10 Genuine Concerns About Spider-Man: No Way Home
Why the year's most anticipated film could disappoint.
We're just a few short weeks away from the release of Spider-Man: No Way Home, which is by far the most highly anticipated film of the entire year.
There are a lot of reasons to be excited, for sure: it's the first truly huge-scale MCU film since Avengers: Endgame, it's the climax of Tom Holland's trilogy Spidey movies, and it's damn-near certain to feature the return of legacy Spider-Man actors Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield.
But if cinema has taught us anything over the years, it's surely that uncritically buying into all the hype is an easy way to end up bitterly disappointed.
This isn't to say that No Way Home will be a bad movie, and with all the will in the world it'll meet and even exceed expectations, but with so much weight and import placed upon it, it's worth considering the areas where it could fall short.
With the film's clear level of ambition in tying three eras of Spider-Man together, No Way Home has the potential to be an extremely satisfying blockbuster, but equally there are massive risks involved which could lead to disappointment.
By all means get excited for the movie, but don't be blinkered to these very genuine concerns...
10. It Might Be Trying Too Hard To Be Avengers: Endgame 2.0
There's no denying that No Way Home is the biggest movie event since the release of Avengers: Endgame back in April 2019.
There's no greater proof of this than the fact that the rush for No Way Home tickets crashed websites around the world, a phenomenon we haven't seen since Endgame was successfully positioned as the must-see movie event of its era.
And while there's absolutely no question that the new Spider-Man film will be a mammoth commercial success regardless of its actual quality, it may ultimately be trying a little too hard to station itself as the next generation-defining global event we all remember years from now.
Endgame's cultural impact was in large part due to the fact that it was the payoff to more than a decade's worth of movies, and while No Way Home will surely exploit our nostalgia for the Sam Raimi Spider-Man movies, it may struggle to muster the same feeling of storytelling importance that Endgame had.
Inevitably if its big marquee moments fall short of Captain America (Chris Evans) grabbing Mjolnir, there are going to be many feeling that No Way Home didn't quite measure up, whether that's a reasonable stance or not. It is one encouraged by the marketing, though.
9. The Story's Questionable Logic
Easily the biggest complaint people have had about the No Way Home trailers so far is the dubious logic of how the movie's main conflict gets set into motion.
The idea that the multiverse fractures because Peter (Tom Holland) interrupts Doctor Strange's (Benedict Cumberbatch) spell just seems a bit silly on paper - why wouldn't Strange have talked Peter through the spell first, and why is the spell so fragile that a mere person talking can screw it up?
While it's highly likely that this will all make more sense in the movie itself, conceptually it does still feel a little flimsy, even if you can accept that Strange would do something this irresponsible in a post-Endgame world.
Naturally some fans are concerned that it speaks to a wider issue in the film's script - being so concerned with its nostalgia-soaked concept that it puts logic in the backseat.
Given that the botched spell seems to be the foundation upon which the entire movie rests, screwing this part up will have major ramifications for everything else.
8. The Epic Runtime
Avengers: Endgame's 181-minute runtime was pretty much pushing the audience's patience - and bladder control - to the limit, and while it's extremely unlikely that another MCU movie will get close to that length anytime soon, you should certainly expect No Way Home to be a long movie.
Though earlier rumours suggested that the film would clock in at a brutal 169 minutes, a recent report from a reputable leaker has the runtime at a more tolerable 148 minutes.
Even so, that would still make it the third-longest MCU film behind only Endgame and Eternals, and while No Way Home will clearly have a lot of characters and plot threads to juggle, that's still quite the sit.
The 120-minute blockbuster feels like a rarer commodity than ever these days, and after Eternals recently proved the MCU's fallability throughout its 157-minute runtime, there's every possibility No Way Home is more exhausting than entertaining, and even an outright slog.
7. It Might Overdo The Nostalgia Element
There's perhaps nothing more reliably profitable in entertainment than nostalgia.
People have always found comfort in the familiar, but in recent years there's been a major uptick in Hollywood using the past as a crutch, and the state of the world being what it is today, rehashing prior successes can resonate especially well with audiences.
Just look at Ghostbusters: Afterlife, which despite mixed reviews was warmly embraced by general audiences for its treacly comfort food appeal, even if for many it's also symptomatic of an infantlised culture averse to genuinely fresh ideas or characters.
And similarly, as inspired as No Way Home's multiversal conceit actually is, that doesn't mean it won't be a shamelessly pandering nostalgia-fest.
While the MCU has generally handled its nostalgic elements fairly well to date, if there's any movie with the potential to lose perspective and just lazily vomit memberberries all over fans - many of whom will love it regardless - it's this one.
To be more than a hollow, cynical exercise in regurgitating the Raimi and Webb movies, No Way Home needs to avoid ham-fisted references to them while providing an emotionally compelling reason for Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield's involvement. Fingers crossed.
6. The Reportedly Rushed Post-Production Schedule
In recent weeks, there have been rumours doing the rounds online that No Way Home is basically in a mad rush to complete post-production before its mid-December release.
If the admittedly unsubstantiated claims are indeed true, then Marvel Studios have their VFX teams working in crunch mode to get the film's ambitious effects sequences finished in time, which of course isn't a great way to make any movie.
Given that the most recent trailer for the film features some very obviously unfinished CGI - particularly during what is presumably its final action scene - it's easy to believe the rumours.
This wouldn't be the first time a major MCU movie has suffered due to tight production deadlines.
The infamously janky VFX in Black Panther's finale was due to time constraints, and while the film overall still turned out great, its visually muddy final battle marked a major step down in quality comparesd to the rest of the movie.
Though it's not uncommon for the final film to look incrementally better than the trailer, you probably shouldn't expect a miraculous glow-up here either, especially with the trailers dropping so close to release.
Don't be shocked if the biggest complaint about No Way Home is its sub-par VFX during the climactic set-piece.
5. Another Spider-Man Movie With Too Many Villains
The irony of No Way Home being an apparently all-encompassing Spider-Man movie is that it may well end up succumbing to the same fatal flaw that ruined the finales of both prior Spidey franchises.
Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 3 was widely criticised for its excess of villains, and similarly, Marc Webb's The Amazing Spider-Man 2 suffered from stuffing its narrative with at least one antagonist too many.
And with No Way Home now confirmed to feature Doc Ock (Alfred Molina), Green Goblin (Willem Dafoe), Sandman (Thomas Hayden Church), Electro (Jamie Foxx), and The Lizard (Rhys Ifans), it's certainly risking the same issue.
When you consider the possibility that we could also see surprise appearances from Vulture (Michael Keaton), a miraculously still-alive Mysterio (Jake Gyllenhaal), and perhaps even The Amazing Spider-Man's Rhino (Paul Giamatti), the potential for an overcrowded canvas speaks for itself.
This is without even getting into the fact the film also has to deal with three Spider-Men, at which point there may not even be much time to deal with the villains in a substantial or satisfying way.
The villains may end up taking a major backseat to the heroes, and through their sheer number be presented in frustratingly little depth.
4. The Multiverse Risks Creating A Stakes Problem
In recent years the MCU has made the bold decision to introduce the multiverse, opening up the franchise's storytelling possiblities albeit at considerable risk to the overall stakes.
The problem with a multiverse, inevitably, is that it becomes more difficult to care about characters with the knowledge that there are effectively a limitless number of them existing at any one time, and that if they die they can be easily replaced by another (looking at you, Gamora [Zoe Saldana]).
Sure, what matters most is the "prime" versions of the characters that we know and perhaps even love, but once the box has been opened it can't really be un-opened, and in a franchise where death already meant so little pre-multiverse, it may now be reduced to a mere triviality.
While it seems incredibly unlikely the MCU will ever dare bring Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) back from the grave given the emotional impact of his demise, No Way Home's multiversal shenanigans may ultimately muddy the narrative waters enough that it becomes difficult to care all that much about anything that's happening.
Though comic book fans are very much familiar with this sort of storytelling where nobody ever really dies, in a continugous movie universe general audiences may find it a little tougher to swallow.
3. A Dubious Farewell To Tom Holland's Spider-Man?
One of the biggest unanswered questions surrounding No Way Home's release is the status of star Tom Holland - namely, will this be his last ever outing as Spider-Man?
Holland recently confirmed that No Way Home completed his contractual obligations to the MCU, and when you also factor in the possibility of Marvel Studios and Sony coming to blows when they renegotiate the character's rights, this could be both the last MCU Spider-Man film and his last MCU appearance full stop.
Of course it may simply come down to Holland wishing to move on from the role, but given both his popularity and relative youth compared to prior screen portrayals of Peter Parker, it'd be a shame if he resigned so fast.
With the status of future Spidey movies up in the air, don't be surprised if the film ends on an ambiguous note which could act as a farewell for this version of Peter but also leave the door slightly ajar for future appearances.
It's extremely unlikely that Holland's Peter will die at the end of the film, but if there isn't a clear commitment to a future direction for the character, fans could be left feeling rather underwhelmed.
2. Killing Off Legacy Characters For Cheap Impact
Though Holland's Peter will almost certainly survive No Way Home, the odds on his fellow Spider-Men making it out alive are much more dire.
Many recent "legacy sequels" have made the cynical decision to bring back beloved, classic characters only to kill them off in an attempt to elevate the current hero - looking at you, Terminator: Dark Fate - and it's entirely possible No Way Home does the very same.
Having either Tobey Maguire or Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man die to save the world would make for a potentially devastating climax, but it'd also be blanketed by a layer of calculation, that the old was being put out to pasture to prop up the new.
This isn't to say that they shouldn't die, but that it needs to make absolute sense for the story and the character, rather than simply serve as a cheap, lazy attempt at an emotional finale.
The most subversive thing the film could actually do is have all three Spider-Men survive, because killing Maguire's Spider-Man off in particular feels like such an obvious, predictable way to give No Way Home its Tony Stark-in-Endgame moment.
This is without even getting into the possibility that the film could kill Aunt May (Marisa Tomei) in an attempt to give Peter his own unique twist on Uncle Ben's death, which naturally has the potential to leave a very sour taste in fans' mouths.
1. The Potential For Hype Backlash
Again, No Way Home is by far the most anticipated blockbuster release since Avengers: Endgame almost three years ago, which combined with a vague-yet-tantalising marketing campaign, holiday season release, and many exciting rumours about what might go down, forms the perfect storm for hype overload.
While it's relatively unlikely that No Way Home pulls a Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker and is a crushing disappointment, what if it scores a perfectly acceptable yet totally unremarkable 60-65% on the Tomatometer?
Many fans already have the movie mapped out in their own minds, such that if it falls short of their ideas of what No Way Home should be, there's going to be an intense hype backlash.
It's entirely possible Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield aren't in the film for more than a mere cameo, and that the multiverse villains are even a much smaller piece of the puzzle than expected.
Given the MCU's rather so-so cinematic output post-Endgame, and No Way Home's status as the next film to "save" theatrical cinema, there's a hell of a lot riding on it being both a critical and commercial smash.
The best thing you can do is just take a step back and accept the very real possibility that No Way Home ends up being a pretty good but flawed movie, rather than convincing yourself it must be great at all costs.