Since his humble beginnings, Batman has always been a dark character. Oh sure, if you're watching the '60s show or reading the Silver Age comics you'll be seeing a lighter incarnation of the Caped Crusader, but within the past few decades, readers and audiences have grown to know Batman as the shadowy vigilante who patrols Gotham City and strikes terror into the hearts of criminals. Batman fights crime in a city that throws every worse thing it can cough up at him, and while most of the time he succeeds, there have been tragedies and losses along the way. Batman's whole life is dedicated towards keeping the innocent safe, but he's not perfect. He's lost people close to him, and most of the time this drives him to do his job even better, although they still affect him deeply. Over the history of Batman in comics, movies, and television, there have been people who have been lost during the fight against evil that have been tragic. Whether it be one of his costumed partners, an ally in the city government, or even a villain who made some wrong choices along the way, death is a constant in the fight against evil. This list will look at those deaths which hit the characters, readers and viewers hard when their lives were ended prematurely. Although Batman has many allies and acquaintances in the Justice League and other organizations, I've primarily stuck with characters who are directly related to the Batman mythos.
10. Warren McGinnis
There's been one defining theme that leads Bruce Wayne and others to don the cowl and begin their fight against evil: tragedy. Most of them time this is through a family member or close friend being killed, and it was no different for the neo-future animated series Batman Beyond and its protagonist Terry McGinnis. While Terry was off fighting a gang of Jokerz an elderly Bruce Wayne, his father Warren McGinnis had gotten ahold of some incriminating information about his employer Derek Powers. Powers, who took over Wayne's company and renamed it Wayne-Powers, has been developing biological weapons for foreign nations. While Terry is accidentally discovering Bruce Wayne's bat-related secret, Powers discovers Warren has the evidence and sends men to retrieve it and kill Warren. When Terry gets home, he finds the police and his mother at the house. Fearing the worst, he runs in and finds his father's body, along with evidence suggesting it was an attack by the Jokerz. Several days later, Terry discovers the disc that contained the information on Powers. With almost no one to turn to, he goes back to Bruce Wayne's house, knowing that he'd want to know what his former company was up to. When Wayne discovers who's behind the biological weapons, Terry steals the Batsuit to go after Powers, and takes his first step as the new Batman.
9. Mr. Freeze (Batman Beyond)
Before Batman: The Animated Series, Mr. Freeze was just another gimmicky Batman villain who loves cold just for the hell of it. The famed '90s series gave him depth by portraying Victor Fries as a tragic figure who would do anything to save the life of his terminally ill wife Nora, whom he cryogenically froze to keep stable. As a result, the crimes he committed weren't to get rich, but to save her life. By the time of The New Batman Adventures, Nora has been cured, but has left Fries for the doctor assigned to her case. Not only that, but Fries' body has deteriorated to the point where only his head remains, which controls his robotic body. With the last of his humanity taken away, Freeze strikes back at Gotham to make them suffer. At the end of their confrontation, Batman discovers Freeze's body, but sees the head is missing. Fast-forward 40 years to Batman Beyond where we learn that Freeze's head has been kept in cold storage at Wayne-Powers all these years, making him immortal. Derek Powers and Doctor Stephanie Lake approach Victor with a way to make a new body for him Freeze, eager to be mortal again, accepts. They clone him a new body, and with his humanity restored, Freeze attempts to atone for his past sins. Unfortunately, the body starts to deteriorate to its previous cold-like condition, and Powers and Lake want to conduct a biopsy to see what went wrong. It turns out, the main purpose of the experiment was to come up with a body for Powers, who by now had become the radioactive Blight. Betrayed, Freeze escapes and digs up one of his old suits out of cold storage (literally). Returning to Wayne-Powers, Freeze kills Lake and attempts to kill Powers, forcing Powers to engage Freeze as Blight. Batman (Terry McGinnis) intervenes, and in a moment of humanity, Freeze saves him from Blight. Unfortunately, Freeze is injured, and although Batman tries to save him when the building starts to collapse, Freeze refuses his help, stating, "Believe me, you're the only one who cares." Batman escapes, but Freeze is crushed by the debris.
8. Jack Drake (pre-New 52)
Most non-comics fans only know Dick Grayson as Robin, but there have actually been as many as five Robins in the main continuity Batman comics. The third Robin, more well-known to watchers of The New Batman Adventures, was Tim Drake. Before the New 52 took effect, Tim was the son of Jack Drake, a business man who was always traveling. While Drake and his wife were traveling, Tim stayed at a Gotham City boarding school. He eventually deduced Batman's secret identity and became the newest Robin. After the death of his wife and his business going bankrupt, Jack went through a phase of depression. Shortly after he recovered, he discovered his son's Robin gear. Knowing his son had a close relationship with Bruce Wayne, he corners Wayne with a gun demanding to know the truth. Although Bruce was able to disarm him, Jack now knew the truth about Batman and Robin. Tim was willing to give up the mantle of Robin for his father, but after a gang war erupted in Gotham, Tim realized that being Robin meant too much for him to give up. Although Jack disapproved, he allowed his son to continue. Jack was killed during the events of Identity Crisis by Captain Boomerang, who was hired by the killer of Sue Dibny, the Elongated Man's wife. In an effort to frame Drake for Sue's murder, the killer sends Jack a gun to defend himself against the assailant. Although he's able to shoot Boomerang, he was still killed by Boomerang. Jack's death hit Tim hard, causing him to become more brooding. Bruce later adopts Tim, leading them to develop a new father-son relationship.
7. Sarah Essen
Introduced in Frank Miller's Batman: Year One, Sarah Essen was then-Detective Gordon's partner in Gotham City. The two of them have an affair, but when Commissioner Loeb threatens to expose the two of them, Gordon confesses what he did to his wife, and Essen leaves Gotham City. A few years later, Essen returns, explaining that she moved to New York City and married a cop, who was later killed in a drug bust. Gordon has divorced his wife by now, so he and Essen resume their relationship and eventually marry. Essen continued to work at the GCPD with her husband until the events of No Man's Land. In the story, a powerful earthquake hits Gotham City, and the U.S. government declares the city a "no man's land" and cuts off every bridge, tunnel and access point to the city, letting no one leave or enter. If this sounds familiar, the same type of premise was used in The Dark Knight Rises. Anyway, the city is soon overrun and carved out by the criminals, and Gordon, Essen, and several other GCPD officers do what they can to protect the city. Near the end of the story, Essen and other officers converge on the Joker's at the police station's basement, where he's holding dozens of babies hostage. Reaching him first, she draws her gun on him when he tosses one of the babies at her. Dropping her gun, she catches the baby but is promptly shot in the head by Joker. The odd thing: Joker, a man who finds humour in death, walks away from the encounter frowning, not finding the situation amusing at all.
6. Harvey Dent (Christopher Nolan Films)
Christopher Nolan's Batman films took a more realistic tone compared to the previous Tim Burton and Joel Schumacher movies of the 90s. Because of this, the characters were reinterpreted to fit their environment, Harvey Dent being a great example. Rather than just have him be the duality loving villain, Nolan decided to focus on Harvey's crusade against crime as a district attorney, leading him to join forces with Batman and James Gordon. Things seem to be going great until that pesky Joker starts screwing things up. After pretending he was Batman and almost being killed by the Joker, Harvey is kidnapped by the Joker's men and trapped in a warehouse filled with gasoline barrels. His girlfriend Rachel Dawes is put in the same situation at a different location (we'll get to her later in the list). Batman, getting the locations of both of them, goes to save who he thinks is Rachel, but discovers is Harvey. The two of them escape, but the warehouse blows up and sets half of Harvey's face on fire. Distraught from losing Rachel and fresh from hearing a existential speech from the Joker, Harvey goes on a revenge crusade against the people responsible for Rachel's death, but only kills them if his newly scarred coin lands burnt-side up. After killing Maroni, Gotham cop Wertz and several others, Dent goes after Gordon's family. Wanting Gordon to feel the same pain he did, he attempts to kill Gordon's son, but is stopped by Batman. Falling off the building, Dent dies a tragic figure who was corrupted by the city he tried to protect.
5. John And Mary Grayson
Like Bruce Wayne, Dick Grayson needed to experience his own tragedy to lead him down the path of crime-fighting and justice. Before coming to Gotham City, Dick and his parents were The Flying Graysons, a family of circus acrobats who traveled around the country with Haley's Circus. While they're in Gotham City, Dick overhears some gangsters trying so extort protection money out of the circus manager. The manager refuses, and in retaliation, the trapeze wires are coated with acid. During their next performance, Dick watches with horror as wires snap as his parents fall to their death during the performance. While the police conduct their investigation, Bruce (who was watching in the audience) goes to comfort Dick and days later adopts him as his legal ward. Meanwhile, Dick learns that the two gangsters he saw earlier work for crime boss Tony Zucco. Seeking revenge, Dick attempts to go after Zucco but is stopped by Batman. Telling Dick he can't take stop Zucco on his own, he reveals his identity to Dick and begins training him. Eventually, the two of them take down Zucco together as the new dynamic duo of Batman and Robin. Although they went through similar traumas, how Dick dealt with his parents' death was different from the process Bruce went through. While Bruce became brooding and obsessed with his mission, Dick was able to keep a relatively positive demeanor when it came to relationships and life. That's not to say he didn't have his moments of anger or despair, but rather than dwell on the negative like Bruce did, Dick attempted to see the good in people and live life to the fullest. Eventually, he left behind the Robin mantle and became a hero in his own right as Nightwing. So although his parents deaths affected him similarly to how Bruce felt when his died, his overall path branched off and Dick was able to become his own man.
4. Rachel Dawes
Aside from reporter Vicki Vale, who appeared infrequently in the comics and starred in the 1989 Batman film, Batman has never had a recurring girlfriend-type figure like Superman or Spider-Man. For the new Batman films, Nolan gave us original character Rachel Dawes, who was Bruce Wayne's childhood playmate. As they grew older, Rachel and Bruce went their separate way: Bruce going to learn martial arts in the Orient and Rachel studying law and joining the District Attorney's office. When the two of them reunite, Rachel sees Bruce's playboy facade as real and chides him for not doing more to help the city. To be fair, it's understandable she didn't automatically realize her former playmate was fighting criminals dressed as a giant bat. By the time Batman Begins is over, Rachel learns Bruce's secret and tells him that although she understands what he's doing, she can't be with him while he's Batman. Fast-forward a year, and Rachel is in a relationship with new District Attorney Harvey Dent, but as we see later, she still has feelings left for Bruce. This becomes clear when she doesn't give Harvey an answer to his marriage proposal. When the Joker's reign of terror plagues Gotham, Bruce has Rachel hide at her penthouse to keep her safe, but she promptly leaves after seeing Harvey take the fall for Bruce's actions as Batman. Before leaving, she gives Alfred a note to give to Bruce. After Harvey and Batman's high speed chase from the Joker, we learn Rachel's been kidnapped. Seemingly getting the address of where she is from the Joker, Bruce goes to save her, but Harvey is there instead. To make matters worse, Harvey and Rachel were able to talk with each other over a phone-bomb, and right before she gets blown up, she tells Harvey that she chose him. Her death drives Harvey insane and devastates Bruce, not realizing the contents of her letter were to tell him she picked Harvey over him. Alfred burned the letter to spare Bruce the pain, but tells him years later to get him to stop being Batman.
3. Damian Wayne
Bruce Wayne had a peculiar relationship with Talia Al Ghul, the daughter of nemesis Ra's Al Ghul. Similar to his relationship with Catwoman, Talia is acted as both a villain for the Caped Crusader, and a romantic interest at other times. After one of their..."encounters," Talia discovers she's pregnant. Rather than give birth naturally, the fetus was grown in a lab, and was eventually born as Damian. Left in the care of her father's League of Assassins, Damian was raised to be a skilled assassin, and by age 10 is extremely experienced. Talia then leaves him with Bruce, hoping Damian would sabotage his father's operations as Batman. At first, Damian was rude, abrasive, aggressive, and was fighting with seemingly everyone he laid eyes on, including trying to kill Tim Drake to take over the Robin role. Eventually, he realizes what he was doing was wrong and helps Bruce take down his mother's operations, although he ends up staying with her. After Bruce "died" in Final Crisis (he was actually sent back in time, it's way too convoluted to explain), Damian returned to become the new Robin and team up with Dick Grayson, who took over as Batman. Although he was still arrogant and rude, Damian learns to work with Dick and together they made a unique new Dynamic Duo. Eventually, Damian renounces Talia and her family, deciding to permanently side with the Bat-Family. When Bruce returned from the "dead," Dick Grayson went back to being Nightwing and Damian teamed up with his father, fighting crime together both in Gotham and globally as part of Batman Inc. Earlier this year, Damian's life ended in the pages of "Batman Incorporated." While fighting her mother's terrorist group Leviathan, he was killed by the Heretic, who was a mutated adult clone of Damian. Bruce's mental state deteriorates from losing his son, and he spends most of his time seeking revenge against Talia and trying to find ways to bring his son back. Most recently, Bruce learns that Damian's body was stolen from his grave, and we learn that Ra's Al Ghul has been engineering new clones of Damian. The nature of comic books suggest that Damian might come back in the future, but for now, his death has hit everybody in the Bat-Family very hard.
2. Jason Todd
As one of the lesser known Robins, Jason Todd was the second to take the name after Dick Grayson left the role behind. Todd was a street orphan living on the streets of Gotham, forced to commit crimes to survive. The circumstances of how he met Batman change with each continuity shift at DC Comics. Back in the '80s, he tried to steal the tires of the Batmobile, while in the New 52, Batman catches him stealing medicine from medical clinic. Regardless, Bruce eventually takes Todd in and trains him to be Robin. Unlike Dick, Todd is a lot more aggressive when fighting criminals, and is more likely to disobey Batman. Todd's life reaches its tragic end when he travels to Europe in search of his birth mother. Unbeknownst to him, his mother is blackmailed into working for the Joker, who captures to boy and, in one of the most painful moments in comic book history, beats him brutally with a crowbar. Joker then traps Todd and his mother in a warehouse with a time bomb. Batman tries to save him, but watches with horror as the building explodes before him, killing Todd. Batman considered Todd's death to be his biggest failure, and kept Todd's uniform on display in the Batcave as a memorial. In a medium where characters are frequently revived, resurrected, or had their deaths faked, Todd's death was one of the few that actually stuck. This changed in the 2000s when Todd was resurrected from the grave. Originally brought back after Superboy Prime altered reality (changed in the New 52 to having his corpse revived in the Pit of Lazarus), Todd went on a journey around the world to enhance his skills, eventually returning to Gotham to take his revenge on the Joker and deal his new form of hard justice on the criminals of Gotham. Taking the identity of Red Hood, Todd reunited with Bruce, who although was surprised to see him alive, disapproved of Todd's new methods. The two of them fought on multiple occasions, but recently Todd has been able to slightly patch things up with Batman and the others, although he still operates separately from the rest of the Bat-Family.
1. Thomas And Martha Wayne
If you didn't expect these two to be #1 on the list, you can't call yourself a true Batman fan. The deaths of Thomas and Martha Wayne not only traumatized Bruce Wayne as a child, but set into motion the events of the entire Batman mythos. To recap, Thomas and Martha were wealthy socialites living in Gotham City with their son Bruce. Thomas was a gifted surgeon and Martha used her family's wealth and name to champion various social causes and charities. Though they may have been rich, they cared deeply about the city and did their best to give back to it, while at the same time taking good care of Bruce. One night after seeing a Zorro movie, Bruce and his parents take a shortcut down an alley and are confronted by a gunman. Attempting to steal the pearl necklace Martha is wearing, the gunman gets into a struggle with Thomas and Martha, shoots them and runs away, leaving Bruce kneeling next to his parents' bodies. Thomas and Martha's deaths pushed young Bruce to avenge their deaths and begin the path towards what would culminate in Batman. Their deaths continue to be the primary force driving his fight against crime and injustice. Recently, Bruce was able to hear from his father one last time during the events of the mini-series Flashpoint. In the story, Barry Allen, a.k.a. the Flash, wakes up on a war-torn Earth radically different from his. Hoping to track down Bruce to understand what is going on, he finds Wayne Manor and discovers that this Earth's Batman is Thomas Wayne. In the changed timeline, Bruce was the one killed, leading Thomas to become Batman and Martha being driven insane and becoming this world's Joker. After being critically wounded from saving Flash's life in the final battle, Thomas gives Barry a note to give to Bruce once Barry fixes the timeline and gets back to his own Earth. When Barry gets back, he goes to see Bruce to give him the letter. After reading the message, Bruce starts to cry and thanks Barry for delivering these final words from his father.