10 Most Essential Coen Brothers Films

The Dude, the CIA, Nic Cage as a human cartoon, and a folk singer who f***ing hates folk music...

By Cathal Gunning /

There are few contemporary American directors more beloved and acclaimed than Joel and Ethan Coen. The pair of helmers have spent the last four decades living on the tricky borderline between mainstream blockbuster stardom and indie obscurity, and their coolly detached visual style, consistently sharp wit, and singular storytelling have carved them out an irreplaceable niche in the history of American cinema.

Advertisement

It’s hard to name every filmmaker who owes their career to this eclectic pair, but even megastars such as Quentin Tarantino and Paul Thomas Anderson can trace the earliest acceptance of their off-kilter, original visions to the success of the Coen Brothers projects before either auteur ever made their multiplex debut.

With an outsized reputation as once-in-a-generation artists and an incredible CV of brilliant films to back up the claim, it can be a tad intimidating to select a mere handful of the brothers’ onscreen efforts and cite them as the most essential offerings from the pair.

But we here at WhatCulture are nothing if not ambitious, so we’ve only gone on and lined up all of the Coens’ filmic offerings, shot down the handful of Ladykillers and Intolerable Cruelties, and ended up with a list of the ten most vital flicks from this dynamic duo.

10. No Country For Old Men

Start as you mean to go on—we’re sticking this brutal contemporary western deconstruction right at the top of this list for numerous reasons, first and foremost because they were deservedly be hell to pay if it weren’t on here.

Advertisement

Adapted from Blood Meridian author Cormac McCarthy’s unsparing story of the same name, this singularly bleak western adds a frisson of the brothers’ trademark black humour to proceedings, but the hopeless, near biblical nihilism of the source text is very much intact here.

Javier Bardem offers a career-best turn as the stoic hitman pursuing Josh Brolin's live wire protagonist, and the future Thanos reminds us how great he is in this sort of genre fare as he embodies a nervy, intense anti-hero we can’t help but root for even as the bodies begin to pile up.

But this film belongs to Tommy Lee Jones, whose closing monologue is amongst the most haunting moments in noughties cinema and earns this film its reputation as one of the brothers’ best.

9. Fargo

A little less nihilistic than No Country For Old Men, though no less gory, this small town mystery is suffused with a strange sense of sweetness which elevates its blackly comic shaggy dog story from countless competitors which would follow in its wake—take notes, The Big White/ The Ice Harvest/ any of a million other knock-offs.

Advertisement

Here the murderous plot follows a hapless William H Macy as he gets in way over his head with an amoral, snide Steve Buscemi and his terrifying partner Peter Stormare, a villain who can rival Bardem’s Anton Chigurgh in terms of sheer chilling screen presence.

But much like No Country, this flick belongs to one actor, and it’s Frances McDormand’s charming earnestness which stops proceedings from becoming pointlessly cruel and ensures that this flick maintains a genuine heart beneath its bleak plot. It’s an odd thing to say about a flick featuring death by wood chipper, but the film is ultimately about family and community, and it shows a kinder side to the brothers’ often unsparing worldview.

8. The Big Lebowski

Come on. Did you think the stoners would let us leave this one off the list?

Advertisement

Shane Black and Paul Thomas Anderson may have made their own attempts at shaggy dog comedy-noirs in the years since and produced a pair of classics in the form of 2005’s uber-cynical Kiss Kiss Bang Bang and 2015’s trippy Inherent Vice, but neither film could have existed without the help of the Dude, and Jeff Bridges’ hilarious central turn remains one of stoner cinema’s finest hours.

The labyrinthine plot, borrowing from the likes of Raymond Chandler and other iconic noir authors, may be impossible to follow, but that isn’t the point here—the point is the razor sharp dialogue, with the brothers’ inventive wit and ear for a surreal one liner making this one of the most quotable films from the nineties.

It’s a flick bolstered by some hysterical turns from John Goodman and Steve Buscemi as the dude’s proverbial devil and angel in his ear, and by a hilariously dark sense of humour wherein everything—death including—is good for a laugh.

7. O Brother Where Art Thou

Perhaps you’re noticing a pattern—any list of the Coen Brothers’ best work will inevitably begin with a journey into darkness as many of the pair’s most critically acclaimed work traffics in serious, heavy themes such as morality, mortality, and the pointlessness of existence, but after a while it’s impossible to forget that damn these two are funny as hell when they want to be.

Advertisement

Featuring a stellar central turn from a game George Clooney, who proves more than willing to send up his heartthrob image as a goofy, wannabe Casanova convict, this surreal reimagining of Homer’s Odyssey sees a trio of rock-breakers escape from the chain gang, only to embark on a series of satirical misadventures which would leave anyone praying for salvation—or even a return to hard labour.

It’s rare that a film can boast both John Goodman as a demented cyclops and a thoughtful meditation on the birth of America, but then there are few feats that the brothers haven’t proven able to manage.

6. Burn After Reading

This CIA satire may be less critically beloved than many of the pair’s cinematic outings, and it’s certainly the coldest comedy they’ve produced in their decades spent making movies. Indeed, almost everyone onscreen in this internal affairs farce is either too stupid, too craven, too crazy, or too all of the above to root for as anything resembling a hero—and the only character innocent enough to believe pays a high price for their relative decency.

Advertisement

Yet that’s pretty fitting for a film as angry and uncompromising as this one, which sees Brad Pitt’s gormless gym attendant and a nervy, typically superb Frances McDormand attempt to blackmail the “intelligence” community, encountering an unhinged John Malkovich and George Clooney in the process.

One of the most vicious indictments of America’s surveillance state in post-Iraq mainstream film, this flick also manages to be hysterically funny and undeniably clever, if a touch too hopeless and coolly detached for the top spot.

5. Miller's Crossing

Okay, we got to it, chill out—Yes, this one made it to the list at the expense of both Barton Fink and The Hudsucker Proxy, so our apologies to those two satirical indictments of consumerism and creative solipsism respectively.

Advertisement

But how could we leave this brutally bleak gangster film off a list like this?

Where other titans of American cinema such as Francis Ford Coppola and Martin Scorsese imagined the Mafia as tragic villains consumed by an operatic ballet of violence or ineffably cool antiheroes whose amoral antics are hard not to admire, the Coens turn to biblical simplicity for their pass at the gangster genre to great success.

A simple and heartbreaking story of an overplayed hand and the dangers of unchecked ambition, Miller’s Crossing is painfully cold and unsparing in its depiction of the inevitable cruelty of a “cops and robbers” criminal justice system in place since America’s wild west days, but strangely moving in its empathy for its godforsaken cast, and features an unforgettable central turns from Gabriel Byrne and John Turturro.

4. A Serious Man

There’s black comedy, then there’s pitch black comedy, then there are the sort of awkward jokes we all feel compelled to make at funerals to ease the tension (just us?).

Advertisement

Then there’s 2010’s A Serious Man. Easily the most brutal but blackly funny of the Coen Brothers’ films, this story of a Jewish patriarch whose entire life unravels around him for no apparent reason manages to be both hysterically funny and surprisingly poignant philosophical treatise on everything from historical guilt to the existence of God.

Transplanting the biblical story of Job’s endless trials into the suburban milieu of fifties Americana, A Serious Man piles misfortune after misfortune on its hapless protagonist, forcing the viewer to empathize with this tragic sadsack right up to its hilarious but cruel final frames. It’s hard to unpack just what the pair are saying here, outside of funding some fun in the inevitability of suffering (very Buddhist, Coens), but there’s not denying it’s a guiltily hilarious ride once you accept the happy ending isn’t on its way. Uncut Gems wishe

3. Inside Llewyn Davis

If A Serious Man is hilarious because it offers the viewer a hapless everyman who deserves none of the cruelties heaped upon him by an uncaring universe, the wildly underrated Oscar Isaac vehicle Inside Llewyn Davis is the exact opposite. Here, the trials and tribulations faced by the eponymous protagonist, a folk singer on the cusp of stardom, are all clearly deserved, and it’s his own hubris and self-centred worldview which leads to each new crisis piled atop the last.

Advertisement

And yet…

And yet, thanks to some incredible supporting turns from the likes of Adam Driver, Carey Mulligan, and Justin Timberlake (of all people), and Isaac’s tragic, searching pleas, we can’t help but root for this hopeless case, and his every setback ends up breaking our hearts as much as it thumps our collective funny bone. It’s a delicate balance which this dark tragi-comedy/ Definitely Not Unofficial Bob Dylan Biopic treads with grace and finesse throughout its hilarious, but bleakly beautiful runtime.

2. Blood Simple

Back to basics—this neo noir from way back in 1984 was the Coen Brothers’ first big screen effort, and already many of the trademarks which will go on to make their work iconic are present in this (appropriately enough) simple but brutally effective small town thriller.

Advertisement

A phenomenal success with critics upon release, this chilling thrill-ride began as a trailer that the pair shot which featured a shadowy figure digging a grave for an unseen captor in his car boot, and the icy noir grew from this iconic image which adorns the film’s famous poster. Borrowing its title from a line by hard boiled author Dashiel Hammett, the film does justice to the author’s sparse, taut thrillers with its story of infidelity, distrust, and eventual bloody murder.

A clear influence on everything from Danny Boyle’s explosive debut Shallow Graves a decade later to more recent stripped back noir efforts such as 2014’s Cold In July and Blue Ruin, this vicious thrill ride plants itself in the mind of viewers and never leaves.

1. Raising Arizona

Damn right this is an out of left field pick for our number one spot—the Coens have proven impossible to pin down throughout their storied screen careers, and what better way to celebrate the diversity of their filmic CVs than by moving from the brutal and vicious neo noir underworld of Blood Simple to this warm hearted live action cartoon from 1987?

Advertisement

Featuring a typically hilarious turn from Nic Cage as a loveable hick caught up in a kidnapping scheme and attempting to hold onto his (well, sort of his) beloved baby, this zany adventure starts at full tilt and only grows crazier from there, bouncing through some surreal vignettes at a mile a minute with a paper thin plot which essentially acts as an excuse to film some supremely silly, hilariously funny chase scenes and bizarre character sketches.

Despite the non-existent story, there’s an urgent pace and real heart in this fun, funny, and beautifully filmed comedy thriller, and it hits every beat which has come to define the director’s careers from violence as comedy, to heartfelt stories of family crossing over with noir and thriller motifs, to some satirical lambasting of all-American society and culture.

Advertisement