10 Things Marvel Wants You To Forget About The Punisher

Because Frank Castle heading to Riverdale is something we all needed, obviously.

By Ewan Paterson /

Marvel Comics

With a new Netflix series on the horizon, the Punisher has once again been propelled into the spotlight. As one of Marvel's more controversial characters, old Frank Castle has enjoyed something of a tempestuous history - one chock full of murder, torture, and the odd crossover here and there.

Advertisement

Said history has meant that a whole bunch of misconceptions regarding the character have become commonplace, but even truer is that there are elements of it that, not for lack of trying, Marvel would much rather prefer you'd forget.

This involves everything from the basic fundamentals of the character to some of the straight-up bizarre narrative decisions writers have taken with him over the years. He's crossed over with Archie (yes, that Archie), smacked around the odd animal here and there, and that's before we even get to the guy's inexorable bodycount.

Advertisement

Frank Castle has always been one to cut a divisive figure on the page as much as off it, but those uglier, more closely guarded secrets remain in the shadows...

10. He's Killed Close To 50 Thousand People

Marvel Comics

There's something particularly unnerving about this figure. Apart from the fact that this is, y'know, a lot of Punishing for any one man to handle, it's also a totally ridiculous bodycount to rack up.

Advertisement

Granted Frank Castle's been preaching vigilante justice for the better part of forty years now, but come on - to reach a figure as high as that you'd have to be punishing at least 1000 people a year. We know New York has a reputation and all, but a statistic that high leaves one to wonder if there actually should be any criminals left for Spidey and Daredevil to beat up, let alone imprison.

So yeah, going off official figures the Punisher is actually a mass murderer of the highest degree. Take that how you will, but we prefer our heroes to be a little more restrained when it comes to enacting social justice...

Advertisement

9. That Time He Wore Blackface

Marvel

Yep, what you're seeing is real. When was it released? 1991. Nineteen. Ninety. One.

Advertisement

In the storyline, Frank Castle - everyone's favourite perennial fugitive - is on the run and in need of a change of identity. Seeking out a disgraced surgeon, Castle goes under the knife and emerges as a black man, with writer Mike Baron using the opportunity to team Frank up with Luke Cage in some bizarre blaxploitation story-arc.

The storyline was as cringe-inducing and insensitive as it sounds, and Baron was taken off the book shortly after. As for Castle? The procedure soon wore off and he hit the road again, probably in search of a better creative-team.

Advertisement

8. Franken-Castle

Marvel Comics

So, Punisher fans, have you ever wondered what your favourite comic book character would look like if he was killed and brought back to life as a literal Frankenstein's Monster? No? Well, Marvel have you covered anyway, with a storyline from 2009.

Advertisement

Chopped to pieces by Wolverine's evil son Daken, Punisher was resurrected and became known as 'Franken-Castle' from that point forward. The pun's tragic, but even more tragic was the premise itself, which involved the resurrected Castle tracking down Daken and dishing out vigilante justice only he knows how.

As a zombie.

Advertisement

Needless to say, it was a massive departure for the character and bookended what had, until that point at least, been a rather enjoyable run to read. Don't expect to see this storyline get the Netflix treatment anytime soon.

7. He's Killed Children

Marvel Comics

God, Frank, this just gets worse and worse.

Advertisement

It's a given that Castle will have killed plenty of innocents in his one man war on crime, it's just that most writers have chosen not to acknowledge it. One writer who did, however, is Frank Miller, who addressed the issue head on during his seminal stint on Daredevil.

Ambushing a group of drug dealers outside New York, the Punisher fires indiscriminately into a crowd and, having assessed his handiwork, discovers that one of his victims was just a kid. Despite this, Frank remains relatively unperturbed by the act, using the moment not for self-reflection, but instead to vent in more of a "look what you made me do!" type thing, laying the blame at the Drug Trade itself and not his approach to crimefighting.

Advertisement

There've been countless occasions where Frank's considered murdering minors, and while the character's usual murderous inclinations are a line too far for most, this is all pretty beyond the pale even for his most virulent defenders.

6. Archie Meets The Punisher

Archie Comics

Comic book crossovers are few and far between these days, at least between publishers. Back in the nineties, however, they were all the rage, and one of the most famous involved everyone's favourite Punisher meeting up with everyone's favourite comic book teen, Archie Andrews.

Advertisement

Written by Batton Lash and drawn by the late, great John Buscema and Stan Goldberg, the book involves Castle heading to Riverdale to track down a notorious drug kingpin, known only as 'Red'. Soon enough, Archie gets caught up in a criminal conspiracy and, fitting the description of Castle's target, soon finds himself in a pretty unfortunate case of mistaken identity.

The book's a fun enough read, but as far as crossovers go this is one of the strangest in Marvel's library. It ends with Frank heading to Gotham City (presumably to kill the Joker), but at least the Archie book has the fun factor to go with it.

Advertisement

5. He Used Polar Bears To Kill The Mob

Marvel Comics/Steve Dillon

Of all the various Punisher runs to have emerged over the years, none are held in more high a regard than Garth Ennis' MAX series.

Advertisement

Together with the infallible Steve Dillon, Ennis wove a violent, psychologically complex storyline that forced readers to reassess their opinion of Frank Castle. It wasn't prone to taking itself too seriously either, as was the case when Ennis had Castle lure his pursuers into a zoo to systematically tear them apart.

One henchman - gearing up for an audition for the latest Piranha film, we imagine - gets caught in a tank full of the critters and is devoured in less than a minute. Turning his attention to a pack of Polar Bears, Castle proceeds to provoke them in the hope that they'll attack the mobsters on his tail. Ma Gnucci, the main villain of the series, loses several of her limbs as a result.

Advertisement

Frank Castle: Polar Bear tamer. At least you can't say he's not resourceful.

4. That Eminem Team Up

Marvel Comics

Okay, so we know we just mentioned the Archie crossover as being one of the character's weirdest team-ups, but that comes nowhere near close to Eminem's cameo in 2009.

Advertisement

The storyline effectively writes Marshall into the Marvel Universe, providing the rapper with an origin that places him directly next to Punisher bad-guy Barracuda during his formative years. After Castle ambushes the rapper's entourage, Marshall embarks on an alliance of sorts with the villain, before realising he's bait for a trap designed to ensnare Punisher.

The covers for the one-shot are beyond funny, but perhaps the issue's strangest moment comes when Eminem escapes from Barracuda's clutches. Wandering aimlessly through an Arctic tundra, Marshall comes across a sole fisherman who, wouldn't you know it, is listening to one of the Slim Shady's newest albums.

Advertisement

There are worse artists to spotlight in a Punisher comic, we suppose.

3. He Actually Killed Both The X-Men And The Brotherhood

Marvel Comics

Punisher Kills the Marvel Universe is one of the barmiest stories Garth Ennis has ever told, in which the vigilante actually takes on and kills all of Marvel's biggest heroes and villains.

Advertisement

Set on an alternate Earth where Frank Castle's family were killed in the crossfire of a superhero-villain fight gone awry, he adopts the mantle of the Punisher to kill every hero and villain out there, starting with the X-Men and the Brotherhood.

Luring both parties to the moon, Castle uses one of Doctor Doom's nukes to kill them all in one fell swoop. While this is part and parcel for an alternate reality story, the fact that Castle was able to acquire one of these weapons is just beyond hokey.

Advertisement

Still think he's a hero?

2. His Films (Even The Good Ones)

Lionsgate

Since that new Netflix show will be arriving shortly, it's clear that Marvel aren't all that enthused about rekindling the cult following behind two of the newest Punisher films.

Advertisement

War Zone was actually released under the studio's Marvel Knights banner - a label that was meant to differentiate the company's darker properties with the lighter, more mainstream ones leading the MCU. The film proved to be a critical and commercial flop though, despite the fact it wasn't all that bad, with news of a future reboot stalling until 2015 (when news of an appearance on Daredevil first came to light).

While all of Frank Castle's films have garnered a divisive response from audiences, it's safe to say Marvel are in no rush to bring them back into the spotlight. John Bernthal is killing it on Netflix, and while we could quite easily sit around and debate the merits of Thomas Jane or Ray Stephenson's portrayals of the titular character, it's safe to say that Frank - much for the better - has found his home.

Advertisement

How great it is that it's in the MCU.

1. That He's Pretty Dull Without Other Heroes To Play Off

Marvel Comics

Here's the thing about the Punisher: he's not all that interesting on his own.

Advertisement

Granted, the new Netflix show looks set to refute that, but it's equally true that the character is infinitely more interesting when he has other superheroes to play off. We saw as much in Daredevil Season 2, and indeed, the Punisher episodes there were some of the best comic book TV we've ever gotten.

It's the same with the comics, with the aforementioned Matt Murdock having served as Frank Castle's greatest costumed sparring-partner for a while now. The two have a spectacular relationship on the page - one that's been explored by the likes of Ennis, Miller et al. - and there are other heroes out there too that have given Frank plenty to think about.

Advertisement

Castle's attachment to Captain America is, for instance, a major talking point in the comics. Everything the murderous vigilante wishes he was, Frank looks up to and respects the star spangled man with a plan in a manner unheard of with other heroes. Much of that can be owed to Cap's military service, but it's telling that it's a dynamic keep returning to time and time again.

Of course there've been plenty of brilliant Punisher stories, but he's always worked best when he's had other heroes to mess with, both on the page and off it.

Advertisement

Learn anything new about the Punisher? What are your thoughts on Franken-Castle? Be sure to let us know in the comments below and, before you do, be sure to hop on over to the WhatCulture Comics YouTube channel for more frank takes on beloved heroes old and new.