John Cena is, beyond a shadow of a doubt, the most polarizing in-ring performer in WWE history. Depending on your demographic, you either love him unconditionally or hate him unconditionally. With Cena, there seems to be no middle ground. But for those of you who detest the man and shower him with abuse at every opportunity, your vitriol is most likely having the opposite of the intended effect, and heres why:
5. It's Exactly What WWE Wants
John Cena gives the WWE the absolute best of both worlds: hes loved unconditionally as a traditional babyface by women and little kids (and moves boatloads of merchandise as a consequence), and hated unconditionally by grown men and internet marks who revile the very notion of a traditional babyface in the post-Attitude Era. In Cena, the WWE has a single performer who functions both as a face for one group of fans, and a heel (a traditional heel; the kind you boo because you genuinely dislike him) for another group. And besides, the anti-Cena crowd often forgets one of the most elemental rules of professional wrestling: any reaction is a good reaction. Cena gets a massive face pop and massive heel heat every time he walks down the ramp, and its music to the ears of the folks who run the company. The only thing that would cause WWE to re-evaluate the manner in which they use him would be if his introduction caused a reaction of silence or indifference. Pro wrestling history is full of fabulously talented wrestlers who were permanently relegated to the mid-card because they didnt engender much of an audience reaction one way or the other.
4. You Used To Love Him, And You Know It
If you think this statement is inaccurate, go back and watch Wrestlemania 20 the next time you get a chance. John Cena was jerking the curtain in a United States Championship match against the Big Show, and he was arguably more over with the crowd than any wrestler ever has been who had yet to win his first title belt. Throughout the match, the Lets Go Cena chants were absolutely thunderous, and unaccompanied by the now-obligatory Cena Sucks chants to which weve since become accustomed. This was without a doubt the only time in Wrestlemania history that a guy in the opening match got the biggest positive crowd reaction of anybody on the card, which is made all the more remarkable and noteworthy by the fact that Cena was barely one year into his WWE career and had yet to work a main event or win championship gold. After that night at Madison Square Garden, it was a foregone conclusion that Cena would become the face of the company, and in very short order. If you cant stand him today, you shouldnt have cheered him so loudly back in 2004.
3. He's Exactly What WWE Needs In The PG Era, And In Times Of Tragedy
Invariably, when the WWE makes international news headlines, its because something terrible has happened. Whether a wrestler dies tragically, gets arrested, or murders his wife and child before killing himself, the value of an unimpeachably squeaky-clean babyface who can be trotted out for damage-control media appearances cannot be overstated. For evidence of Cenas utility in this regard, look no further than his pitch-perfect appearance on Larry King Live in the wake of the Chris Benoit tragedy. He was respectful, sympathetic, conscientious, and thoughtful, and no one else on the roster could have done the job more effectively. For those of you who wonder why theres never been a John Cena heel turn, this is the number one reason. Cenas detractors are also quick to forget that the PG Era is not the Attitude Era. The WWE experienced a massive downturn in its business fortunes in the mid-2000s, and while it wasnt due to any single factor, it didnt help that the Attitude Era featured a product geared almost exclusively toward younger adults, and when sufficient numbers of those adults got older and lost interest, there were no young kids to replace them. The PG Era has been largely an attempt to correct that damage, and a necessary component of that effort is to have the companys #1 star be as clean-cut and kid-friendly as possible. For all intents and purposes, Hustle, Loyalty, Respect is the 21st century version of Train, say your prayers, and eat your vitamins. Cenas critics tend to be so wrapped up in finding things to dislike about him that they fail to view the issue from a pragmatic business standpoint, when thats the only standpoint that matters.
2. Your Criticisms Of Him Are Not Unique
His move set is limited, he doesnt sell well enough, his move calls are too obvious, he doesnt have a high enough workrate. These are the normal complaints leveled at Cena by his army of critics, but they also happen to be the exact same criticisms that were once directed at Steve Austin (post-neck injury), Hulk Hogan, The Rock, Triple H, and almost every WWE performer who has enjoyed a long run of main event-level status in the past 25 years. Lets face it, not everyone can be Chris Jericho or Kurt Angle, and the five moves of doom have been part of the repertoire of pretty much every professional wrestler who ever lived. In Hogans case (and Austins, for that matter), it was more like two moves of doom, and it didnt impede him from being the biggest superstar in the history of the industry. Why? Because a wrestlers skills on the mic have always been more important than his skills in the ring, and its not even a matter of debate. The guys who attain main event status do so because they have the right combination of physical appearance and bearing, acting and promo-cutting skills, and in-ring competence, with the latter being the least important. As much as the internet marks dont like to admit it, 90% of the wrestling audience doesnt care about a guy being a gifted mat technician. They want to be entertained, and John Cena obviously entertains the hell out of them.
1. He Makes Boatloads Of Money For The Company
Take a look at any WWE crowd during any WWE event, and whose t-shirts do you see on the most people? John Cena, and its not even close. Even if he couldnt execute a front facelock to save his life, hed still be the face of the company on this basis alone. Put simply, Cena has made more money for Vince McMahon in the past 10 years than any other performer on the roster, and hes done it despite being utterly detested by a good portion of the WWEs audience. But then, those people clearly dont detest him enough to stop buying pay-per-views and tickets for live events, or he wouldnt have headlined five Wrestlemanias and the last two in a row. Make no mistake, I find Cenas character just as bland and uninteresting as anyone else does. His in-ring work, on the other hand, while mostly unremarkable, is not as bad as his more ardent detractors make it out to be. It is certainly not my intent to make anyone like John Cena who isnt otherwise predisposed to do so, I merely think it would behoove his critics (many of whom stridently insist that an out-of-touch WWE is intentionally alienating its fans by continuing to push Cena) to step back from their unalloyed contempt long enough to consider the factors that make it perfectly good business sense for him to be the primary face of the WWE.