10 Horror TV Shows With Terrifying Surprises
Sometimes, the scariest surprises in horror TV shows are hidden until the last minute.
Shock and horror often go hand in hand, with horrific revelations being part and parcel of the genre. The killer hiding in plain sight only to be revealed last minute? Scary stuff! The innocent little girl turns out to be possessed? How chilling! Hearing the doorbell ring when you’re on the toilet? God save us all!
Sometimes the scares are right before our eyes, and sometimes they hide in the background. However, some horror shows take it to the next level, and hit us with scares completely out of nowhere.
Plot twists, when done well, can be an incredibly effective way to subvert the audience’s expectations and really frighten them. It can also be played for laughs, or simply a way to shake up the story. Take the iconic trope in Scooby Doo where The Gang unmask the killer – its surprising, spooky and often pretty clever. But the horror hounds that grew up with these surprises have grown to want them more and more from the genre.
These horror shows have shocking surprises that end up being some of the most memorable moments in the whole series, and they are absolutely terrifying too. This list will contain spoilers.
10. Demon Dean - Supernatural
The world feels weird without Supernatural. It ran for fifteen years and boasted over 300 episodes, plus it had one of the most uh… passionate fanbases of any television show. For all its highs and lows, monster hunting brothers Sam and Dean Winchester will sorely missed for a long time.
The show, being as long s it was, often had to come up with new ideas to keep it going (killing off the main characters over and over again lost its’ impact pretty quickly). One of the most shocking twists occurred at the end of season nine, when Jensen Ackles’ Dean is killed by Metatron, the Scribe of God.
Prior to his death however, Dean was afflicted with the Mark of Cain, which prevented his death from being permanent. The demon Crowley hands Dean a weapon known as The First Blade, and the camera lingers on Dean’s unmoving face for a few moments. The his eyes open, and they are pitch black: the eyes of a demon.
This cliff-hanger caused a huge amount of theorising within the always energetic Supernatural fandom, as what became known as Deanmon became one of the show’s most surprising twists. It was hauntingly foreshadowed back in Season 3, but seeing Dean become the thing he hated most was nothing short of jaw-dropping.
9. Bullies - All Of Us Are Dead
It’s always when you think the zombie subgenre is finally
dead that it reanimates, kicking and thrashing with new life. This series from
South Korea did just that when it dropped on Netflix in January 2022.
Taking the tired ‘zombie virus’ trope and well, bringing it back from the dead, All of Us Are Dead is a fast-paced horror blood fest set in a school. Like a lovechild between Train to Busan and Battle Royale, it pitches plucky and determined youngsters at Hyosan High against hordes of vicious undead.
For the first few episodes, the source of the zombie outbreak is shrouded in mystery, but it is during the fourth episode that things become clearer.
At the beginning of the show, bullied teen Lee Jin-Su falls from a rooftop and is the first to transform into a zombie. His father, a science teacher at the high school called Byeong-chan, obviously notices his son’s change in behaviour (puberty, amirite?), but suspiciously locks another student away when she also exhibits the bitey and rotting sensibilities.
It is revealed that Byeong-chan himself created the virus, as he was so angry that his son was left completely defenceless against his bullies that he created a serum that he hoped would give his son superpowers. It sort of did?
We’re so used to seeing evil scientists being the reason for
a zombie outbreak, but a father desperate to help his bullied son? Refreshing,
and really painful.
8. The Girl Who Cried Monster - Goosebumps
Any horror fan worth their salt credits Goosebumps for sparking
their interest in the genre as a child.
It’s absolutely iconic and actually packs some real spine-chilling scares, which haunted the dreams of every child who saw it. The Ghastly Grinner is easily one of the scariest horror villains ever – Art the Clown would cower before this menace.
One of the cleverest episodes took place in Season One and aired in 1995. It follows a fairly standard story for the show: girl sees monster, girl spooked by monster, girl tells disbelieving parents about monster. All pretty straightforward stuff.
The monster in question is her librarian, who protagonist Lucy sees transform into a monstrous creature who eats bugs. To try and quash her fears, her parents invite the man to dinner, unknowingly welcoming the beast into their home. You think you know where this is going, especially when the librarian asks what he’ll be having to for dinner. Her parents respond in a very odd way: the librarian is on the menu!
Suddenly, the two adults grow sharp !*$% and transform into
creatures themselves, devouring the librarian. Then, they turn to Lucy and her
brother and tell the two children that soon, their training fangs will grow and
they’ll be able to join in. It’s such a clever and darkly comedic twist that
came out of nowhere, making viewers want to immediately rewatch the episode.
7. Carl Gets Bitten - The Walking Dead
For many, this juggernaut of a series is the best zombie TV
show out there. And in many respects, that’s true. It’s gritty, emotional,
bloody scary and has become an icon of pop culture. Nobody can look at a
baseball bat these days without wincing a little.
The human characters drive the heart of this show, with well developed arcs that really made audiences care about them. One of these characters was Carl Grimes.
Watching him grow from just an innocent kid into a hardened warrior who tried to do the right thing in an unforgiving world was both interesting and heart-breaking – but at least fans of the comics knew he was going to get a happy ending!
Then Season Eight happened. In a horrifying twist of events,
Carl was bitten by a walker. This was hugely surprising, leaving both viewers
and Rick reeling. His death brought tears and controversy in equal measure,
proving what a stellar character he was. Brave until the end, Carl’s death was
a surprise that nobody expected or wanted.
6. Eye On You - Chambers
Netflix cancelling this show will forever be one of life’s greatest disappointments. The intriguing plot, beautiful cinematography and fantastic cast come together to create a unique and genuinely disturbing tale of identity, privilege and possession.
After getting a heart transplant due to suffering a heart attack, teen Sasha Yazzie gets weirdly adopted into the family of the girl whose heart she has, Becky Lefevre. Yet Sasha soon sees alarming visions of Becky, and realises that whatever caused Becky to die, is starting to happen to her.
It’s undeniably creepy, and the reveal that Becky’s death was the result of suicide after a cult that her family belong to had sacrificed her body to be a vessel for the demon Lilith was nothing short of pan wetting. Sasha thankfully has Becky removed from her heart, and the evil is vanquished.
However, the final episode drops a huge bombshell: Becky was keeping Lilith at bay, protecting Sasha from becoming fully possessed. The terrifying final moments of the show depict Sasha’s iris splitting into two: Lilith has control, and that is really not good.
But we probably will never know how or if this resolves as the show was cancelled which, considering the fact it's one of the few sources of Native American representation in horror shows, and TV at large, really sucks. But hey, at least we got The Kissing Booth 3 right….
5. Angela - The Exorcist
Ten years ago, if someone suggested that a TV show set in the same universe as William Friedkin’s legendary film about demonic possession could be good, they would have been booed, put in the stocks and had tomatoes thrown at them like the village fool they were.
Then, in 2016, The Exorcist series came out, and everyone had to eat their words. It was absolutely terrifying and held together by a fantastic cast of characters. Even without any familiar faces or themes, viewers began to wonder how this series was linked to the original story.
The answer lay with Geena Davis’ matriarch, Angela. Her daughter Casey is showing signs of possession, and she enlists the help of two priests. Angela seems to know an awful lot about the subject, and the fifth episode of the show dropped a huge bombshell that explained why.
In the episode, Angela recalls her difficult childhood to Father Tomas, explaining that she had a difficult episode when she was young that she can’t recall in detail due to the trauma. But her mother kept using the story to make money, and so Angela changed her name to escape. Only Angela Rance is an anagram… an anagram for ‘A Clean Regan’.
The episode ends with Sharon Gless arriving at the door, announcing herself as Chris MacNeil, looking for her daughter. Angela was Regan this whole time?! The best thing about this twist is that viewers were left to figure it out for themselves rather than being spoonfed the answers. Our minds were blown and the series shifted gears from really good, to bloody brilliant.
4. Violet's Fate - American Horror Story: Murder House
Murder House, the first instalment in the anthology series
American Horror Story, wove a complex web of plot threads that required close
attention. That is, if you were brave enough to not watch through your fingers
the whole time!
Following the central Harmon family as they move into the titular house, they each face a unique but linked set of supernatural threats. Teenage daughter Violet has to deal with the crumbling marriage of her parents, social ostracization at school, and the weird affections of a creepy ghost boy called Tate who lives in her house.
Understandably, it’s a lot to deal with. After finding out that Tate was killed by a SWAT team after committing a massacre at her high school, she attempts suicide. Tate saves her, and they reconcile. She stops attending school, which her dad is pretty unhappy about. He promises to let her change schools, but Tate isn’t happy about this. He tries to convince her to stay, but she really wants to leave.
So, Tate pulls the wool from Violet’s eyes and takes her
into the house’s crawlspace, where Violet sees her own corpse gazing lifelessly
back at her. It turns out that her attempt was successful, and she has become a
ghost trapped in the house. It’s very well executed and utterly horrific, and
the audience really empathise with the distraught Violet.
3. Annie's Fate Revealed - Being Human
Being Human is a criminally underrated British horror-sitcom
about a werewolf, a vampire and a ghost sharing a house in Bristol. Lenora
Crichlow stars as Annie Sawyer, a newly deceased ghost who is quite simply, the
sweetest little angel ever put to screen. She’s absolutely lovely and deserves
the world.
One of the central plot points of the show is that Annie can’t seem to move on to the afterlife, which her pals George and Mitchell help her with. The three reside in Annie’s old home, which her fiancé Owen has rented out. Annie remembers falling down the stairs to her death, but nothing else.
However, after a fellow ghost tells her that she has unfinished business which is keeping her on Earth, Annie has a horrifying flashback. Owen was not the man she thought he was, and during an argument she accuses him of cheating. He becomes verbally and physically abusive, and he pushes her down the stairs.
Annie, and the audience, are utterly horrified that such a
cruel fate befell such a good person. Her retribution could not come sooner.
2. Time Enough At Last - The Twilight Zone
This show is filled to the brim
with legendary, eye-popping and pant-wetting plot twists. It was therefore
really, really hard to choose just the one, with honourable mentions going to
Five Characters in Search of an Exit, The Invaders, To Serve Man and Eye of the
Beholder.
However our winner is Time Enough at Last, one of the bleakest stories in television history.
The plot follows a man called Henry. He has an ordinary life, a loving wide and a well-paid job. Something isn’t right though, as he is constantly berated for his love of reading. It borders on obsessive, as he bores everyone around him with plot points and useless facts about fiction. He’d do really well at WhatCulture to be honest.
He locks himself into one of the bank vaults to read in peace, only to read a headline in the newspaper about a nuclear bomb. The bomb goes off, knocking Henry unconscious and he awakes to find himself the last man on earth. This is, without a doubt, one of the worst fates that could befall a person.
However, Henry soon discovers that the library is undamaged, as are the books inside. Finally, he can read in peace for as long and he likes! But he trips on some rubble. His glasses fall of his face and shatter.
Henry cannot see without them,
and so he cannot read. Watching Henry cry into an empty void of destroyed civilisations
is, without a doubt, one of the most haunting images in fiction.
1. The Bent Neck Lady - The Haunting Of Hill House
Poor, poor Nell Crain.
Mike Flanagan’s masterpiece, The Haunting of Hill House, follows the tragic lives of the Crain family who move into the evil Hill House. All of the children suffer, but it is Nell who quite possibly has the worst luck of them all.
She is haunted by a horrific apparition known as the Bent Neck Lady during her time in Hill House and suffers from PTSD throughout her whole life after the death of her mother. After seemingly finding peace when she falls in love and marries Arthur – but he suddenly dies of an aneurysm. She also suffers from sleep paralysis, and The Bent Neck Lady starts haunting her again.
The series opens with the news that Nell has died, with her family believing it to be suicide. However, the truth is far darker.
Nell went back to Hill House to confront her demons, where she is greeted by her mother’s ghost. The two have emotional reunion, where Mrs Crain gives Nell her locket atop a staircase. But suddenly, we see that the locket is in fact a noose, and Nell slips. Her neck breaks, and it is then we see the truth.
Travelling back through time, Nell realises that she was in fact the Bent Neck Lady, haunting herself for all these years.
Nell’s life is marked and defined
by tragedy, and realising that she was doomed to her fate and that that the
things we are most scared of often lurk inside us, was a terrifying and gut
wrenching twist.