8 Comic Book Characters Who Should Have Stayed Dead

Heaven in comics has a revolving door, but could it benefit from a one-way system?

By Kevin McHugh /

In comics, no one ever stays dead. Readers know that even before the dirt hits the coffin, editors are plotting a character's return. Sometimes though, the characters and their world would be better if they remained in the hereafter.

Advertisement

If publishers and creators took the time to weigh what they would lose against what they would gain from a given resurrection, then the outcome might be very different. One could even suggest that if they took this into account before deciding to kill a character off, they might have fewer continuity problems in the long-term.

For a brief time, Marvel tried to apply the "dead means dead" rule, but even the most naïve of readers knew that it would only be a matter of time before that rule would, ironically enough, get left for dead. Ultimately this is an issue of money over creativity.

Sadly, preserving the status quo is of more significant financial benefit to publishers than even the most well-reasoned creative argument. The following are eight instances where the creative value of a character's death being permanent far outweighs any benefits of a headline-grabbing resurrection.

8. Legion Of Super-Heroes

To say that the Legion Of Super-Heroes has a tumultuous history would be something of an understatement. The characters have been through so many incarnations we may not even be picturing the same group of characters when talking about this title.

Advertisement

The Legion Of Super-Heroes is an army of super-powered individuals gathered from all corners of the galaxy, whose goal is to protect all life in the universe. From this premise, there have been at least three slightly different incarnations of the group, and that is before you take into account time-travel, retcons, Crisis on Infinite Earths and the New 52.

The problem comes that no one seems able to leave any particular incarnation alone, and depending upon the whim's of a given editor, any combination of characters, concepts and storylines can be brought back as canon and shoehorned into current continuity - only for this to be undone a couple of years later, with a slightly different permutation presented as canon.

This pattern then ultimately leaves DC with no choice but to suspend publication of the title because even they can't make it work anymore.

7. Aunt May

Aunt May died of a heart defect during the Clone Saga story arc. Her resurrection is not only one the worst in comics history but also one of the most convoluted and confusing. It involved a clone, Spider-Man and Mary Jane's "baby", and Norman Osborn returning from the dead after nearly 20 years.

Advertisement

The reason Aunt May's time had come was that Peter no longer needed that figure in his life and the writers were struggling to come up with ways to keep her around and, more importantly, keep her relevant. Since her return from the dead, May has become a perennial plot device. She serves little to no purpose beyond being a weight around Peter's neck, keeping him trapped in this strange space between adolescence and manhood, despite how subsequent writers have chosen to portray him.

Aunt May has long since stopped being a character in her own right and has become a crutch for lazy writing. She was even the cornerstone of One More Day, arguably the most despised event in the history of Marvel comics.

6. Superboy

There is an adage that goes, "Just because you can, doesn't mean you should!" and this is never more true than when it comes to the death of a beloved character.

Advertisement

During the DC crossover Infinite Crisis, Superboy-Prime killed Connor Kent but within six months he had returned from beyond the grave. An observant reader could have seen that several unresolved plot threads would necessitate Connor Kent's resurrection.

Like countless other temporary or short term deaths, this would come to personify just how meaningless the powers that be at both Marvel and DC view the loss of life. Resurrections like this would breed generations of jaded and cynical readers who now see every hero's fall or villains ultimate triumph as little more than a publicity stunt or an excuse to remove a given character from the board temporarily.

In an age where perception is reality, there can be no greater crime than devaluing how readers view your product.

5. DC's Legacy Heroes

Barry Allen was the second man to take up the mantle of The Flash. During Crisis on Infinite Earths, Jay Garrick, the original Flash, would be folded into mainstream continuity just in time to see Barry die and the then-Kid Flash, Wally West, take up the main Scarlet Speedster mantle.

Advertisement

Like Allen with the Flash moniker, Hal Jordan was technically the second Green Lantern whose tales readers read. When Jordan died during the Emerald Twilight arc, his power ring would pass on to the then-unknown Kyle Rayner.

These two events would introduce the idea of "Legacy" heroes; heroes whose names and powers could be passed from one generation to the next, allowing the people under the masks to be more relevant to that age without altering existing characters, and also removing the certainty that they would survive beyond the next adventure.

Resurrecting Jordan and Allen negated these legacies, of course. It not only dilutes the individuality of the superhero identity but leaves their successors lost in the shuffle. No longer would Rayner and West star in their own monthly titles; instead, they would be supporting characters in someone else's. What was once a legacy is now a uniform.

4. Ben Reilly

Some will say that nothing good came from the Clone Saga, Marvel's failed attempt to shake up the Spider-Man continuity in the mid-'90s. For the most part, these people are correct; however, the problem's didn't lie in the individual story elements but their confusing and repetitious use.

Advertisement

Ben Reilly was one such idea; Spider-Man's clone who would become a brother of sorts to Peter Parker, dubbing himself the Scarlett Spider. There was even a brief period where he became Spider-Man.

In an attempt to bring the meandering mess that was the Clone Saga to an end, writers resurrected Norman Osborn, revealing him to be the architect behind the whole thing. Reilly would sacrifice himself to save Peter, Mary Jane, their unborn child, and most of New York.

During his polarizing tenure on The Amazing Spider-Man, Dan Slott would resurrect Reilly and reveal him as the mastermind behind the Clone Conspiracy. Once Slott finished that story arc, Reilly was in limbo; his noble sacrifice forgotten so he could be a bit-part player in various "line-wide" Spider-Man crossovers and star in a couple of failed spin-off titles.

3. Anti-Monitor

Once in a while, a villain will appear who holds such destructive force that every hero (and villain, as well) must band together to defeat it; Monstrous entities like the Anti-Monitor who are capable of slaughter on a planetary scale.

Advertisement

Once the dust settles, the cost calculated, and the various heroes return to their everyday adventures, it is only a matter of time before a writer or an editor decides to bring one such universe threatening 'big bad' back. Once again, the heroes gather, sacrifices must be made, and the universe will survive by the skin of its teeth.

What this does is make future returns inevitable. The Anti-Monitor will keep coming back, and eventually it will win. The problem is it only needs to win once, and it's game over. In turn, this means that no matter how many times Superman saves Earth from Brainiac or Batman thwarts the Joker's latest rampage, the entropic Anti-Monitor will return and kill both hero and villain.

If a threat never ends, then it cannot be beaten.

2. Jason Todd

While there has only ever been one "real" Batman, everyone has their favourite Robin. For some, it's Dick Grayson, others Tim Drake, and no doubt there are more than a few Stephanie Brown fans out there as well. Pretty much no one will say Jason Todd.

Advertisement

Todd was the second boy to take on the mantle of Robin. He was a character so unpopular that when DC readers were given the choice of life and death in a phone poll, the decision was almost unanimous to have the Joker smash his brains in.

The death of Jason served as a harsh reminder that even the great Batman is fallible. It took the "Uber-Bat", as fans had come to dub him, and showed that not only was he human, but his actions have real consequences. Todd would become the shadow that haunted Batman, the Joker's cruellest punchline and the seed of doubt in the mind of his allies.

Since the Under the Red Hood arc that detailed his resurrection, Jason Todd has been little more than a bit-part player in Batman's already massive family -another yearly crossover issue replacing a powerful symbol of guilt, failure and pain.

1. Every X-Men Member Ever

The X-Men have become defined by three things: soap opera dramatics, a sprawling cast of characters, and epic plot threads that run over many, many years - be that intentionally or not.

Advertisement

At its best, the main X-Men title is a lens through which writers can talk about politics and social themes; be it Charles Xavier as a proxy for Martin Luther King and Magneto as Malcolm X, or the Legacy Virus as a poorly handled look at the AIDS epidemic.

But this misses the most fundamental point of the X-Men: they are mutants, and mutation is all about change.

The Darwinian adaptation of a species dictates it must always be moving forward. However, for such a system to work, there must be an element of death. Without it, humanity would never have crawled its way out of the primordial soup, and in comics, homo-sapiens would never have begotten homo-superior.

So mutant heaven with a revolving door would serve no other function than the stagnation of that species and a once constantly evolving line of comic books.

Advertisement