Another month, another WWE special event. Hell in a Cell is entering its 7th year, emanating this year from Los Angeles with a main event consisting of Brock Lesnar and The Undertaker doing battle for the final time in the demonic structure. There will also be another Cell match, as Roman Reigns and Bray Wyatt continue their never-ending blood feud. The cell represents their final chapter. But what of the six Hell in a Cell events that have preceded the 2015 edition? The cell match itself has main-evented all six to date, with matches varying from D-Generation X taking on Cody Rhodes and Ted Dibiase all the way to Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose continuing the implosion of The Shield last year. Who have been the major winners and losers over the years? Last month we learnt that Daniel Bryan is undefeated at Night of Champions, how has he fared at Hell in a Cell? What of CM Punk, the man with the worst Night of Champions record? What surprises are in store for us when we unearth the men who have had their hands raised the most, along with those who have spent their event staring at the lights. Here are the five best and worst records (minimum two matches), starting with the losers...
Advertisement
5. Dolph Ziggler (3 Matches, 2 Losses)
Oh Dolph, poor poor Dolph. He has been around for what seems like forever, and the majority of his Hell in a Cell performances have come in losing efforts with gold on the line. In the inagural event in 2009, Ziggler came up short when challenging for John Morrison's Intercontinental Championship. His next defeat came in tag competition, as he joined forces with Jack Swagger to challenge the team of Kofi Kingston and Evan Bourne in 2011. Ziggler and Swagger had joined forces for no reason other than the fact Vickie Guerrero managed both. The team had potential, but the team didn't win diddly-squat. It hasn't all been lose lose lose for Ziggy though, although his victory in 2014 defending his Intercontinental Championship against Cesaro is a good indication of his lack of movement throughout his career. Five years on from the first Hell in a Cell event, Ziggler was still in the same position. This year, Ziggler is in pre-show competition teaming up with the man he defeated last year (Cesaro) and Neville, taking on the Super European team of Sheamus, King Barrett and Rusev.
4. John Cena (5 Matches, 3 Losses)
Considering he is John Cena, it is surprising how many PPV matches he has lost over the years. His Hell in a Cell record is fairly similar to his Night of Champions one, with a couple of victories scattered in between a plethora of losses. In this instance, his two wins have come in his last two appearances, against rival for life Randy Orton and Alberto Del Rio. His losses? Well, one came against Orton of course, as it is WWE law for Randy Orton and John Cena to face off a thousand times in all possible types of match. Cena also came up short against Alberto Del Rio in a triple threat match that also included CM Punk, for the WWE Championship in 2011. Surprisingly, Cena's other defeat at the event came at the hands of WWE's most losingest-loser, Wade Barrett. The stipulation here was that if Cena lost, he must join the Nexus. He joined the Nexus, and the rest is history. Which obviously means that the Nexus was history.
3. Ryback (2 Matches, 2 Losses)
Not only has Ryback come up short in his two appearances at WWE Hell in a Cell so far, he has come up short on both occasions against the very same opponent, that man CM Punk. The only differences between the two cell matches was that the alignments had switched, and in 2013 Ryback had the mighty Paul Heyman alongside him. Truth be told, WWE booked themselves into something of a hole towards the end of 2012 with Ryback, as he was given the big undefeated streak and then thrust into a WWE Championship program with CM Punk, who was clearly moving towards at least a year long reign. As such the match had a dirty finish, with Brad Maddox (then-referee) low-blowing The Big Guy and allowing Punk to roll him up for the three. Ryback would get the last laugh by Shellshocking Punk on the roof, but it still comes up as a big fat L in his Hell in a Cell statistics. 2013 was a bit more a straight-forward affair, Punk pinning Ryback in the middle of the ring before climbing on top to beat the tar out of Heyman. This year, Ryback gets his Intercontinental Championship re-match against Kevin Owens, and I've got a feeling he'll be returning to this column next year with the number two replaced by a three.
2. Jack Swagger (4 Matches, 4 Losses)
Hey, remember this guy? I'm not even sure if he is still signed to the company to be honest. A cursory google search suggest he is, but the chances of him getting any more showcase event matches are slim to none. Thus, Jack Swagger will most likely never win a match at Hell in a Cell. To be fair to the All-American American, only one of his four losses has come in singles action, coming up short against Edge in 2010. He also came up farts in challenging Kofi Kingston for the United States Championship in 2009, in a triple threat match that also included The Miz. Swagger also has two tag team defeats at the event. His loss against Air Boom has already come up, but more embarrassingly Swagger and Cesaro (known as the Real Americans) lost to Los Matadores in 2013. Yes, Los Matadores. That kind of sums up Jack Swagger I guess.
1. The Miz (4 Matches, 4 Losses)
The king of losing at Hell in a Cell, The Miz features above jack Swagger in this list by virtue of losing less tag team matches. In fact, Miz has lost a grand total of zero tag team matches, but has come up short in two multi-man matches. Both were for the United States Championship in 2009 against Kofi Kingston and fellow frequent-loser Jack Swagger, and then a year later against former tag partner John Morrison and former rookie Daniel Bryan. The Awesome One also has two singles defeats at the event, both in championship matches once more. 2012 saw him stare at the lights after a Trouble in Paradise from Kofi Kingston, a match that gave Kingston an extra determination. Supposedly. Last year Miz lost against, this time against Sheamus with the United States Championship on the line. The only real positive that can be said about the match last year was that it came at a time when Damien Mizdow was a thing and still a funny thing, so there was at least that. This year, Miz isn't involved at all. WWE still gives the impression of being invested in his character though, so there is every chance that he could be replaced at the bottom of this list by Mr Swagger in the future. Now, on to the winners...
5. Sheamus (4 Matches, 2 Wins)
We start with the man who defeated The Miz last year, the 'Celtic Warrior' Sheamus. The flame-haired one came up short in his first appearance at the event, losing to Randy Orton in 2010. A couple of years later he would fall again, dropping the World Heavyweight Championship to The Big Show in one of the big man's last good matches. His wins? 2011 saw him defeat 'Captain Charisma' himself, Christian. The two had a good series of solid back and forth matches, with Sheamus coming out on top more often than not. The two had great chemistry, and their show opener in 2011 is something of a lost classic. We've already covered his vanquishing of The Miz last year, so no need to go over that again. On to the next...
4. The Big Show (3 Matches, 2 Wins)
The Big Show has tasted victory twice at Hell in a Cell, and on both occasions gold was on the line. He also knows what it is like to lose at the event, failing his quest to beat Rusev last year. His first victory came in tag action, as Batista and Rey Mysterio failed to defeat Show and Chris Jericho (Jeri-Show) for the gold in 2009. Show picked up the pinfall on Rey that night after knocking him out, as the two legends continued their tag team title run. As mentioned, his beating of Sheamus in 2012 for the World Heavyweight Championship was one of his last great matches, and saw both the Brogue Kick and the Knockout Punch being kicked out of. In a world where finishing moves are seemingly kicked out of every match, this still felt shocking, as they are two of the most protected moves in the company.
3. Randy Orton (6 Matches, 4 Wins)
Did you know that Randy Orton is the only man to have wrestled at every single Hell in a Cell event? Well, you do now. Six times Orton has competed at the event, and he has come out on top on an impressive four occasions. His two defeats came against John Cena and Mark Henry, as the latter embarked on his great Hall of Pain run. The names that Orton has defeated at the event read like a Who's Who of modern WWE. In 2009 he beat John Cena, followed by a victory over Sheamus in 2010. He defeated Alberto Del Rio in 2012, in what was his only match at the event that didn't take place within the confines of the cell. In 2013 he defeated Daniel Bryan for the vacant WWE Championship, although this came thanks to help from Shawn Michaels. This was when the 'best for business' story was in full-flow, and HBK turned on Bryan to help out his buddy, Triple H. If anything, Orton felt like something of a bit-player in the story despite being champion. Still, four out of six isn't too shabby.
2. Cody Rhodes (5 Matches, 4 Wins)
This one surprised me a little bit. Cody Rhodes has only ever lost once at Hell in a Cell, and this came in the main event of the very first event. He teamed up with Legacy buddy Ted DiBiase to take on D-Generation X (Triple H and Shawn Michaels), and despite isolating Michaels for the majority of the match the two legends still came out on top. Since then, Cody has been undefeated at the event, although the majority of his matches have been in tag competition. His only singles victory came in 2011 when defending his Intercontinental Championship against John Morrison. Subsequent tag victories came in 2012, 2013 and 2014. At the former, Cody partnered Damien Sandow to defeat then-champions Team Hell No (Daniel Bryan and Kane) by disqualification. Over the last two event, Cody has teamed with his brother Goldust to defend the gold, both times against The Usos. An extra bit of spice came in 2013 as Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins of The Shield were also involved. Tag matches or not, Cody has an impressive record at Hell in a Cell.
1. Kofi Kingston (3 Matches, 3 Wins)
Hands up who saw this coming? Don't lie. Kofi Kingston is the only man to have competed in more than one match who is still undefeated at the Hell in a Cell event. He has performed at three, and on each occasion has come out on top. Not only this, but he has defended gold on each occasion. The first of these was in 2009, when he held onto his United States Championship despite the twin challenge of Jack Swagger and The Miz, although in hindsight they are the two biggest losers in the history of the event, so that isn't so surprising. He beat The Miz once more in 2012, gaining a new determination along the way. Finally, he teamed up with Evan Bourne in 2011 to defend the tag team titles against Jack Swagger and Dolph Ziggler. Of course, you can enter all sorts of contextual 'stakes' to change rankings, but the simple fact is that Kofi Kingston has a 100% winning percentage at Hell in a Cell. 2015 sees him team up with Big E Langston to take on the Dudley Boyz, and if the WWE has any sense Kofi's record will go up another notch. Is it the streak to replace The Undertaker's WrestleMania one? Maybe.