10 Actors Who Confirmed They Were Almost Batman

There's bad casting, and then there's THIS...

By Danny Meegan /

Is there a single actor in Hollywood who doesn't want to be a superhero right now?

Advertisement

With the huge success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe - and the general climate of excellent comic-book movies we've been living in for the last two decades - there are very few downsides to strapping on a cape and pretending to beat up some bad guys.

There's just something alluring about getting the chance to define an iconic character on the big screen, and for proof that plenty of big actors are more than willing to sweat inside a rubber costume for a months-long shooting period, look no further than the list of names who've been in the running to play Batman over the years.

Seriously, some massive, massive stars have come surprisingly close to stepping inside the extremely polished shoes of billionaire playboy Bruce Wayne and his batty alter-ego, and as a result, the majority of the Batman movies we've seen over the last thirty years were almost wildly different.

It's hard to imagine anyone other than Christian Bale or Michael Keaton starring in their respective Batman movies, but those guys were never the sole options...

10. Pierce Brosnan - Batman (1989)

Before he became Bond, Pierce Brosnan had the opportunity to play another incredibly famous pop-culture icon.

Advertisement

During the casting process for Tim Burton's classic 1989 Batman movie, the director actually approached Brosnan to talk with him about the title role, but the actor turned the part down because he "couldn't really take it seriously".

In a 2014 Reddit AMA, Brosnan talked about why he rejected the cape and cowl, while adding that, in hindsight, he perhaps acted a little foolishly:

"I went and met with Tim Burton for the role of Batman. But I just couldn't really take it seriously, any man who wears his underpants outside his pants just cannot be taken seriously. That was my foolish take on it. But how wrong was I? Don't get me wrong, because I love Batman, and I grew up on Batman."

In the end, Michael Keaton became Burton's Batman, while Brosnan went on to star as womanising super-spy James Bond in four films between 1995 and 2002.

All things considered, he can't really be too unhappy about the Batman thing.

9. Ethan Hawke - Batman Forever

After Michael Keaton played Batman in two movies, he chose not to reprise the role for a third, and so, the decision was made to recast the part for 1995's Batman Forever.

Advertisement

Eventually, Val Kilmer landed the coveted gig, but before he was locked in, Warner Bros. pursued several other actors, including a young Ethan Hawke.

According to the actor, he turned the role down because he didn't want to be known as Batman for the rest of his life, but he also acknowledged that accepting the job would've been better for his career, and would've afforded him more opportunities:

"This was after Tim Burton's [Batman films], before the bad period. I just didn't want to go to the [New York] Knicks game and have everybody go, 'Wow, you were a great Batman!' That wasn't my f**king goal in life. Now I wish I'd done it, because I could have used it to do other things."

Interestingly, Batman Forever wouldn't be the last time that Hawke's name cropped up in connection with Batman. In the mid-2010s, there was an unfounded and probably untrue rumour that he was being considered to play an older Batman in Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice, before Ben Affleck was ultimately cast.

8. William Baldwin - Batman & Robin

This one will make you feel really sorry for William Baldwin, so be warned.

Advertisement

When Val Kilmer's Batman tenure started and ended with a single movie, the issue of recasting the role was yet again on the table. While George Clooney eventually won the part - before going on to star in the dreadful Batman & Robin - director Joel Schumacher originally had someone completely different in mind: William Baldwin.

Baldwin was actually Schumacher's number one choice for the role, and in a 2009 interview, the actor described how frustratingly close he got to joining the exclusive live-action Batman club - not just once, but twice, only a few years apart.

He also talked about how Daniel Day Lewis and Ralph Fiennes were involved at certain points, although, from the sounds of it, Baldwin came closer then either one of them:

"I was one of Joel Schumacher's top choices when Val Kilmer wound up playing Batman. Tim Burton and Michael Keaton had left, so Joel had the luxury of replacing Michael Keaton and he told me that his four choices - which was an eclectic, diverse array - were Daniel Day Lewis, Ralph Fiennes, Val Kilmer, and me. The next time, when George Clooney did it, [Schumacher] said, 'You were on my original short list with those other three actors, but the studio went with Val and this time I'd like to go with you.' And that Friday afternoon, I thought I was playing Batman - and then Monday morning, the headlines in the trades said that George Clooney had gotten the part. So apparently, I did actually come very close."

Possibly the only thing worse than not playing Batman is thinking that you're going to be playing Batman... and then not playing Batman. Poor guy.

7. Joaquin Phoenix - Batman: Year One

Unlike the actors in the previous entries, Joaquin Phoenix lost out on playing Batman in a movie that was never actually made.

Advertisement

After the failure of Batman & Robin in 1997, Batman's big screen adventures went quiet while Warner Bros. figured out what to do with the character next. Eventually, they settled on Christopher Nolan's Batman Begins - more on that later - but at one point, they were considering letting Darren Aronofsky make a movie based on acclaimed comic-book story arc Batman: Year One.

And if this movie had gone ahead, Aronofsky wanted Joaquin Phoenix to be his Batman. Yep - the same Joaquin Phoenix who just won an Oscar for playing the Joker.

Unfortunately, the project fell apart when Aronofsky realized that the studio didn't share his vision, because, as we recently learned, they wanted someone completely different to play the title role...

6. Freddie Prinze Jr - Batman: Year One

It's a crazy thought, but in an alternate reality, the guy who played Fred in those live-action Scooby-Doo movies could've been Aronofsky's Batman.

Advertisement

In a recent chat with Empire, Aronofsky opened up about his failed Batman movie, revealing that it started to become clear that he and Warner Bros. were on totally different pages once the two parties started discussing casting:

“The studio wanted Freddie Prinze Jr and I wanted Joaquin Phoenix. I remember thinking, 'Uh oh, we're making two different films here.' That's a true story. It was a different time. The Batman I wrote was definitely a way different type of take than they ended up making.”

Now, no disrespect to Freddie Prinze Jr - the dude is awesome as Kanan Jarrus in Star Wars Rebels - but comparing him to Joaquin Phoenix is like comparing Sunday league football to the Premiership. No wonder Year One fell apart.

5. Eion Bailey - Batman Begins

Christian Bale was the lucky chap who ended up playing Batman in Christopher Nolan's epic Dark Knight trilogy, but he didn't secure the role without enduring a bit of friendly competition. In fact, at the same time that Nolan was screen-testing Bale, he was also doing the same with other actors.

Advertisement

One of these was Eion Bailey, who most people will recognise from his role in 2001 miniseries Band of Brothers. Bailey came surprisingly close to landing the part, and got so far into the casting process that he actually got to wear the cape and cowl while auditioning for the filmmakers.

Footage from this audition even made its way online, and upon watching Bailey's performance, it's clear that he wasn't the man for the job. His Bruce Wayne was decent but his Batman was quite underwhelming, and it's hard to picture him pulling off Bale's fierce take on the character.

Still, Bailey has a claim to fame that few will ever achieve: he got to wear an official Batsuit. Can't really complain about that.

4. Cillian Murphy - Batman Begins

Another actor who was in the running alongside Bale and Bailey was Cillian Murphy, and unlike everybody else we've discussed so far, he actually did get to appear in the movie he was circling - although not as the main character.

Advertisement

Murphy was ultimately cast as Jonathan Crane/The Scarecrow in Batman Begins, but originally, he was in the running for the main heroic role rather than a villainous one.

Murphy - whose Batman audition is also viewable online - was one of the select few who was chosen by Nolan to potentially be his Batman, but during this process, the director realized that Murphy would be better served in a different role.

Like with Bailey, it's abundantly clear that Murphy just wouldn't have been the right choice for Batman in this particular movie. The complete opposite of Bailey, his Bruce Wayne felt like a serial killer whereas his Batman seemed unhinged in the right way, but the overall package just wasn't present.

Amusingly, Murphy was recently asked about Batman on Late Night With Seth Meyers, where he confessed that he didn't feel like he was the right fit for the part, and that he felt like Bale was the obvious choice all along. Hey, at least he's honest.

3. Armie Hammer - Justice League Mortal

If William Baldwin was disappointed with the way his Batman courtship ended, then Armie Hammer must've been full-on tilted.

Advertisement

In 2007, Warner Bros. commissioned a script for a movie called Justice League Mortal, and later that same year, they hired George Miller to direct it. The movie was intended to be separate from the Nolan films, and would instead take place within its own cinematic universe.

For this reason, a brand-new Batman needed to be cast - and that's where Hammer entered the picture.

The actor was actually cast as Batman - alongside D.J. Cotrona as Superman and Common as Green Lantern - and was all set to play the character in Miller's vision for Justice League, but sadly, the movie collapsed due to several complicated reasons, including the 2007-2008 Writers Guild of America strike.

Hammer's name once again entered the Batman picture when the time came to replace Ben Affleck, although he wasn't so lucky that time.

2. Josh Brolin - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice

Josh Brolin is no stranger to the world of comic-book movies, having played Cable in Deadpool 2, and Thanos in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Advertisement

Also... there's Jonah Hex. But we don't like to talk about that one.

If things had gone differently, he could've also been in a Batman movie as the title character, giving him another film to add to his pile of superhero projects.

Before Ben Affleck was cast in Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice, Brolin spoke with director Zack Snyder about the possibility of him being the one to face off against the Man of Steel. In the end though, both men agreed that it wasn't the right fit, with Brolin revealing that there were "several reasons" why this was the case:

“Me and Zack had a conversation about it, and there were several reasons why we said it wasn’t the best idea on both sides. I had mine and Zack had his.”

Again, since Brolin has played Cable and Thanos - with the latter character appearing in two of the highest-grossing films of all time - we doubt that he's even bothered about not playing Batman, especially after seeing how Affleck's stint turned out.

1. Nicholas Hoult - The Batman

In early 2019 - after it was confirmed that Ben Affleck would be stepping down as Batman - the entire film fan community turned its attention to that all-important question: who will don the famous costume next?

Advertisement

At the time, we knew that Matt Reeves - director of the upcoming Batman film - was seeking a younger actor to play the part, and in May 2019, we learned that he'd selected Twilight's Robert Pattinson as the next Dark Knight. But, as is always the case with these things, there were other names in the mix too.

And one of those names was Nicholas Hoult, who is most familiar to audiences for his role as Beast in Fox's X-Men prequel films. Hoult, reportedly, was in the running for the Batman role alongside Pattinson, and the two actors were neck-and-neck for the vast majority of the casting process.

He even got to wear a Batsuit too, with Reeves trying to gauge who would be the best fit for his take on the source material. Clearly, Hoult came ridiculously close to scoring the part, but after Reeves and Warner Bros. deliberated for a few days, they decided that Pattinson was their guy.

Annoyingly for Hoult, he's also lost his role in the X-Men movies too, considering the high likelihood that the series will be rebooted under Disney. 2019 really wasn't a good year for him.

-

If you could see just one of these actors appear as Batman, who would it be? Let us know your choice in the comments section below!

Advertisement