10 Movie Characters Whose Fates Are Never Resolved
Dead or alive?
Though it's enormously satisfying when a movie reveals the truth about an ongoing mystery, both ambiguity and subtle restraint can also be dramatically rewarding in their own ways, giving the audience plenty to think about once the end credits roll.
But sometimes movies take this to head-scratching extremes, such as by leaving viewers bafflingly clueless as to the fates of certain characters.
To be clear, we're not so much talking about films where a character's unknown fate is the entire point of the movie - say, The Wrestler, for example - but rather films where a character just...disappears from the story.
This list is mostly concerned with significant supporting characters who, despite their prominent placement in the narrative, are left dangling on a thread by film's end.
While none of these unresolved character arcs are movie-derailing, they are all in the very least mystifying and some might say frustrating.
In some cases we know that the original plan for the character was scrapped during post-production, leaving fans to draw their own conclusions, while in others the filmmakers just clearly didn't perceive the character to be as valuable as the audience did.
Either way, the means by which these supporting players duck out of their respective movies are very strange indeed...
10. Lee Montgomery - Death Proof
Death Proof may be near-universally accepted to be Quentin Tarantino's worst film, but it's still a fun slice of B-movie exploitation that knows exactly what it is.
And though the film deals out memorable fates to most of its focal characters, there is one significant supporting character who is bizarrely left hanging at film's end.
Mary Elizabeth Winstead appears in the movie as Lee Montgomery, a beautiful cheerleader who ends up unwillingly left as collateral with creep Jasper (Jonathan Loughran) while her friends take out Jasper's 1970 Dodge Challenger for a ride.
While Lee's friends mete out bloody revenge against Stuntman Mike (Kurt Russell) at the end of the movie, Tarantino never actually bothers to return to Lee.
This is especially troubling as Lee's pal Abernathy (Rosario Dawson) told Jasper that she was a porn actress, and so the last time we saw Lee, she was catching some extremely unsavory looks from the guy.
It's also worth noting that actor Jonathan Loughran played an unnamed rapist trucker in Tarantino's prior Kill Bill movies. The dual casting is surely an intentional implication on the director's part, as befits the film's thoroughly sleazy tone.
Lee's fate is never resolved, though it seems highly likely that she's either raped and/or killed by Jasper, or in a "best" case scenario, is forced to have sex with him when the girls return his destroyed car and he cashes in the collateral.
9. Kristoff - Die Hard
Die Hard is such an incredibly tight, well-crafted action movie from start to finish, and though John McClane (Bruce Willis) ambiguously vanquishes smooth-talking terrorist Hans Gruber (Alan Rickman) at the end, the fate of one low-key character is still left up in the air.
Once Gruber is dealt with, there are two terrorists who appear to remain alive, the first being computer hacker Theo (Clarence Gilyard Jr.), who is of course knocked out in the underground garage by Argyle (De'voreaux White) in the movie's finale.
But there's another villain everyone always forgets about, and that's Kristoff (Gerald Bonn), a French terrorist who assists Theo when he's busy cracking the vault. Moments before Hans is killed, he can be seen running away and then getting knocked out by John.
But the hit itself clearly wasn't forceful enough to kill Kristoff, and yet he's never seen again.
It's of course entirely plausible that he's taken into custody after this, but amid the utter carnage of it all, he probably has a not-terrible chance of slipping away undiscovered.
After all, canvassing 35 floors is no easy feat, especially with the FBI's finest blown to smithereens and Dwayne T. Robinson (Paul Gleason) calling the shots.
If the gigantic Karl (Alexander Godunov) was able to sneak his way out of Nakatomi and almost murder John in the film's final scene, why not this petite, harmless-looking Frenchman?
While Clarence Gilyard Jr., who played Theo, has claimed he was the only terrorist to survive the movie, he of course isn't remotely the Word of God here, so Kristoff's fate still remains a total mystery.
8. The English Sergeant - Kingdom Of Heaven
Ridley Scott's Kingdom of Heaven is a gorgeous mess of a movie, and absolutely a film that benefits enormously from watching its effortlessly superior Director's Cut.
But even the three-plus-hour extended version doesn't explain the sudden, bizarre disappearance of a notable supporting character - the English Sergeant played by Kevin McKidd.
The Sergeant is one of Balian's (Orlando Bloom) likeable pals who appears to be ready to accompany him to the Holy Land, and yet, once Balian takes a ship to Jerusalem, he's never seen again.
Some have suggested that he may have been one of the casualties of the shipwreck during Balian's journey to Jerusalem - of which Balian was the only survivor - yet this isn't in any way indicated in the movie itself.
On the home video release, it's stated that a dummy of McKidd was made for the shipwreck scene, implying that he was intended to die, yet going by what we actually see on-screen, it's just as easy to believe that he simply never got on the boat and stayed in Messina.
Either way, given that the Sergeant was supposedly Balian's confidante, he clearly deserved some sort of notable send-off rather than, well, nothing.
7. Nauls - The Thing
John Carpenter's sci-fi horror The Thing is a masterpiece of tightly-wound suspense and grotesque imagery, as a group of American researchers find themselves attacked by a shape-shifting parasite in the remote Antarctic.
The film famously ends with protagonist MacReady (Kurt Russell) and Childs (Keith David) living out their final hours together, each succumbing to the mortal cold while unsure whether or not the other is The Thing.
It's a wonderfully bleak ending, except it entirely glosses over the fact that Nauls (T.K. Carter) literally just disappears from the movie moments before. After Garry (Donald Moffat) is attacked by a Thing-infected Blair (A. Wilford Brimley), we see Nauls head in the same direction, and that's all she wrote.
It's never made clear whether Nauls was assimilated by the Thing or died when MacReady detonated the station.
The movie's home video release did reveal, however, that the original plan was to have Nauls be assimilated, yet due to time and budgetary constraints, the scene was never filmed.
Both the film's novelisation and a comic book meanwhile have Nauls die in different ways - killing himself and being blown up respectively - so there's clearly no single canonical answer here.
It's tough to imagine a scenario where Nauls survived, but who are we to insist that he didn't end up joining Mac and Childs for a chilly, paranoiac swig of booze two minutes after the movie ended?
6. The Puppy - Apocalypse Now
Francis Ford Coppola's war epic Apocalypse Now is a brilliantly thought-provoking film, and one that's left viewers low-key agonised over the ambiguous fate of one beloved central character for 40 years.
Of course, we're talking about the adorable puppy which is informally adopted by the soldiers during their mission, and which bafflingly disappears when they're ambushed later in the movie.
The cute canine serves as a striking metaphor for innocence throughout the film, so perhaps it's fitting that the pup vanishes into thin air along with it.
Given that the dog disappears when the gang is attacked, it's reasonable to deduce that it was either killed or jumped overboard and paddled to shore, but despite its absence being noted to the audience, it's never followed up on.
Then again, Coppola is hardly much of a sentimentalist, so it's not terribly surprising he'd refuse to have the puppy rejoin Captain Willard (Martin Sheen) at the end of the movie after terminating Colonel Kurtz (Marlon Brando).
5. Paul Holt - Friday The 13th Part 2
The entire point of the Friday the 13th franchise is to serve up a platter of dopey, over-sexed young folk to the machete-wielding maniac Jason Voorhees, so especially bizarre it was that the series' second entry wasted a perfectly ripe opportunity to off one of its principal characters.
After Jason is seemingly "killed" in the climax, survivors Ginny (Amy Steel) and Paul (John Furey) are resting up back at their cabin when, all of a sudden, Jason bursts through the window, grabbing Ginny.
Except...it's all a dream, at which point Ginny awakens to find herself being tended to by the medics, while calling out for Paul, who is nowhere to be seen.
None of the subsequent news reports or glimpses at Jason's makeshift shack confirm that Paul indeed died, leaving his fate weirdly ambiguous for a blood-thirsty slasher flick.
The film's screenwriter, Ron Kurz, did however confirm that the original filmed ending more explicitly implied that Paul was dead, with the decapitated head of Jason's mother Pamela (Betsy Palmer) smiling creepily, rather than being totally motionless as it is in the actual ending of the movie.
While it's not terribly likely that Paul survived, we also have no concrete evidence on film that he definitely ended up on the business-end of Jason's machete.
4. Caesar Flickerman - The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 2
Stanley Tucci's casting as The Hunger Games' Master of Ceremonies Caesar Flickerman is one of the franchise's several note-perfect decisions, playing the part as he does with a deliciously entertaining mix of high-camp and scarcely-veiled contempt.
And despite being a major character in the franchise, he disappears long before the end of Mockingjay - Part 2, his ultimate fate being left entirely ambiguous.
In both the movie and the novel, Caesar makes his last appearance announcing the apparent death of protagonist Katniss (Jennifer Lawrence). Whether he'd be eaten alive by the newly-liberated citizens, arrested, or simply let go is anyone's guess.
In fairness, back in 2011 franchise author Suzanne Collins stated that Caesar did indeed survive the rebellion due to not being directly affiliated with President Snow (Donald Sutherland).
However, given that she was talking about the books and there are many clear differences between them and the movies, it doesn't necessarily mean that his screen counterpart also survived.
3. Peggy Brandt - The Mask
Jim Carrey's The Mask is one of the rubber-faced comic's best movies, and it's aged surprisingly well over the last 25 (!) years. But there's one major character who is conspicuously absent from the third act of the movie - reporter Peggy Brandt (Amy Yasbeck).
She ends up betraying Stanley Ipkiss (Carrey) to gangster Dorian Tyrell (Peter Greene) and...is never seen again. It's jarring given the expectation that there'd be some kind of follow-up to her duplicity, and yet, there's nothing.
But as it turned out, truer to the harsher tone of the comic on which the movie was based, director Chuck Russell originally filmed a macabre scene where Peggy is murdered by Dorian.
Once she gives Stanley up, she's thrown into a printing press, after which a series of blood-stained newspapers are printed out reporting her demise in a "freak accident."
Despite how well-executed the scene is, Russell felt it was out of step with the rest of the film, and was also toying with the idea of bringing Peggy back for the sequel. So instead, Peggy just vanishes and the rest of the movie continues without her. Weird.
While we at least know the original intent, given that the deleted scene was cut for specific storytelling reasons, we can't possibly conclude that it sufficiently explains her absence from the rest of the plot.
2. The Four Other Basterds - Inglourious Basterds
By the end of Quentin Tarantino's blood-soaked masterpiece Inglourious Basterds, the eleven-member team of Nazi-hunting "Basterds" has seemingly been whittled down to just Lieutenant Aldo Raine (Brad Pitt) and Private First Class Smithson Utivich (B. J. Novak).
Except, wait a minute. What happened to the four other Basterds who were neither killed nor seen with Raine and Utivich in the final scene of the movie?
These soldiers are Gerold Hirschberg (Samm Levine), Andy Kagan (Paul Rust), Michael Zimmerman (Michael Bacall), and Simon Sakowitz (Carlos Fidel), and there's nothing even remotely close to an implication as to what became of them by film's end.
The four pretty much just disappear from the movie's finale, which given their potential usefulness in the successful execution of Operation Kino, is just totally bizarre.
Tarantino doesn't seem to do anything by accident, but at the same time, it feels like there's a whole sequence missing where the four men get taken out of commission.
1. The Joker - The Dark Knight Rises
And while he's far more of a major character than anyone else on this list, the specifically tragic circumstances of The Joker's (Heath Ledger) unexpected exit from Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Saga make it one of the most agonising character cliffhangers in movie history.
The supervillain of course appeared in scene-stealing fashion in The Dark Knight, and ended up captured by the authorities at film's end, with the clear implication that he'd be sent to Arkham Asylum.
However, Ledger's untimely death made the character unavailable for the sequel, The Dark Knight Rises, with Nolan (quite rightly) adamant that, without Ledger, the character wouldn't be referenced at all.
Still, it's hardly a leap to suggest that an antagonist as iconic as the Clown Prince of Crime would've returned for the sequel had Ledger lived, and some have even speculated that he may have taken the cameo role ultimately given to Scarecrow (Cillian Murphy) in the final film, of a kangaroo court judge.
But given that The Dark Knight Rises is centered on a Gotham deprived of its infrastructure by Bane (Tom Hardy), The Joker's lack of presence is definitely a bit odd narratively speaking, given the high likelihood he would be sprung from Arkham.
The film's novelisation suggests that he's Akrham's only inmate, though also hints at the prospect that he may have been freed, not that this is definitively canon to the movie at all.
All things considered, Nolan probably made the shrewdest choice possible under the circumstances - a recast would've been criminal - but it doesn't change the fact that, in-universe, The Joker's absence is very strange indeed.