10 Films That Suffered In The Editing Room

It doesn't matter what you shoot, it's what comes out of the edit that counts.

By Gareth Morgan /

It often gets overlooked just how important the art of editing can be in creating what could eventually turn out to be an epic movie.

If after assembling the shots filmed by one of the world's top directors the decision is then made to drop vital scenes or leave pointless sequences untouched, a move can suffer because of it.

Advertisement

Yet, some pieces of editing are so bad that they leave the film's audience wishing they'd never bothered being interested in the flick to begin with.

It's a shame, as with a few precise tweaks and a greater understanding of what the completed movie needed to be - in order to actually be watchable - the majority of these entries could have soared instead of plummeting into the realms of notoriety.

Sadly though, these badly pieced together submissions weren't lucky enough to be saved from fan/critical backlash, but at least their inclusion on this list may act as a stern warning for future filmmakers and studios, alike.

With all that in mind, let's delve into 10 Films That Suffered In The Editing Room.

10. Warcraft

When the devout worshippers of the legendary World of Warcraft game caught wind of a cinematic adaptation of their beloved universe, they were right to be anxious about the outcome.

As far as movies based on video games go...well, there's been a fair few of them. The only problem is that 99% of the time they are god-awful.

Advertisement

Prince of Persia, Assassin's Creed, Resident Evil or even the dreaded Mortal Kombat: Annihilation all proved to be absolutely terrible entries, so the omens weren't good for this foray into the world of Azeroth.

Despite some truly stunning visuals and an impressive level of world building, the pacing of the film felt off and many scenes weren't given enough time to breath.

With the story's structure being virtually non-existent and routinely finding ourselves thrown into random scenes/locations without any warning, it came to light that a massive 40 minutes had been chopped from the first cut in order to produce a theatrical version.

This deeply affected our investment in some of the key characters involved in the movie and left some audience members struggling to piece together valuable plot points.

Apart from that, the acting and CGI used in creating the iconic orcs was of a decent standard and the film possesses beautiful cinematography, so perhaps a director's cut could salvage the disjointed mess we were presented with in 2016?

9. Original Star Wars Trilogy

Remember a long time ago in a galaxy not so far away, when George Lucas' original sci-fi fantasy trilogy brainchild wasn't a butchered computer generated mess?

Ok, mess may be too harsh a term, but, you can't deny that Lucas' constant 'revitalising' of a trilogy that didn't need the added lick of paint - which the director insisted on adding in subsequent trips to the editing room post-theatrical release - led to the old flicks actually losing some of their original charm.

Advertisement

Part of what made the original iteration of the series so engaging was the 'lived-in' feeling and authenticity which Lucas managed to conjure up from a low budget production and a reliance on practical effects.

Yet, a large portion of that flew out of the window in 1997 (and 2004 and 2011) when Lucas decided to cram a ton of disjointed CGI into the special releases of the original saga and also created a Greedo debate which still rages on today.

Lucas definitely had the films' best interests at heart, but in trying too hard to visually connect the dots to his darling prequels he distanced the first trilogy from what made it so special to begin with.

8. Once Upon A Time In America

Studios have a habit of caring a little too much for their own good. Yet, sometimes it's wiser just to let the people you've hired to do the actual filmmaking... do the actual filmmaking.

Sergio Leone was widely regarded as one of the finest directors to have ever lived and that's why The Ladd Company roped him in to write and direct their epic crime drama, Once Upon a Time in America in 1982.

Advertisement

Yet, despite the dream collaboration of Leone combined with the likes of Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci and James Woods, the film suffered from the director simply filming too much footage. After logging somewhere between eight and ten hours of action, Leone and his editor managed to get the film down to six hours and wanted to release the feature in two separate parts.

That idea was rebuffed and the runtime was then shortened down to four hours and 29 minutes. However, Leone knew this would still be too long for his employers and shaved nearly another whole hour off the runtime.

After all his painstaking work to cram an understandable narrative into the significantly shorter feature he put together for the 1984 Cannes Film Festival crowd, the studio still decided the film needed cutting further and took another hour and 30 minutes away from the movie - against Leone's wishes.

The shortened American theatrical release was a critical and financial disaster, which was labelled as a 'travesty'. After the incident Leone would turn his back on directing entirely and this now sits as a vital reminder of what can happen when a studio assumes too much creative control.

7. Die Hard 4.0

Speaking of directors being treated with little respect, here's another example of a studio who felt that their own vision was more important than that of the person they'd hired to craft the feature in the first place.

To decide midway through production that your film needed to have a completely different rating to what was originally planned, surely must've felt like a bad idea. Dune Entertainment obviously thought not and opted to change the expected rated R version of Die Hard 4.0 into a PG-13, but only after three months of production had passed.

Advertisement

Director, Les Wiseman, and star Bruce Willis, both seemed upset by the studios lack of clarity and you can see why, as the movie they thought they were creating would be significantly diluted before it ever reached an audience theatrically.

Much of the gore and violence was toned down in post-production and the film felt like a shell of the earlier entries in the series because of it. Fans at least got a DVD unrated cut in the end, but this decision still ranks as a downright dumb one in hindsight.

6. Blade Runner

It was only a matter of time before one of the most edited movies in cinematic history made its way onto this list. However, you would probably be right in saying that the subsequent cuts of Blade Runner - after its initial theatrical release in 1982 - substantially improved the film.

So instead, this entry will focus on a piece of crappy editing that was held responsible for the first iteration's fairly limp ending.

Advertisement

Forced into recording dialogue that would help spoon-feed The Ladd Company's (them again) rosey vision of the film's conclusion to the audience, Harrison Ford and Ridley Scott intentionally did a terrible job on the vocal work in the hope that this same studio would deem it unusable.

They didn't and the jarringly monotonous narration was kept in the theatrical release, along with the closing image of Rick Deckard and the replicant, Rachael, riding off into the sunset together.

Numerous other cuts of the genre-defining picture would be willed into existence over the coming years and Scott's own cuts hinted at a more ambiguous/open ending, which involved Deckard himself being revealed as a replicant.

Luckily the uninspired 'happy ending' of the theatrical release was eventually undone, but Blade Runner definitely suffered for a while before Scott decided to take back his movie in 1992 (Director's Cut)...and then really take it back in 2007 (Final Cut).

5. Suicide Squad

The controversy surrounding the release of the DCEU's Suicide Squad in 2016 was plastered onto many a tabloid by the time the flick debuted onto our screens.

A lot of this was down to the madness that was reported to have gone down whilst shooting, with Jared Leto going full-method and delivering gifts of rats (among other things) to his co-stars. Yet, even more of a stir was created by the actual content that was presented to the fans in cinemas - or lack of in this case.

Advertisement

The studio (Warner Bros.) initially made a big song and dance about this film being a grungy dark journey into the world of some of DC's eclectic villain-turned-anti-heroes. But, when Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice (we'll get there) was panned for its overly serious/grim tone, WB quickly scrapped those plans and chose to remarket the film as a sparky tongue-in-cheek dark comedy.

This sudden change of direction was evident in the finished article, as the film felt like the amalgamation of two conflicting styles and came across as disjointed because of it.

After the studio had stripped all editing control from David Ayer - in the process of creating this monster which fans eventually had to be subjected to - they went one worse and cut out the majority of Leto's scenes as The Joker, despite the character being the focal point of most of the marketing in the build-up.

There's a fantastic untouched Suicide Squad movie and Jared Leto Joker performance out there somewhere, it's just a shame that we were lumbered with this studio-ruined mismatch of a feature instead.

4. I Am Legend

I Am Legend is a pretty decent film across the board.

Advertisement

Will Smith's leading performance as Dr. Robert Neville is among his best work and the film's overarching themes of hope and humanity make for a thoroughly enjoyable watch for the most part.

That is until the film enters its climax and Neville is forced to sacrifice himself in order to save his cure from being destroyed by the leader of the former-human entities, running head-first into his adversary whilst simultaneous pulling the pin on a grenade.

Spectacular as this ending was, it proved to be a bit of an epic blow-off to what had been a much more personal story up until this moment.

The actual 'alternate' ending - which was more in-line with the book's message - involved the leader suppressing their rage and then greasing the image of a butterfly onto the glass in-between the 'darkseeker' and Neville. This alluded to the woman 'darkseeker' Neville had been testing his cure on - who had a tattoo of the very same creature - and forced him to realise just how human these beasts still were.

This original ending, where the leader takes back one of his own and Neville survives long enough to take his cure elsewhere, apparently didn't sit well with some test audiences and this led to the studio opting to alter the film's ending into the more dramatic - yet simplistic - one we saw in the cinema.

It didn't completely derail the film to have the explosive theatrical ending it did upon release, but it was definitely made to look inferior in comparison to the thoughtful alternative version which was released shortly after.

3. Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice

As promised, we arrive now at one of the biggest cases of dreadful editing completely tarnishing what could have been an excellent entry into the superhero genre.

Advertisement

Fans find it hard to agree on most things, but Ben Affleck's performance as Bruce Wayne/Batman and the promised showdown between The Dark Knight and Superman - brief as it was - both rank as two moments which prove just how incredible this Zack Snyder feature could have actually been.

Yet, the studio seemed to have had their hearts set on presenting a film that was too obsessed with feeling dark and gritty than actually being a logically told story.

The first example of this was evident in the desaturated look of the film, which completely extinguished any nuances of hope and light in Henry Cavill's performance of Kal El. This could have been easily rectified in editing, yet it proved to be a conscious choice to keep the depressing colour scheme in spite of what the character represented.

Another editing issue also led to the film being cut to a still quite lofty two-and-a-half hours long. With that amount of time to play with, you'd have thought that Snyder would have had plenty of room to cram believable character motivations into the project. But, somehow the film managed to feel half-empty, whilst incredibly still containing a lot of fatty scenes that could've been trimmed down on.

The director's cut of the epic superhero clash went some way in addressing some of these missing character motivations/plot holes, yet the sombre tone of the flick still remained and proved to be a defining editing choice which didn't please the majority of those who endured the movie.

2. Justice League

Contrary to what you're probably thinking, this list wasn't formed as a way of throwing stones at the DCEU franchise. Their continual presence here simply highlights just how unsure the studio were as to what film's they wanted to produce and this confusion sadly led to a few high profile cases of awful editing completely murdering any hope of a watchable movie.

Advertisement

Warner Bros.' answer to Marvel Studio's Avengers proved this point and then some, as The Justice League suffered massively from some truly haphazard editing.

Through no fault of the studio or Zack Snyder himself, the director was forced to leave the picture halfway through development and The Avengers' own leader, Joss Whedon, stepped in to finish the project. This led to two distinctly different tones being pumped into production and Whedon's zippy universe was awkwardly interlaced into the gritty stylised world of Snyder.

Critics panned this 'Avengers-lite' output and the flawed editing exposed some badly placed quips/levity that didn't mesh with the DCEU's continual misguided attempt to be overly-dark.

On top of this tonal clusterf*ck, the crappy editing meant that vital exposition was dropped so that the studio's aim of a two-hour runtime could be met.

If Snyder is to believed and a more coherent version of his film does exists in the ether, then there could be hope for DC's mighty team, yet.

That being said, it probably still wouldn't make Henry Cavill's disappearing moustache come across as any less disturbing...

1. Fan4stic

It's incredible to think that at one point fans were unapologetically excited about the prospect of another impending attempt to bring Marvel's first family, The Fantastic Four, to the big screen.

Advertisement

However, if rumours of Fox locking director Josh Trank out of the editing room are to believed, there's little wonder as to why the eventual release of Fan4stic was met with such confusion and overwhelming disappointment.

Epic shots from the film's trailers - which lured fans into the cinema in the first place - were dropped from the finished feature and the film's tone seemed to change on a scene to scene basis, going from an indie character driven piece to an attempt at a 12A slasher horror flick at alarming speed. Also, the decision to wait until over half of the film had passed to finally gift the titular characters their powers, led to the film feeling tired before the heroes even had a chance to properly strut their stuff.

Fox clearly weren't in the mood to entertain Trank's sole vision of the project and in doing so birthed a movie that suffered from trying to be too many things at once.

Trank did state that he had a 'fantastic version' of the film a year before its release in 2015, but confessed that we'd 'probably never see it.'

It's been an overriding theme of this list, but perhaps if the studio would have allowed their director to just do their actual job, this film could have been a little more Fantastic than Fan4stic.

Advertisement