso, as of 2023, might have morphed into the best version of himself. Or second best, because the clown heel chewing scenery in SmackDown segments couldn't have existed without a babyface come-up a year earlier.

A SummerSlam 2023 heel turn on brother Jey was initially rendered nonsensical when the company seemed to retcon everything he'd stood up for in the first place, but his increasingly stupid attempts to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with Roman Reigns has helped give the 'Tribal Chief' gimmick one last lease of life before Cody Rhodes stubs it out at WrestleMania 40.

His on-the-spot attitude changes, his mimicking of Reigns' actions in his absence and his hilarious lack of self-awareness have given Solo Sikoa and Paul Heyman new nonsense to cope with, and WWE an inexplicably possible brother Vs brother match on the 'Grandest Stage' next year.

In 2023, The Usos made history teaming together in the main event. A year later, and they might do the same against each other.

7. Stone Cold Steve Austin (2003)

It brings nobody any joy to talk about Stone Cold Steve Austin as if he wasn't the coolest character in wrestling history. But it's a walk in the park compared to what it felt like to live through it.

Advertisement

Austin has spoken extensively about his post-retirement years as a period where he couldn't/wouldn't get wrestling "out of his system", but watching him try on television with his Raw GM/Sheriff power trip era was bleak.

From relentlessly battering heels without ever eating any sort of real response, to doing a pale imitation of his most iconic rivalry opposite a game Eric Bischoff, the ATV-riding Austin was his original, industry-altering persona placed through a content production meat grinder.

As a wrestler at the peak of the boom, Austin often did well to mask his insecurities at the top of the card by being undeniable in the spot. As a bit part player simply too big to be marginalised, he looked and felt like he was getting in the way of WWE as a brand ever moving onwards and upwards from their post-Attitude Era decline.

6. Hollywood Hulk Hogan

There’s a miserable November 1998 Nitro segment in which Hollywood Hulk Hogan spends an eternity banging on about his supposedly real presidential aspirations, all so he can make the same crass gags about interns and extend a ludicrous publicity stunt he’d kicked off in response to Jesse Ventura gaining actual political power in Minnesota.

Advertisement

'The Hulkster' was in opposite land for more than just White House-related reasons. This egotistical nonsense had dated quicker than the original Hulkamania run and was just another victim of the weekly television churn. Every novelty had worn off, and it became clearer and clearer why so many people were changing the channel.

The aforementioned segment goes head-to-head with the post-Survivor Series: Deadly Game edition of Raw featuring Steve Austin challenging WWE Champion The Rock for his newly-won title, by the way.

Everybody leans on the fingerpoke of doom as The Moment, but WCW was booking a minimum of one of those a week for the better part of two years.

5. Macho Man Randy Savage (1999)

Randy Savage was maybe the coolest man alive in the 1980s. Both a tonic to the bombast of Hulk Hogan and somehow fifty times more bombastic than ‘The Hulkster’ himself, Savage was a psycho in sequins and nobody could even get close to mirroring his genuinely magnificent idiosyncrasies. He encapsulated the preposterous aspiration of the era, and yet never once felt destined to become a relic of the day.

Advertisement

The Macho Man as we knew him was forever timeless. The Macho Man of 1999 was dated before he arrived.

Believing the trick to modernising his act was creating a 90s retrograde version of it, Savage became a jacked-up dudebro clad in black leather as shiny as his oiled-up (and bigger than ever) biceps. His in-ring work had been ultra-valuable to WCW’s upper midcard for three years, but his zip and dynamism were sacrificed for the size.

It also didn’t help that the company had one ludicrously oversized nutcase already, and Scott Steiner (ironically aping much of the Hogan stuff that had been lifted from Billy Graham) was a study in contrast to how an industry icon really lost his cool.

4. Seth Rollins (2019)

30 years on from Randy Savage losing his cool once and for all, a man that'd later be compared to him did the same.

Advertisement

It took Seth Rollins a long time to find the magic formula as a WWE singles star, especially after his first run at it was terminated by an unfortunate injury when he was on the crest of a wave. As the heel Champion in 2015, he was well on the way, but it took until 2022 and the complete transformation into a Seth Freakin Rollins gimmick that actually made sense (sort of) for him to be booked and received as the star he fought to become.

In 2019, it looked like he was never going to make it.

Fresh off of daring to suggest that possibly the worst ever version of WWE was the "Best pro wrestling on the planet. Period" and getting into an embarrassing spat with Will Ospreay, he tried to big league Brock Lesnar by mocking him in a segment right out of the Vince McMahon schoolyard mockery playbook. It only widened the gap between both men, and took a miracle in-ring job by both Champion and Challenger to make a SummerSlam title change feel believable.

3. Triple H

Triple H was many, many things over a 25+ year WWE career, but "cool" was almost never one of them.

Advertisement

Perhaps he was still carrying the scars of the cartoonish blueblood gimmick he was saddled with on his debut, but as soon as he was able to shake it off, he aimed to pivot as far away from it as possible. As both lackey and leader in DX, he pined to be the coolest guy in any room even if everybody's attention was realistically elsewhere. In Evolution, he claimed to be funny, handsome and hard as nails. Likewise in his ludicrous "*ss Kicker" promo that went nose-to-nose with Brock Lesnar and The Undertaker. He's done so much, but it always felt like he pined to be beloved for something slightly more.

Almost never cool because he cracked it precisely one time.

Wrestling without insecurity for perhaps the only time in his career, the period between January 2000 and his May 2001 injury confirmed that he was indeed 'The Game'. A fabulously enjoyable heel, he was so respected that his 2002 Madison Square Garden remains one of the longest and loudest in WWE history.

A leather/denim jacket combo looked destined to age within a month, but it was and is fondly remembered by fans to this day.

2. The Undertaker

The Undertaker absolutely needed the character shift he underwent between 2000-2003, but the ‘American Bad Ass’ (and the rest of his motorbike-adjacent nicknames) was strictly only cool in the smallest of doses before the man himself couldn’t help but do something that undermined the whole facade.

Advertisement

White hot when he returned and Judgment Day 2000 and sent Shane McMahon crashing through a table the following month, he was a big loser rather than ‘Big Evil’ when he gave Kurt Angle absolutely nothing in an unproductive squash at the next pay-per-view.

His unproductive performances during the Invasion highlighted the problem with him being a locker room leader too - the example he was setting was the worst one to follow, and gave license to those below him to do the same. WCW wasn’t the shoot enemy anymore, but “the conscience” of WWE wasn’t gonna let ‘em terk err jerbs.

Morphing into Motorbike Mark was no walk in the park either. Undertaker’s overlong 1999 missive about riding bikes in the desert with the Big Show and killing snakes for shoes was so preposterous that newcomer Chris Jericho infamously couldn’t credibly hold back how bored he was.

But those that don’t learn from their mistakes…

1. Chris Jericho

As a man who makes a point to reimagine his persona every few months can't maintain a perfect hit rate, but the more missteps he makes, the more the evidence piles up that he might too much of a chancer to stay cool. Not least when as recently as 2019, he appeared close to maintaining the "it" factor forever.

Advertisement

When AEW launched, he became everything a lot of people in powerful positions in WWE told him he simply couldn't be. His star power contributed to the brand's instant credibility, his television experience was integral for countless wrestlers who hadn't yet worked in that setting, and as the World Champion of a thriving operation, he was a bona fide and objective draw.

He was also funny, working good-to-great matches, and giving the rub to as many people as he could share the screen with. This was superstar stuff, and as he approached 50, it couldn't have been cooler.

Several years later, and the bloom's gone on and off the rose so many times that arguing for him will make you a fool and arguing against him risks positioning you as a liar. He's many, many things, still, but cool can never be one of them again.

Advertisement