10 Terrible Moments Featured In DC Comics' The New 52
Of all the terrible things about the New 52, these are some of the worst moments of the run.
Following the controversial Flashpoint storyline, the New 52 was a company-wide relaunch of all titles that began in September of 2011. It relaunched these titles with #1 issues and revamped continuity, starting many characters from square one. The idea was to eliminate the decades of continuity and history that some believed scared away new readers, and instead give these newbies a fresh place to start reading brand-new DC titles.
The New 52 also brought the Vertigo and Wildstorm imprints into the larger DC continuity, making those characters part of DC history. For example, former Justice League of America founding member Martian Manhunter was now a member of Stormwatch, and the Justice League makes its first appearance battling the incursion of Darkseid on Earth with former Teen Titan mainstay Cyborg as one of their core members.
While it had a few good stories and created a few ideas that endured, the New 52 was ultimately a failed experiment. The Powers That Be at DC alienated and angered their older readers by completely disregarding everything that came before. The rich history of legacy characters like Superman and Batman was a strength not a weakness. They forgot that while trying to entice new readers, instead of doing the one thing that always makes people want to pick up the books: write compelling stories.
Due to the reaction to the New 52, DC Comics rebooted once again after only five years, fixing most of those mistakes with Rebirth in June 2016.
10. Aquaman “Claims” Mera
There were not a lot of positives about the entire arc of the Convergence storyline. Brainiac had taken cities and heroes from various timelines and left them on a planet and then abandoned it. In Convergence: Justice League #1, Jesse Chambers has gone into labor at her baby shower and Zatanna, Vixen, and Jade hurry her to the hospital just as a dome goes up, robbing them of all their powers.
For a year, the heroes live regular lives but their friend and former Atlantean princess Mera was having trouble dealing with life as a land dweller. Just then, the doom fell and Tellos tells the cities that they must fight. A different Aquaman from the Flashpoint timeline sees a Mera like the one he lost and decides he must have her. Supergirl spots Mera being dragged away by Atlanteans who call forth a Kraken to block their escape.
Mera is brought before an Arthur that she knows is not hers. He forced a kiss on her and she punched him in the mouth. He said that he hoped in time that she could forget their differences and embrace each other. When she said that her friends would come for her, Aquaman laughed and said he welcomed all challenges.
9. Harley Forced Deadshot To Wear Joker’s Face
Harley Quinn’s obsession with the Joker goes to a whole new level. When she hears that he may be dead and that his face was removed by the Dollmaker, she abandons the Suicide Squad and runs to Gotham City. In Suicide Squad Vol. 4 # 7, Amanda Waller sent the Squad to Gotham and used the illusionary powers of Light and Lime to make King Shark look like Clayface while Deadshot and Savant infiltrated the Gotham Police Station.
While Harley is on her way to the evidence room to retrieve Joker’s face, she remembers her time as a psychiatrist at Arkham Asylum when she aided the Joker in his escape. At GCPD, Savant cornered Harley in the holding cells and they fought. She traps him in a cell on a pressure mine and told him to enjoy his stay. Outside, Light and Lime’s illusion broke down. King Shark and Waller exploded the nanobomb in Lime’s head for revealing the Squad’s existence.
Inside, Deadshot awakens tied to a chair. Harley stretches Joker’s severed face over his and demands to know why he left her, stating how she loved him. Deadshot/Joker said that he must prove it by killing the distractions in Batman’s life. She said that she knew Joker would return to her, just as Deadshot shot her in the stomach.
8. Batwoman’s Relationship Disaster
When a relationship is so beloved that its forced desolation caused two creators to quit in the real world, it’s easy to understand the upheaval it caused in the life of Batwoman. She is Kate Kane, a former decorated West Point cadet who was kicked out for being a lesbian. After being inspired by Batman and an extensive training course by her colonel father, she became Batwoman.
Kate met Maggie Sawyer, the head of the Gotham City Police Department Major Crimes Unit at a Police Charity Ball and the two began dating and, at one point, moved in together. Batwoman even asks Captain Sawyer to marry her. But in Batwoman # 34, Kate moves out. She made a deal with Maggie’s homophobic ex-husband to leave so that the man would drop his bid for full custody of his and Maggie's daughter. Kate broke up with Maggie in a letter.
Publisher Dan Didio claimed the reason that Kate and Maggie couldn’t get married was that taking up the cape and cowl meant giving up their personal lives to be heroes. And yet, they inexplicably had The Phantom Stranger get married and have two children. Additionally, there had been a number of successful DC marriages for years. Also, that doesn’t even take into account the close familial relationship within the Bat Family itself.
7. Starfire’s Personality Change
Princess Koriand’r of Tamaran, aka the Titan known as Starfire, has been one of the sexiest characters in mainstream comics since her introduction in 1980's DC Comics Presents #26. But her portrayal in Red Hood and the Outlaws # 1 pushed her portrayal from sexy to sexual. And this change seemed to be less about being progressive than salacious.
Kori had lived on Earth for a while and fought injustice. It was implied that she had a relationship with Dick Grayson. However, if she had ever been part of the Teen Titans, she didn’t remember it by the New 52. She lived alone on a Caribbean island until an injured Jason Todd washed up. Starfire used the Tameranean technology of her ship to heal him, and Jason told her of his Red Hood identity and his time as Robin and the pair began a sexual relationship.
Red Hood learned that Roy Harper was about to be executed in Quarac for protesting. Jason requested Kori’s aid in saving Roy, and she donned a barely-there costume and knee-high boots as the pair sought to save Arsenal’s life. Once back on her island, Kori asked Roy to sleep with her. When he inquired about her relationship with Jason, she said her people saw humans as little more than “sensory experiences.” These were later revealed to be lies.
6. Red Robin Kills
None of the Teen Titans came out of “the Culling” unscathed, but Red Robin, aka Tim Drake, fell apart and betrayed the core tenant of his training with the Dark Knight. Just before Teen Titans Vol. 4 # 8, the team had been defeated by Harvest, an agent of N.O.W.H.E.R.E. Omen, amnesiac former Titan Lilith Clay, and another agent of the nefarious organization captured Red Robin. She tortured the hero and used her mental powers to make him believe that she was turning him into a bird-like creature.
Tim awoke strapped to a table while Omen used her abilities to torture other members of the Teen Titans. Harvest re-emerged to taunt Red Robin about his inability to find and save Superboy, and reminded Drake that he was a leader despite his protests. In his next torture session, Tim used the wings of his costume to slash the blind Omen across the heart, killing her.
Red Robin woke back up on the table, with an alive Omen standing over him. It had all been an illusion. But the point is that Tim Drake, who Nightwing had called the Best of the Robins, had been pushed to kill. Tim betrayed Bruce’s most sacred rule. And that made him and the team ready to be Harvest’s New Ravagers.
5. Lois Lane Outs Superman
Superman has given up his Clark Kent identity a number of times over the decades and told the world his secret, but those revelations are usually on his terms. This time, it was forced on him. In Superman # 43, having barely escaped the HORDR-PLEX - the evil organization that was weaponizing information - Clark, Lois, Jimmy and Condesa all retreated to Lois’ apartment to allow Superman to recover.
Lois had just confirmed that Clark Kent was Superman. Tearfully, Lois tells Clark that she will keep his secret. Meanwhile, Jimmy threw up a small robot into the bathroom toilet.
The robot attached to a cell phone and told Superman to go to a specific location in one hour or his identity will be revealed to the world. Still not fully powered, the Man of Steel had to carry Lois and leap there. Lois hid and Clark was taken to a room where robots were setup to absorb the power of his solar flare. Seeing no option, Kal complied.
Lois had snuck inside the mountain and revealed that she had just uploaded the secret of Clark Kent and Superman and the story of HORDR to the internet, thus removing the organization's hold on him. The Boy Scout destroyed the robots but was angry with Lois, saying she had no right. When General Sam Lane arrived attempting to apprehend him, Clark angrily left Lois with her father.
4. Defining The Undefinable Phantom Stranger
The Phantom Stranger was one of the few characters that readers knew virtually nothing about for decades. His enigmatic nature, his incredible powers, and his ability to exist both in the world of superheroes and the magical world, made him unique among the DC heroes.
The New 52’s Trinity of Sin storyline tied the Stranger to a specific origin. It was heavily implied that the Stranger is Judas Iscariot, the man who betrayed Jesus Christ to the Romans for 30 pieces of silver. Judas killed himself but found that he and two others, The Question and Pandora, were brought before the Council of Wizards and were judged as the world’s worst sinners. The Stranger is judged with avarice and returned to the world to wander for all time. The Presence, DC’s God, charges him to don Jesus’ robe and become “nothing but a stranger” to everyone he meets.
The Phantom Stranger spent his centuries helping others indirectly when possible and only took a direct hand when absolutely necessary. His actions resulted in the creation of the Spectre and the defeat of Trigon. However, in the first issue of his own title, The Stranger is shown with a wife and two children. They do not know of his other life and they are kidnapped and he has to go to Hell to save them.
3. Death Of Robin/Damian Wayne
The life of a Robin is apparently a deadly job to undertake. In Batman Incorporated Vol. 2 # 8, Gotham City was under all-out attack by the forces of Leviathan. Wearing a powerful endoskeleton, Damian Wayne as Robin flew to Wayne Tower and defeated a number of Leviathan agents. He was nearly overrun but was saved by Nightwing, and the pair briefly reminisced about their time as Batman and Robin - and Damian even admitted Dick was his favorite partner.
The pair reengaged the Leviathan henchmen and defeated them. The Heretic, a clone of Damian who was artificially aged, knocked Nightwing out and challenged Damian to a fight to prove who is Talia al Ghul’s “chosen” son. The two were evenly matched and Damian began to get the upper hand, but Leviathan agents shot arrows into Robin but he continued to fight. The Heretic ran his sword through Damian, lifting him into the air on its tip.
Batman freed himself from a safe at the bottom of a pool and fought off a group of Man-Bats while Talia taunted him about the idea of Robin being a failed experiment. Bruce was shocked to find the bodies of his sons on the ground, one dead, the other unconscious. He cradled Damian’s dead body in his arms.
2. Nightwing Unmasked Before The World
In Forever Evil # 1, Nightwing was returning Victor Zsasz to Arkham Asylum. He loses his comlink with Barbara Gordon and instead hears a voice say “This World Is Ours.” A flying woman rips the doors off Arkham just as a man in a cape and cowl punched Dick in the face. Nightwing prepared to return the attack when a barbed lasso wrapped around his neck and he was yanked up in the air. The two unknown people decided that Grayson “will do”, as they take him away.
The super-powered people are revealed to be the Crime Syndicate from Earth-3. They mostly ruled their planet unopposed and apparently crossed over to the Prime Earth to do the same. The Syndicate had been busy, assembling a veritable army of villains including the inmates of Arkham Asylum and the Flash’s Rogues.
Dangling the bound and beaten Nightwing in front of the assembled villains and televising it on media they controlled, Superwoman peeled off Nightwing’s mask and revealed his identity, driver's license, and other papers as Richard Grayson. The Syndicate promised to find everyone and everything connected to Dick or anyone who got in their way. Meanwhile, the members of the Justice League had seemingly disappeared.
1. Death Of Superman
The death of any Superman is a sad affair but the death of the New 52 Superman felt more like the hero was going down a slow, depressing checklist than going out in one last heroic battle. The Final Days of Superman story arc saw this version of the Man of Steel check in with his friends and loved ones as he dies.
Superman’s cellular structure had been irreparably damaged by his exposure to the fire pits of Apokolips, A.R.G.U.S.’s kryptonite room, and the energies of Rao. The hero accepted that he was dying. After visiting Lana and Lois, Clark went to Batman to ask him to find Supergirl, who was getting help with her waning powers from the DEO. He asks her to carry on for him. Superman also tried to say goodbye to Wonder Woman but their farewell was ruined by Denny Swan, the supposed Energy Superman.
In Superman #52, the Man of Steel attempted to fly the out-of-control Swan into the upper atmosphere where he could unleash his solar flare and have their powers cancel each other out. However, his flare fails. The New Earth Superman, who had been living there secretly with his Lois and son, arrived and took them all into the atmosphere where Swan exploded. New 52 Clark succumbed to his kryptonite poisoning and the world mourned the loss of their hero.