10 Films Directors Wanted You To Hate

Next level punk move: Make a film bad on purpose.

By Kyle Mustain /

Some painters make paintings that are pleasing to the eye. Then there are painters who say screw beauty and create something to make the viewer feel something else for a change. Some musicians make music that is meant to open up your heart or move you to dance. Then some put out entire albums that evoke the sound of a monster truck driving over a symphony’s worth of musical instruments.

Advertisement

It’s art. There’s a full range of human emotions to explore with any artistic medium, and anger, annoyance are among that range.

Film as an art form is no different. So would it surprise you to discover that some films are made with the express purpose of pissing you off?

10. Mars Attacks!

When director Tim Burton’s alien invasion film Mars Attacks! opened in 1996, many people went into it expecting it to be a parody of the blockbuster Independence Day, which had opened just a few months before.

Advertisement

The comedy, which starred an ensemble of big names such as Annette Bening, Danny DeVito, Martin Short, Pierce Brosnan, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Jack Nicholson (who played two characters), was an exercise in camp and cynicism, sprinkled with moments of graphic (albeit cartoonish) violence. Many people left the theater baffled at what they had just seen, mostly because they weren’t in on the joke.

From its inception, Burton’s Mars Attacks! was supposed to be a throwback to the cheesy alien invasion movies of the 1950s. Not only that, but the entire film was an homage to the works of Ed Wood, who was considered to be the worst filmmaker of all time. Mars Attacks! was Burton’s follow up to the 1994 biopic he had made about Wood which was a critical darling and won many awards.

While making of Ed Wood, Burton grew to empathize with the man so much that he decided for his next project he would bring to life what he felt the director would have made had he ever gotten a shot to make a major Hollywood film. In the end, he pulled it off because not many people appreciated it. The confusion and general dislike for the film allowed Tim Burton to live in Ed Wood’s shoes for a moment.

9. Sin City: A Dame To Kill For

Sin City took the world by storm when it came out back in 2005. It changed the way films are made and it helped legitimize the comic book film genre by showing how comic art and tones could be adapted to film. It took 9 years for a sequel to be made; a sequel which utilized the same green screen filmmaking approach as the original. But by the time A Dame to Kill For came around, it all felt pretty dated. And virtually no one liked it.

Advertisement

Even though there was an immediate interest in fast-tracking a sequel to Sin City, directors Robert Rodriguez, Frank Miller, and Quentin Tarantino chose to prioritize other projects and the sequel kept getting pushed back. Then a pair of producing partners attained the rights to the sequel in 2012 and pressured the filmmakers (aside from Tarantino) and the Weinstein Company to get the ball rolling on another film, even though there wasn’t much public demand for a sequel anymore.

Now the same two producers are suing Rodriguez and the Weinstein Company in two different court cases. The producers accuse Rodriguez of not taking measures to keep the film from going over budget. The case against the Weinstein Company claims the film was poorly advertised.

This is highly speculative, and the outcomes of court cases will provide a clearer picture of what went on, but it is likely that the creatives behind the film turned in an inferior product solely because they didn’t want to make it in the first place.

8. Rubber

Rubber is the story of a crusty old tire lying in the Southern California desert who bolts upright and discovers that it is alive! Not only that, but it can make things explode with its, er, mind?

Advertisement

This transgressive take on slasher film tropes came out in 2010 to baffled and yet delighted audiences. French director and techno musician Quentin Dupieux’s film challenges tropes of genre while also making meta-commentary about how movies “poison” their audiences. The story of the tire is merely a story-within-a-story, as an audience stand out in the desert and watch the tire stalk its prey—through binoculars?

If none of this makes sense to you, that’s because it isn’t supposed to. Rubber’s intention (aside from watching heads explode) is for the viewer to question the purpose behind viewing film, ultimately coming to its own conclusion that film is a pointless art form. Watch Rubber only if you are in the mood to be trolled.

7. Tim And Eric’s Billion Dollar Movie

How could a show as indescribable as Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job! even be adapted into a feature film? Tim Heidecker and Eric Wareheim play two filmmakers who were given a billion dollars to make a movie, then end up spending most of it on their lavish lifestyles and an expensive guru played by Zach Galifianakis. When the movie’s financiers demand their money back, Tim and Eric somehow think the best way to raise the money they owe is to take over as managers of a rundown shopping mall.

Advertisement

The film has nothing to do with the TV show, but borrows some of the low-fi video manipulation humor that the show so often utilizes. The film is hard to digest, featuring such subject matter as a man taking another man’s son as his own, a wolf on the loose that lives inside the mall, and a man cutting off his own arm during a drug bender.

The film features a supporting cast and cameos from well-known actors and Tim and Eric collaborators such as Jeff Goldblum, Will Ferrell, John C Reilly, and Will Forte. Against a $3 million budget Tim and Eric’s Billion Dollar Movie made a mere $223,000 worldwide. Of course critics hated it, but that was actually kind of the point.

6. Wet Hot American Summer

Today, Wet Hot American Summer is considered a comedy classic that spawned two Netflix series and gave birth to several actors’ careers including Elizabeth Banks, Bradley Cooper, Amy Poehler, and Paul Rudd. It had to have been beloved from the day it hit theaters, right? Actually, Wet Hot American Summer was hatedby mainstream audiences and critics. Factor in who made the film and where they were in their careers at the time, then it becomes clear that Wet Hot American Summer’s vitriolic reception was completely by design.

Advertisement

The send-up of the summer camp movie genre was directed by David Wain and co-written with Michael Showalter, both of whom came from the 1990s MTV sketch comedy troupe The State. The State was known for its punk-spirited take on sketch comedy. Think Mr. Show and The Whitest Kids U’ Know, but going a step further. This group of young New York comedians were hired to make a hip sketch comedy show for teens, but week after week it actually made fun of teen culture, thus going above most of the target audience’s heads.

Several years after The State went off the air, Wain and Showalter gathered many of their friends, went into the woods of Pennsylvania, and shot this little indie as a semi-reunion of the State. Wet Hot is a continuation of that same brand of humor; namely, Wain, Showalter, and company were going to do whatever they though was funny, knowing full well that the majority of people weren’t going to get it. Comedy is subjective, and after the film became a cult hit, Wet Hot American Summer changed the industry into what it is today.

5. Rob Zombie’s Halloween II

Rob Zombie has gone on record stating that writing and directing the remake of John Carpenter’s Halloween was the worst experience of his career. He claimed that the studio heads and producers looked over his shoulder during the entire production and insisted on many changes which diluted his original vision for the film.

Advertisement

So why did he come back and make the sequel? Well, he nearly didn’t. Two other directors, a filmmaking duo from France, were attached for a long time while the film was in preproduction. Zombie had sworn off the project, but then suddenly he opted to come back. Why was that? He was guaranteed complete creative control this time around. So he took the opportunity and churned out this total stinker on purpose.

It was almost as if Zombie made a list of the things that would most piss off Halloween fans and checked them all off: He showed Michael Myers’s face for long bouts of screen time, he made the final girl, Laurie Strode, unlikable, he even elected to use sparingly little of the original Halloween score and sound effects.

Then there are all the additions he made to anger fans, such shoehorning his own wife into the film even though she died in the first, fixating on the brutality of the murders instead of creating suspense, and adding a supernatural element that completely retcons its predecessor film. “Weird Al” Yankovic even shows up for an appearance? Not to bag on Weird Al, but he has no place being in a Halloween movie.

It would seem that once hired on, Rob Zombie made Halloween II purely as a middle finger to the meddling studio and to everyone who hated the first film. Today, H2 has a cult status just for its sheer weirdness, compounded by its fans’ knowledge that the director went full Zombie against his keepers on this one. H2 is on this list solely because of how many people it made angry. But honestly, all of Zombie’s films carry the common thread that they are meant to piss off anyone who clings to convention.

4. Gus Van Sant’s Psycho Remake

After indie director Gus Van Sant’s 1997 film Good Will Hunting won awards for Robin Williams, Matt Damon, and Ben Affleck, Van Sant chose to follow up the smashing success with a remake of Alfred Hitchcock’s classic slasher film, Psycho.

Advertisement

Only he stipulated that he wanted to do something which had never been done before: an exact remake. The same script would be used and every single shot would be recreated exactly as it appeared in the original film. Obviously the cast would be updated and it would be in color, but aside from those, Van Sant set out to make a near-perfect replica of the film Hitchcock made some 30 years prior. The film tanked at the box office and has been hated on ever since.

So why did Van Sant do such a thing? Turns out he just wanted to see how far studio executives would let a hot director take a stupid idea. The Psycho remake was basically a big budget performance art installation.

Shortly after his first big success, Drugstore Cowboy, Universal executives offered to let Van Sant remake any of their classic films. Van Sant pitched the oddball idea of doing an exact remake of Psycho in that meeting. The executives balked at the idea and showed him the door. Fast forward to a few years later, after his Oscar nomination, and Universal rang up old Gus again asking if he wanted to do business with them. Van Sant remembered the meeting he’d had with them years earlier, and this time having the bargaining chips that he had, he reminded them of his idea: Psycho, shot-for-shot remake. They took the bait and he got to do his art project.

As Van Sant recently stated on the WTF podcast: “during the 90s the joke about the executives was that they would rather make a sequel than they would an original piece, because there was less risk.” Studios always want to make the safe bet, which is why they keep remaking old IPs. Now a couple decades later, the story is a little better known, and while the Psycho remake doesn’t have a lot of fans per se, the intent behind it and its place as an art piece that comments on the industry has gained respect in some circles.

3. Tusk/Yoga Hosers

Kevin Smith’s body-horror-comedy Tusk started as a prank. Back in 2013, on their podcast, Smith and collaborator Scott Mosier discussed a classified ad offering free room and board to anyone willing to dress up as a walrus full-time. Smith and Mosier proceeded to go off on a long riff about what the possible backstory to this ad could be.

Advertisement

They were so into the over-the-top narrative that they asked their listeners to vote on Twitter whether they should turn the idea into a feature film. The fans voted overwhelmingly in favor, and so Smith and Mossier began fundraising for Tusk. Later, a poet named Chris Parkinson came forward admitting that he had posted the original prank classified ad, and he was rewarded with a producer credit on the film.

The film, about an immature jerk podcaster (where doesSmith get his ideas?) ventures to Manitoba, Canada to interview a retired seaman who lives alone in a mansion. The old man drugs the podcaster and then proceeds to mutilate his body until he has surgically transformed him into a human-walrus. The film is a mixture of stoner comedy and body horror that, despite early buzz, garnered lackluster reception. Oh, and Johnny Depp shows up playing a role based on Inspector Clousea from the Pink Panther series.

Speaking of Depp, his daughter and Kevin Smith’s daughter appear in Tusk as convenience clerks, as the two are friends in real life (which was how Smith was able to cast Depp). Even though Tusk was by no means a success, Smith went on to make a spinoff film starring he and Depp’s daughters called Yoga Hosers. The film was considered even worse than Tusk and many fans and critics called it a low point in Smith’s career.

Both are complete vanity projects, and have been said to be Smith’s response to how loathed he is by critics, especially for 2010’s Cop Out. Smith has even stated that the third act of Yoga Hosers is supposed to be his way of reaching out to the critics who hated his films. For a time having been one of the most promising filmmakers of his generation, directing such films as Clerks, Chasing Amy, and Dogma, Smith now spends most of his time podcasting.

His past few films seem to emanate from the bubble of his own fandom with little to no regard how anyone outside this bubble care about the quality of his films.

2. The Dead Don’t Die

Jim Jarmusch’s 2019 zombie flick is an anti-zombie-flick flick, if you can wrap your head around that. The film, which takes place in a small town being overrun with zombies, stars Bill Murray, Adam Driver, Chloë Sevigny, Steve Buscemi, Tilda Swinton, and a host of other familiar faces. It veers away from the traditional zombie film by including zany elements such as characters who not only know they are in a movie, but can actually hear the film’s theme song whenever it comes on. It’s really out-there, and for intended purpose.

Advertisement

Writer-director Jim Jarmusch, who has been making films synonymous with “avant garde indie” going back to the 1980s, actually hates zombie movies. Well, most. He loves the George Romero zombie movies and the ones that predate them, but he hates the current zombie craze. So he made a movie about his hatred of the zombie craze.

The intent of star-studded The Dead Don’t Die was to draw fans of zombies into the theater, only to completely disappoint them. While promoting the film, Jarmusch told Rolling Stone:

I’m just sick of zombies, man. Like, the real zombies that are just walking around us, not paying attention to anything, letting the end of the world happen . . . And look how unconscious so much of the world is right now, for the most part, of its impending end. It’s sad and it’s maddening. And I’m really !*$% sick of it.

The Dead Don’t Die is reflection of the political and cultural state of the world right now: if nobody plays by the rules anymore, why should Jarmusch’s zombie movie have to be just like all the other zombie movies?

1. Star Wars: The Last Jedi

[Beleaguered sigh] Okay, you knew this one was coming. Regardless of whether you liked or didn’t like Rian Johnson’s 2017 entry into the Star Wars series, we should all agree that we hate how much people have come to argue over it. Johnson made some radical changes to beloved characters, among them are Haggard Luke Skywalker, Mary Poppins Leia, and he even made Chewie learn to think without his stomach? Blasphemy!

Advertisement

Someone unearthed a video of Johnson while making his first film, Brick, in which he stated:

I would be worried if everybody across the board was like ‘yeah, it was a good movie’ it’s much more exciting to me when you get a group of people who are coming up to you who are really, really excited about it. Then there are other people who walk out literally saying ‘it’s the worst movie I’ve ever seen.’ Having those two extremes is the mark of the type of movie that I want to make.

With this in mind, Johnson is the kind of guy who likes movies that don’t just check off all the boxes to ensure everyone is satisfied. Heck, this entire list has been about filmmakers who consciously made films to give people something other than they are used to. If you look back, chances are you like some of these movies. The final point being, The Last Jedi is a film that tried to challenge the audience.

When filmmakers try to please everyone we end up getting something like The Rise of Skywalker.

Advertisement