Professional wrestling fans are known as one of the most fanatical fanbases there is. The pro wrestling fanbase is not simply limited to the WWE Universe, independent wrestling diehards, and pro wrestlers in-training who dream of one day becoming a part of what they love so much; there is also a virulent strain of fans who search far and wide for what they want and are willing to throw down hundreds, and even sometimes thousands, of dollars in the process. And those dollars aren't being spent on WrestleMania; theyre spending it on toys. Wrestling figure collectors are one of the most dedicated fan bases in the world of pro wrestling, often purchasing every version of ever figure, regardless of how many times a toy company regurgitates the same wrestlers action figure, without any changes, and releases it as part of a new series line. Not only that, they're also known to purchase multiple figures: one to keep mint, and another to display. They're hardcore, but for good reason - after all, there are specific wrestling figures out there that are worth hundreds of dollars. Wrestling figure collectors are a tight community where you know someone who has that rare figure, or they know someone who has that rare figure, or that rare figure is just urban legend and doesnt exist. Unfortunately, unlike other big toy franchises such as Star Wars or Barbie, the pro wrestling figure aftermarket isnt as organized. There is no official price guide bible, and it's understandably hard to track value. So, what wrestling figures are considered rare? How do you know when you come across a wrestling figure thats possibly worth a fortune? Now, thanks in part to a few private collectors and Jac Sabboth who runs a growing chain of stores, The Wrestling Universe, that deals almost exclusively in collectable pro wrestling action figures, a list of those such figures is available. From Wrestling Superstars, the WWEs very first line of action figures, by LJN to WCW first action figure line from Galoob, from the popular WWE action figures series from well known toy companies like Hasbro and Jakks Pacific to wrestling figures you never knew existed brought to you by companies youve probably never even heard of like Remco and Popy these are the rarest wrestling figures that are worth an eye-watering amount of money.
Honourable Mentions
Before we get to the list itself, there is a small list of incredibly rare figures that are *possibly* worth an absolute fortune but did not fit the criteria to make the main list - either because they were discontinued, limited editions released only in certain territories (or exclusively kept off the main market) or because they're a different thing entirely, like the wrestling ring sets above. Though the main list is populated only with figures, it would be remiss to ignore the market for accessories, like the Battle Royal variants above, which each go for around $1000 - $1200 each.
Rhythm And Blues Greg Valentine (Hasbro)
Considered to be one of, if not the, rarest wrestling figure of all time, Hasbros Greg Valentine decked in Rhythm and Blues gear was first seen in a ToysRUs ad for the WWF Hasbro line in the March 1991 edition of WWF Magazine. The figure was never released, apparently because the Rhythm and Blues tag team of Honky Tonk Man and Greg The Hammer Valentine broke up just months before the ad went out. The Honky Tonk Man figure was eventually released, but Greg Valentine no longer had the same gimmick, so this particular version of his figure was scrapped. While various other unreleased wrestling figure prototypes spanning from LJN to the current Mattel line have eventually found their way into collectors' collections, this figure never even made its existence known to the public outside of that 1991 ad, until recently when a single Greg Valentine Rhythm and Blues Hasbro prototype was put up for sale. Current WWE superstar, and wrestling memorabilia collector himself, Zack Ryder bid $12,000 for the figure, though the figure currently remains unsold with a $55,000 asking price.
The British Bulldogs: Davey Boy Smith And Dynamite Kid Single Packs MOC (LJN)
The figures in this LJN tag team 2-pack set were also released on single cards or individually packed, and the singled-carded tag team members are considered some of the rarest wrestling collectables ever released, though the only way to prove these figures were the single-carded version would be if they remain Mint On Card. While the box set of the British Bulldogs tag team goes for a couple of hundred dollars, the MOC singled-carded versions, released in limited amounts exclusively in Canada, have an asking price of a couple of thousand.
Classic Superstars ToyFare Employee Only Exclusives (Jakks Pacific)
In the mid-2000s a number of extremely limited run of the Classic Superstars figures were made, in conjunction with Jakks Pacific and ToyFare, for Employees Only, including just 25 Ric Flair in a Rhinestone Robe figures and 20 Roddy Piper with Golden Gloves and though they were not released to the general public they have sold for more than $1500. So, now on to the main list...
15. The American Dream Dusty Rhodes, Series 2 (Hasbro) - $400-$700
Hasbros Dusty Rhodes figure might be one of the most infamous wrestling collectables there is: released in 1991 as part of the second series of Hasbros popular WWF line, this figure was ridiculously hard to find, and at the time, many wrestling fans thought the figure may not have even been released. There are a few different theories thrown out as to why the figure was so hard to find at the time. One is that they simply made fewer units of the Dusty figure because of his perceived lack of popularity at the time in the WWF, while another, more likely, theory is that by the time this series rolled out in 1991, Dusty Rhodes was already on his way out of the WWF and retiring from full time in-ring competition. Loose Hasbro Dusty Rhodes figures can go for up to $50, however a mint on card (MOC) The American Dream Dusty Rhodes on the Series 2 blue card can send you to the pay window, commanding anywhere from $400 to $700+ depending on condition and landing it at #15 on the list.
14. Sgt. Slaughter Mail-away (Hasbro) - $650
In 1987, this an LJN-style Sgt. Slaughter figure was advertised in various wrestling magazines as a mail-away exclusive, and while they usually retain some value thanks to exclusivity, the story behind this particular figure probably adds on the bulk of it. Sgt. Slaughter left the WWE in 1984 when he was easily one of the companys top stars, allegedly over a dispute with Vince McMahon over Sarges likeness being used in the G.I. Joe toy line. Slaughter didnt return to the WWF until 1990 so why would LJN, who owned the rights to the WWF toy line at the time, release this special mail-away Sgt. Slaughter figure in 1987? The simple answer is they didn't: while the figure looks like an LJN figure, even shown standing a top LJNs WWF figures in the advertisement, it was actually made by Hasbro, the company that created G.I. Joe, to capitalize on the popularity of wrestling and G.I. Joe. The figure is also hard plastic, not rubber like the actual LJN figures. The Sgt. Slaughter figure did not come in branded card packaging and arrived in a mailing box, with the figure wrapped in plastic bag, but if you mailed away for the Sgt. Slaughter figure, kept that mailing box and the original plastic, you could net just over $650 for it today.
13. Limited Run ToyFare Exclusive Classic Superstars (Jakks Pacific) $450-$800
The WWE Classic Superstars line of figures from Jakks Pacific are easily the most valuable of the Jakks line of toys, and some figures can go for as much as a few hundred dollars depending on their scarcity with the ToyFare Exclusive line the most valuable Classic Superstars figures. These figures, limited to 100 of each, were distributed in conjunction with ToyFare, though they were available to purchase for the public, and some of the rarest figures on the line was the WWE Classic Superstars Glow in the Dark The Undertaker of which only 100 were made in 2005 and which can collect anywhere between $500 to $800. An Ultimate Warrior Classic Superstars ToyFare exclusive, also limited to 100, can go for $800 at auction. One of the coolest figures in the the exclusive ToyFare limited run lineup is the Bloody Funk U Terry Funk Classic Superstars figure, which recently went for $450 MOC. Widely regarded as the greatest wrestling manager of all time, Bobby Heenans ToyFare figure is a collectors favorite: wearing a weasel suite, this limited run of a figure of The Weasel sells in the collectable community for $500.
12. Tiger Mask II (Popy) - $700
When Joey Styles visited The Wrestling Universe store in Queens, NY, he tweeted out a pic of some of the rare wrestling figures lining the stores shelves and gave us an "OH MY GOD!" saying it was the greatest store Ive ever seen wrestling heaven. So when store owner Jac Sabboth tells you about the rarest figure hes probably ever sold, you know it has to be a true collectable. Popy was a Japanese toy manufacturer owned by Bandai that produced a number of toys in the 1980s based on Tiger Mask, a manga and anime series about a professional wrestler. Around the same time New Japan Pro Wrestling licensed the Tiger Mask character to create a real life pro wrestler, and then in 1984, All Japan Pro Wrestling acquired the Tiger Mask rights and gave the gimmick of Tiger Mask II to Mitsuharu Misawa. An interesting fact about this line of figures is that the Tiger Mask II figure is actually based on the Tiger Mask II anime series and not Misawas portrayal of the character, even though both probably factor into the figure's value. Mitsuharu Misawa, a wrestling legend, tragically died in the ring at the age of 49 in 2009, and in response, related merchandise has risen substantially in value, with Tiger Mask figures in the Popy line usually going up to $300, though a variation of the Tiger Mask II figure sold at the grand opening of The Wrestling Universes Massachusetts store for $700.
11. The Undertaker (Hasbro / Funskool) - $800
As one of the biggest names in ever in WWE, The Undertaker has probably had dozens of action figures created spanning various toy series lines, but this particular The Undertaker is considered to be the rarest of them all. Funskool is a joint venture with an Indian corporation and Hasbro to bring Hasbros line of toys to India, though the India-only distributed figures have made their way over to the States over the years, including the WWF Hasbro line. When originally introduced to American collectors, many thought the Funskool line were actually bootlegs due to their extremely thin cardboard packaging, but this feature is now considered a boon to the collector. The Funskool line of WWF figures are rare enough as it is, and because they were actually created in India, separate from the Hasbro U.S. line, there are variations between the two so a true collector can tell the difference. When you add the flimsy slim cardboard backing to the mix, certain MOC WWF Funskool figure can net you up to $500, but this particular Funskool figure, perhaps the rarest figure that exists of the Deadman, MOC in the Red card packaging has sold for as high as $800.
10. WWF Magazine Mail-aways (Hasbro) - $799-$1200
If an unopened Funskool produced version is considered the hardest The Undertaker figure to find, then the Hasbro mail-away The Undertaker should take the title of most coveted. The extremely hard to find mail-away was advertised through WWF Magazine and is nearly identical to the Funskool version, apart from the slightly darker skin-tone and the eyeliner on his lower eyelids. Another WWF magazine mail-away rarity is the Bret Hart mail-away figure. The first Bret Hart figure released in Hasbros Series 4 lineup in 1992 has a pink heart on his gear, but the mail-away Bret Hart has a purple heart on his black tank top. Toy store KB Toys were selling a carded version of the purple heart Bret Hart figure, believed to be UK importsand it proved difficult to spot the difference between the carded purple heart Hitman and and the mail-away but collectors have discovered that the mail-away Bret Hart has a different shade of purple and pink, a pushed back hairline or bald spot on the right side and a different color skin tone. Other collectors just simply refuse to classify a loose purple heart Bret Hart figure as a mail-away, saying due to the manufacturing process every mail-away Bret Hart is different, making it impossible to be sure without the figure still in the unopened plastic bag. Hasbro also released a special Hulk Hogan WWF Magazine mail-away though it's not as hard to find as The Undertaker and Hart figures and sells on the aftermarkets at a price that simply does not make this list. The Undertaker mail-away figure, still in the plastic packaging, has sold on the auction block anywhere from $799 to $1200, while the Bret Hart mail-away, still in the plastic packaging, was last seen picking up as much as $1025.
9. Various LJN WWF Wrestling Superstars Black Card Figures ( LJN / Grand Toys Of Canada) - $800-$1130
The LJN 1989 black card re-release Wrestling Superstars figures, mint on card, are considered to be the most valuable wrestling figures among many collectors, and were distributed by Grand Toys of Canada as LJN had just shut down their toy division. This final line of the LJN style figures consisted of 6 new figures and a slew of re-releases, and exactly which advertised figures were actually released on the 1989 black card is still subject to debate now. Though popular and mass-produced, the MOC black card line still fetches some real value (though loose exceptions like Big Boss Man have commanded $100 alone, and $300 complete with accessories- mint it's $800). Each came with a bio card, though many were packaged wrongly with a Hulk Hogan card, prompting some collectors to pay more for the correct card backing. Big Bossman isnt the only mid-carder of the time to command prices that high. A Honky Tonk Man black card, with his guitar, MOC has been sold for prices ranging from $600 to $1130, while a Demolition Ax black card, MOC, sold recently for around $900. There are certain figures that were advertised as part of the black card release, that still have not seen the light of day. Whether some truly exist or not is still up in the air, but one such figure that many collectors thought was a myth but has surfaced is the Adrian Adonis Wrestling Superstars 89 black card re-release, which was ruled a myth as he had left the WWF and died before it was even released.
8. Hulk Hogan Wrestling Superstars Black Card ( LJN / Grand Toys Of Canada)- $1000
Speaking of the LJN black card figures, not all LJN black card figures are equal, and some have gone for more than most of the rarest of WWF figure series in existence, including this Hulk Hogan figure. Hogan, the face of pro wrestling and one of the biggest WWE stars of all time, was THE man in the business when this figure was released. This white shirt Hulk Hogan figure is part of the re-releases in the final line of LJN figures distributed by Grand Toys of Canada and, MOC, is one of the most sought after Hulk Hogan action figures. Recently, this rare figure was featured on an episode of Toy Hunter this year when Jordan Hembrough was helping Taboo, of the Black Eyed Peas, in his search for LJN WWF wrestling figures for his collection. Jordan ends up meeting with Hulk Hogan and taking a look at the Hulksters own personal collection where he found this figure MOC, which Hogan then sold to him for $700 before he sold it on to Taboo for $1000.
7. AWA Mat Mania (Remco) - $1500
Many wrestling fans are unaware these figures even exist, but the American Wrestling Association wrestling figure line by Remco hit the shelves just before LJNs WWF Classic Superstars did in 1985, making them the first ever line of wrestling figures made for sale in the United States. The Remco line of AWA figures were sold only as sets of 2 or 3 figures. This continued for 3 full series releases as well as various special boxed releases until Series 4 in 1986, the final series in the Remco AWA line. Called Mat Mania, this figure line were the only AWA toys sold on single cards and are easily the most valuable. The AWA Mat Mania line included figures of superstars such as Shawn Michaels, Marty Jannetty, and Ric Flair, and loose figures, if they still come with their original accessories, can go for hundreds of dollars, while MOC figures have sold at auction for as much as $1500.
6. Ultimate Warrior Wrestling Superstars 89 Black Card (LJN / Grand Toys Of Canada) - $800-$2280
The LJN black card Ultimate Warrior figure is another that commands a significant fee, and this one is not a re-release - it is rather the first Ultimate Warrior toy ever made, and as these black card figures released in 1989 were the last of the LJN style figures, this is Warriors only figure in the WWFs first line of toys. Ultimate Warrior memorabilia usually goes for top dollar and anything with his likeness generates higher sale prices than the same product featuring other wrestlers, and given that this is his very first toy that counts doubly. It certainly tops most wrestling figure collector and Ultimate Warrior fans' list of must-have items. Loose Ultimate Warrior LJN figures have been sold for as high as $150, a premium price for a loose figure line known for not holding up outside of its packaging due to chipped off paint, but like all LJN black cards, an unopened figure greatly raises the value. A MOC Ultimate Warrior black card has previously sold for as low as $800 and as much as $2280.
Given how in-demand Ultimate Warrior merchandise is, it's no surprise that exclusive limited run figures the Jakks Pacific Ultimate Warrior Classic Superstars 2004 Toy Fair exclusive - limited to a run of 100 - ranks highly in value. Sometime in the mid-2000s Warrior himself also struck up an exclusive deal with Jakks to make a number of even rarer, extremely limited line of custom Ultimate Warrior figures in partnership with his Ultimate Creations. The line included 3 Deluxe exclusives in the Classic Superstars line: the WCW 1998 Return figure, an OWN: One Warrior Nation figure, and a stylized Marble Finish figure that is also known as the Zombie figure. Only 20 were made of each. An Unmatched Fury Warrior figure with Warrior America gear was also made in a limited run of 20, as well as a Warrior America Ring Giant figure of which there is 25. And finally there is the most limited of all the Ultimate Warrior exclusive Jakks figures, the Limited Edition Classic Superstars Warrior America figure. There were only a total of 5 made of those, and though it is said that Warrior kept a couple himself, these figures were available but only through Ultimate Warriors website. One collector one of the One Warrior Nation limited figures from Warrior himself for $800, another simply bartered with Warrior and traded him a piece of memorabilia Warrior wanted in exchange for a limited figure. In aftermarket terms, one of the Ring Giants sold on public auction for $1225 recently, and that One Warrior Nation figure that was available from Warrior for $800 has sold for $2000 at auction whereas the Unmatched Fury has hit over $2000 at auction, and though the value of the rare 1/5 Warrior America figure remains undisclosed by the collector, he has shared that it was in the 5-figure range.
4. Miss Elizabeth Wrestling Superstars Purple Skirt (LJN) - $1800
LJNs Wrestling Superstars figures were not all men. The one and only women to be transformed into an action figure in WWFs first toy line was the legendary valet and wrestling manager Miss Elizabeth. The Miss Elizabeth figure seems to have been produced with a number of variants: one came with a glossy gold skirt and one with a purple skirt, and there's also a prototype out there wearing a leather skirt. Another variation concerns the figure body itself: one versions seem to be have made out of rubber like all the other figures in the Wrestling Superstars line and another seems to have been made of plastic. There is also a rumored Wrestling Superstars 89 Black Card version of the Miss Elizabeth figure. Collectors have said they rarely found Miss Elizabeth on store shelves, and when it comes to the availability of the Miss Elizabeth figure, the gold skirt wearing figure seem to be much easier to find than the purple skirt wearing one especially when it comes to being in its unopened original packaging. A recent Series 4 MOC purple skirt Miss Elizabeth in perfect condition sold earlier this year for $1800.
3. Hart Foundation: Bret Hart And Jim Neidhart Wrestling Superstars Tag Team Box And Singles (LJN) - $1200-$2025
The LJN tag team box sets are another one of the rarer LJN wrestling figure series. Each set came with 2 figures, a poser, and 2 tag team championship belts: Strike Force, Dream Team, and The Killer Bees make up some of the rarest tag team box sets out there and the few that have sold have gone for around $1000. However, no LJN tag team boxed set is as popular as the Hart Foundation. The Hart Foundation boxed set consists of Bret The Hitman Hart and Jim The Anvil Neidhart and is easily one of the most sought after of all the wrestling figures, spanning any line with an opened box set going for as much as $500, and unopened fetching a minimum of $800. Lees Toy Review, a well respected toy guide, had valued the set at $1200 but two perfect condition MOC sealed boxes have sold this year: one for $1650, another for $2025. Like the British Bulldogs figures from the honorable mentions, LJN tag team figures also go for a high price on single cards as they are sometimes even harder to find than the box set. Both members of the Hart Foundation were released in the Wrestling Superstars Series 4: the Jim Neidhart figure, MOC, has previously sold for $510, while a loose Bret Hart in perfect condition can sell for close to $100, and MOC can land around $750.
2. Macho Man Randy Savage Wrestling Superstars 89 Black Card (LJN / Grand Toys Of Canada) - $4500
Unopened, mint on card, the Wrestling Superstars 89 black card Macho Man Randy Savage is likely the rarest LJN wrestling figure ever made. Many collectors have never even seen a picture of one MOC until they first come across one for sale and the rarity of this figure is best put into perspective by WrestlingFigs.com collector perfectlyrude:
Gem mint 10 MOC the black card Randy is currently in the $4500 ballpark. But if you ever see it listed I'd bet they're gonna be asking double that. I have coveted this very figure my entire childhood and adult life. I keep $5000 in a bank account which I never touch, strictly for the purchase of this figure... if one EVER surfaces.
To give you an even crazier example of how much this Macho Man figure can go for, the poster that comes with it alone has fetched $180. An unopened black card Randy Savage recently went for $2,250 and the card was far from good condition with a number of bends and creases on the card. This figure also had the card error with the Hulk Hogan bio card on the back and not the Macho Man bio card. One can only guess how much a mint, perfect condition black card Macho Man Randy Savage would go for with the correct bio card on the back.
Figure collector or not, many wrestling fans are aware of this figure and how extremely rare it is and that it commanded the highest sold price of any wrestling figure. The Kamala Hasbro figure was released in 1993 as part of the Yellow Card Series 7 line. There was something interesting about the run of Kamala figures. Instead of his trademark moon painted on his belly, there was a yellow star. However, Kamala figures with a moon belly do exist and it is worth a lot. It is believed that no more than 24 of the Kamala moon belly figures are in existence. Many collectors claim to know of no more than 6 that are sitting in private collections, including Kamala's. However many Kamala moon belly Hasbro figures exist, theyre all believed to be part of a run of pre-production carded samples. Did Hasbro or WWF decide to go with a yellow star instead of the moon due to legal issues, being that Kamala himself owns the rights to his gimmick? Was it a factory mistake that was never corrected such as a paint issue? Or was there a problem with the machine printing the moon and they decided to just print the stars not only on his chest but on his stomach too? Some have wondered if the change was made on purpose to create a rare carded action figure, as exclusive variations are big in the toy community. What is known is that a test run was most certainly sent out, as at least one hardcore collector has a Kamala moon belly figure mint on card with a Hasbro Standards tag sticker on the back. These stickered figures were sent out within the company so they could make notes about each particular figures run before they went out with mass production and distribution. The collector who owns this one purchased his from a former Hasbro safety engineer. Just how many Hasbro Kamala moon belly figures that are still out there are a mystery. Did the existing ones exist thanks to Hasbro employees who took them home before they were destroyed? Is it possible these figures made it to store shelves? The figure is certainly complete and the packaging is store ready and the number that are believed to be out there are not all confirmed to have come from Hasbro employees. If you are looking to pick up a Kamala moon belly figure, be wary and avoid loose figures as there are a lot of fakes out there, but then there would be since a MOC, nearly perfect, graded Kamala moon belly figure was sold at the end of 2013 by the well known figure price guide and collectors, Lees Toy Review, for $6,500. Collectors claim to have seen it sold for as low as $3,000 and as much as $10,000, making the Hasbro Kamala moon belly figure easily the rarest, most expensive wrestling figure of all time. Do you have any of these figures? Share your own favourite WWE figures in the comments.