10 DC Heroes Who Were Once Criminals
Not every hero has the typical origin story.
The journey of a hero is never really set in stone - especially when it comes to the various continuities that can exist within different versions of a comic book universe. In one universe, for example, they might be seen as a hero, while in another they’re considered a villain.
Elsewhere, however, there are comic book heroes who simply have a totally different beginning from that of the typical Batman or Superman origin story. Instead of starting out as an alien from a foreign planet or as a billionaire orphan, characters might begin life as a professional thief, or even as an assassin, long before deciding to switch sides.
So, while not all heroes start out in the sunlight, that doesn't mean that they have to in order to be considered a hero later on. Some of the most famous and beloved superheroes were once criminals, proving that redemption isn't as elusive as readers may think. So, with this in mind, here are 10 DC heroes who were once criminals.
10. Ravager (Rose Wilson)
As the daughter of the infamous Deathstroke the Terminator, Rose Wilson didn't really have much of a chance for a happy childhood. His relationship to her alone often brought the attention of enemies like Wade Defarge - the first Ravager. Rose had initially been kidnapped by Defarge, after learning that she was Slade's offspring, and had planned to use her to torment Slade. It was also during this encounter that Rose had learned from Defarge that she was indeed Slade's daughter.
Slade himself decided not to intervene, however, because he thought it was best for him not interfere in her life. This unfortunately left Rose without a parent in the long run, though, as her mother Lilian Worth would die during the efforts to rescue her from Defarge. Later on, Slade finally decides to forgo his earlier decision by setting into motion a plan to capture Rose and kill her foster parents.
Once she is in his custody, Slade then explains to Rose that he wanted to renew their relationship by having her as an apprentice. Seeing Slade as her only family left, Rose decides to accept his offer- and her first mission is to kill Wade Defarge. After doing this, Rose then takes DeFarge's moniker and becomes the new Ravager- continuing to serve as Slade's partner in crime under this name.
Rose ultimately suffers from the effects of Slade's manipulative will, though, and even goes so far as to gauge out her own eye as a sign of her loyalty to him. Eventually, Rose decides to leave her father for the Titans, after finding out that he had knowingly exposed her to the carcinogenic effects of Kryptonite.
9. Wonder Girl (Cassandra Sandsmark)
As a single mother, archaeologist Dr. Helena Sandsmark often took her daughter with her to the various dig sites that she had visited all around the world. Unknowingly, though, it was this very quality of her work that acted as an alibi for the thefts that were committed by her daughter, Cassandra Sandsmark- who had often stolen from museums within the countries that her mother had been currently visiting.
At one point, though, Cassandra's career in crime was nearly ended, after being caught in the act by a security guard. Yet, she escapes imprisonment, after a random stranger knocks this guard unconscious. The stranger's name, as it turns out, was Diesel - a man who had immediately recognized that Cassandra was a thief. Rather than turn her in, however, he confesses to her that he was a professional thief himself, and offers to work with her as a partner.
They would then go on to commit more heists together, and even grow closer to each other romantically. Eventually, though, their luck would soon run out during an encounter with a parasitic alien armor. Here, Diesel becomes engulfed by this sentient armor, and in response, Cassandra attempts to save him by convincing it that she would be a far better host than him.
Convinced, the armor then latches on to Cassandra- which would inevitably come back to bite her later on. Despite her saving him, though, Diesel immediately resents Cassandra for interfering- saying that she had taken all of the power for herself. It was at this point then when Cassandra finally realized that Diesel had never really loved her. She then abandons her thieving pursuits not long after this- where she would later find her true calling as the superhero Wonder Girl.
8. Booster Gold (Michael Carter)
The fame-hungry attitude that Booster Gold darns can sometimes imply a completely superficial personality- even though his backstory indicates otherwise. Michael Carter's beginnings in the 25th century initially had him starting out growing up in an impoverished family, which had often suffered from the debts acquired by Micheal's gambling father.
To improve his lot in life, Michael eventually decides to pursue a career as a professional athlete, which he saw as a promising opportunity for a wealthy existence. His efforts to achieve this goal were supplemented further by his accomplishments as an excellent American college football player.
His plans, however, would unfortunately take a sudden turn, after his mother becomes severely ill. Michael then starts to gamble on the games that he had played in, and subsequently won, in order to take home all the cash that had been been betted on his team. He would then use that money to pay for his mother's treatments. He was soon found out by school officials and law enforcement alike, however, and as a result, he was expelled from his college and arrested for gambling.
Ironically, though, had this not have happened, Michael wouldn’t have needed to work at the Metropolis Space Museum. While there, he would later commit yet another crime by stealing some historical superhero gear, and a time machine that would send him back to the 21st century.
7. Tigress (Artemis Crock)
Current continuity holds that Artemis Crock is a hero who grew out of a family with major ties to the League of Assassins. In her original comic book debut, however, Artemis was actually cast as a villain. Similar to her heroic counterpart on Young Justice, Artemis originally went by her birth name, Artemis, and then later became Tigress (which had initially been her mother's moniker).
Despite her status though, Artemis would not remain a villain forever and would have a change of heart following the death of a fellow teammate (who was killed as a part of a plot designed by the leader of the Injustice Society). She and her romantic partner, Icicle, then decide to leave the Injustice Society to act independently as a duo.
Even though they decide to go solo, the two would have to later reconsider their villainous motivations once again, after Artemis becomes pregnant. Icicle himself becomes very preoccupied with the pregnancy, due to his worry that Artemis would die in childbirth just as his own mother with him. Under these circumstances, Artemis and Icicle would decide to forgo their villainous intentions in favor of teaming up with the JSA to find a magical staff, that could help Artemis safely give birth to their metahuman child.
Although they do not succeed in obtaining the staff, the JSA nevertheless vouches on their behalf, after they had sought out professional assistance for their pregnancy. With this taken care of, Artemis can thus safely give birth. Later on, the new parents would finally then retire to raise their daughter within a stable environment.
6. Harley Quinn (Harleen Quinzel)
Even though Harley Quinn's role in the DC Universe reflects more of an anti-hero leaning, she nevertheless has moments of heroism within other continuities. For example, she is clearly seen as a hero within the Injustice comic book series.
Although Harley started off as an assistant to the Joker’s mad scheme of destroying Superman’s spirit, it was nevertheless in the aftermath of his death that she had finally realized her true potential as a solo act. Now far away from the Joker's influence, Harley finds genuine purpose in fighting against the developing Superman regime, as a member of Batman’s resistance organization. She was also one of the more optimistic ones of the bunch, where she had an incredible tenacity to keep fighting even against heavy hitters like Shazam.
Harley would then later become instrumental in the regime’s eventual defeat, by establishing an anarchist following of civilians who worked to both undermine the regime’s control over the world, as well as ensure the protection of those who had suffered under the regime's might.
5. Beast Boy (Garfield Logan)
Following the death of his parents, Garfield Logan would have to suffer the abuse of various adults who would seek to use his transformative powers for their own personal gain. He was at first abducted by some American bandits who were originally hired by an African witch doctor, who originally had a vendetta against the Logan family. Due to an unexpected turn of events, Gar would then be used by these men to commit crimes for them in exchange for their protection.
Although they would eventually kill one another, Garfield would soon find himself manipulated once again, but this time by an evil circus owner. The owner would then proceed to use Garfield by hypnotizing him to not only steal from the audience but unwillingly perform for him as the star attraction for his circus.
In time, however, the Teen Titans would free Garfield of his influence and finally end this cycle of abuse. Later on, Gar would eventually find a home with the Doom Patrol and join their team as the hero Beast Boy. He would eventually also join the Teen Titans under the same name.
4. Orphan (Cassandra Cain)
Similar to Rose Wilson's upbringing, Cassandra Cain was the daughter of two of the most powerful trained killers from the League of Assassins. Specifically being the daughter of Lady Shiva and David Cain - the latter, of which, who had raised Cassandra from birth to be a weapon of destruction.
During her training, Cassandra had learned to read the body language of an opponent well enough so that she could determine what their next move was, as well as hone in on their weak points. This had unfortunately limited her ability to communicate vocally, though, and it also left her slightly dyslectic.
As a witness to her father’s work, Cassandra seemingly became desensitized to death. Though when it finally came time for her to actually kill someone, her actions would nevertheless prove otherwise. Reading the body language of the dying man that she had just killed, leaves Cassandra incredibly distraught - whereupon she immediately turns on her father. Cassandra then attacks David out of rage and finally leaves him for good.
She eventually finds herself in Gotham City, where Cassandra meets Barbra Gordon (aka Oracle). In the time that Cassandra spends in helping her with random errands, Barbra soon learns that Cassandra has had some martial arts training in the past. Barbra becomes so impressed by Cassandra's advanced capabilities, that she even begins to consider her as a potential successor to her Batgirl title.
Cassandra would later indeed become the new Batgirl, though she would later take on a name of her own as the vigilante Orphan.
3. Clayface (Basil Karlo)
Although most might solely see him as a villain from Batman's rogues gallery, the recent updates to Clayface’s arc have nevertheless put him in league with the Batfamily. Prior to this, Basil Karlo (aka Clayface) would try his hand at fighting Batman through villain based organizations, like the Secret Society of Super-Villains, as well through any of the many hair-brained schemes previously concocted by other Gotham based villains.
Over the years, however, Basil began to grow weary of his criminal ventures that really weren't much of a success. Basil then decides to throw in the towel and proceeds to spend his days watching old films that he had acted in before he was irreversibly transformed into a monster. Batman then later finds Clayface like this, and rather than let him waste away in his own misery, he instead offers him the chance to find fulfillment in protecting Gotham City.
He then accepts Batman's offer and joins the efforts to contain the actual monsters that Hugo Strange had then unleashed onto Gotham City. Though it is certainly a departure from the traditionalist view of him, Clayface’s arc is nevertheless a reminder that villains are capable of redemption.
2. Huntress (Helena Bertinelli)
Most might assume that Batman would expect all Gotham vigilantes to follow his “no killing” code (but that wouldn’t necessarily be true). This doesn't mean that Batman abides those who kill, rather, there have been some in Gotham City who have gone about enforcing their own brands of justice.
Helena Bertinelli (aka Huntress) is a prominent example of this because her mission began as a vendetta to kill those who had murdered her parents. Before she became Huntress, Helena grew up in the shadow of organized crime - where her father was the leader of the Bertinelli crime family. His reign would one day come to a sudden end, however, when both he and his wife are assassinated as a part of an organized hit.
Following this incident, Helena would then set into motion a long-term plan for her revenge, by undergoing intense training in Italy - later then becoming the vigilante named Huntress. Batman himself would then learn of Helena's bloodthirstiness after she returns to Gotham City to start killing the men on her hit list. Batman obviously didn't trust her due to this quality of hers, but often just kept her at an arm's length when it came to crime-fighting.
She would finally come to earn his trust, however, during No Man’s Land, where Helena nearly sacrifices her life to protect innocent civilians. Eventually, Huntress would begin to forgo her deadly methods in favor of becoming closer to other vigilantes- like those a part of the Birds of Prey.
1. Plastic Man (Eel O’Brian)
Plastic Man is probably the most famous former criminal in comic book history, due to his past experiences as a thief leading him to become a superhero. In the beginning, Eel O’Brien was a part of a burglary ring that regularly committed heists with an established crew - of which O'Brien was relied on for his knack of cracking safes
On one fateful night, however, a botched heist at the Crawford Chemical Plant would lead to O'Brien being shot and exposed to a vat of chemicals. Though he manages to escape the incident, O'Brien would nevertheless discover that that the chemicals had given him the profound ability to stretch his body to extreme lengths. Still, he is left entirely distraught by this discovery and even goes so far as to contemplate suicide.
However, O'Brien was convinced otherwise by his partner, Woozy Winks - after he persuaded him to consider the profitability that was to be had as either a marketable superhero or a legendary criminal. The two inevitably decide on which path he would pursue based on the outcome of a coin toss.
Although obviously O'Brien later became Plastic Man, it was nevertheless the case that he didn't nearly see as many of the profits that had originally been promised to him. In the end, however, he is still far better off as a hero than as a villain (and really, we wouldn't have any other way).