"At Survivor Series, you will bear witness to the Elimination Chamber!"- The words of Eric Bischoff, long seen as the creator of the Elimination Chamber Match- he isn't, by the way- on October 21st 2002. The scope of the Attitude Era in WWE is remembered and remarked upon, routinely regarded and revered for some of the most famous and infamous match creations in WWE history. Hell in a Cell, Last Man Standing, First Blood (adopted from ECW) and Tables, Ladders & Chairs amongst others. However, perhaps WWE's greatest match creation of recent times came shortly thereafter- when the blazing conflagration of Stone Cold & The Rock had quelled into dying embers. It is something WWE has lacked, in recent years, a fresh, powerful new match type to get the fans' juices flowing. In fact, one could argue that the success of the Elimination Chamber has left a curse upon WWE, as every new creation they've attempted since then has fallen squarely between dismal or insipidly uninteresting. Punjabi Prison, Last Ride Match, Championship Scramble come to mind. The success of the Elimination Chamber in its early years led to a period where Chamber matches were thrown together seemingly at random, simply because the Chamber itself acted as a draw for a while and one could hope for at least a decent match guaranteed when the "two miles of chain" engulfed itself around the squared circle. In 2008, WWE began the process of putting on Elimination Chamber Matches annually in February, first at No Way Out and then under its own name from 2010 to present. There have been some outstanding Elimination Chamber Matches in WWE history. There have been some classic regular matches at the Elimination Chamber/No Way Out PPV's since 2008. However, as always when you ride a concept into the ground for the sake of it, there have been some not so great matches- ranging from totally forgettable to downright awful. Here are the top 10 Elimination Chamber related matches you wish you hadn't had to pay for.
10. Elimination Chamber #4, New Year's Revolution (2006)
Shawn Michaels vs John Cena (c) vs Carlito vs Kurt Angle vs Chris Masters vs Kane (WWE Championship)Everyone remembers the ending to New Year's Revolution 2006 but it's not because of an old-school, classic, Elimination Chamber Match, nope. Good job too otherwise this event would've been a complete let down- anyone remember Jerry Lawler vs Gregory Helms or Shelton Benjamin vs Viscera? Edge cashed in the first Money in the Bank Championship contract following this Chamber match and, in barely over a minute, the previous thirty, overwhelmingly mediocre, ones were blasted into Purgatory. WWE went with an angle throughout this entire Chamber match. Young guns Carlito and Chris Masters- both still very green- were a tag-team at the time and WWE decided that having both of them go over established stars like Kurt Angle, Kane and Shawn Michaels in this match would take them to the next level. A decent idea on paper, the problem, of course, was that both would then job out to John Cena, right at the death of his first of eleven WWE Championship reigns. To skirt around this, they had Carlito turn on Masters in the match, betraying him at the apex before being swiftly rolled up by a bloodied Cena whom had started the match. It didn't help their cause. It made them look daft, immediately destroying the momentum they had built up with the previous eliminations. They would go on the languish in the mid-card until their respective releases. The other issue was the live crowd. This was right when the anti-Cena movement hit into full stride with predominantly male residuals from the Attitude Era rejecting Cena as the next Hogan or Austin. Cena was roundly booed in this match for the first time and so soon after WWE had placed him on the pedestal as the top guy. They all knew where this was going. 8 years later, we're still there. When Cena won the match and before anyone knew of Edge's sudden appearance, the finish fell completely dead. Nobody, not a soul in that arena believed either Carlito or Masters would win the strap. Once Shawn Michaels was eliminated, the place went dead. It's actually a good thing for this match that Edge cashed in afterwards, otherwise nobody would care to ever mention it. Compared to the lofty standards of the previous year's Chamber Match (New Year's Revolution '05) this was just a little bit stagnant, to be honest. By no means the worst, however.
9. WWE Title #1 Contenders Elimination Chamber Match - Elimination Chamber (2011)
John Morrison vs Sheamus vs Randy Orton vs John Cena vs R-Truth vs CM PunkThis match actually had some decent moments. John Morrison's scaling of the top of the Chamber, hanging upside-down before dropping on Sheamus to eliminate him and the CM Punk angle where he was trapped in-between his pod door, allowing Randy Orton to attack and eliminate him first before the infamous Anonymous Raw GM allowed him to re-enter his pod when he would later enter last to eliminate Orton; those were all good attempts to do something different and they needed to, as by this point a lot of their old tricks had ran their course. The problem with this match was two-fold: 1) the lacklustre build-up and 2) the blindly obvious predictability of the match, two factors which might well have quantified to the 86,000 buy-rate drop this event suffered from the 2010 edition. This match was the culmination of a lot of poor choices WWE made between Wrestlemania 26 and Wrestlemania 27- widely regarded as the two worst Wrestlemania offerings of the modern era. From the mishandling of the Nexus, to the 40-man Royal Rumble, the failed Edge heel turn, the RAW GM angle, Michael Cole's heel commentator persona and pushing The Miz to the main event of Wrestlemania where they obviously, since, believe he had no place being. WWE was poor in 2010 through till the summer of Punk, very poor. Part of their problem was the failure to generate interest in their stars. Orton was fresh out of the novelty of his babyface turn and lacking direction, Sheamus was going through the motions as a heel, Morrison was hot at the time but never truly given the ball the way he, perhaps, deserved to be and Punk was being so drastically misused, it led to a certain pipe-bomb promo he cut in Las Vegas. As for Cena, well, he was the guy who won and it was tedious as hell. You put all that together and you have a cold Chamber Match which Cena would obviously win on his route to one of the worst Wrestlemania main events in history against The Miz. All I can say is thank God WWE convinced The Rock to come back and finally banked on CM Punk because they were spinning tires around this time. I'm not a John Cena hater, for the record, I think he's drastically improved since CM Punk decided to light a fire under his ass but I'm well aware the first two matches on here have been Cena central and critical. Just a fair warning there are also two more to come. Sufficed to say, Elimination Chamber has not been the herald of his finest moments.
8. Alberto Del Rio vs The Big Show - Elimination Chamber (2013)
World Heavyweight Championship MatchLast year's Elimination Chamber event was a mixed bag to say the least. With the drawing power of The Rock bringing home a strong buy-rate in his second straight main event with CM Punk and the excellent, career making 6-Man Tag victory by The Shield over super-powers John Cena, Sheamus & Ryback, the event was a noteworthy one, in particular contrast to it's predecessor which remains anything but. However, two big matches on this show left a sour taste in my mouth. The first was the opener for the World Title. Del Rio was shortly into a babyface turn that even the most casual of fans could have told you wasn't going to work. Having defeated Big Show for the 'Big Gold Belt', in a great Last Man Standing Match at the turn of the year, WWE decided, as they tend to do, to milk the response for all it was worth with yet another Last Man Standing Match and then, if it weren't enough for Del Rio to keep Big Show down twice, another regular match on this event. The match was unremarkable and completely obsolete. Nobody cared. WWE, at the time, seemed determined to get Del Rio over as a top Hispanic babyface with Sin Cara and Rey Mysterio both on the shelf for the foreseeable future, as that market has always been a large draw for the company and clearly felt a submission win over Big Show would go some ways to getting him there. The problem was - and still is- that Del Rio just wasn't all that likeable. Everything from his look, his voice, his music stemmed from a stern effort WWE had previously made to establish him as a top heel; they were fighting against their own creation with this. Take away his expensive cars, try to make his music more upbeat, script his promos to sound like some pioneering, Mexican hero; nobody bought it. As for the World Title, it had been long since that belt made the man. Simply put, this didn't work. The angle, nor the match. It was a waste of time.
7. Jack Swagger vs Finlay - No Way Out (2009)
ECW Championship MatchIn my opinion, the 2009 edition of No Way Out (and the last in its traditional, February slot) might just be the best ever. In contrast to, overall, disappointing productions of the Royal Rumble & Wrestlemania 25 either side of it, that year, everything WWE went for with this event paid off. Building on the success of the previous year's event, WWE brought back the dual-Chamber Match concept, only this time, placed the World Titles into play. The event started and ended strong, with the compelling and original story of Edge losing the WWE Title in the opening Chamber match before coming back to win the World Heavyweight Title in the final match on the show striking a chord with the live crowd. In addition, you saw Shawn Michaels' break free of the control of JBL on his way to a certain match with Undertaker at Wrestlemania and a red-hot Randy Orton tear it up with Shane McMahon. It's unfortunate, then, that WWE placed an extremely green Jack Swagger in the middle of all this in a throwaway title defence against Finlay. The ECW brand, by this point, was so diluted that people had simply ceased to care. When you're having one match at every PPV event and it's often the worst of the night, that kind of thing can happen to you. Chavo Guerrero, as ECW Champion, entered the 2008 Royal Rumble. That says it all really. WWE has been hot and cold with their opinion of Swagger over the years. His look and natural athletic ability have led them to invest in him, intermittently before giving up and leaving him stranded in mid-card hell for as long as they choose- more on that next- his lack of natural charisma providing a roadblock to what, otherwise, could've been a far more prominent career thus far. From ECW Champion here to the most forgettable World Heavyweight Champion in history, WWE has never managed to push Swagger correctly. Placing him as an unfortunate buffer match in an otherwise stacked show certainly didn't help his cause. I wonder how many of you remember a single thing that happened during this match? Nope, me neither. Swagger won with his powerbomb, I think. Speaking of Jack Swagger...
6. Elimination Chamber Match - Elimination Chamber (2013)
Daniel Bryan vs Chris Jericho vs Jack Swagger vs Kane vs Randy Orton vs Mark Henry (#1 Contendership to the World Heavyweight Title) This is going to be a controversial one. This match, in of itself, wasn't bad at all. You need only look at some of the workers in the match to know it would be fine in terms of match quality and it was. I loved this match and I hated this match and I'ma tell you why. How many people, going into this match thought Jack Swagger would win? A fair few I would say. How many thought it would last? Not many, I would say. Now, yes, Jack Swagger's subsequent arrest for DUI and possession of marijuana didn't help- not one small jot but had he not suffered that DUI, would it lasted anyway? No. This match was obsolete from the moment the bell rang. Swagger had just returned from 5-month hiatus prior to this match with an old-school wrestling hand, albeit a new one to today's audience, Dutch Mantel, aka Zeb Colter at his side. The combination of this, the anti-immigration gimmick Colter is still running with today and WWE's push of Del Rio as mentioned earlier meant the writing was well on the wall before this match began. Make no mistake about it, the DUI didn't cost Swagger a win at Wrestlemania 29, he was losing anyway. The whole angle was designed as part and parcel of Del Rio's push as a Mexican babyface. Swagger was but a means to an end which is why watching this match was like watching a pantomime. You can try and suspend disbelief all you want but, eventually, you have to stop and ask the question: "Why am I watching this match?" in context. This is not a healthy way to watch wrestling, don't do it! Much like Swagger's Money in the Bank victory in 2010, I'm afraid this match was doomed to fall into the dusty catacombs of Elimination Chamber history the moment they decided they'll use it to find a man to feed to misguided Del Rio at Wrestlemania 29. Nothing on Swagger; he was placed in an impossible situation here. Probably why he thought "To hell with it, chuck me the bong Buddha."
5. WWE Title Elimination Chamber Match - Elimination Chamber (2010)
Kofi Kingston vs Sheamus (c) vs Triple H vs Randy Orton vs Ted DiBiase vs John CenaIt's difficult to actually describe this Chamber match, it was just there. You had the story of the Legacy stable of Orton, Rhodes & DiBiase breaking up here, with Rhodes and DiBiase turning on Orton in this match and eliminating him- they would have a triple threat match at Wrestlemania 26 but other than that, this match was simply nothing new. Kingston was making up the numbers, Sheamus was the freshman year Champion WWE pushed too soon for his own good and Cena & Triple H in a Chamber match had been seen and done before- especially Hunter whom had won 4 of the prior 9 Chamber matches before this one. The problem with this match was that we had seen all their tricks before. Sheamus, as the defeated Champion was placed in the match from the start to keep as much heat on him as they could, the Randy Orton elimination mirrored that of Shawn Michaels' I discussed earlier, Triple H in there doing the same stuff he'd done in all his prior matches and Cena winning, of all this had little to no impact. It had all been done, all been seen... including what happened after the match. So Cena wins the Chamber Match only for Vince McMahon to come out and announce Cena was going to immediately defend the title there and then against someone else in another match he then loses in less than two minutes... sound familiar? This was, essentially, a Money in the Bank cash-in angle, without an actual MITB contract and it was cheap as hell. The live crowd in attendance cheered simply in respect of Cena not being Champion and when you consider John has had reigns like this and his random 2-week reign between Del Rio's two in late 2011, it's not hard to see where all of those 14 World Title Reigns WWE likes to mention a lot have come from. This was the first Elimination Chamber match I can recall watching and being completely bored by. There were worse ones that preceded it but none that moved me less.
4. The Smackdown Elimination Chamber Match - No Way Out (2008)
The Undertaker vs Batista vs Big Daddy V vs The Great Khali vs Finlay v MVPWhen WWE announced on January 28th 2008 that they were integrating two separate Elimination Chamber Matches into that year's No Way Out PPV, to determine the #1 Contenders for Raw & Smackdown's World Championships at Wrestlemania 24, response was mixed. On one hand, the gesture smacked of trial and error. It had been two years at that point since the Chamber had been featured on a WWE themed PPV and the honeymoon period of the Chamber itself was well and truly over. Despite only 5 Chamber matches taking place in the previous 5 years and change since its inception, one might have been forgiven for wondering if the Chamber had jumped the shark already. On the flip-side, with only 3 weeks between the event and the 2008 Royal Rumble, it surely superseded the alternative of a rushed, stagnant regular PPV; a notion that was supported by it's buy-rate- up a full 111,000 buys from the previous year's event. Since then, it has remained a ratings draw for WWE in a difficult spot, between the Royal Rumble and Wrestlemania. Venture a success I would say, boys! Not that you'd tell from the first of WWE's 2nd generation of Chamber Matches, the opening Smackdown/ECW offering at the event. Starting strongly with The Undertaker & Batista, the match quickly degenerated into a random assortment of slow, plodding clotheslines and chops with the aging Big Daddy V and critically limited Great Khali entering the fray. Offerings of veteran Finlay and, granted, the excellent MVP later led to each of them being routinely squashed by Taker and Batista as they renewed a rivalry that headlined a the first 5 months of the previous year as they 'topped and tailed' an otherwise dire and uninspiring Chamber Match. Falling in stark contrast to the, much greater, Raw offering later that same night and both offerings of the following two years' events, this match stands out like a sore thumb. The booking of the match itself did little to offset the limitations of Big V and Khali and relative lack of heat for Finlay and MVP, instead choosing to make all 4 appear like jobbers as the were systematically fed to Undertaker and Batista. I would not encourage anyone to watch this Chamber match, as I did. It's one big huge, cumbersome chore. Not the absolute worst Elimination Chamber Match... but not far off. In a quick aside, my personal condolences to the family of Big Daddy V, aka Mabel & Viscera; Nelson Frazier, Jr. whom passed away earlier this week.
3. John Cena vs Kane - Elimination Chamber (2012)
Ambulance MatchThis feud was abysmal. This match was abysmal. I'm tempted to leave it at that. Urgh, fine, a few more words. Whilst 2012 will probably go down fondly in a lot of fans' minds for CM Punk's history making title reign, it was also the year of quite a few really bad John Cena PPV main events against guys who had no business being in such a spot in 2012. John Laurinaitis, Big Show in a Cage and this one-- talk about another one of WWE's failed match stipulations, an Ambulance Match, where to win, you must place your opponent in an Ambulance and close the door... wow, because such an action really constitutes victory. Well, at least it aint grabbing something off of a pole. The problem with this PPV was that both Elimination Chamber Matches, won by Daniel Bryan and CM Punk, were relatively straight forward, both Champions retained their gold. It's not always enough for a match to be good, otherwise we'd all be watching Ring of Honor, there needs to be two other critical components: drama and uniqueness. This often comes in the form of 'Will he, wont he!?', will snap and get DQ'd? Will he win with his career on the line? Those two Chamber matches, whilst not bad- certainly not enough to feature on this list- lacked such drama and uniqueness and was perhaps the reason WWE felt compelled to place Cena vs Kane on last, as it had both of those things. The problem was, they were terrible. Will Cena 'embrace the hate' and snap? Will he turn heel? And do what, beat the hell out of Kane? It didn't make any logical sense, it was never going to happen anyway and nobody would've cared if he had've wasted Kane. Instead, they wasted all our time with a stupid angle and dismal match. Cena won, status quo renewed. Please can The Rock come back now? The sooner this match ended, the better... which is why we were all grasping for the razor blades when it ran 21 minutes.
Chris Jericho vs Shawn Michaels vs Randy Orton vs Kevin Nash vs Triple H (c) vs Goldberg (World Heavyweight Title)It's a wonder quite how WWE managed to screw this one up as badly as they did. Let's just bypass the bit-parts quickly. Kevin Nash & Randy Orton (in his very first PPV match, by the way) were there to make up the numbers, Orton as an ally of Triple H in Evolution. Michaels and Jericho were there to be the workhorses, starting the match and lasting most of the way until the finale and then you had Goldberg who had come into WWE hot 4 months prior, after much anticipation and the reigning heel Champion whom every man and has dog would have drop the belt to Goldberg in this high-profile, Summerslam main event. True to his form, Goldberg had yet to taste defeat since entering the company, as it should've been. Building on the success of the first Chamber match, all the pieces were set to swap your top strap in a major way. That's not what WWE did. They did it all right until the very end. Goldberg came in last and completely destroyed and eliminated Orton, Jericho & Michaels in a matter of about three minutes before turning his attention to the Champion, Triple H, cowered as he was in his pod which he had yet to leave. What should've happened is Hunter would make a small comeback attempt, before being overwhelmed and dropping the belt, it's all anyone in that arena and the 415,000 people who bought the event wanted to see. Instead, as Goldberg's set to spear him for the finish, Flair tosses Hunter his devastating sledge hammer, Hunter hits Goldberg once in the head and beats him. Just like that. One hammer shot and every last shred of momentum ripped away from Goldberg. They tried to rectify the problem at the next month's Unforgiven PPV, when Goldberg did beat Triple H clean in a regular match but it was too late. The live crowd were dead for that match, they remained lukewarm at best for Goldberg's 3-month title run, before he dropped it, was booed out of the building in a match against Brock Lesnar at Wrestlemania 20 and hasn't appeared once in WWE since. What a failure. What a flop. Every bit of it the result of that one sledgehammer shot to Goldberg's head during Elimination Chamber #2. The match became completely pointless.
1. "Extreme" Elimination Chamber - ECW December To Dismember (2006)
Hardcore Holly vs Rob Van Dam vs CM Punk vs Test vs Bobby Lashley vs Big Show (c) (ECW World Championship)I know, I know. Y'all are thanking me for not linking you to highlights of this debacle. It's cool man, you don't need to thank me. I'm a humanitarian, you know, I care. I really do. You're all lovely people. Enjoy Big Show pulling a stupid face instead. 90,000. That is the number of people whom bought this PPV event, headlined by the "Extreme" Elimination Chamber match, the lowest PPV buy-rate in WWE history- bar none. Take a look at that match above as your main event. It's not hard to see why. An ECW themed PPV headlined by a 6-man Match that contained one genuine ECW talent. The rest? A combination of rookies and guys who who would only ever get close to the main event of a regular WWE PPV if they were in a buffer match for people to go urinate in. The Elimination Chamber, here, was a Hail Mary- a desperate attempt to salvage a dreadful card with an attraction, something people might want to buy the PPV for. As Vince McMahon always says, PPV is an attraction based business. The only thing attractive about this match was Rob Van Dam's singlet. They even tried to buff it up a bit by adding the "Extreme!" aspect to the match, which basically meant each of the guys in the pods would have a weapon with them when they came out. Doesn't that smack of desperation!? Ironically, I think the live crowd popped more for the entrance of the crowbar than Test, whom was carrying it. God rest your soul, Andrew Martin. On a more serious note, the issue with this match wasn't just its lack of star power, it was that the two genuinely over guys in the ECW realm, at the time, Punk and RVD, were both passed over in favour of a vastly out of shape Big Show (he would take a sabbatical from pro-wrestling shortly after this) and the charisma vacuum that was Bobby Lashley. Not that Lashley wasn't without his potential, he was just way too green at this time. It's, perhaps, a blessing in disguise that the PPV buy-rate was so low and has such passed into the dungeons of WWE history, never to be spoken of again, as I think it allows the majority of the current crop of WWE fans to live in ignorance that this match ever even existed. What you don't know wont hurt you, right? Right?... And now, a brief summary which will link this article to the upcoming Chamber PPV on Sunday: The 2014 edition of WWE Elimination Chamber occurs this Sunday and quite honestly, there's a very good chance I might end up revising this list come Monday. I don't like to go into PPV's expecting the worst but with the WWE network launching the following night, it's clear where the focus and attention at the head office lies right now and it isn't on making this PPV a resounding success. The Chamber match itself has all the potential to fall into either one of the categories of Elimination Chamber Match history; the dregs I've listed here or the idolised that others have listed over and over again everywhere else. The under-card looks uninspiring to say the least but with a powerful effort from The Shield and The Wyatt Family, a breakout performance from Cesaro, not too much of a convoluted screw-job when Cena gets beat and perhaps, even, a history making night from Daniel Bryan, maybe just maybe the show might be worth the price of admission.