10 Blockbuster Leading Men So Boring They Almost Put Us To Sleep

Writing about these actors has bored us so much, we don't even have the energy to write a witty excerpt for you...

By Scott Campbell /

With most big-budget blockbusters now being adapted from existing properties, it seems as though the days when A-list stars were used to sell movies to general audiences are fast becoming obsolete. Instead, studios churn out sequels, remakes, reboots and re-imaginings based on recognizable brands in order to get people into the multiplex. Does this mean that actors are becoming increasingly less important when it comes to marketing studio tent-poles? Well, yes and no. Some of the biggest franchises in Hollywood are sold more on the strength of the characters or the brand rather than the actors who star in them; like Batman, Superman, Star Wars and Harry Potter. On the other side of the coin, there are franchises that are inextricably tied to their lead actors, so much so that it becomes impossible to envision a movie without them; imagine Iron Man without Robert Downey Jr., Pirates of the Caribbean without Johnny Depp or Indiana Jones without Harrison Ford and they suddenly become completely different prospects. Take Gareth Edwards' Godzilla as a recent example; the movie opened to over $93m domestically and in less than two weeks has grossed well over $300m worldwide, yet one of the biggest criticisms of the movie was Aaron Taylor-Johnson's one-dimensional and uninteresting central character. You'd be hard-pressed to guess he was the lead from the marketing, which centered more on Bryan Cranston and the titular monster. With that in mind, this article will take a look at ten actors that have delivered boring leading performances in blockbuster movies, some more than once. This isn't an attack on any of the actors on the list; many have proven themselves capable in a variety of movies in different genres. It's just that taking a starring role in a big-budget studio picture clearly isn't their forte. Do you agree with the choices in the article? Are any of these actors being harshly treated by their inclusion? Are there any other names that you would have included? As always, sign off in comments below.

10. Logan Lerman

Boring Blockbusters: Percy Jackson & The Olympians: The Lightning Thief (2010), The Three Musketeers (2011), Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters (2013) At the age of just 22, Logan Lerman has already built up a solid filmography. Since making his debut as one of Mel Gibson's children in The Patriot, the actor has impressed in the likes of 3:10 to Yuma, The Perks of Being a Wallflower and Noah. However, as a blockbuster leading man his performances have failed to match his supporting roles in terms of quality. In the first Percy Jackson movie, Lerman's limitations are exposed when sharing the screen with the big names in supporting roles (Sean Bean, Pierce Brosnan, Rosario Dawson and the like) and the young actor fails to stand out amongst the CGI and extended ensemble. The sequel offers much of the same albeit on a slightly lower budget, featuring little character development (surely a prerequisite for a sequel?) and another flat performance from the usually-likeable actor. In Paul W.S Anderson's preposterous (and very loose) $75m adaptation of Alexandre Dumas' classic, Lerman's D'Artagnan is the only character in the movie with an American accent, and for some reason the actor decides to play the character as irredeemably smug, failing to bring any charm or personality to the role and being easily overshadowed by the rampant scenery-chewing from the rest of the cast.

9. Ryan Reynolds

Boring Blockbusters: Green Lantern (2011), Safe House (2012), R.I.P.D (2013) Ryan Reynolds is an actor who tends to operate best outside of the confines of blockbuster leading man. A veteran of poorly-received comic book movies, the Canadian has given the best performances of his career in either smaller supporting roles or low-budget independent projects, although he was unfortunate enough to take leading roles in two of the biggest box office bombs of recent years. After over a decade in development, the $200m comic book adaptation of Green Lantern saw Reynolds play Hal Jordan, a character as underdeveloped and one-dimensional as the movie's script. Usually a naturally charismatic presence on-screen, Reynolds is buried under an avalanche of exposition and CGI that neuters his talents and results in a protagonist as dull as the movie itself. The following year, Reynolds would play a by-the-numbers CIA rookie in the forgettable Safe House, a predictable actioner largely carried by the always-reliable Denzel Washington. Last year saw the actor co-star with Jeff Bridges in R.I.P.D, a thoroughly terrible Men in Black knock-off that didn't even recoup two-thirds of the $130m budget at the box office. Although Bridges is enjoying himself in a scenery-chewing role, Reynolds is burdened by one of the dullest and poorly-written lead characters in recent blockbuster history. After Blade: Trinity, X-Men Origins: Wolverine, Green Lantern and this debacle, perhaps he should stay away from comic book movies. Unless we ever get that R-rated Deapool, of course...

8. Matthew Broderick

Boring Blockbusters: Godzilla (1998), Inspector Gadget (1999) Aaron Taylor-Johnson's flat performance in Gareth Edwards' 2014 reboot may have served as the inspiration for this article, but at least the young Englishman was marginally more interesting that Matthew Broderick's character in Roland Emmerich's widely-maligned Hollywood redo of the iconic Japanese kaiju. Broderick's Nick Tatopoulos is seemingly only given that name in the script for a series of poor jokes in which no-one can pronounce it correctly, which pretty much sums up the movie's lazy writing. Given the occupation of a scientist investigating the effects of radiation on wildlife also gives him the chance to recite some thoroughly awful dialogue with little conviction. Broderick can be a charismatic presence on-screen, but in Godzilla his performance never climbs above thunderously dull. The following year Broderick took the lead role in the $90m live-action adaptation of the popular animated series Inspector Gadget, but for the second year in a row his performance in a big-budget studio movie was hugely uninspired. Lacking any humor, wit or personality, Broderick acts as if he knows the movie is going to suck, which it does. Even at less than 80 minutes, Inspector Gadget sure drags in.

7. Garrett Hedlund

Boring Blockbuster: Tron: Legacy (2010) Joseph Kosinski's sequel arrived a full 28 years after the original cult classic, and while the movie is visually stunning at times and boasts a great soundtrack, the human element in the story is sorely lacking. When even Jeff Bridges fails to give a strong performance, what chance did Garrett Hedlund have with such a poorly-realised character and stilted dialogue? Given the standard big-budget Hollywood character motivation of 'daddy issues' and little else to work with, Hedlund tries his best but just doesn't convince with his puppy-dog expressions and charisma-free lead performance that ranges all the way from wooden to just plain bland. Sure, a lot of blame can be laid at the hands of a weak script in a movie that favours visual style above character development, but in a production that was designed to sell tickets based on the eye-popping 3D Hedlund's performance is painfully flat and one-dimensional.

6. Colin Farrell

Boring Blockbusters: S.W.A.T. (2003), Alexander (2004), Miami Vice (2006), Total Recall (2012) Colin Farrell can give a great performance with the right material, as evidenced by strong turns over the last decade in projects as varied as Minority Report, Daredevil, In Bruges and Horrible Bosses to name but a few. However, whenever the actor has taken the lead role in a big-budget feature he has failed to deliver anything near his best work. In Clark Johnson's $70m adaptation of the 1970s television series, Farrell plays Jim Street, a hot-shot rookie S.W.A.T officer with a personality as uninteresting as his name. The actor fares no worse than the rest of the cast, although that is hardly a compliment given the by-the-numbers dialogue and overall mediocrity of the final product. The following year, the Irishman played the title character in Oliver Stone's long-gestating $155m epic Alexander. Although subsequent cuts of the movie have marked an improvement on the theatrical version, Farrell seems painfully miscast and fails to hold the audience's attention as one of history's greatest strategists. The actor would then share leading man status alongside Jamie Foxx in the $135m big-screen adaptation of Miami Vice, which is as great-looking as you would expect from a Michael Mann movie but suffers from taking itself too seriously and a frankly alarming lack of chemistry between the two leads. Farrell's latest big-budget leading role would see him step into Arnold Schwarzenegger's shoes as Douglas Quaid in the lifeless Total Recall remake. Vastly inferior to Paul Verhoeven's sci-fi action classic, the actor delivers a frustratingly one-note performance as soulless as the movie itself. Without a doubt Colin Farrell is a more than a capable actor, although he is one who struggles in carrying a major studio picture.

5. Robert Pattinson

Boring Blockbusters: Twilight (2008), New Moon (2009), Eclipse (2010), Breaking Dawn - Part 1 (2011), Breaking Dawn - Part 2 (2012) The Twilight Saga may have a huge fanbase that propelled the franchise to a frankly ridiculous $3.3bn in box office receipts, but the three central protagonists are quite possibly the most perpetually boring trio in the history of blockbuster cinema. However, as much as some people loath the franchise, there is every chance that Robert Pattinson hates it more than anyone. This would surely go some way to explaining why Pattinson plays the character of Edward Cullen as a virtually-expressionless borderline stalker that spends a lot of time giving intense stares to a girl almost 100 years his junior, and which despite their well-publicized romance, Pattinson and Kristen Stewart generate zero chemistry on-screen. If it seems as though the actor isn't interested, it's probably because he's not. Pattinson has stated that he began to hate the character after reading the script, and went as far as to say that if he wasn't a part of the franchise he would 'mindlessly hate it', which at least goes a way to explaining his crushingly dull performances in the franchise. Now embarking on the next phase of his career, Pattinson has proven himself as a decent actor in projects outside of Twilight and has since worked with auteurs David Cronenberg and Werner Herzog.

4. Ben Affleck

Boring Blockbusters: Armageddon (1998), Pearl Harbor (2001), The Sum of All Fears (2002), Daredevil (2003), Paycheck (2003) Ben Affleck has had one of the most interesting movie careers in recent memory. An Academy Award-winning writer at 25, he was one of the biggest movie stars in the world at the turn of the 21st Century before a string of critical and commercial flops saw his star drastically fade. In the last few years, he has reinvented himself as a critically-acclaimed filmmaker, culminating in a Best Picture win for his third movie Argo at the Academy Awards. Oh, and he's Batman. Armageddon features all of the style over substance and paper-thin characterisation synonymous with a Michael Bay movie, and Affleck struggles to bring any depth or personality to his bland and overly-sentimental character. Re-teaming with the same director for epic war romance Pearl Harbor, the actor suffers much of the same problems as he struggles with the cliche-ridden script loaded with awful dialogue. Inheriting the mantle of Jack Ryan for franchise reboot The Sum of All Fears, Affleck delivered the weakest and most poorly-realized incarnation of the character yet in a mildly entertaining if overly predictable thriller. In Daredevil, the actor suits the role of Matt Murdock much better than the titular superhero but fails to convince in the melodramatic moments and is easily overshadowed by Colin Farrell's scene-stealing Bullseye. Affleck's last big-budget leading role for over a decade also served as John Woo's final Hollywood effort as the director and star both failed to elevate Paycheck above dull mediocrity. Here's hoping his take on the Caped Crusader is more interesting than his previous blockbuster starring roles...

3. Taylor Kitsch

Boring Blockbusters: John Carter (2012), Battleship (2012) Taylor Kitsch probably couldn't believe his luck when he landed the starring role in not one, but two of 2012's most expensive blockbusters. Unfortunately for the Canadian actor, the reception to both was lukewarm to say the least and his career as a viable blockbuster man was seemingly over before it had even began. Andrew Stanton's John Carter was a wildly ambitious production, and will no doubt be heralded as a cult favourite years from now. However, the fact remains that it is one of the biggest box office disasters in history, one that reportedly cost Disney a financial write-down upwards of $100m. A visually stunning old-fashioned adventure, it speaks volumes about Kitsch's performance that he is arguably the least convincing character despite being surrounded by creatures from another planet. Unconvincing at the best of times and downright wooden at the worst, such an expensive epic could have greatly benefited from a stronger leading man. Battleship, the Michael Bay-iest movie ever that wasn't directed by Michael Bay, sees Kitsch fare no better. The concept seemed doomed from the start, and the movie holds the record for worst opening weekend ever for a feature that cost over $200m. Playing a character as dull and formulaic as the script, Kitsch displays little emotion or charisma while delivering plenty of head-shakingly terrible dialogue. As proven by Friday Night Lights, Savages and Lone Survivor, Kitsch can act when given the right material. However, it seems that leading a big-budget studio movie is an opportunity he won't be given again anytime soon based on his history.

2. Hayden Christensen

Boring Blockbusters: Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones (2002), Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith (2005), Jumper (2008) If you thought Jake Lloyd was awful as Anakin Skywalker (and he was), at least audiences only had to put up with him for one movie. Inheriting the role for the sequels, Hayden Christensen makes the cardinal sin of turning the young Jedi who becomes Darth Vader into an unforgivably dull spoiled brat whose affections for Natalie Portman's Padme can occasionally come across as downright creepy. Granted, George Lucas' terrible dialogue doesn't do any of the cast a favour but Christensen's acting in Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith is so wooden it makes Jaden Smith look like Jack Nicholson by comparison. With stilted line readings more suited to a bad soap opera than a blockbuster franchise, Christensen seems unable to emote convincingly and his chemistry with Natalie Portman is virtually non-existent. Given a chance to prove himself in a blockbuster outside of a galaxy far, far away, Christensen took the lead in Doug Liman's $85m Jumper and yet again failed to convince. Once again displaying a startling lack of charisma for a leading man, the movie botches the potential of the premise thanks to some ropey acting and a realised narrative. Hayden Christensen has shown he is capable of delivering a decent performance on occasion, but the evidence is there to definitively prove he can't deliver one in a studio blockbuster.

1. Sam Worthington

Boring Blockbusters: Terminator Salvation (2009), Avatar (2009), Clash of the Titans (2010), Wrath of the Titans (2012) Sam Worthington seemingly came out of nowhere in 2009 and ended up with his name above the poster of Terminator Salvation alongside Christian Bale, in what was his first major Hollywood feature. Suddenly pegged as 'the next big thing' in Hollywood, he starred in three studio blockbusters in a row that grossed over $3.5bn at the box office. However, things cooled down considerably when people began to realise his obvious limitations as an actor. In Terminator Salvation, Worthington's performance was suitably robotic for a man unaware he was a cyborg, but its debatable as to whether that was by accident or design. More questionable was his wayward accent, which veered almost uncontrollably from American to his native Australian and back again. Several months later came James Cameron's game-changing Avatar (which had actually been shot months before the Terminator reboot), in which the actor delivers another monotonous performance utterly devoid of personality until he gets to be big and blue. In Clash of the Titans, Worthington's Perseus is an incredibly dull hero, devoid of any warmth or charisma. So much so that the actor even described his own performance in the movie as bland. Which makes it all the stranger that he does the exact same thing in the sequel, resulting in yet another one-note, emotionless performance. In the last few years the actor has shied away from taking starring roles in any more big-budget blockbusters, which is probably for the best. Although he bears the chiseled looks of a Hollywood leading man, the actor is too generic and uninteresting a screen presence to convince as one.