WWE Vs. AEW: Which Promotion Does It Better?

The establishment battles the alternative.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE/AEW

This article is not going to go down well with sections of the pro wrestling audience.

Advertisement

It's best to just get that out of the way first. Phrases like, 'different strokes for different folks' instantly come to mind, and they're true. People do like different things - that extends to their taste in wrestling, and it'd be an outright lie to say this one wasn't sprinkled with at least some personal opinion.

At the same time though, your writer has done his able best to remove any lingering partisan bias from the equation and look at the facts laid out before everyone. Any argument like this needs some kind of objectivity to be credible, and this topic certainly deserves it. So, here it is. Who does it better? Established juggernaut WWE or new kids on the block AEW?

Advertisement

Each company will battle it out across 10 distinct categories to be crowned the winner. Some will agree, some will smash up their keyboards in frustration and fire off abuse via the comments, but that's the beauty of this industry. Everyone is entitled to their own thoughts, and everyone wins because there's more than one option.

Here goes nothing...

Advertisement

10. Presentation & Production

WWE.com

Those who watch episodes of WWE telly with eagle eyes could tell you that Kevin Dunn has let standards slip in WWE. Camera angle changes sometimes miss important moments, and there's been a worrying lack of attention to detail over the past few years when it comes to production-style botches.

Advertisement

Even so, WWE remains king of the hill when it comes to overall presentation.

Wide shots gleam with that traditional big-time feel Vince McMahon favours, especially on larger events, and the overall sheen WWE has outweighs AEW's more basic (but not exactly shabby) look. Over in Tony Khan's world, episodes of Dynamite occasionally feel like they lack a bit of tightness; for example, those lengthy breaks with fan signs, commentary banter and other ad-libs on FITE TV can be painfully amateurish.

Advertisement

This is perhaps something AEW will improve over time. For now though, they're naturally behind a crew who has been producing WWE events with top-quality gear since the 1980s.

Winner: WWE

Advertisement

9. Commentary

WWE

There isn't a better commentator in wrestling today than NXT's Mauro Ranallo, and he helps WWE mightily in this category. The way Mauro passionately projects his admiration for what he's seeing, puts over hidden storyline beats and energetically ties it all together is quite stunning to witness.

Advertisement

AEW's Jim Ross, Tony Schiavone and Excalibur trio do have freedom on their side. They're not burdened by having a control-freak boss scream over their headsets during broadcasts like the WWE lot are, and that must be bliss. In a weird way however, that makes the job the likes of Michael Cole, Corey Graves, Tom Phillips and others do even more special.

How they're able to concentrate on shilling products, being live-edited and still put over matches, stories and characters is anyone's guess. Despite not having that McMahon hairdryer in his ears constantly, Ranallo is just so good that he sways this one.

Advertisement

AEW's commentary core is solid, but Ranallo is the man.

Winner: WWE

Advertisement

8. Roster Depth

WWE

This one is a no contest for now.

Advertisement

AEW are only around one year old, and they've only got one TV show (two if you include the supplementary Dark) to worry about filling. Over in WWE, wrestlers are deployed to four main brands, and others are needed for house show work, 205 Live, Main Event and other basement-level programming.

WWE need rosters for Raw, SmackDown, NXT and NXT UK. That's a lot of workers, and the depth required blows AEW out of the water. They might not use it in the best way all the time, but WWE's writers can call upon a wealth of talent to use - whenever a hole needs filled, somebody with skills will be there to fill it.

Advertisement

AEW, meanwhile, need a bit more time to pad out their ranks. Though they're helped by young stars like Sammy Guevara and Darby Allin, that's not quite enough to put them ahead of Vinnie Mac's league here. He has well over 200 wrestlers under contract, for crying out loud. That's serious (and probably unnecessary) depth.

Winner: WWE

Advertisement

7. Roster Freedom

AEW

AEW has fallen to an early 0-3 deficit, and it needs a big win to start pulling the nose up here. Good news: Tony Khan's group has it in spades in this category. WWE simply cannot compete with the freedom Khan's management style gives his roster.

Advertisement

His approach is a real throwback to how wrestling used to be. Instead of painstakingly scripting every bit of work from curtain-to-curtain, Khan's AEW prefers to let talent express themselves and come up with the bulk of their own promos, presentation and match content. It's refreshing to see after years of WWE's overly-produced product.

Freedom enticed megastars like Chris Jericho and Jon Moxley to the promotion too. They were turned on by the thought of controlling their own destiny, and they've been able to properly assert their own authority over storylines as a result.

Advertisement

No contest. WWE is left bleeding on the floor here.

Winner: AEW

Advertisement

6. Nostalgia

AEW

The winner of this one might come as a surprise.

Advertisement

WWE do love a nostalgic blast from the past. Goldberg is the latest example (again), and they regularly produce those 'Old School Raw' episodes when they want to pop a quick rating or can't be arsed to think of a more standard broadcast. The problem with those is that they feel half-baked and one-off.

There's more love in AEW's nods to wrestling history. Whenever stars from yesteryear like Arn Anderson, Tully Blanchard, Jake Roberts or DDP have been wheeled out for a performance, they've been used to enhance ongoing storylines rather than work one-night angles aimed at those longing for the 1980s/90s.

Advertisement

That 'Bash At The Beach' edition of Dynamite was also a homage to a WCW great, and there's no doubt the 'Blood & Guts' War Games match they're about to present will knock WWE's NXT version for six. It'll be more authentic, for a start, and that authenticity rings true whenever AEW drum up fond memories.

Winner: AEW

Advertisement

5. Star Power

WWE

Roster depth is a different animal to roster star power. WWE could have 200+ wrestlers on deals all they liked, but it wouldn't matter if a large number of those didn't come with heavyweight name value. There's no denying it; WWE's star power trumps AEW's as things stand.

Advertisement

For every Chris Jericho, WWE has Brock Lesnar, Goldberg and The Undertaker. For Jon Moxley, Vinnie Mac can counter with John Cena, Randy Orton and Edge. Sure, most of those are part-timers, but they're waiting to be called upon and readily available during the most important time of the year: WrestleMania season.

Away from the top-line mix, WWE has it made too. AJ Styles, Daniel Bryan, Seth Rollins, Kevin Owens and more stand out as meaningful stars. On the female side of things, AEW's Riho, Nyla Rose and more can't hold a candle to Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair, Sasha Banks, Bayley, Shayna Baszler, Rhea Ripley and others.

Advertisement

This is a hands down win for McMahon.

Winner: WWE

Advertisement

4. Pay-Per-View Output

WWE.com

Before digging into the meat of this one and explaining the decision, it's important to state that AEW does pay-per-view very well. Each one All Elite has produced to date has felt worthwhile, if not must-see, and the fact the calendar isn't littered with unnecessary events makes their supershow output easy to digest.

Advertisement

Does that mean WWE don't do pay-per-view well? No, it doesn't.

OK, so nobody could point to filler shows like Super ShowDown, Elimination Chamber, TLC and the like as shining beacons of the supershow world. They're hardly essential compared to rip-roaring specials like Royal Rumble or WrestleMania, and yet they have one thing in their favour. That old chestnut, the WWE Network.

Advertisement

Until things change (which they could this year), WWE offers more bang for your buck. If timed correctly, fans could've watched that epic Rumble 2020 show for free with a trial. It's easy to forget just how excellent that night was, or how much value a Network sub comes with.

If WWE switch back to a more traditional method of pay-per-view, then this result would change with it. Until then, they nose ahead here.

Advertisement

Winner: WWE

3. Storyline Logic

AEW

As good as recent angles involving Randy Orton, Edge and Beth Phoenix were, they lacked some simple psychology. Here's a quick example. If Orton really wanted to save Edge from himself the night after Royal Rumble like he told Beth, why didn't he go after another body part? WWE expected fans to temporarily buy in to the idea that Randy had tried to stop Edge from breaking his neck by...almost breaking his neck?

Advertisement

Little touches like that one don't seem to count for much under Vince McMahon's watch.

Over in AEW, those flourishes are everything. The logic Tony Khan's company has shown in feuds like Cody vs. MJF or the infighting amongst 'The Elite' is more grounded. Seeing Nick Jackson re-focus his brother Matt at Revolution and remind him that he shouldn't injure a friend before trying to win the Tag-Team Titles was stellar work.

Advertisement

Everything carries more weight in AEW's world. Storylines, with few exceptions (not every single one is going to be a winner), are easier to follow, and they're easier to invest in because the workers playing each role react like real human beings during promos.

Winner: AEW

Advertisement

2. Match Quality

AEW

Another no contest.

Advertisement

Whether you prefer a bit more in-ring psychology to your matches or not, it's true that AEW is the place to be for pure wrestling thrills. This writer did roll his eyes a few times at the litany of near falls towards the end of The Young Bucks vs. Kenny Omega and Hangman Page at Revolution, but even he can't claim they didn't give the audience exactly what they wanted.

People in Chicago craved that sort of epic-ness, and they were willing to suspend their disbelief if one of the four refused to sell for longer than two seconds before moving onto the next spot. In terms of giving the core fanbase following the product what they want to see bell-to-bell, AEW does a much better job than WWE.

Advertisement

Every match seems important, even on Dynamite, and that's a great thing. Combine that with a hungry roster who are left to their own devices and things get even better. Regardless of personal preference (and this guy, again, would like a bit less in the way of 'movez' and way more selling), AEW's matches are high quality.

Only a fool would insist some of this stuff isn't blistering.

Advertisement

Winner: AEW

1. Depth Of Content

WWE.com

It'd be a real challenge for WWE to go back to the way things were pre-Network. That subscription service is a titan of good value, and it's the only library of wrestling some fans will need. Without the back up of stunning documentaries, almost every supershow ever and endless hours of TV history, the company would struggle to sell their latest pay-per-view.

Advertisement

The depth of content in WWE's archives is quite staggering.

Away from the Network, things are also positive. If someone doesn't like what's presented on Raw or SmackDown, they'll probably enjoy NXT or NXT UK. If nothing modern suits there, then it's back online for some old-school Attitude era stuff, or huge amounts of content from WCW, ECW and other historic promotions.

Advertisement

AEW can't boast that. If individual fans tune into Dynamite and don't like what's presented, there's nowhere for them to go. It's not like Dark is significantly different to the main show. WWE has something for every taste, and that sets them apart.

Winner: WWE

Advertisement

WINNER: WWE

WWE

Cue an outcry of hysteria from hardcore AEW fans or WWE haters on social media. Cue hatred for the guy writing this. Cue Vince McMahon's smug smile.

Advertisement

His WWE takes home a 6-4 victory here. They're superior in terms of production, commentary (thanks largely to Mauro Ranallo), roster depth, overall star power, big-time pay-per-view and sheer volume of content. Meanwhile, AEW can crow about better freedom for wrestlers, respectful nostalgia, overall logic and match quality.

It was close, but McMahon gets the prize. There is hope for AEW however. If Tony Khan's company continues to progress at the rate it has in that first year, then it should be taken seriously as a genuine alternative to WWE, and it can definitely force McMahon to be more proactive.

Advertisement

The opening line perhaps said it best. "This article is not going to go down well with sections of the pro wrestling audience".

It probably hasn't.

Advertisement

Do you agree with the outcome of each category? For more wrestling, check out WWE 2K21: 10 Ways To Save A Dying Franchise and 10 Times Wrestlers Ignored All Advice!