Elimination Chamber is one of the most unique Pay Per Views in the WWE, its titular stipulation providing an unrivalled blend of suspense and brutality beloved by fans. Its quiet disappearance from this year's calendar was understandably met with widespread disappointment, especially as it was seemingly replaced by the comparatively bland Fastlane. However, an official announcement indicates that the Chamber is back, WWE slotting in a special Network exclusive showcase on May 31st. The official reason for its temporary disappearance is that many large US arenas have undergone renovations in recent times, dramatically shrinking the amount of potential locations capable of holding the bulky Chamber structure. However, the American Bank Centre in Corpus Christi, Texas has no such issues, and looks to be a convenient host. While this does seem a smart piece of business by the promotion, utilising an already-established Pay Per View to drive up subscriber numbers, there are several downsides. Here are six of the biggest reasons the WWE are making a serious mistake in this seemingly savvy piece of business. Although many of these points are made out of speculation and subject to change, given the relatively restricted information released about the show so far, they suggest that the show is set to be a strangely rushed, corner-cutting attempt to solve a pair of far more complex problems: the Network subscriber figures, and the shrinking number of Chamber-ready arenas.
6. It's An Event Worthy Of Main PPV Status
The Elimination Chamber is perhaps the most imposing stipulation the WWE has to offer. It is gigantic, intimidating, and limited to annual appearances - all features which make it one of the most spectacular match types in wrestling. Fans know that a Chamber match guarantees drama, furious action, and a level of brutality not usually seen in today's PG landscape. Surely the event therefore deserves to be treated as one of the biggest PPVs of the year, perhaps even eclipsing Survivor Series (generally regarded as the least popular of the "big four") in this regard. The relegation of the show to a Network exclusive robs both the stipulation and the PPV of the incredible gravitas and intensity it has always possessed. Even if the show is a monumental success from an in-ring point of view, it will reach a far smaller audience than it probably deserves. Subscribers to the Network are clearly an important priority for the WWE, but they should be more careful about potentially tarnishing the grand image of their established TV PPVs as a sacrifice.
5. There's Talk Of A Limited Roster
The PPV will take place on the same night as a house show in a different state (Elimination Chamber is in Texas, the house show in South Carolina), sparking rumours of a severely limited roster for a show which should really be going all out to impress potential Network subscribers. It also seems rather unfair to those attending both shows, having to put up with potentially missing out on their favourite superstars due to the WWE's hasty rearrangements. Big names advertised for the South Carolina show include Cena, Rusev and Barrett - a clear indication that Elimination Chamber isn't being given the same treatment as a televised Pay Per View.
4. Similarities With Lockdown
Of the two matches announced so far (a tag title match, and a presumably multi-man contest for the recently vacated Intercontinental Championship), both are said to be taking place in the Elimination Chamber itself. This is strange, as even when the Chamber match graduated to its own eponymous PPV, the structure itself was reserved for WWE and World Heavyweight title matches. The idea of putting more than one match inside the Chamber smacks of TNA-esque amateurism. Their all-cage Pay Per View, Lockdown, was apparently invented on the back of a suggestion made in jest, and it does seems slightly bush-league to stage an entire show within the constraints of a single stipulation. It's the sort of thing one would expect from a trashy deathmatch promotion such as CZW on a regular basis, but not a company as proud and (relatively) by-the-book as the WWE.
3. No Major Storyline Advancement
This is a problem commonly associated with the old UK exclusive PPVs. You could almost always predict the results of a Rebellion or Insurrextion main event; a babyface champion would always retain his belt, while a heel champ would lose via DQ to keep his belt, before suffering a feel-good beatdown at the hands of the major face(s). Because the shows were broadcast to a far smaller, non-US audience, the promotion always hesitated to advance any of their major storylines at all. The odd lowercard belt may have changed hands, but viewers could largely skip the shows and tune into Raw the following day without having missed any significant developments. The upcoming PPV faces a similar issue considering its Network exclusive status. Will the WWE be brave enough to significantly advance any of their big storylines, or will the whole thing become a glorified episode of Smackdown, maintaining the status quo as much as possible?
2. There Potentially Won't Even Be A WWE Championship Match
Rumours have already begun to swirl regarding the relevance of the WWE Championship in relation to the Pay Per View. With Money In The Bank scheduled only a fortnight ahead of Elimination Chamber, many are speculating that the belt may not even be defended at the Network PPV. While it would fit Rollins' character to squirm out of an incredibly tough stipulation, it would surely deflate fans' expectations. Although the Intercontinental Championship match seems a fantastic idea (and will likely be a good match, given the amount of under-appreciated talent currently in the midcard), it's unlikely to be accepted as a satisfactory replacement for a match for the promotion's top title.
1. The History Of The Elimination Chamber Will Be Severely Diluted
The major problem with this year's Elimination Chamber is a microcosm of a key issue within the WWE as a whole. The company's attitude towards its own history and continuity has been far too aloof for years, with storylines being conveniently forgotten, remembered, rehashed and retconned to fit the current mood. It also has bizarrely little respect for its own traditions; commentators rarely refer to anything further ahead than the next PPV, refusing to acknowledge the past or even near future. Everything is suffocatingly geared around the present. Staging an Elimination Chamber PPV exclusively on the Network will almost certainly dilute its legacy and future relevance. The show is likely to be shorter, packed with considerably less fanfare than a standard PPV, and missing various key figures - all due to the short notice with which it has been arranged. The match stipulation itself looks to be in danger, with the shoehorning of various lowercard matches into its enclosed walls (and the potential absence of a WWE Championship bout). This has all happened before of course. Hell In A Cell used to be the most fearsome match stipulation around, before it was watered down beyond recognition by the predictability of annual Pay Per Views. Cell matches were no longer reserved for blood feuds; any two main event stars feuding at the right time of year would find themselves arbitrarily put into such a match. Sadly, all signs point to the Elimination Chamber match enjoying a similar fate. At this rate, how long before we see a Network-exclusive Royal Rumble for the Divas Championship? Hopefully Vince, Triple H, or somebody with enough influences spots the negative impact of this trend sooner rather than later.