10 Movie Sequels That Completely Changed Tone
It's boring when films are the same all the time, but is a drastic change always for the best?
Last week, we were treated to the much lauded trailer for Logan, Hugh Jackman's swan song as Wolverine, and much to everyone's apparent surprise, the teaser was completely unexpected. It highlighted the character dynamics between Wolverine and Charles Xavier to the accompaniment of Johnny Cash's iconic cover of Trent Reznor's Hurt, demonstrating a shift in tone that is unfamiliar territory for superhero franchises.
It remains to be seen if this trailer is merely deliberately constructed in such a way that it tugs at our heartstrings, or if it is a genuine representation of what the movie is going to be like. If the latter is the case, then this will be a new side of mainstream comic book movies, but not a wholly unique thing within movie franchises themselves.
History has given us a slew of sequels that have departed from their predecessors and to varying levels of success. The best case scenario is the new change will rejuvenate a franchise and extend its lifespan beyond what was originally thought possible. But a calculated risk must be taken as you're rolling the dice on whether you alienate your existing fan base or not. That's the gamble Hollywood takes.
Here are 10 movie sequels that completely changed tone.
10. Captain America: The Winter Soldier
The second instalment in the Captain America trilogy is arguably the best entry in the Marvel Cinematic Universe: The First Avenger was a solid jumping off point, but it failed to resonate in the same way the original Iron Man had, the ante needed to be upped for the sequel.
In come the Russo Brothers, who decided to experiment with a more politically focused narrative and a throwback style in the same vein as 1970s Cold War thrillers.
The experiment was certainly a success, as critics and fans alike agreed that TWS was a significant improvement over TFA. There was a certain bleakness within the tonal shift, the bright and colourful patriotism of the previous film had been replaced with a muted colour palette and a cynical distrust of the American government.
The Winter Soldier himself was presented as a menacing figure, the booming musical score that signalled his arrival wouldn't be out of place in a horror movie. This was a superhero film with some real weight, and it succeeded in making Captain America relevant to a mainstream audience again.
9. Batman Forever
Now for a superhero movie that had almost the exact opposite effect. 1995's Batman Forever presented a change in tone that would incur the wrath of Batman fans the world over. While it is a solid film in itself, its campy presentation and whimsical humour had no echoes of Tim Burton's past two efforts with the colossal franchise.
The disappointing box office results for 1992's Batman Returns caused a knock on effect that would lead to the series lying dormant for eight long years.
The first blow dealt was Tim Burton being dismissed from the third Batman movie, with Michael Keaton closely following him out of the door. In came Joel Schumacher, a director who could be viewed as the antithesis of Burton, and he proved exactly that.
Stylistically, Batman Forever resembled nothing of Burton's work on the Caped Crusader, everything was now neon and Gotham had gone from looking like a giant cathedral to resembling the world's largest nightclub. Unfortunately, the film found success and was followed up with the infamous Batman & Robin.
8. Fast 5
The Fast and Furious franchise is a curious one in that it actually hugely improved after completely altering its identity. The first four were passable if uninteresting street racing flicks, then the powers that be decided "screw it" and made all of the characters Superman but with cars.
It's safe to say that none of us were ready for the fifth film in a street racing series to be an international heist movie, with a finale that featured muscle cars dragging a monolithic bank vault through the streets of Rio de Janeiro.
Yes, these movies have now become impossible to take seriously, but the lack of pretence has allowed them to breathe more. Asking us to be fully invested in a relatively bland team of street racers for four movies is a big ask, but how about a movie where that same team are now soldiers of fortune in pimped out automobiles?
The fun factor of the last three films has been off the scale, with stunts steadily escalating in ridiculousness to the point where I think we'll be a little disappointed if the last film isn't set in space. We owe it all to the reinvention of the franchise's premise that Fast 5 gave us, and for demonstrating the true meaning of "family".
7. Casino Royale
Possibly the most sorely needed change of tone in the history of cinema, the Bond franchise had lost a lot of its lustre in the early-to-mid 2000s. Die Another Day was a real letdown for fans and many thought Bond had finally jumped the shark. It would be four agonising years before the wrongs of DAD were righted, but it was most definitely worth the wait.
Daniel Craig's casting as Bond was initially met with controversy due to his supposed lack of resemblance to the character, but that was quickly washed away when Casino Royale arrived on the scene in 2006.
Taking notes from the Bourne films, James Bond became more grounded in realism, with less of a reliance on gimmicky and increasingly ludicrous gadgets. Casino Royale kicked off in black and white, cross cutting between Bond violently disposing of a henchman with his bare hands and smoothly assassinating a target.
This was then followed with a pounding chase through Uganda, which featured a terrifying jump between two cranes. We were treated to a much darker Bond than we were used to, but it was at the right time and was embraced by the masses.
Despite Spectre being being rather underwhelming, the Bond films are firmly established in modern blockbuster filmmaking, and it's all owed to Casino Royale changing the game.
6. Mad Max 2: The Road Warrior
The odd thing about Mad Max 2 is that it created the tone that we all identify with the franchise. Most people will think of leather clad gangs of marauders in insane vehicles, a stark desert landscape, and a protagonist who wanders without saying a whole lot when they hear its name.
But this style wasn't introduced to the franchise until The Road Warrior came around. The original Mad Max bears almost no resemblance to the following three films: the stunts are tame, Max is explored more as a person, and the cars are pretty normal. It's not even really an action movie so much as it is an old school exploitation revenge flick.
This can all be attributed to budgetary constraints: George Miller made the original Mad Max on a shoestring budget. Luckily, the film was a hit and became one of the most profitable movies of all-time. This allowed Miller to fully realise his vision with the subsequent Mad Max films.
The Road Warrior changed action filmmaking forever, the stunts were over the top and terrifying. All of the characters dressed like they were in some kind of BDSM fantasy and it really gave the franchise an identity of its own. 2015's Mad Max: Fury Road captured the hearts of millions, and it can be traced back to the second Mad Max movie, not the first.
5. Evil Dead 2: Dead By Dawn
Evil Dead 2's chief virtue is its total disregard for its own existence. Sam Raimi's follow-up to his 1981 horror masterpiece The Evil Dead ignores the events of the first film and decides to just do its own thing. Raimi had actually lost the rights to the first film at this point, so he had to recreate a lot of the scenes for the recap at the start of the second. This has led to many believing Dead by Dawn isn't even a sequel, but a remake of the original with a bigger budget.
It might as well be a remake though, when you consider its injection of humour and complete ignorance of the fact that Ash actually dies at the end The Evil Dead (or is at least attacked by an evil spirit).
The setting is identical, but Raimi has stated that he always intended for the first film to be a black comedy and that he felt like he missed the mark. Well, consider the mark well and truly hit with Evil Dead 2. The dark humour is pitch perfect, with one-liners, quips, absurdist body horror and splatter galore.
This is the movie that launched The Evil Dead into a fully fledged franchise with video games, comics, a remake and even a TV series. Groovy.
4. Return To Oz
This one isn't technically an official sequel to the 1939 classic, as MGM had lost the rights for L. Frank Baum's books to Disney, but it is still a continuation of the Oz narrative and perfectly functions as a sequel if you let stuff like studio disagreements slide. When anyone thinks of The Wizard of Oz, an image of wonder and beauty is conjured up. Gorgeous colours that engage your inner child, lovely songs and dance routines, these are what we associate with the merry old land of Oz.
Of course, if that is your preferred perspective of Oz, then this film will shatter all of that and possibly induce nightmares that will forever soil your love of Dorothy and company. Return to Oz was marketed as a children's film, but it contains elements that wouldn't be out of place in a David Cronenberg movie.
There's a hall of severed heads, Tin Man looks like he's just come off a rather nasty meth binge, and don't get me started on Jack Pumpkinhead, who is supposed to be a friend but is a crucible for sheer terror. The change of tone wasn't necessarily a bad thing, as Return to Oz was actually heavily faithful to the source material, but it could be construed as somewhat ill-advised.
3. Terminator 2: Judgement Day
It's safe to say that Terminator 2 is among the mist universally praised and beloved action movies ever made, and rightly so. The set pieces are mesmerising, the story has a real emotional core, and the character arcs are profound in their contrasts with the original film.
James Cameron's 1984 hit film, The Terminator, served as the launching pad for his and Arnold Schwarzenegger's careers. On their way to becoming Hollywood legends, they made sure that the eagerly anticipated sequel followed the same beats as the original, but cleverly twisted the delivery to create a fresh experience.
We all know about the mind blowing special effects, but the humanity at this film's core is what has made it into such a giant in the pantheon of cinema. Sarah Connor is evolved into a badass action heroine, Arnie is a saviour, and Guns 'n' Roses have a song in the soundtrack.
It's a perfect recipe for for genius, the low budget horror tone of the first film is switched up for a hyperbolic action romp that packs a mean punch. There's a reason this film is still talked about fondly today, and that is the careful handling of its evolution into a pure piece of resounding spectacle. And now none of us can see a thumbs up without shedding a tear.
2. Aliens
Speaking of James Cameron making a sequel to a horror movie as an action flick, here's the one that started that trend. Ridley Scott's Alien was such a perfect horror masterpiece that there was no point in even attempting to replicate it.
That leaves you with one option: Do something entirely removed from that. Aliens took the original and injected it with steroids, creating a war movie between man and alien. Instead of one Xenomorph, there's hundreds, rather than no guns, let's have an armoury. No punches are pulled in this 1986 classic.
Much like Sarah Connor, Ripley evolves as a character into a strong-willed action heroine who refuses to give up. The crack team of marines around her provide memorable characters that are still quoted today.
You've got Vasquez's rebuttal to, "Have you ever been mistaken for a man?" with, "No, have you?", and Bill Paxton profoundly stating "Game over, man" Game over!" (a quote I still like to use whenever anything ever goes wrong for me).
The 80s was the golden age for action and Aliens sits right at the top with Die Hard. Also, the M56 Smartgun is one of the coolest weapons ever.
1. Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back
Here it is, the granddaddy of them all. Empire's dark tone in contrast to the fun adventurousness of the A New Hope has led to any darker instalment in a trilogy being referred to as "the Empire Strikes Back" of that particular series. That's some serious staying power for a movie that has since had five follow ups so far.
It's such a perfectly executed evolution from the first film: the stakes are higher, the mood bleaker, the narrative colder. The concept of good versus evil has never been more extreme, there is a distinct black and white morality that is skewed at the last moment with a twist that led to many a jaw hitting the floor in 1980.
One of the all-time great sequels with a tone so different from the first, this is the gold standard of franchise evolution. Every series needs to take notes, because Empire Strikes Back wrote the guidebook.
Which other tone bending sequels belong on this list? Share your reactions below.