WWE Royal Rumble 2019: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
A surprisingly solid show.
The Royal Rumble has come and gone for another year, and you know what? Despite plenty of fan pessimism in the lead-up to the PPV, it was a pretty decent outing for the most part.
Sure, the 7-hour run-time (including the kickoff show) was exhausting and obscene, but between the surprise results, the rock solid title bouts and two decently entertaining Rumble matches, it was a well-booked show that didn't leave too many fans fuming.
It also wasn't a hugely memorable Royal Rumble event by any means, though. There were no terrible matches but a number of forgettably workmanlike ones, and both of the Rumbles lacked that special something that iconic moments are truly made of.
But again - WWE's usual commitment to torturing its fanbase was barely anywhere to be seen during the show, with a focus on results that were (mostly) crowd-pleasing, unexpected and well-earned.
And so, the Road to WrestleMania truly kicks off...
10. Bobby Roode & Chad Gable Vs. Rezar & Scott Dawson
Result: Gable pins Dawson following a Moonsault-Neckbreaker combo (6:55).
Rating: The worst match of the night was mercifully on first. This was totally typical for a kickoff match, in that nothing was lost if you missed it, but it was hardly terrible either.
The oddball Rezar-Dawson pairing teased something interesting, but ultimately everyone involved was just going through the mediocre motions for its mercifully brief entirety.
Watchable but forgettable and ultimately another sad indication that WWE doesn't know what to do with The Revival.
On the plus side, WWE appears to have finally stopped showing commercials during their kickoff matches, which was effectively the major takeaway from this match. 5/10
9. WWE United States Title: Rusev (C) Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura
Result: Nak murders Ru-Ru with the Kinshasa to win the strap (10:15).
Rating: In the span of a year, Nakamura's gone from winning a Royal Rumble to...this.
One one hand the match existed solely to get Lana out of the Women's Royal Rumble, but on the other, wasn't it nice to see a kickoff match which actually had a significant impact on the outcome of a marquee bout?
Either way, this was a solid battle that took a while to ramp up but proved surprisingly competitive by the end, and Nak's win was nothing if not a surprise (if, arguably, also a bit of a shame given the brevity of Rusev's reign).
Rusev getting distracted by Lana's injury was Lazy Booking 101, but at least it had a clear storytelling purpose. 6/10
8. WWE Smackdown Tag Titles: The Bar (C) Vs. The Miz & Shane McMahon
Result: Shane O'Mac kills Cesaro with a Shooting Star Press (!) to scoop the straps (13:20).
Rating: Though a lot of fans clearly wanted to hate this one from the outset, you have to hand it to Shane McMahon for going out there and putting himself in this position when he really doesn't have to.
Sure, the guy's punches are still embarrassing, but he bumped hard, and as daft as McMahon pinning Cesaro sounds in 2019, that Shooting Star Press really spoke for itself.
Would it be better to see The Bar lose the straps to an actual, card-carrying tag team? Sure, but given the potential for disaster, this was surprisingly good. 6/10
7. WWE Title: Daniel Bryan (C) Vs. AJ Styles
Result: Styles receives a Chokeslam from Erick Rowan, allowing Bryan to steal the win (24:35).
Rating: Though Bryan and Styles were really trying here, this match just wasn't well thought-out by anybody involved.
Running it straight after the Women's Rumble was an atrocious idea, and if WWE was insistent on that booking order, then this match should've been a snappy 10-minute sprint rather than a 25-minute slog.
And of course, the shenanigans finish with the knocked out ref and Rowan's bizarre appearance really sucked the air out of the room.
People don't want to see these bulls*** finishes when two of the company's finest are involved. Easily the most disappointing match on the card. 6/10
6. Men's Royal Rumble
Result: Seth Rollins eliminates Braun Strowman to win the Rumble (57:35).
Rating: This was a totally typical Royal Rumble match: it was neither bad nor inspired or really interesting in any way. Needless to say, outside of the entertaining Nia Jax spot, there's not a lot here that fans will be remembering for long.
Rollins was an acceptable if not terribly creative winner considering he spent long stretches of the match doing nothing, while the likes of Drew McIntyre, Samoa Joe and Andrade were busy giving their everything.
But the hungry talent at least got plenty of time to shine, with Mustafa Ali perhaps having the most impressive showing of all (eliminating both Nakamura and Joe).
Also, WWE had enough prime rib talent that they didn't need to waste numerous spots on bloated legends: that was reserved solely for Jeff Jarrett (whose ring attire was, er, a choice).
It takes a lot to make a Rumble match truly bad, so even though this was just fine, overall it turned out decently enjoyable. 6/10
5. WWE Universal Title: Brock Lesnar (C) Vs. Finn Bálor
Result: Brock makes Balor tap to the Kimura Lock to retain (8:40).
Rating: Nobody's going to argue that this was a technical classic, but it was exactly what it needed to be and made great use of both men.
Far from the stock Brock squash many were expecting, Bálor was booked to put up a strong fight and looked fantastic, with Lesnar putting him over big time.
It seemed like the match was going to play-up the diverticulitis angle more, but it ultimately ended up feeling a bit throwaway and half-baked.
Still, Brock fought like he actually cared, and between Becky and Bálor both tapping to submissions on this show, it's nice that WWE is finally starting to appreciate that having a top-line face submit isn't some epic disgrace. 7/10
4. WWE Raw Women's Title: Ronda Rousey (C) Vs. Sasha Banks
Result: Ronda beats Sasha with the Piper's Pit to retain (13:55).
Rating: A totally solid match that continued to bolster Rousey's strength while giving Banks one of her most impressive showcases of recent times.
If Sasha choking Ronda with her ring gear - which probably should've resulted in a DQ, by the way - wasn't enough of an indication that she needs to turn heel, then what is? The way she carries herself is just so better suited to playing the villain.
But back to the match itself, which wasn't without a few sloppy moments from Ronda, but Banks flourished as the glue holding it all together. The result was never in doubt, but a fine showing from both regardless. 7/10
3. Women's Royal Rumble
Result: Becky Lynch eliminates Charlotte Flair to win the Rumble (1:12:00).
Rating: Though the ending wasn't really in doubt once Lana got injured during the kickoff show, a satisfying result is more important than being surprised, and satisfy Becky's win certainly did.
The best thing about this Rumble, however, was its lack of reliance on nostalgia and legacy talent (as was an issue last year), with WWE instead showing confidence in their talent pool in a way that totally paid off.
Fun extras were in pretty short supply this year - apart from the hilarious Zelina Vega/Hornswoggle spot - but so many top-tier talents came out of this looking superb (especially Ember Moon and Rhea Ripley), while Kacy Catanzaro temporarily stole the show in her main roster debut.
Not an all-timer Rumble by any means, but a very solid one, if lacking the synthesis of drama and humour that the best Rumbles achieve. 7/10
2. WWE Cruiserweight Title: Buddy Murphy (C) Vs. Akira Tozawa Vs. Hideo Itami Vs. Kalisto
Result: Murphy puts Itami away with the Murphy’s Law to retain the title (12:05).
Rating: This was without question the strongest kickoff match in recent memory, and clearly should've been on the main card. Everyone here was working at a high gear and sustained throughout, with Murphy booked to look like the absolute star that he is.
The pacing was excellent, the hits were insanely stiff and Itami did a great job convincing the crowd that maybe, just maybe, he might actually snatch the belt from Murphy.
This had all the right elements and the result was one of the most kinetic 205 matches of late. 8/10
1. WWE Smackdown Women's Title: Asuka (C) Vs. Becky Lynch
Result: Becky taps to the Asuka Lock, allowing Asuka to retain (17:10).
Rating: This was a cracker of a way to kick off the main show, and though some may take umbrage with Becky's loss - especially as it was clean - it was a fully earned result and, of course, set up Becky's subsequent Rumble win.
At once epic and scrappy, this hit all the right beats while confirming just how great these two are together.
The storytelling and psychology were note-perfect, especially in terms of selling Asuka's effectiveness in grounding Becky and finally preventing her escape.
Asuka may have been the winner, but nobody really lost here. The decisive Match of the Night. 8/10
-
What did you think of this year's Royal Rumble? Shout it out in the comments!