10 Movie Flops That Will Become Cult Classics
Coming to a cult film festival near you.
Blockbusters sometimes appear to have been made for (and by) pod people: they all cost the same ridiculous amount, star the same people and carry on forever. The differences between characters and storylines are not great. Every so often, though, a movie will come along that ignores the cookie-cutter mentality in favour of doing things on its own terms. We call these cult classics.
They happen when an audience sees a movie they were warned away from, and realize for themselves that it’s not the mega-bomb they were told. In fact, it has several elements in its favour, be it good casting, a cool action scene or an attitude that sets it apart from the rest.
Failing that, there’s always the chance that future generations will look at the garish lighting, elaborate costumes and interplay between the leads and proclaim the movie a classic of the camp variety. Anyone who’s seen Batman & Robin knows what I’m talking about.
It doesn’t matter whether these films are good or bad, their box office returns are immaterial to the place they go on to hold in our hearts. All that matters is that they’re worth catching, and in some cases they’re more entertaining than that year’s biggest releases.
10. The Wicker Man
Destined for “so bad it’s good” status, Neil LaBute’s remake throws out everything that made the 1973 original work and brings in all the usual horror clichés: false scares, dream sequences and a cop hero who’s also a caricatured tortured soul.
To the delight of Bad Movies Fans, the role is played by Nicolas Cage, who conveys his character’s frustration by SHOUTING HIS LINES and saying everything 3 times. Should that fail, he also knows Kung Fu.
After dropping the F-bomb in front of small children and stealing a teacher’s bicycle at gunpoint, Nic steals the show by dressing up as a bear (long story) and punching out as many women as possible. Any hope that he’s reprising his character from Con Air literally goes up in smoke when he’s burned alive as a sacrifice.
The movie went up in flames too, making less than its $40 million budget at the worldwide box office.
9. Piranha 3DD
Piranha 3DD had the temerity to turn its back on Piranha 3D, ignore the film’s cliffhanger ending and go in a campier direction, for which it paid dearly at the box office. While the original was a modest success, taking $83 million on a $24 million budget, this $20 million sequel made less than half its budget worldwide.
That might be because nobody came out the first movie thinking, “I can’t wait for the next one” or it might be because the title promises the ultimate sleazefest. Whatever the case, there’s more to Piranha 3DD than babes, blood and boobs: for one thing, there’s David Hasselhoff doing a hilarious self-parody.
Arriving at Big Wet Water Park, the home of the “cooch cam” and “water certified strippers”, The Hoff looks around and announces, “Welcome to rock bottom.” When Piranhas invade the pool, he has fun poking fun at himself, running in slow motion and failing to save a cute kid who’s decapitated by a flying fish. If you’ve ever wanted to see that, tune in.
8. Catwoman
Yes, Catwoman is the most laughably awful superhero movie in recent memory, but a cult audience embraces a film for the qualities that separate it from the herd, something the picture has an in abundance.
If you’re looking for camp, here’s a movie about a hero whose costume covers her face but leaves her midriff exposed, who dominates men with a whip (seriously, what’s with that?) and hisses at passing dogs. If you’re looking for corny, there are clunky one-liners (“What a purr-fect idea!”), an eye-rolling speech about how an Egyptian feline imbued Halle Berry with her powers and a plot about Sharon Stone controlling the world with a skin care product.
If you’re watching the movie for unintentional laughs, don’t miss the scene where, after being left for dead by Stone’s henchmen, Halle’s lifeless body washes up on land and is immediately set upon by some hilariously unconvincing CGI cats. The leader of which – get this – stands over her and reanimates her with its breath. Not since Freddy Krueger was resurrected by a dog’s urine have filmmakers dared to be so lazy, or taken their audiences to be so stupid.
7. The Incredible Hulk
Released a month after Iron Man, The Incredible Hulk is the ginger-haired stepchild of the MCU, the movie that flopped at the box office, failed to launch a franchise and caused Marvel to recast the lead role for The Avengers. So this must be a coiled and steaming mess that makes even Thor: The Dark World look good, right?
Well, no. It’s a solid action movie in its own right, and the Hulk shown here is meaner, greener and more dangerous to know than the character portrayed in Ang Lee’s 2003 movie. The movie also excises the psychobabble that weighed down Lee’s version, opting instead for a chase thriller whose lead character happens to turn green when angry.
Lighter on its feet and less crassly commercial than many of the later MCU films, The Incredible Hulk not only clocks in at under 2 hours (a rare thing these days) but being the 2nd movie from Phase One means that characters from future instalments aren’t clumsily shoehorned into the narrative. There is a cameo from Robert Downey, but that comes right at the very end.
6. The Three Musketeers
Paul WS Anderson was the just the right guy to mount a steampunk version for the Alexandre Dumas classic for a modern crowd, and his version was one of the most entertaining in years. It caught the eye of Quentin Tarantino, who named it as one of his favourite films of 2011.
Sadly, American audiences didn’t share his enthusiasm and the $75 million movie struggled to make $20 million during its domestic run, making it one of the year’s biggest flops. There’s plenty to enjoy here, though, including a cast that includes Mads Mikkelsen as Rochefort and Christoph Waltz as Richelieu. Even Orlando Bloom’s pretty good as the Duke Of Buckingham.
If you didn’t know you were watching a movie from the director of Resident Evil you’d be able to guess from action scenes, which are as slick as you’d expect from Anderson. You might argue that they disrespect the laws of physics, but that’s a minor complaint in a movie that just wants to give you a good time.
5. Fantastic Four
I’m probably sticking my neck out with this one, but consider this: there was a good movie in amongst the bad wigs and obvious reshoots that we never got to see. If Josh Trank’s 2 hour plus cut ever sees the light of day, it will blow the release print out of the water.
Time Out called Fantastic Four a movie of two halves “the first likeable and fun, the second tiresome and loud.” It takes its time (50 minutes) setting up the characters, but then goes horribly wrong as second guessing by the studio dilutes their motivations and muddies the narrative. By the second half, you’re no longer invested in the characters or their story because they’ve become more like pieces on a chessboard.
It wouldn’t be the first time a studio threw away a decent film and ordered reshoots to make it “commercial” – exactly the same thing happened to Clive Barker’s Nightbreed, whose scope and majesty was junked in favour of a slasher movie that would appeal to the Friday The 13th crowd.
4. Terminator Salvation
Salvation is unique among Terminator sequels: it has no use for humour, time travel paradoxes or any cast member from the previous films (using Linda Hamilton’s voice and digitally mapping Arnie’s face onto another actor’s body don’t count).
That may explain why it was the first Terminator to miss the #1 spot at the box office and with takings of $371 million the lowest grossing entry in the series (even Genisys made more money). But there’s a terrific cast headed by Christian Bale, the first Oscar winner to play John Connor (and more intense than any of his predecessors), and the movie’s action scenes reward a second viewing.
Special mention has to be made of the attack by the Harvester Terminator, which simply put is one of the most accomplished moments in any recent action movie. Buildings are demolished, Moto-Terminators are employed, dragged for several miles and hurled into the air, then once the HK-Aerials get in on the action, bridges are destroyed before Resistance planes engage them in a dogfight.
3. Jupiter Ascending
Jupiter Ascending has a bonkers plot, an underlying campiness and nearly as many coherent ideas as there are garbled ones. It went toes up at the US box office, grossing only $47 million despite a $176 million production budget.
Mila Kunis is Jupiter Jones, a toilet cleaner who for some reason has been targeted for assassination by alien agents. When she meets Stinger (Sean Bean), Jupiter realizes she can control bees, the only insect genetically programmed to recognize royalty. This can only mean one thing: Jupiter is genetically identical to the deceased matriarch of a family that owns a string of planets, and is therefore Earth’s rightful owner (are you getting this?).
During her adventures, Jupiter encounters such colourful characters as Titus Abrasax (great porn name), who requests her hand in marriage after informing her that all humans are cattle and Caine Wise (Channing Tatum), who’s supposed to be a man-dog hybrid but looks more like a gay hairdresser’s idea of an action hero.
2. Tomorrowland
Tomorrowland is your typical story of a teenager, a disillusioned genius and an audio-animatronic robot who travel into space in a rocket hidden beneath the Eiffel Tower. Arriving in an alternate dimension known as Tomorrowland, they find a tachyon machine that shows the future and upon realizing that the apocalypse is imminent attempt to save the Earth.
Got that? Good. You wouldn’t have known any of it from the marketing because Disney pitched it as a loony hybrid of The Wizard Of Oz and Terminator Genisys, a movie with a ton of explosions and special effects and oh yeah, there’s some stuff about alternate dimensions also. Nobody wanted that, and the film made less than half its $190 million cost in the US.
Tomorrowland has more heart and soul than that and it spins its exciting tale better than most blockbusters, even throwing in some ecological concerns for good measure. If the film has a flaw, it’s that the time-shifting narrative is probably a little too complex for the target demographic.
1. Scott Pilgrim Vs The World
In order to win the heart of Ramona Flowers, Scott Pilgrim has to defeat her seven evil exes, including a skateboarder he tricks into performing a dangerous stunt and a vegan he brings to the attention of the “Vegan Police.” So far out so good, but there’s also a ninja, evil twins and a mystic who can throw fireballs to defeat.
This was Edgar Wright’s first American film and it’s a quantum leap from his last movie, the disappointingly one-note Hot Fuzz. Loaded with quick-fire gags and told with such gusto that it rattles along like a freight train, it should’ve catapulted Wright onto Hollywood’s A-list, but when it took less than its $60 million worldwide, he returned to the UK to make the equally brilliant (and underrated) The World’s End, which was perhaps a little too English for American tastes.
Wright got the last laugh, though: when the film reached Blu-Ray, sales went through the roof, and it’s not being unkind to suggest that the movie will stand up to reappraisal better than 2 of 2010’s biggest hits, Iron Man 2 and The Twilight Saga: Eclipse.