10 DC Comics Movies That Almost Happened

Even Superman can't get off the ground sometimes.

By Mark Langshaw /

After Joel Schumacher had dragged Batman's reputation through the mud, superhero movies all but disappeared from Hollywood. It became more common for projects to fall apart before they even reached the cameras than actually make it to cinemas, but today it's a totally different scenario.

Advertisement

After the likes of X-Men and Spider-Man hit big at the global box office, capes and spandex officially became fashionable, and the mega success of the Christoper Nolan Batman films and the Marvel Cinematic Universe which followed has made comic book adaptations cinematic gold dust.

The rights to virtually every property on Marvel and DC's books have been snapped up, but not all of them are guaranteed to make it to the big screen. Although superheroes are more lucrative than ever, projects are still swallowed in development hell from time to time, or capitulate in the early stages.

In the DC camp, this is a problem no character - regardless of how A-list they happen to be - have proven immune to. Batman, Wonder Woman and even Superman have all had films cancelled on them, occasionally for the best, but at other times leaving the fans wondering what might have been...

10. Batman Unchained

In fairness to Joel Schumacher, his third Batman films sounds like it would have been the most bearable of the bunch, had he been given the opportunity to make it.

Advertisement

Warner Bros misguidedly thought Batman & Robin would turn out well and, ahead of its release, they hired the director to work on another sequel titled Batman Unchained.

The third Schumacher film would have been darker in tone - basically a two-hour apology for its predecessors - and had bold ambitions to bring back all of the villains from the previous movies, including Jack Nicholson's Joker.

In the script, the main antagonists were the Scarecrow, whose fear gas causes Bruce Wayne to see visions of his past foes, and Harley Quinn, rewritten as the Joker's long lost daughter, rather than his abused love interest.

Nicolas Cage is said to have been sought for the role of Scarecrow, which would have been worth the admission fee alone, and Courtney Love targeted for Harley. Who knows how that one would have turned out?

Warner pulled the plug on Batman Unchained after Batman & Robin was savaged by fans and critics, instead turning its attention to potential adaptations of Batman: Year One and Batman Beyond, neither of which happened, but that's okay because the world got the Nolan trilogy instead.

9. Green Arrow: Escape From Super Max

Years before DC's master archer Oliver Queen featured in a hit TV show, his cinematic debut was being lined up with some pretty big names involved.

Advertisement

The Dark Knight and Man of Steel writer David S. Goyer was set to direct Green Arrow: Escape From Super Max based on a screenplay he penned with Justin Marks.

The movie's premise saw the hero banged up in a prison full of B and C-list DC villains for a crime he didn't commit. There would have been A-list cameos too, as Goyer had clearance to include Lex Luthor, The Joker and The Riddler in minor roles.

It sounds like a lot of work went into the planning stages of Super Max, with architecture major Marks having spoken at length about the titular prison's design and how it was specifically built to house super-powered criminals.

Goyer gave a few sporadic updates about the project since it was first announced in 2008, but since it isn't listed as in active development under the new DC Entertainment brand, it's prsumed canned.

8. Sgt. Rock

Sgt. Rock would be a valuable addition to the DC Extended Universe. An army sergeant who exists in a world of superheros would be a unique twist on the genre, but all of his previous film outings have stepped on a landmine on their way to cinema.

Advertisement

Between the late 1980s early 1990s, Arnold Schwarzenegger was sought to play the military man on screen, which makes absolutely no sense since Rock is an American G.I. and Arnie is quite clearly Austrian.

For obvious reasons, that project was court-martialed but producer Joel Silver spent the next two decades attempting to get a Sgt. Rock movie rolling, with Guy Ritchie attached to direct.

Bruce Willis was, at one point considered for the lead role, but Ritchie bowed out when he took on the Sherlock Holmes franchise, and there hasn't been an official update since 2010 when Silver announced the film's setting was being switched from World War II to a near-future conflict.

So don't expect to see a Sgt. Rock film anytime soon, but there's a chance he could crop up in the DCEU in some capacity. In the comics, he's served as Lex Luthor's chief of staff while the villain was president, and had a stint in the Suicide Squad.

7. Swamp Thing Reboot

Swamp Thing hasn't featured on the big screen since 1989, but he almost returned from the murky depths last decade when Joel Silver was hired to head up a reboot.

Advertisement

Silver doesn't have the best of luck with DC projects and this one also appears to have gone the same way as Sgt. Rock since there hasn't been an official update since 2009, the same year the revival was announced.

Little is known about Silver's plans for Alec Holland, other than the fact they would have been based on a screenplay from Akiva Goldsman and included ambitions to shoot the whole thing in 3D.

Although the project was probably long cancelled even before the DC Extended Universe had started to take shape, the announcement of Justice League Dark - which will include Swamp Thing on its roster - is no doubt the final nail in its coffin.

6. Green Lantern 2

When Warner Bros handed Green Lantern his cinematic debut with Ryan Reynolds in the lead role, the aim was quite clearly to kickstart a franchise. They threw in a post-credits sting and everything.

Advertisement

A sequel was firmly pencilled in, with writers and producers on board, but the reception the original was met with made follow-ups pretty much untenable.

Presumably the idea was to have Sinestro serve as the villain in Green Lantern 2, but exactly how that would have played out the world will never know. That post-credits scene of him donning the yellow ring is now nothing more than a cliffhanger destined to go unresolved for eternity.

Warner has firm plans to bring Green Lantern back, but not in a sequel to its 2011 flop. Green Lantern Corps is in development for a 2020 release, and it will tie in with the DC Cinematic Universe.

5. Batman Vs. Superman

Batman and Superman locked horns in last year's divisive Dawn of Justice, but these two comic book titans almost clashed on screen many years earlier.

Advertisement

In 2001, Warner Bros hired Wolfgang Petersen to direct a film based on a showdown between DC's finest from a screenplay by Akiva Goldsman. It got well into the planning stages and was assigned a summer 2004 release date.

The story saw Batman and Superman come to blows because the latter spares the Joker's life, allowing the Clown Prince of Crime to evenutally kill Bruce Wayne's future bride. The whole thing, including Bruce's wedding, turns out to be part of a convoluted Lex Luthor plot, which the duo thwart after inevitably joining forces.

Goldsman's script paints a picture of another popcorn-fuelled blockbuster, but it does have its moments, including a poignant scene where Batman has the chance to kill The Joker and only refuses to do so when Superman insists he delivers the coup de grace with his mask removed.

Whether it would have been better than Dawn of Justice is impossible to determine because Warner canned the movie to pursue Batman and Superman solo projects.

The only thing tangible to come out of this version of Batman Vs. Superman is an Easter egg in I Am Legend, which was written and produced by Goldsman.

4. Batman: Year One

Warner Bros didn't have much luck with Batman projects between the Joel Schumacher and Christopher Nolan eras, with movie after movie burning up on entry.

Advertisement

One film which fell by the wayside is Darren Aronofsky's Batman: Year One, a movie that would have forced fans to forget everything they know about the Caped Crusader.

Loosely based on the Frank Miller comic book of the same name, the movie would have depicted Bruce Wayne as homeless, having lost his fortune when his parents were murdered, and reimagined Alfred as an African-American mechanic called Al.

It would have been grounded, R-rated and might have starred Joaquin Phoenix, had Aronofsky got his way. The Gladiator star is said to have been the director's first choice, although Christian Bale was later approached.

Batman: Year One could well have been the darkest superhero film ever made, but it came along at a time when Hollywood was very much into traditional comic book adaptations, hence Warner putting its eggs into the Nolan basket instead.

3. Justice League: Mortal

Long before cinematic universes were the done thing in the superhero space, Warner Bros attempted to do the unheard of an dive head-first into a Justice League movie.

Advertisement

Mad Max director George Miller was hired to helm the project and he made the bold decision of hiring little-known actors to play some of history's most iconic heroes, in the hope they would grow into the roles over the course of a planned trilogy.

Armie Hammer would have played Batman, Australian model Megan Gale was Wonder Woman and D.J. Cotrona was cast as Superman. The team roster also included The Flash, Martian Manhunter, Green Lantern and Aquaman, so that's the Zack Snyder version outgunned.

Miller was inspired by the Justice League of American storyline Tower of Babel and the Superman: Sacrifice arc, planning to loosely adapt them with Talia Al Ghul and Maxwell Lord as the movie's villains.

The decision to hire relative unknowns in the lead roles was met with fan vitriol online, but opponents of Mortal needn't have worried since the 2007-2008 Writers Guild of America strike derailed the project shortly after the cast was leaked.

Essential revisions to the screenplay could not be made due to the Hollywood unrest and a series of other setbacks left the project in development hell. By this time, Marvel was already getting its cinematic universe off the ground one film at a time, inspiring Warner to follow suit with a series of connected DC solo movies.

2. Joss Whedon's Wonder Woman

It took a criminal amount of time for the powers that be to hand Wonder Woman a cinematic debut. Even if it had come more than 10 years earlier as originally planned, that still would have been considered long overdue.

Advertisement

Diana Prince came close to her first solo outing in the mid-2000s, years before Hollywood's comic book boom, when Joss Whedon was tasked with writing and directing a film about the Amazon warrior.

Whedon's script took place against a modern backdrop and had Diana travelling from Themyscira to Gateway City with Steve Trevor in tow as the pair journeyed to help refugees, encountering numerous foes along the way.

Creative differences eventually forced the Avengers director off the project, and when his script was leaked online years later, the reception was overwhelmingly negative. But it's important to point out that the world would have had its first female-led superhero movie a decade earlier had this film been made.

Back in the mid-2000s, when the comic genre wasn't bogged down by countless origin stories, Whedon's Wonder Woman could have held its own with a few script rewrites.

1. Superman Lives

Nicolas Cage as the Man Of Steel, polar bears guarding the Fortress of Solitude, Brainiac transforming into a massive spider creature - Kevin Smith must have been raiding Jay and Silent Bob's secret stash while he was writing Superman Lives.

Advertisement

This failed DC Comics revival is perhaps the most infamous cancelled superhero movie of all time, and its demise was so drawn out and eventful that somebody made a documentary about it.

Superman Lives would have been loosely based on the Death and Return of Superman arcs, following the Man of Steel as he perishes in battle by Doomsday's hand before returning from the dead in his black costume to save the day.

Lex Luthor and Brainiac would have been the movie's antagonists, together hatching a plot to block out the sun (clearly been watching too many episodes of The Simpsons) and unleash Doomsday on the underpowered Last Son of Krypton.

Whether Superman Lives would have been good, or set comic book adaptations back by 10 years, is unknown, but one thing's for sure - this would have been Supes as you've never seen him before.

At no point in the script does Cage's Man of Steel fly, with Smith describing him as flashing across the screen in a blue and red blur. Tim Burton was, at one point, attached to direct, which would have only made it more unconventional.

Test shots of Cage is costume are widely available online, as is the movie's script, if you fancy having your brain scrambled.

Advertisement