10 Comic Book Movies That Aren't Based On Comic Books

No pen and ink for this lot (though some of them stink)...

By Steve Palace /

Throw a stone at your local multiplex and you'll more than likely hit someone on their way into a comic book movie. When I grew up I had to make do with Nicholas Hammond as Spider Man and Bill Bixby as The Incredible Hulk. We didn't have any of that CGI sorcery in those days, you know. Today's audience is treated to a smorgasbord of costumed cinematic mayhem every other week, be they acne-ridden teens or life-ridden adults. Such is the hold that Marvel and DC exert on the box office the non-spandexed competition is squeezed out like a frankfurter from the bun of an overloaded hot dog. 1989's Batman changed the rules of filmic conquest, and since then studios and indies alike have wanted a bite out of that super-powered pie. The solution is clear to a lot of filmmakers - if you can't beat 'em, join 'em. However they don't necessarily need a source comic to do it. Here we find those movies that look like a comic book, sound like a comic book, but aren't ripped from the panels of a book itself. Some are amazing. Some are decidedly earthbound. Yet all of them owe their existence to those hardworking writers and artists with their hunched backs, clawed hands and allergy to opening the curtains. Let's turn the page...

10. My Super Ex-Girlfriend

Ghostbusters director Ivan Reitman cast Amazonian all-rounder Uma Thurman in this 2006 romantic comedy with an evil-smashing twist. Luke Wilson brought the beefcake as mortal Matt, whose new date appeared bookish and shy, but who actually was the secret identity of profoundly pneumatic superheroine G-Girl. Seems a pair of spectacles and a cardigan was enough to fool this charming lunkhead. Essentially Superman with boobs, G-Girl claimed numerous powers and a typical radiation-fuelled origin story, but suffered from those problems often afflicting prominent female characters in the flicks, namely possessiveness and mood swings like you wouldn't believe. You'd have to have Kryptonite in your head not to like Thurman, but she sure can pick 'em at times. The film co-starred Eddie Izzard (currently comic booking it on the small screen in Powers), Anna Faris and a certain Rainn Wilson, more on which later...

9. Sky High

Kids go to school. Kids like comic book movies. So why not have a comic book movie about superheroes going to school? It all made perfect sense to Disney, who hired Mike Mitchell to direct this teen titan affair in 2005. Following the hormone-powered tribulations of super-sprog Will Stronghold (Michael Angarano), it was a fairly standard catalogue of whining and derring-do and a canny way for the House of Mouse to hitch a ride on the gravy boat. A cult trio of seismic proportions led the grown up side of the equation - former Wonder Woman Lynda Carter, former Snake Kurt Russell and current chainsaw-wielding Ash Bruce Campbell. For some reason the villain was called Royal Pain, a name which some parents dragged along to screenings may have appreciated. Respectable returns made Sky High a decent investment for the studio, though it walked up walls rather than soared into the clouds. It gave the genre a good-natured ribbing, but the efforts weren't enough to launch a franchise.

8. Unbreakable

Having spooked up the place with The Sixth Sense, riddler extraordinaire M. Night Shyamalan tackled pulp heroics in this 2000 thriller. Bruce Willis looked like just another bald man in a raincoat, till brittle-boned egghead Samuel L. Jackson informed him he was an advanced form of bald man in a raincoat. Soon after Willis was displaying mind-boggling levels of strength and reading minds to squash crime. The idea was to make a comic book film that didn't shout from the rooftops, but rather let the concept reveal itself gradually. The result didn't perform well at the multiplex, though enough interest has persisted for a sequel to be talked up over the years. Jackson of course went onto become a mainstay of the Marvel Cinematic Universe as Nick Fury. On the flipside of the coin, Shyamalan's rise faltered with the likes of animated adaptation disaster The Last Airbender before The Visit boosted his stock, so he could be eyeing Unbreakable 2 as a potential project.

7. Condorman

Sky High wasn't Disney's first go at a superhero-derived movie, as unfortunately the 1981 Michael Crawford vehicle Condorman shows. He played Woody Wilkins, a milder-than-mild-mannered illustrator who wound up becoming his own feathery, fist-flinging creation. Part-nerd, part-bird, part-kite, he romanced KGB spy Barbara Carrera and tangled with Oliver Reed's formidable Krokov. Robert Sheckley's novel The Game Of X provided the source material, though it appears Uncle Walt took this and surgically-grafted a comic concept over the plot. It didn't help that the poster for Charles Jarrott's picture depicted Crawford in a beige mac, an image associated with his legendary role, Frank Spencer. In a strange twist, the character who emerged from a fictional comic book into the real world was then converted into an official print version by Whitman Comics. Unlike the cinematic adventure, that one got a follow up.

6. The Incredibles

Ratatouille/Tomorrowland shot-caller Brad Bird was responsible for Disney's family-focused, suited-and-booted spectacular in 2004. Taking a simple idea and running with it, the retro-styled CG romp featured a brood of bad guy bashers, from square-jawed Dad (Mr Incredible) to infant powerhouse Jack-Jack. Super-strength, super-speed, super-invisibility and elasticity... all the boxes were ticked in an adventure that pitched them against evil hoodwinker Syndrome. If anyone was going to give the studio a box office comic book colossus it was Pixar. Bird managed to give the Comic-Con crowd a knowing wink whilst crafting characters who were both derivative yet convincing in their own right. Well-designed and genuinely thrilling, the smooth animation pushed the excitement to new heights. The voice cast were perfectly-selected. Holly Hunter, Samuel L. Jackson (his second appearance on the list), Jason Lee and ubiquitous Pixar choice John Ratzenberger were present and correct. A sequel is smashing into cinemas in 2019.

5. Super

Troma alumnus James Gunn wrote and directed the darkest entry on our rundown, a journey into vigilante territory where the laws of the comic book were put into deadly action by fevered minds. Rainn Wilson played a burger-flipping functionary who dreamed of donning red lycra and meting out a beating to the city's great and not-so-good. Assisting him was the over-eager Ellen Page as a sexier, more violent version of Burt Ward's Robin. Together they became The Crimson Bolt and Boltie. The 2010 movie was funny throughout, with the catchphrase of "Shut Up, Crime!" proving particularly memorable. It capitalized on Wilson's haunted goofiness and Page's winning cynicism as we followed the pair into a true nightmare scenario. As superhero sagas go it was definitely in the realm of Watchmen rather than Homer Simpson's Pieman. It also gave unexpected rise to an offbeat, cash-guzzling phenomenon when Gunn was selected to helm Guardians Of The Galaxy on the strength of Super. Giving fans a premium dollop of acid-tongued escapism, he's currently setting Vol.2 in motion, to rock out in cinemas 2017.

4. The Adventures Of Buckaroo Banzai

Big Trouble In Little China creator W.D. Richter took the director's chair for this ultimate cult escapade. Future Robocop Peter Weller was the title character, a polymath capable of doing everything from perform brain surgery to playing a fine guitar riff. He battled aliens from another dimension, commanded by the mighty John Lithgow, with the help of his band of boffin brothers the Hong Kong Cavaliers. When the story finally made it to the screen in 1984 it had gone through a mind-boggling number of variations. Banzai's author Earl Mac Rauch came up with the character idea, then fleshed him out over a series of aborted screenplay drafts, encompassing several stories. When the film didn't recoup its budget the concept became a comic book. Marvel adapted the movie and Moonstone went on to continue the ride in print. Appropriate, as the jumbled mix of genres and large scope suggested this could well have been a graphic novel. As it happened it only ended up that way.

3. The Matrix

Creative partnership the Wachowskis left a sizeable mark on Hollywood with the opening chapter of their Matrix trilogy. Keanu Reeves took a trip into Wonderland when he discovered the world as we know it was in fact a battery bank for a machine race, and humanity lived in a dream state whilst they leeched our energy reserves. Cue a cyber-bucketload of martial arts, headache-inducing stunts and slo-mo effects. The 1999 movie owed a lot to Hong Kong cinema, but also paid a major due to the comic book world. Indeed, the directors had to get two well-known artists (Hard Boiled's Geoff Darrow and Marvel's Steve Skroce) to create an elaborate storyboard in order to convince Warner Bros to sink funds into the project. Laurence Fishburne's Morpheus was inspired by his namesake in Sandman by Neil Gaiman. Imagery contained in The Matrix, including matter-bending henchmen in cool sunglasses and mechanized squid soldiers the Sentinels, were straight out of a comics franchise. The Wachowskis' background as Marvel writers meant they wasted no time in exploring their concept via those platforms, converting it into a long-running print series.

2. The Fifth Element

Luc Besson has given us some bizarre cinematic visions in his time, but arguably the strangest was this 1997 space opera. Bruce Willis played futuristic cabbie Korben Dallas, who got mixed up in a plot to protect a perfect being (Milla Jovovich, and why not?) who held the key to a centuries-old intergalactic conundrum. Aiding and abetting the ensuing carnage were Gary Oldman, Ian Holm and Chris Tucker as a ludicrous variation on Prince. As if pop's purple prince wasn't ludicrous enough! Jean-Paul Gaultier designed the costumes, ensuring the experience got an extra injection of weird. Euro-helmer Besson consulted heavily with comic book artists M“bius and Mézières to help realize a unique big screen landscape, which was both colourful and dangerous. The collection of extreme characters lumped into a universe-spanning storyline best categorized as vague gave The Fifth Element a pulp quality that wouldn't have looked out of place on the shelves of Forbidden Planet.

1. Darkman

Liam Neeson got an early starring role as a phantom crimefighter in Sam Raimi's homage to '30s pulp fiction from 1990. After getting his face melted by acid at the hands of a ruthless gang pursuing an incriminating document, Dr Peyton Westlake became his own test subject, plastering himself in the synthetic skin he hoped would save the world's burns victims. Kitting himself out in trenchcoat and fedora, Westlake took on the identity of Darkman. Raimi intended the film to reflect the classic Universal Horror stable, however the spectre of '89's Batman loomed large, both in the dark urban setting and the use of the same composer (Danny Elfman), who turned in a bombastic score reminiscent of Tim Burton's multi-milion dollar moolah-sponge. The project wouldn't even have taken off had Raimi been able to secure rights to the Dark Knight in the first place. The production was reportedly an unhappy one but it resulted in a legacy of comics (through Marvel and Dynamite Entertainment) and two straight-to-video instalments with Arnold Vosloo. Darkman is that rare example of an original comic book-style idea that had legs, albeit ones maintained by copious skin grafts. What do you make of this list? Are there any non-comic book comic book movies you feel should have been included? Let us know in the comments section.