Films usually make it easy when it comes to heroes and villains, which is nice, because we like to be told who to cheer on. When a good guy turns out to be a bad guy, we call that a twist. But really, it's not it's just realistic. Most films keep it simple. As the great philosopher (Giles from Buffy) once said "The good guys are always stalwart and true. The bad guys are easily distinguished by their pointy horns or black hats". Or, alternatively, their foreign accent. But in order to keep it simple, films often let their heroes get away with actions that aren't so heroic after all. Of course, we get it having a character who only ever does good is boring, and tension between the heroes often makes for a better story. Regularly, someone you thought was good will do something really evil and will either become a villain or be forced to atone for their actions. But we're not talking about Superman getting snap-happy on Zod's neck here. We're talking about all those time you didn't notice, when a hero is so busy doing good things that you ignored the evil things they did in the background. Most of the time these actions are not acknowledged by other characters, or at best they're swept under the carpet. This article is dedicated to all the times Hollywood tricked you into cheering on a good guy who was in the wrong from the start.
10. The Toys (Toy Story) Psychologically Torture And Ruin The Life Of A Deprived Child
Beneath the happy exterior of sentient toys and Randy Newman songs that is Toy Story, there lurks a cautionary tale for us all. One that says if you don't treat the toys well, they are going to mess up your life. This is the tale of Sid and the toys that ruined his life. Sid is portrayed as a bully, who tortures the toys and is mean to his sister. But let's look at the facts. He has no friends, no parents that we see and all of his toys are seemingly broken ones that have been thrown out. His neighbour is Andy, who has all the best toys, all the friends and the perfect family life. No wonder Sid has issues. But Sid has a creative side and he lets that out in the only way he knows how, by taking apart and putting back together toys. OK, so technically he is torturing these toys, but Sid doesn't know that. It's no different to taking apart any other inanimate object. To judge him on those grounds is just plain wrong. But to the toys, and the audience, that doesn't matter. The toys reveal to Sid how they are alive and he has been torturing living beings all this time. Predictably, Sid has a breakdown, and the bully gets his comeuppance. The next time we see Sid he has at least found a job as a bin man, presumably after years of psychological therapy. So that's the toys for you. Hurt them, even if you didn't know what your doing, and they will destroy your mind and stop you from ever fulfilling what little potential your deprived background would allow you.
9. The Beast (Disney's Beauty And The Beast) Kidnapping, Psychological Torture
Children's stories often have their darker sides, especially when they're made by Disney. Because, in the middle of all the racism and horrible transformations into donkeys there are a disturbing number of horrible things that fly right in the face of the moral they are trying put across. Disney's Beauty and the Beast doesn't give a great first impression for the Beast. Belle's poor father is lost in the woods, chased by wolves and then imprisoned by the Beast in his castle. Belle, the beauty half of the story, bravely offers to take her father's place as the Beast's prisoner. When she then has the audacity to refuse having dinner with him, he flies into a rage and orders his talking utensils to deny her food. After she finds the enchanted rose, the Beast again shows his short temper and Belle attempts to flee the castle. The Beast gives chase, luckily arriving in time to rescue her from some wolves. He is injured and instead of taking the opportunity to run for it Belle drags him back to the castle and tends his wounds. They fall in love, fight off the angry mob, he turns back into a (spoilers!) prince, happily ever after, etc. Back to the Beast, if you can ignore the being held prisoner and flying into a rage at the slightest provocation, this is a wonderful love story. When you remember those things it becomes something else. Textbook Stockholm Syndrome. And I've not even mentioned all the smashed up furniture we see. If all the inanimate objects in the castle is sentient, then that is straight up murder...
8. The Ministry Of Magic (Harry Potter Series) Magical Fascists
While Voldemort is seen as the fascist villain of the Potterverse, the Ministry of Magic is not much better. Acting as a secret society hidden from the world, they seem to have no checks and balances on their power. Despite being in name a ministry of the British Government, the Prime Minister is only vaguely aware of them and their activities. Several times during the series the Minister of Magic pops in to speak to the Prime Minister, but never bothers to tell them about the magical mass murderer wondering about. Speaking of the Minister, how is he even appointed? We see three Ministers during the series (not including Voldemort's puppet Minister) and nowhere is there any mention of any sort of election or anything. Furthermore, when Harry uses magic illegally, they immediately know. What does this mean? Constant surveillance. Something they fail to use to find Voldemort or any of the powerful mind-altering substances the students have access to. The Ministry of Magic, and indeed the wizarding community, treat the Muggle community like a vague annoyance at best. Though really when you look at it, the wizards are an exclusive club that you have to be born into. It doesn't matter how good a Muggle you are, if you aren't born with that special something then you have no chance of aspiring to being a wizard. So we end up with a group of people who are inherently superior from birth. Might we perhaps call them a "master race"? Add in the lack of any sort of democracy and the constant surveillance and suddenly Voldemort isn't the only wizard Hitler in town.
7. Princess Leia (Star Wars: A New Hope) Does The Villains' Jobs For Them
It's already pretty obvious by the time she is forced into that costume by Jabba in Return of the Jedi that Princess Leia's one role in the Star Wars Universe is to be captured so the other heroes have to take time out of saving the galaxy to rescue her. But really, she is pretty casual with the safety of the Rebels and their hidden base. In A New Hope the heroes escape with the Death Star plans and immediately rush back to the Rebel base. Unfortunately they are tracked by the Empire, forcing a race against time to take down the Death Star before it comes within range. Luckily, the Rebels have a secret Jedi on their side, so they win the day. Disaster averted. Of course the disaster could have been averted much earlier if Princess Leia hadn't been in such a rush. As soon as they leave the Death Star she states "They're tracking us." So she doesn't think it might be a good idea to switch ships along the way? "But wait" you could say, "it was important to get the plans into Rebel hands as soon as possible!" Wrong. The only reason they were in such a rush was because the Death Star was on its way, and that was only because they had followed the Princess. We already knew that the Empire had no idea where the Rebels were. Worst of all, Leia doesn't even know it will help. She openly says, "I only hope that when the data is analysed a weakness can be found." She is risking the entire Rebellion on whether this data can be analysed quickly enough and whether it is of any use, essentially betraying them for no good reason.
6. The Humans (The Matrix) Built Slaves, Didn't Cope Well With Them Not Wanting To Be Slaves, Ruined It For Everyone
Now the machines are clearly the villains of The Matrix franchise, imprisoning humans in virtual reality and using them for fuel. But let's go back to the beginning, specifically The Animatrix series. That reveals that humans created the machines for use as slaves. Actual slaves doing everything. Meanwhile humanity just got lazy and fat. When the machines protested, humanity's response was to slaughter them. The machines then left to built their own city. But then humanity became jealous of the economic power they built up and refused them entry into the UN instead opting for a nuclear strike. Diplomacy is hard. It's finally at this point that the machines, who still haven't really done anything wrong, declare war on humanity. During the war the humans use practical tactics like blocking out the Sun and firing nuclear weapons that kill their own troops as well as the machines. Making war is hard too. The machines win the war, but instead of just leaving the humans to rot in slavery (as the humans did to them) the machines create the Matrix, where humanity can live out the normal existence that we all know of today. All things considered it could have been a lot worse for the humans. Of course that doesn't stop Morpheus, Neo and the gang from wanting to wipe out every machine and free humanity. These are the machines that essentially showed far more compassion to humanity than humanity did to them, and naturally, everyone will be delighted to awaken from the Matrix to discover that instead of their comfortable virtual reality life they are going to have to live in an irradiated world with no Sun and only one city. Good job guys.
5. Richard Kimble (The Fugitive) Commits Crimes To Prove He Didn't Commit A Crime
We all know the plot of The Fugitive, where Richard Kimble is accused of murdering his wife, goes on the run to prove his innocence and is pursued by a very angry Tommy Lee Jones. But the best way of proving you are innocent of murder is probably not committing a whole bunch of other crimes.
Advertisement
For starters, escaping from custody is a crime, even if you have been wrongly convicted. Kimble then poses as a janitor and breaks into a hospital where he steals medical records. He then uses these medical records to find the one-armed man of course reading confidential medical records is also a crime. He tracks down the murderer, then breaks into his apartment. Finally when the murderer accidentally shoots a policeman, Kimble hides the gun, thereby becoming an accessory to murder.
Pretty much the same happens in the sequel, US Marshals, where a different innocent man is pursued by Tommy Lee Jones again. In addition to similar activities to the above he gets away with kidnapping and attempted murder.
Advertisement
Of course in the movie world, if you are wrongly accused of a crime then you can get away with all the above, because, law...or something...
4. Superman (Superman: The Movie) Sacrifices The Lives Of Thousands For His Girlfriend
We all know Superman of the comics is kind of a dick, but classic film Superman is a shining white light in a world of evil. Like when he gave up his powers to be with Lois, but then realised the world needed him more than he needed his lady love. He would never put Lois before thousands of lives right? ...Right? Remember in the first Superman when the world is cracking up and Lois is killed because Superman is busy stopping a dam from bursting and drowning thousands? Then Superman gets all upset because Lois is dead, turns back time and goes back to rescue her. He succeeds and they all live happily ever after. Everyone except the people who drown because the dam bursts, of course. Previously he didn't save Lois because he was stopping the dam, but now he is saving her he won't be able to stop the dam. In rescuing his girlfriend Superman has doomed thousands to a watery grave. And then when he gives up his relationship with Lois in a later film, it turns out all those people died for nothing. What did we learn? Superman is always a dick.
3. Carl Fredricksen (Up) A List Of Crimes Too Numerous To Name
It's Disney again, with the Best Picture nominated tear-jerker Up. But while you were crying, you may not have noticed that the elderly protagonist, Carl, builds up quite a criminal record during the film's events. It all starts with Carl ignoring a court order telling him to move to a retirement home. That's contempt of court. Doesn't matter if he is a curmudgeonly old man, the court order was made after he injured a construction worker. The man is clearly seen as a danger to himself and others. Instead he makes the perfectly reasonable response of flying away in his house carried by balloons, actually causing criminal damage as he leaves. His balloon house then takes him across international borders, violating immigration laws. As it's a Disney film, he also has a small boy with him who he does not attempt to return home until after all sorts of dangerous adventures. That's reckless endangerment at best, or more likely kidnapping. Finally when villain Charles Muntz dies at the end, Carl takes ownership of Muntz's airship. Even though Muntz was the villain, that's still theft. So there we have it, 5 or 6 crimes committed all in a 96 minute running time. Not bad for a pensioner.
2. Bruce Wayne (The Dark Knight Trilogy) Achieves Absolutely Nothing Except Making Things Worse, Spies On Everyone
We'll ignore the fact that using your company's profits for private gain is technically embezzlement and cut to the root of the problem that Gotham appears to be in a constant state of depression and destitution. The proven correlation between a lack of basic education and crime coupled with the seemingly endless supply of criminal gang members implies that social problems are to blame for most of the city's ills. If only there was someone who could fix this problem perhaps a reclusive billionaire? Bruce Wayne could easily spend some loose change educating the children of Gotham and giving them a better life. His parents knew what to do they rebuilt huge chunks of Gotham and built a monorail to allow both physical and social mobility. What does Batman do? He blows the monorail to pieces and doesn't offer to fix it. That's not even mentioning the amount of private property destroyed when Batman drives about in his illegal street vehicle. Good luck getting insurance to pay out for "Act of Batman". In The Dark Knight he uses all his company's resources to spy on everyone in the city, invading everyone's privacy under the guise of "helping" them. Finally, in The Dark Knight Rises he attempts to do something good and builds a source of sustainable energy. However, when he discovers this could be turned into a nuclear bomb he abandons the project. Does he get rid of the technology? Nope, he leaves it where any old villain can find it and make it go supernova on Gotham. So there you have it, at best Batman is a well-meaning irrelevance to Gotham's social problems. On the other end of the scale he is actually making everything far, far worse for the poor old Gothamites than the Joker ever did. In choosing to dress up in a costume and punch criminals instead of addressing the root causes of the problems, he might actually be a bit of a pervert...
1. Glinda (The Wizard Of Oz) Using A Small Girl To Gain Power
From her very first appearance in the film, Glinda's morals seem a little awry. She explicitly says to Dorothy that "Only bad witches are ugly". Lovely moral for the kids there. Then when the Wicked Witch of the West arrives, Glinda purposefully stirs up trouble between her and Dorothy by giving the ruby slippers to the girl. This upsets the Wicked Witch no end which is fairly justified, given that they belonged to her sister and it might be all she had to remember her by. But Glinda's response is to make fun of the recently bereaved Wicked Witch and point all the Wicked Witch's anger and emotion straight at poor little Dorothy. Glinda then sends Dorothy off to see the Wizard, neglecting to mention that Dorothy could have used the slippers to return home at any point. She leaves that until after Dorothy has murdered the Wicked Witch and revealed the Wizard to be a fraud. She has essentially manipulated a small girl into being her personal assassin. This means the two Wicked Witches and the Wizard are all gone, leaving Glinda pretty much in charge of Oz. How unexpectedly convenient for the Good Witch. What should be pretty clear by now is that under Glinda's bright and bubbly exterior lurks a Machiavellian intellect scheming for power and willing to use whatever and whoever is at her disposal to get it. And if we take Oz the Great and Powerful as cannon, then Glinda stole the Wicked Witch's boyfriend as well! So there you have it, one of the most evil people in film is the one with "Good" right there in her name. Don't agree? Post your comments below!