What a year it's been for nerds. Superheroes continue to dominate the cinema (even when they're ones you'd previously never heard of) and have staked their claim on your disposable income up through the next decade, Comic-Con finally started to return to actually being about comic books, and the industry as a whole has gone from strength to strength in terms of quality, invention, and diversity. The latter has been a particular sticking point for a form that's been dominated by white dudes since the dawn of the four-colour printing press, and let to the stagnation of the former two. 2014, meanwhile, has seen more and more women and people of colour producing work with similarly diverse characters, from the all-ages and queer-friendly girl scout adventures of Lumberjanes through to the new Ms Marvel Kamala Khan, a Muslim teenager. It's been twelve months of leaps and bounds for comic books, but that journey's not been without a few stumbles along the way. It's still an industry dominated not only be a certain demographic but also certain attitudes towards gender, race, creativity vs making money, and trying oh-so-desperately to build your own cinematic universe because they have one and we don't and IT'S NOT FAIR. In many ways this has been one of the best years for comics in a good long while, but it didn't get there without having to navigating a few bumps in the road along the way. Here are the ten biggest comics controversies of 2014: Racism! Transphobia! Making Grant Gustin cry! Excelsior!
10. The Sony Leak
Just when it looked like the entertainment sector had peaked for 2014, coasting by on the goodwill from the long-teased Star Wars trailer and the inevitably big box office receipts from the final Hobbit film (for now anyway), Sony had to go and have its systems hacked. Which meant that some unreleased tentpole pictures made their way onto file sharing websites but, even more excitingly, all their emails leaked onto the internet too. It's a little bit mud rake-y to trawl through all of this private correspondence, but it's also exciting in a pulling aside the curtain sort of way, discovering that Aaron Sorkin's reputation hasn't quite recovered from those wilderness years between The West Wing and The Social Network, and that Channing Tatum writes emails in exactly the sort of way you'd think and hope he would. For comic fans the big news to come out of this was regarding Spider-Man, the Marvel superhero Sony still own the rights too. Apparently they're considering all sorts of ways to take the franchise, including plans to hand the film rights over to Marvel unfortunately plans to give him back for the third Captain America film were nixed. And everyone was much happier not knowing that thank you very much.
9. Batgirl Is Transphobic
The other recent addition to this year's comic book outcries came just this past week, from a very unlikely source. Since DC rebooted their whole continuity (long story) (long, stupid story) Barbara Gordon has been out of the wheelchair she was put in during classic graphic novel The Killing Joke and back on duty as Batgirl, with a new series written by regular Gail Simone which introduced one of the company's first major transgender characters in Babs's room mate Alysia Yeoh. Simone recently left the book due to editorial intereference that made the book uncharacteristically dark, something which has been totally undone by a fresh new take on the character by writers Brendan Fletcher and Cameron Stewart and artist Babs Tarr, who have moved Batgirl over to Gotham's equivalent of Brooklyn (hip, young, free of masked vigilantes) and attempted to provide a progressive, modern take on young womanhood. Casual sex and all. It looked like everything was on the up and up until a recent issue where it turned out an impostor Batgirl who had been bothering Babs since the new creative team's debut issue was actually a man, who was depicted as being dangerously deranged and murderous not a particularly helpful characterisation of gender fluidity. Unlike the rest of the mistakes on this list, Stewart, Fletcher and Tarr actually apologised. And did it properly, which was nice.
8. Comic-Con Volunteer Is A Big Old Racist
Many of the issues reflected in comic books are symptomatic of a wider cultural cancer, as is the case with the worrying spate of murders of young black people by older white men in the US. The white men being almost universally cops and almost universally they don't get charged for the murders is even more troubling. It's also impossible to argue with: if, say, you side with police officer Darren Wilson, who shot unarmed 18-year-old Michael Brown to death? You're a racist. Still, there are people who think that it isn't quite as simple an issue as that, and for some reason one of them is somebody involved in organising San Diego Comic-Con. SDCC has become not only the biggest comics convention in the world but also the place where the majority of the entertainment industry will make its big announcements for the year ahead, with Hollywood and TV execs rubbing shoulders with funnybook folk. All the more troubling, then, that one Comic-Con International volunteer known as Bill in San diego chose to take to Twitter in the light of the Michael Brown murder and post a series of inflammatory and disturbing messages. SDCC have since identified Bill Purcell as someone who's volunteered at the show for over a decade, before quickly distancing themselves from him.
7. David Finch And Wonder Woman's Feminism
Bill Azzarello and Cliff Chiang's run on Wonder Woman came to an end this year, a series that wasn't without its own controversies, like the rejigged origin story that saw Diana Prince as the actual daughter of a couple of Greek Gods, and a lot less like a badass Amazonian superhero. Still, it was a good run in other ways especially when the character has been pigeon-holed into simply being Superman's girlfriend in every other book she appears in. The Azzarello and Chiang Wonder Woman didn't sell like gangbusters but it did receive consistent critical praise and had a noticeably vocal fan base. The news that they would be leaving the book and handing over the reigns to wife-and-husband writer-and-artist (respectively) team Meredith and David Finch was met with some trepidation which, following a couple of interviews with the pair, appeared to be confirmed. We want her to be a strong - I don't want to say feminist, but a strong character. That is the David Finch quote that got picked out of DC's long, mostly boring interview with the couple with the announcement. Wonder Woman was designed as a feminist icon, and has rarely been considered anything else, and Finch treating the word like a negative didn't help matters either. Since then he's backpedalled significantly, and the publisher's PR department have kept him on a tight leash, but the damage was done. And the comic sucks.
6. Creepy Sexy Power Puff Girls Cover
Sugar. Spice. And everything nice. These were the ingredients chosen to create the perfect little girls...except then Professor Utonium accidentally threw in some Chemical X with the rest of the ingredients and thus, the Power Puff Girls were born! The cult favourite Cartoon Network series with magical girl anime stylings, a sharp sense of humour and kicking soundtrack returned this year thanks to a new comic book series published by IDW. The comic retains the stylised artwork of the series, alongside the similar wit and really much too clever writing for a book that is mostly menaced by a hyper-intelligent monkey with an exposed brain called Mojo Jojo, hoping to appeal to the same audience it did when it was on TV: not only the hip older crowd who grew up with it, but also the young kids attracted to the cartoony look (not to mention the Cartoon Network branding). So then who was Mimi Yoon's variant cover for the sixth issue for? Perverts. Really gross perverts. The little girls (who are meant to be, like, middle-schoolers at the oldest) are depicted as older, sexualised figures who nonetheless retain their infantalised big eyes, outfits and hairdos. Yeesh. After an outcry Cartoon Networks licensing division confirmed they would be pulling Yoons cover.
5. New Flash Movie Upsets New Flash TV Show
Struggling to play catch-up with Marvel's well-established (and cash-rich) Cinematic Universe, this year saw DC accidentally kinda sorta announcing their entire slate of superhero films up through 2020 during an investor meeting, the info of which inevitably leaked and lead to a fairly low-key official confirmation not long after. Amongst that schedule of forthcoming blockbusters include some characters who are already gracing our screens. Besides the already known (or else assumed) new Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman and Justice League films there were the surprise solo outings for Aquaman, Cyborg, Suicide Squad and The Flash. The latter of which was a particular shock because DC had just launched a new scarlet speedster on the small screen not a week beforehand, with Grant Gustin slipping into the role for the CW TV show that's actually super good. The Flash television series has had some of the highest ratings in its channels history, but that news seems to have been somewhat overshadowed by not only the existence of a movie, but one in which the character will be played by feted young actor Ezra Miller. Stephen Amell, star of other DC TV series Arrow, has spoken out by essentially saying that was a d*ck move on Warner Bros part.
4. The Artist Of Rat Queens Gets Fired (For Good Reason)
Rat Queens is one of those aforementioned great strides forwards in terms of providing new, interesting and diverse female characters in a comic book landscape that's mostly dominated by either subservient, one-dimensional girlfriends or else equally shallow badasses, both of which are expected to wear ludicrously revealing outfits and contort their bodies into anatomically impossible poses on a regular basis. Compared to all of that, Rat Queens is positively progressive. An Image series about an all-female group of adventurers in a Dungeons & Dragons-style fantasy world who drink, shag and murder to the point that all the males in their town are scared of them (not to mention a few of the women too), the Rat Queens are a more boorish, flawed and funny group than is used to gracing comic books. The fact that the creators are a couple of dudes isn't ideal, but it's a step in the right direction. As has been the immediate reaction to the news that co-creator and artist Roc Upchurch had been arrested for beating his wife. Writer Kurtis J Wiebe, in a refreshing zero tolerance policy, swiftly replaced Upchurch with new artist Stjepan Šeji for the foreseeable future. See? That's how you deal with unacceptable behaviour in comic books.
3. Sexist Merchandise
On the other hand is the way that the Big Two publishers (Flash Fact: that means Marvel and DC) pitches their merchandise. Specifically the shaky gender lines they draw for everything from board games to clothing, from ages toddler and up. It's an issue that's prevalent across all forms of toys and other such products aimed at kids, which have long bought into the traditional read: boring gender binary. That doesn't make it any less glaring that, in this day and age, there are still ridiculous examples of sexist merchandise as has been drawn attention to throughout 2014. Gamora was missing from the majority of Guardians Of The Galaxy merchandise available at the Disney store, and female superheroes are absent from the majority of stuff pitched at kids because presumably boys find girls icky, and girls are busy with Barbie. Then there was the Justice League: Axis of Villains board game that didn't feature a single female character to play as, much to one eight-year-old-girl's disappointment. DC also sold t-shirts and even toddler pyjamas with sexist connotations, and a particularly troubling books for kids just hit the stands. Not a good year for progressive ideas of gender, in many ways.
2. Milo Manara's Spider-Woman Cover
All of which are examples of a problem with not only the wider culture in general but also comic books, which still struggle with breaking out of this imagined sole audience of straight white male dudes. That may have been the principal readership of comics in the early days and they certainly appear to dominate conventions, shops and message boards to this day, but all sorts of people read comic books. Why wouldn't they? They're awesome. Despite some of the previous examples, this year has actually seen publishers finally reaching out for those different audiences. The new spate of Bat books over at DC have been pitched towards hip women (Batgirl) and the young adult novel crowd (Gotham Academy), whilst Marvel have been courting a similarly diverse readership with the new Muslim Ms Marvel and the promise of an upcoming Spider-Woman series. Sure, it's being written by Dennis Hopeless and drawn by Greg Land, but it's a Spider-Book being headlined by a woman! Pretty cool. Considering the publisher has been pretty nakedly going after the female audience, choosing Milo Manara to draw a variant cover of the series is spectacularly wrong-headed. The Italian erotica artist has worked for Marvel before, but his absolutely awful (and super sexist) Spider-Woman painting was one of the biggest mistakes of the year, and one of the biggest controversies. The level of outcry online and elsewhere saw them pulling the cover altogether.
1. DC Poison An Ohio Water Supply
2014 has, in many ways, been a year when the comics industry tries to move forward from its roots, and from a lot of its more troubling, ingrained prejudices and old-fashioned attitudes. That hasn't always been successful, and they've certainly made their fair share of mistakes along the way, but ultimately things are looking up. So, to cap off the year in comic book controversies, here's a story that hasn't been reported on quite nearly as much as it should've been especially considering it sounds like a supervillain's scheme. Whilst it has being very much looking forward to the future, 2014 also saw DC leaning on some wonderfully old-school gimmicks to try and boost sales, including falling back into the nineties speculator boom trope of providing shiny covers to try and entice people into buying flagging books. They planned to provide 3D variant covers for climactic final issues of their year-long crossover event Future's End, a process which apparently requires certain special chemicals. One of which is called microcystin, and is highly toxic. Exactly the sort of thing you wouldn't want to, say, get into a municipal water supply. Woops, that's exactly what happened though! Some sort of spill at the printing plant were the books were being published caused the deadly toxin to end up in Lake Eerie, which provides the water supply of eleven million coastal inhabitants in Northwestern Ohio. Yes, DC poisoned the water supply of eleven million people. Lex Luthor would be proud. It's going to be tough to top that in 2015! And please, Dan DiDio, don't take that as a challenge.