10 Comic Book Story Arcs EVERYONE Hated
Those story arcs everyone wishes Thanos would snap out of existence.
Watching the Hulk smashing a monster through a building or the Avengers battling aliens in space sounds like the coolest thing in the world at first, but you'd be surprised how quickly readers get desensitised to this sort of spectacle.
To keep the fans invested, publishers regularly release story arcs that aren't just epic, but bold, zany, and a little bit controversial.
Sometimes, these storylines work. In The Infinity Gauntlet, Thanos wiped out half of all life in the universe. In Crisis on Infinite Earths, the Anti-Monitor ended all realities save for one. Not only were these events amazing, they helped shape the world of comics for years to come.
But more often than not, these daring story arcs drop the ball. Sometimes creators try to do something ambitious but go too far, creating a plot that's non-sensical, convoluted, or downright disrespectful. These series can be so abominable, they have tarnished a given comic's legacy, ended a whole line of comics, or put the publishing company on the verge of bankruptcy.
Here are 10 comic story arcs that most comics readers just absolutely detest.
10. Amazons Attack
When Wonder Woman was held in a detention centre by the US government, her mother, Hippolyta, saw her imprisonment as a declaration of war. This inspired the Queen of Themyscira to order the Amazons to invade Washington D.C.
As a concept, that plot synopsis sounds totally fine.
But when the first issue opens with Amazons slaying innocent civilians (including children), you know Amazons Attack was doomed from the beginning. Because Hippolyta acts uncharacteristically cruel, readers naturally assumed she was a supervillain posing as Wonder Woman's mother, especially since she was considered dead at this point. Even when we learn this is the one and true Hippolyta, you may assume the story can redeem itself if it turns out she was mind-controlled.
But she wasn't. Hippolyta slaughtered thousands of innocent people of her own volition.
Not only that, Wonder Woman barely appears in the story. (She only appears in the first issue for one page.) Amazons Attack may not be the worst DC comic but it is a shoe-in for one of the worst Wonder Woman comics for sure.
9. All Star Batman & Robin, The Boy Wonder
In 2005, DC Comics launched a rebooted series of the Caped Crusader called All Star Batman & Robin. With visionary writer Frank Miller joining fan favourite artist Jim Lee, it sounded like the series couldn't be in safer hands.
But Miller managed to create the worst Batman story ever written. The moment where the Dark Knight introduces himself as "the Goddamned Batman" has been memed to death but it's only one of many absurd moments in this failed saga.
Batman kidnaps Robin immediately after his parents die, punches him in the face, and abandons him in the Batcave, forcing him to live off rats. The Justice League are written as whiney and intolerable. Bats has sex with Black Canary while a biker gang they just murdered burns to death in the background. Batman paints himself yellow and beats up Green Lantern.
If you thought that sounds awful, the original script is more embarrassing. In the scene where Vicki Vale struts in her bra and panties, Miller wrote notes like, "Detail her bra. It'll drive them crazy." "Give them an ASS shot." "Make them drool."
When you read notes like that, it's not too surprising the planned follow up to All Star Batman & Robin never came to fruition.
8. Xorn Gets Retconned
In X-Men Annual 2001, the titular heroes discover a mutant called Xorn. Because Xorn's mutation caused his brain to develop a star, he must wear a specially designed helmet to risk incinerating everyone around him. Believing Xorn to be a compassionate man, the X-Men invited him into their ranks.
But during the Planet X saga, Xorn revealed he was none other than Magneto! At the time, this was a great twist since Mags had infiltrated the X-Men mansion when they were at their most vulnerable. However, the story arc goes off the rails when the Master of Magnetism destroys most of New York and murders Jean Grey, before later perishing in Cassandra Nova's genocidal attack on the mutant haven of Genosha.
Now, since Marvel can't just kill off the X-Men's arch-nemesis, we know Magneto would come back somehow. So what did the creative team do? Was this Magneto a clone? A robot? An illusion?
Nope, it turns out that Magneto WAS Xorn after all! This means that Xorn was pretending to be Magneto... pretending to be Xorn.
And that sums up why so many readers have such a hard time getting into the X-Men...
7. Countdown
52 was a weekly series revolving around the DC superheroes dealing with Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman taking a sabbatical for a year.
Despite the fact 52 was heavily praised DC editor Dan DiDio loathed it. Even though Didio devised 52's concept, he was furious how little control he had over how the story unfolded. According to Mark Waid, who helped pen the story, Didio would "storm up and down the halls, telling everybody how much he hated it".
As a result, Didio created a follow-up series called Countdown which he referred to as "52 done right". But it was anything but. The story is so inconsistent, the average reader would have to read every single tie-in to have the slightest clue what's going on.
As bad as Countdown starts, it gets so much worse when it introduces Superboy-Prime as one of the Big Bads. Prime may have been whiny in Infinite Crisis and Sinestro's War but he is an insufferable man-child in Countdown, spouting dialogue like, "I'll kill you to death!"
Countdown turned out so abysmally, many big moments like Jimmy Olsen learning of Superman's identity, Darkseid's death, and the demise of the New Gods, was retconned almost immediately.
6. Ultimates 3
Even though the modern Marvel reboot, Ultimate Marvel, was considered a huge success for years, it was ultimately cancelled after a staggering drop in quality.
If you had to pinpoint the exact moment where the Ultimate universe began bursting from the seams it would have to be the third volume of the Ultimates, which replaced writer Mark Millar with Jeph Loeb.
Very simply, everything about this story is ridiculous. Wolverine is unveiled as the father of Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver. Wolverine cruelly and uncharacteristically makes fun of Hawkeye's murdered family. Pyro, who is meant to be a reformed supervillain, turns out to be a rapist. Captain America pretends to be Black Panther and it's never explained why. Ultron talks about vibrators. (That actually happens.) A sex tape of Tony Stark and Black Widow leaks and the Ultimates put it on full-display on a massive screen so everyone can see it.
Not only that, we learn Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch are in a sexual relationship despite the fact they're brother and sister. Weirder still, none of the Ultimates have a problem with it! When Captain America (who is actually Ultron in disguise) points out how inappropriate the twins' behaviour is, Wasp teases him for being old-fashioned!
Tragically, this isn't even the worst the Ultimates had to offer...
5. Ultimatum
Ultimates 3 may have been the first sign of dwindling quality in the Ultimate universe but Ultimatum was the final nail in the coffin. The saga begins with Magneto reversing the Earth's poles, causing entire cities to freeze or be consumed by tidal waves, killing tens of millions.
In events like this, it's not too uncommon for one or two big names to bite the dust (for a while). But during this series, over 30 main characters die including Cyclops, Daredevil, Doctor Strange, Angel, Nightcrawler, Magneto, Professor X, and Wolverine.
What's worse is that many superheroes and supervillains' deaths are gratuitously violent. Doctor Strange's head bursts like a zit. Blob devours Wasp while comparing the taste of her entrails to chicken, and Hank Pym bites Blob's head off in retaliation. Ultimatum is so grisly, it feels like one is reading horror fan-fiction rather than a real comic.
Writer, Jeph Loeb, tried so hard to tell a story that was edgy and shocking but it's self-evident he overplayed his hand. Although the comics had some great moments after this travesty (including the creation of Miles Morales in Ultimate Spider-Man, which managed to exist unpurturbed by the craziness of the other Ultimate books), the sales never recovered and the Ultimate universe was discontinued in 2015.
4. Heroes In Crisis
After Barry Allen died during the first ever Crisis his sidekick, Wally West, became the new Scarlet Speedster. When Barry returned to life decades later, readers assumed Wally would still play a significant role in the comics. I mean, it's not like he's going to be kicked to the curb after being the Flash for 33 years, right?
Actually, what DC did was worse. When the New 52 was launched, Wally West was erased as if he never existed. For half a decade, Wally was nowhere to be seen.
So, when he was reintroduced in DC Rebirth, fans were beyond excited. However, that excitement turned to horror when multiple superheroes were murdered in the Heroes in Crisis storyline, including Wally. Just to REALLY tick off fans, the story concludes by revealing that the superheroes were murdered by Wally and the "dead Wally" was placed to throw everyone off his scent!
But guess what? It gets worse!! The higher ups at DC then decided to redeem Wally by transforming him into the new Doctor Manhattan! Wally has suffered so many character assassinations recently, it would've been better if he was never reincorporated back in the comics.
3. Heroes Reborn
The Spider-Man and X-Men comics were a big hit in the 1990s but other Marvel properties such as the Fantastic Four, Captain America, Iron Man, and the Avengers were tanking big-time.
To counter this, the House of Ideas had these characters killed off in the conclusion of the Onslaught saga and had them relaunched in a separate universe. Marvel rehired artists and Image creators, Jim Lee and Rob Liefeld, to reboot these flagging series under the banner, Heroes Reborn.
Although some of the series sold well at first, the new lineup was shredded by critics. Even though the storylines were bland and the dialogue was ridiculous, it was the artwork that drew the most criticism. Many of the characters were drawn with tiny noses, bulging biceps and pecs, and absurdly thin legs. Thor's muscles are so disproportionate, his body resembles a sock full of walnuts. Rob Liefeld's Captain America's chest juts out so much it's been lampooned for years after. (Also, because Liefeld was in charge, every character has a costume equipped with 37 pouches - including the Fantastic Four.)
Only a year after Heroes Reborn launched, Marvel realised the reboot was a mistake and so, reincorporated all the characters back into the main continuity.
2. One More Day
When the Kingpin learned of Spider-Man's identity during the Civil War event, he hired an assassin to shoot Peter Parker's Aunt May. Left gravelly wounded, Peter made a deal with the lord of hell, Mephisto, to spare her life.
The demon promised to create a new reality where May lives but only at the cost of Peter's marriage with Mary-Jane Watson, with Mephisto also promising to erase Spidey's unmasking in Civil War from reality.
Defying common sense, Peter and MJ agreed to these terms. Readers loathed this storyline as it unravelled Peter and Mary-Jane's marriage reversing decades of continuity in an instant.
What makes this story worse is that Marvel could've undone it. In the storyline, One Moment in Time, it is finally explained what happened in the new reality that prevented Peter and MJ's marriage. It turns out Peter failed to show up at his wedding because... a criminal fell on him and knocked him out.
It's also explained in One Moment in Time that Peter saved May's life simply by performing CPR despite the fact every medical expert (including Doctor Strange and Doctor Doom) said reviving her was impossible.
One Moment in Time could have taken the sting off One More Day but it ended up making a reviled story even worse.
1. Secret Empire
When the Super Serum flowing through Captain America's veins was nullified, he rapidly aged, turning him into an elderly man. Luckily, Steve Rogers was exposed to the Cosmic Cube two years later, returning him to normal.
Since Cap had been out of action for a while, readers were excited to see the patriotic Avenger's latest adventures. So, how did Marvel kick off his return in Captain America: Steve Rogers #1? By turning Winghead into an agent of the fascist regime, Hydra! Worse still, we learn Cap has been working for Hydra from the very beginning.
Not only was this an absurd gimmick, turning Cap into a super-Nazi was offensive since the character was created by Jewish creators Joe Simon and Jack Kirby as a distinctly anti-fascist symbol. Marketing around the event depicted Captain America with fascist-adjacent imagery, compounding what was an already ill-thought out storyline even further.
Throughout the event Marvel also maintained that this was the REAL Captain America. But it turns out this Cap was created by a corrupted Cosmic Cube. The story doesn't mention this until the very end so readers believed Captain America betrayed his teammates for well over a year, which was encouraged by Marvel themselves.
By the time the readers learned this wasn't the real Steve Rogers, they were too angry to care.