I'll start off by saying that I'm simply not that big of a DC fan. Marvel is much more my style. However, one medium where DC rules the roost is in the medium of television. Wonder Woman, Batman (now a hilarious comic by the name of Batman '66), Lois And Clark: The New Adventures Of Superman, and most prominently, Smallville the show which made Chloe Sullivan and Whitney Fordman an official part of the Superman lore have all brought the publisher's heroes to the small screen in appropriately grand fashion. The show actually broke the record (albeit by five episodes) for the longest consecutively running sci-fi television series of all time. Not the proudest title to hold, but no matter what, 218 episodes and 10 seasons is an impressive feat for something that is pretty much Dawson's Creek with superheroes. After going down in history as television's answer to 2012's The Avengers (which is surprisingly not picked up on all that often, most probably because the only characters never featured in the show were Batman and Wonder Woman, the most prominent characters in the DC universe apart from our humble Kal-El), Smallville gracefully bowed out of the small screen on May 13, 2011. However, on February 8, 2012, Smallville Season 11 was announced, not as a television series, but as a comic book. So a comic book based on the series which was based on the comic book? I don't care, the show was excellent and it was good to see it come back, in any form. April 13, 2012 came around, and the results were, as Larry David would say, pretty good. The humour was enjoyable, the action was fitting, the characters seemed as if they were fresh of our television screens and it seemed as though this would be an enjoyable endeavour. Characters were being brought back, others introduced for the first time (such as the aforementioned Batman and Wonder Woman, who weren't able to appear in the series due to them being too expensive to buy the rights for), and everything seemed to be going well. That was until just after issue 11, when the Argo storyarc began. Suddenly, characters looked different, if they were there at all, and the quality just didn't seem as good anymore. Thankfully, Bryan Q. Miller (the creator and genius behind such an idea) must have seen this too, and is currently in the process of revamping the show uh, I mean, comic. Miller had decided that Olympus/Hollow would be the final "episodes" of the series (we'll get to that later), and Clark Kent would return in Smallville: Miniseries. Effectively, Season 12. This list compiles five reasons as to why this change is most definitely a good thing...
Honourable Mention: The Strange Publication Schedule
Smallville Season 11 is not a print comic. Nor is it a digital comic. It's both. The show has this extremely strange release schedule, that really can only be shown via a diagram: Week 1 of 4 - The first third of Issue X is released digitally. Week 2 of 4 - The second third of Issue X is released digitally. Week 3 of 4 - The final third of Issue X is released digitally. Week 4 of 4 - The three thirds of Issue X are collected and released in print form. However, after 12 issues of doing this they decided to alter it slightly: Week 4 of 4 - The three thirds of Issue X are collected and released in print form. The first quarter of a side-story called "Smallville: Special" is released online. The collected print versions of the Special are released sporadically. Confused? Join the club. It's not particularly good when I have to look up the comic on Smallville's Wikia page to know what I'm going to be reading on any given week. However, it is at the very least convenient in the sense that we are getting our Smallville fix every week of the year, no matter how confusing. That is one of two reasons that this is merely an honourable mention, the other being that they haven't fixed it for the revamped Season 12. If you're up for a quick Google search every Saturday, then get the digital version. If you're not a fan of that and you're more of a patient person, just get the print releases. Not to mention that now Season 12 has begun, the "Special" side-series hasn't rebooted, so Special #4 will be either the ninth or the tenth story in the timeline, the ninth story released, the fourth issue of the "Special" side-series but the first of the new "Miniseries" Season 12 series. It really is that mind-boggling, so let's try to ignore it and move on. Click "next to begin the countdown!
BONUS: There Are Just Enough "Episodes" For It To Be A Full Season
This is an extremely nerdy response that only myself, Adrian Monk and Sheldon Cooper would ever care about. As of the end of the season, there have been 19 issues and the "specials" (which were made up of the side stories), totaling 22 episodes, which is how many we usually got to see in a typical Smallville season. This is extremely geeky and should not be considered an official part of the countdown, and now I'll stop talking about it. Click "next" for the real countdown to begin.
5. Weaker Storylines/The Season Ended On A Cliffhanger
I'm not saying that all of the storylines in Season 11 were bad. In fact, Guardian (i.e. Issues #1-4) did a brilliant job of picking up where Season 10 left off, and reintroducing our main cast Lois Lane, Lex Luthor, the reinvented Tess Mercer, Oliver Queen and, of course, Chloe Sullivan. Otis Berg was even thrown in the mix, and ended up appearing in more issues than Ollie did!. Detective (Issues #5 through #8) provided a superb introduction to Batman in the Smallville mythos, including the raspy-voiced Batman and his hilarious sidekick (and one of my favourite characters in this comic), Nightwing, A.K.A. Barbara Gordon. Admittedly, the only problem with including Mr. Freeze in your comic book is the struggle that the reader goes through to NOT read his dialogue in an Arnold Schwarzenegger impression (thanks a lot, Batman And Robin). It's not like they didn't just abandon the characters, either. Both Bruce Wayne and Barbara Gordon made subsequent appearances in the season it was only one a piece, but it's still nice to see. They also carried on their story in the first of three "Specials", which were the aforementioned side-stories that took place on the fourth week of the confusing production schedule. This story, titled "Effigy", even brought back John Jones, everybody's favourite Martian Manhunter (some of the story was even brought back in Season 12, which we'll get too later). Haunted (Issues #9-12) side note: this is where I had to start checking the Wikia page was interesting and definitely good, although not to the standard of the first two stories. The arc actually brought back Bart Allen (called "Impulse" here), who is now faster than Superman because apparently his ability to fly detracted from his running prowess slightly. It's mainly for plot convenience and it doesn't really affect him in any way, so there's no point in dwelling on something that will most likely never be mentioned again. It also brought back Jay Garrick the original Flash. However, after this, things moved swiftly down hill. Suddenly, as Argo (#13-15) came around. Clark was sent to the future to do something entirely uninteresting and boring, and relied on the return of two or three characters to keep us buying the issues/segments of the issues. This was soon followed by the final main storyline Olympus, which introduced Wonder Woman, but with nowhere near the same amount of excitement as the Detective storyline. Again, the series was now only relying on introducing new characters we are familiar with and old characters we had become acquainted with to keep us buying the comic. The quality had sincerely dropped and it became a comic that felt more like a chore than a weekend treat.
4. The Lack Of Actor's Likenesses In The Artwork
If you've seen some of the images thus far, you'll find that the likeness of the characters is actually kept rather well. Now, I get that artists are working full time and cannot get everything perfect (I for one totally accept that Rick has both hands in the occasional panel of a Walking Dead comic, especially considering that it's the same guy every month), and that the likenesses were a real treasure to see, as it kept us familiar with the show, helping us to transcend back to the comic book world. Again, I must present a however. Unfortunately, and ironically around the same time as the storyline drop off, the artists rendering of Tom Welling or Erica Durance's likenesses really reduced to some generic Superman and Lois Lane that we've seen a million times before in a million other comics. The reason that this comic is so special, and read at all, is because it's a continuation of the series! A series we want to remain familiar with. In the case of recurring characters (which is really all we had left by the end of the season), they still couldn't get the likenesses right, with Kara/Supergirl looking like some generic blond-haired doll, and I even had to Google who the hell was Brainiac 5 was supposed to be. Once again, it appears as though they have stepped up their game and returned to form with Season 12. Thank God. Also, can we not sexualise the computerised Tess/Watchtower? It's just creepy. Yet again, they improved upon this slightly in Season 12. They even thought about it and refused to give her clothes. Weird.
3. Not Stopping To Smell The Roses
Every story arc in this series strives for something to do. Guardian reintroduced us to the world of Smallville, but apart from that, every other story has been reestablishing old characters, or introducing new ones to the Smallville lore so they can make a bigger world to play around in. I understand that to some extent this is a necessity, but for once in this comic continuation I'd really like to see a Smallville story, not an introduction of yet another character we already know or were waiting to be introduced in the series but they never got round to it. Maybe even as one of the Specials, just do a "Freak of the Week" case, like in the days of old? Not to sound like a broken record, but the earlier half of the season also had some side stories, and the finale improved upon itself by having Superman announce to the President that he is in fact an alien, which is being continued throughout Season 12.
2. The Lack Of Familiar Characters By The End Of The Season
When we began our journey this season, we were reintroduced to the still familiar Clark Kent, Lois Lane, The Green Arrow and Chloe Sullivan, with the return of Lex Luthor (as was established in the finale) as well as returning Tess Mercer (who was killed in the finale), in the form of a vision (well, slightly more than that). Even Emil Hamilton and Frank The Newspaper Vendor made appearances! This trend continued throughout the second and third main stories, the latter of which contained, impressively, a Lana Lang cameo, although this was very much blink-and-you'll-miss-it. Tess Mercer also took on more of a prominent role as Watchtower. In the fourth main story, we were given some cameos including the introduction of Alfred and Commissioner Gordon, as well as the return of Bats and Nightwing. However, this is where everything started to fall apart character wise, too. Clark was the only main character, with only Lois and Tess making nothing more than cameos (to be fair, Lois was busy in the second side story with Lana), although we did see the return of Kara Kent and Brainiac 5 and Doomsday. Olympus (the fifth and final main story) advertised a similarly minimal cast, with only Lana and a very limited appearance by Tess (this time it was her turn to star in the side story). Martha Keny and Speedy The Dog did return, however. Somewhere along the way, we had lost most of our main characters, with the only other main characters left appearing in a very limited role. The side stories were understandable as they were smaller and took ace at the same tie as the main story, but some of the time they featured more - and better- characters than the main story. Take for example the final side story, Hollow. We had a cameo from Superman, and the story itself starred Tess, Lex, Otis and Emil, and developed the relationship that we briefly saw in the episode that ripped of The Hangover, wherein Tess and Emil slept together in an enchanted drunken stupor. Automatically in the twelfth season, we have so far been greeted with the appropriate returns of Lois, Lex, Tess and Chloe, with recurring characters such as Kara and Otis also appearing. And guess who they finally decided to bring back? Jonathan Kent. And Martha again, but mainly Jonathan. You know what? This was a very touching scene, to boot.
1. The Equivalent To Season 12 Is Starting
Season 12 is starting with the side story Titans which, while not having yet featured Superman, it certainly is an improvement in terms of continuity. Megan Morse, the last White Martian, returns from the Effigy side story along with Jay Garrick (the original Flash) and Superboy himself. This looks to be quite promising, as long as it leads somewhere, unlike the other introductory stories so far. Chloe and Oliver Queen have been promised to return (although only Chloe has done so thus far), and the storyline wherein Earth-2 seemed destroyed and Chloe-2 came to the town of Smallville to meet her counterpart and die in her arms will also be resumed after being meekly disregarded in the latter half of the last season. As before, the return of Jonathan and Martha Kent, as well as the return of Kara Kent (which was very reminiscent of Alfred dressing up as Batman to fool the authorities) were welcome and well done. Here's hoping this trend continues throughout the rest of this comic's run! Anything else you'd like to add to the discussion? Leave your answers in the comments and thanks for reading!