10 Best Harry Potter Plot Twists
The Harry Potter stories were abundant with plot twists, but which one will make it to the top spot?
There were many factors that contributed to the success of the Harry Potter series. A tightly bound yet rich setting, an extensive list of distinctive personalities, and an accessible magic system were amongst the greatest of J.K. Rowling’s literary achievements with this franchise.
In terms of the plot, the Harry Potter stories were greatly influenced by the titans of detective fiction. Writers such as Margery Allingham, Agatha Christie, Ngaio Marsh, and Dorothy L. Sayers were all huge inspirations for Rowling.
Consequently, the Harry Potter books and movies were loaded with intrigue, and often felt closer to mystery stories than fantasy stories.
With such mysteries, there also came a significant number of plot twists. Whilst many of her influences were limited by the physics of the real world, Rowling’s winding narrative was forged in the magical setting she herself had created, allowing her to craft some truly wonderful plot twists…
10. Harry Rescued Himself And Sirius From The Dementors – The Prisoner Of Azkaban
There were many highlights of Harry and Hermione's adventures with time. Yet the best moment was undoubtedly the former’s realisation that it was he who had defeated the dementors.
Initially, Harry believed his father to have saved himself and Sirius. Though this seemed unlikely to be the case, the true identity of Harry’s saviour was certainly an intriguing enigma when reading The Prisoner of Azkaban.
By having Harry be the one to cast the Patronus Charm, Rowling exemplified for the first time just how magically gifted he was. Up until this point, Hermione had always been the standout student when it came to magical talent, but this particular moment demonstrated that Harry was in some ways the most powerful of the leading trio.
In this sense, the strength of this twist is not the unveiling of the truth itself, but rather what it signifies.
9. Snape Was The Half-Blood Prince – The Half-Blood Prince
The identity of the Half-Blood Prince was kept secret until the very end of the penultimate Harry Potter story.
Prior to this revelation, the Half-Blood Prince was a very ambiguous character. He certainly had plenty of talent and helped Harry continuously during class, which in turn made the Prince somewhat likeable.
However, he also had a knack for harmful and often dark magic. Indeed, Harry’s use of the Sectumsempra Curse against Malfoy demonstrated that the Half-Blood Prince was as dangerous as he was helpful.
Given that Snape informed Harry that he was the Half-Blood Prince only minutes after murdering Dumbledore, the weight of such information was particularly heavy for Harry to bear.
Such a twist was also very difficult to predict. Beyond the obvious assumption that the Prince was likely to be a half-blood wizard, there were very few clues as to who he truly was, making the ultimate reveal that much more impactful.
8. Professor Quirrell Was After The Philosopher’s Stone - The Philosopher's Stone
Compared with its sequels, the first entry in the Harry Potter series was relatively devoid of plot twists. Yet the final chapter still provided an unexpected development in the form of Professor Quirrell.
Prior to this revelation, Harry, Ron and Hermione had assumed – with good reason – that it was Snape who had been trying to steal the stone. Quirrell, on the other hand, had come across as rather pathetic throughout the story and seemed unlikely to be a villain.
It was to everyone’s surprise, therefore, that Harry found Quirrell standing in front of the Mirror of Erised during the finale of his first year.
As with many of her twists, however, Rowling had sprinkled a number of clues throughout the narrative that indicated the truth, the most obvious of which was that Quirrell had been in Diagon Alley the same day someone had tried to steal the stone from Gringotts.
Still, even the most astute of individuals could never have predicted Quirrell’s true allegiance.
7. Ginny Opened The Chamber Of Secrets – The Chamber Of Secrets
As with the twist at the end of The Philosopher’s Stone, the fact that it was Ginny who had opened the Chamber of Secrets was unexpected yet still hinted at throughout the story.
The most obvious clue to this reveal was that Ginny appeared to be deeply upset if not traumatised by the events of her first year. However, when reading The Chamber of Secrets for the first time, such behaviour did not appear particularly suspicious given the context.
Such a twist was also unexpected given that Rowling had suggested that whoever was opening the Chamber was a Slytherin. Indeed, Malfoy always seemed the obvious culprit.
Consequently, the fact that the real culprit was Ginny was a massive shock. Even though she had been acting under the influence of Voldemort, Ginny’s involvement was impossible to predict.
6. Harry's Invisibility Cloak Was A Hallow – The Deathly Hallows
Harry’s Invisibility Cloak was one of the most fascinating items in Rowling’s world. Given by Dumbledore in The Philosopher’s Stone, the cloak was an essential tool in Harry’s arsenal during his many adventures at Hogwarts and beyond.
From the moment it came into our hero’s possession, the cloak carried an aura of mystery. The fact that it used to belong to Harry’s father was not particularly remarkable, but the question as to why Dumbledore had the cloak at the time of Lily and James’ death was certainly an intriguing one.
The answer to such a question was not given until The Deathly Hallows. After a narrow escape from the Lovegood’s house, Harry pondered The Tale of the Three Brothers. He then came to the realisation that he was descended from the Peverell brothers, and that the cloak was in fact the Third Hallow, which was why Dumbledore had been so interested in it.
Though it was by no means the biggest reveal in The Deathly Hallows, this particular plot twist provided a highly satisfactory answer to the ambiguity surrounding Harry’s Invisibility Cloak.
5. R.A.B. Was Regulus Black – The Half-Blood Prince And The Deathly Hallows
There were several times in which Sirius referred to his family’s dark past. Much like the Malfoys, the Black family were synonymous with Slytherin House.
Given that Sirius’ brother had been a Death Eater, he certainly did not spring to mind as someone who would steal one of his master’s Horcruxes. Even with the initials ‘R.A.B.’ as a clue, it was almost impossible to make this connection.
Consequently, when Harry discovered the truth whilst at Grimmauld Place in the final novel, fans of the series were not expecting this reveal.
Yet it made sense. As a Death Eater, Regulus would have had a closer relationship with Voldemort than most, and therefore be likely to discover his secrets. Moreover, Regulus’ death was always somewhat ambiguous. In the fifth novel, Sirius informed Harry that his brother had died after attempting to leave the Death Eaters, but the specific circumstances of his death were always unknown.
Kreacher’s tale of his young master’s death, therefore, was an unexpected yet fascinating chapter in The Deathly Hallows, and is all too often overlooked given the many other revelations in the final novel.
4. Scabbers Was Peter Pettigrew And Sirius Was Innocent – The Prisoner Of Azkaban
Scabbers seemed an unlikely source for a plot twist. During the first two entries in the series, he was merely an additional quirk for Ron. In the third, however, Rowling revealed that Scabbers was in fact Peter Pettigrew.
Despite Harry having noticed the name ‘Peter Pettigrew’ on the Marauder’s Map earlier in the story, no one could have predicted that Ron’s rat was an Animagus.
In tandem with such a revelation came the knowledge that Sirius was innocent and had been wrongly imprisoned for the crimes that Peter had committed.
As well as the shock of this multifaceted twist, from Harry’s perspective, it also meant that he now had a father figure. Though Hagrid and Dumbledore had a somewhat parental relationship with our hero, Sirius felt closer to a genuine family member given that he was Harry’s godfather.
In this sense, as well as being highly unexpected, this twist had an emotional resonance with both Harry and the audience.
3. Mad-Eye Moody Was Barty Crouch Junior – The Goblet Of Fire
The plot twist at the end of The Goblet of Fire was one of Rowling’s greatest. As well as being beautifully hinted at throughout the narrative, said twist had two shocking elements to it. Specifically, Mad-Eye Moody was not just an imposter in disguise, said imposter was also a Death Eater who was believed to be dead.
During Harry’s fourth year, there were a number of clues to this ending. Yet such clues were wonderfully masked by Rowling. For instance, Moody routinely tried to help Harry during the tournament, indicating that he was looking out for him, when in reality he was trying to give him a head start into the maze, making him more likely to reach the cup first.
There was also a clue during Harry’s ventures with his golden egg. After leaving the prefects’ bathroom, he noticed the name ‘Barty Crouch’ on the Marauder’s Map, believing this to be Barty Crouch Senior when it was in fact his son.
Still, given that Crouch had supposedly died in Azkaban many years ago, such clues were easily passed over. As a result, the unveiling of Moody’s true identity came as a massive shock.
2. Harry Was A Horcrux – The Deathly Hallows
Since The Philosopher’s Stone, Harry had an usual connection with Voldemort. The pains in his scar, odd dreams, and an ability to speak to snakes all suggested that there was more to Harry and Voldemort’s relationship than Rowling was letting on.
Granted, she did offer us some information at the end of The Chamber of Secrets when Dumbledore explained that Voldemort had transferred some of his powers to Harry when he tried to kill him. However, such information was a mere hint to the actual truth.
Within the many revelations that took place during Harry’s final venture into the pensieve, the twist that Harry was in fact a Horcrux was amongst the best. Whereas most twists throughout the series were memorable for their shock factor, this one had a dark overtone which made the reveal more sombre than surprising.
Now aware that he would have to die, the aftermath of this revelation saw Harry walk into the Forbidden Forest to face death at the hands of Voldemort.
Though other plot twists were certainly more shocking, this particular twist stands out for its deep significance to Harry’s personal journey and development.
1. Snape’s True Allegiance – The Half-Blood Prince And The Deathly Hallows
Snape’s allegiance was a story arc involving multiple twists, the first of which came in the form of Dumbledore’s death at the end of the penultimate story. Crucially, this twist raised a key question – was Dumbledore’s death preordained or was Snape loyal to Voldemort?
Snape’s memories at the end of The Deathly Hallows confirmed the former to be true, yet few could have predicted why this was the case.
As with other twists, Rowling had skilfully masked the truth earlier on. During one of Harry’s previous exploits inside the pensieve, he had seen Snape describe Lily as a Mudblood, suggesting that he did not care for her.
However, in The Deathly Hallows, it was finally revealed that Snape had loved Lily since childhood, and that this was the foundation of his loyalty to Dumbledore. This in turn also explained why Snape felt such animosity towards Harry and his father, as both of them were a reminder that Lily had loved another.
Despite the fact that some fans correctly guessed that Snape had always been loyal to Dumbledore, it was almost impossible to predict the reason behind such loyalty.
--
Which Harry Potter plot twist do you think is the best? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.