10 Movies That Would Actually Benefit From A Remake

In the business of moviemaking, name recognition is the key...

By Scott Campbell /

In the business of moviemaking, name recognition is the key. Even if you have the greatest original idea in the world, it faces a much tougher road to the big screen that something that can be easily marketed and sold. This is why Hollywood continues to fill up their schedules with remakes, reboots, sequels and adaptations; it's much easier to cater to a built-in audience than trying to build a new one. For this reason, the remake train shows no sign of slowing down anytime soon. Of course, not all remakes are inferior to the original. Some are on a par with the original (True Grit, The Departed), some are arguably superior (Ocean's Eleven, Let Me In) and some all-time great movies from various genres are remakes (Scarface, The Thing, Cape Fear, The Magnificent Seven). That being said, a lot of them are pointless and some downright awful (Total Recall, Conan the Barbarian, the majority of horror movie retreads). This article will take a look at ten movies that would actually benefit from a remake. It could be a brilliant concept that was executed poorly, a great script that was unrecognizable by the time it hit theaters, or a dated classic that in the right hands would be perfect for a 21st Century update but either way, read on and find out which ten titles deserve the remake treatment. Do you agree with the article? Who would you cast in these hypothetical remakes? Are there any other movies you think would benefit from a being remade? As always, sound off in the comments below.

10. Jason And The Argonauts (1963)

Although the movie was directed by Don Chaffey, Jason and the Argonauts will forever be associated with Ray Harryhausen, thanks to the most iconic stop-motion work of a long and distinguished career. A bona-fide classic fantasy adventure, it remains a staple of Sunday afternoon television schedules over 50 years after its release. However, under the right circumstances I believe that Jason and the Argonauts would be ripe for the remake treatment. The generation that grew up with this movie were absolutely spoilt for choice when it came to mythological adventures featuring a heroic quest and innumerable gorgeously designed creatures. What do we have? Sam Worthington's turgid, CGI-drenched Titans movies. It just isn't fair. That being said, Clash and Wrath of the Titans grossed almost $800m at the box office despite some vitriolic reviews, so the audience is there for blockbusters based on Greek mythology. It's hard to believe given its standing in the annals of fantasy movie history but Jason and the Argonauts wasn't a smash-hit first time round, and only grossed back twice its $1m budget at the domestic box office. Due to the obvious advancements in both practical and visual effects, in the right hands a remake could be something truly special. Imagine something visually akin to Wolfgang Petersen's Troy (which featured an ancient Greek setting and seamlessly blended practical sets and CG landscapes) that also featured updated versions of Talos, the Hydra and of course, the iconic skeleton fight. If it avoided the pitfalls that blighted the recent Titans movies then a Jason and the Argonauts remake could be old-fashioned entertainment on a blockbuster scale.

9. A Sound Of Thunder (2005)

The reputation of this movie will probably stop a remake from ever getting off the ground simply by association, which is a real shame as Ray Bradbury's original 1952 short story has a brilliant central concept, and an inherently cinematic one at that. Unfortunately, the 2005 adaptation is well-known for all the wrong reasons. When the best thing about your movie is Ben Kingsley's wig, you know you're in trouble. A Sound of Thunder's $80m budget was provided by companies from the UK, United States, the Czech Republic and Germany but a tortured production saw floods in Prague wipe out some of the sets, while Franchise Pictures went bankrupt before the movie was completed, which left no money to finish the project to a suitable standard. It showed, as A Sound of Thunder has some of the worst effects ever seen in a Hollywood movie. A full two years after the end of principal photography, the movie was dumped in theaters to overwhelmingly negative reviews and an embarrassing box office total of $11.7m worldwide. There is a reason that the original short story is one of the most published sci-fi stories in history and done right, A Sound of Thunder has the potential to be a great high-concept blockbuster. The idea of 'time tourists' on a dinosaur safari in the past would lend itself to some great set-pieces, while the repercussions from the smallest alterations could blend in elements of a dystopian thriller, with a twisting plot that could balance smarts with spectacle.

8. Hancock (2008)

Is it fair to say that a Will Smith summer blockbuster that grossed almost $625m at the worldwide box office is in need of a remake? Based on the wildly uneven quality of the final product and the potential of the initial script to completely subvert the superhero genre, I would certainly say so. After a promising and hugely entertaining first act, that sees Smith play against both his on-screen persona and the typical superhero as the alcoholic, homeless and unlikeable hero, things become increasingly muddled thanks to a mid-movie twist and the movie's inability to successfully balance the elements of superhero movie, summer blockbuster, dark comedy and family drama that are all going on at once. The final product bears the heavy fingerprints of studio interference, which is unsurprising considering the script (originally titled Tonight, He Comes) was written way back in 1996 and went through numerous rewrites (including one from Vince Gilligan) and passed through Tony Scott, Michael Mann, Jonathan Mostow and Gabriele Muccino before Peter Berg was finally hired to direct. The original script was a much, much darker affair that featured a protagonist unlike any superhero movie ever. Tonight, He Comes didn't just stretch the boundaries of the genre, it smashed them to pieces. It is readily available to read online, and would easily be a hard-R movie and a very uncomfortable watch at some points. However, if it was treated as a dark comedy and given a budget in the $40m range, the result would be an instant cult classic and the ultimate deconstruction of the superhero movie, which would be especially prescient given the number of comic-book adaptations that currently saturate the multiplex.

7. Fantastic Voyage (1966)

Richard Fleischer's classic sci-fi is a movie that surprisingly hasn't been remade yet, although it isn't for lack of trying. Although the special effects and Cold War allusions have become terribly dated, which of course you would expect 48 years on, the central concept remains strong; a scientist that developed a miniaturization process lays in a coma, causing a team to use his technology in an attempt to save his life. Despite some questionable logic regarding the miniaturization, the movie remains one of the decade's greatest adventure movies. The set design and effects are brilliant for the time period, and resulted in Academy Award wins for both Art Design and Special Effects. A remake has been talked about for decades now, with James Cameron initially writing a script that was rejected by potential director Roland Emmerich, before Paul Greengrass was mooted in 2010 with Cameron still attached as producer. Recently, Shawn Levy has been circling the project although there has been no news in recent months. A remake of Fantastic Voyage has the potential to be both intelligent and entertaining, and an updated version utilizing cutting-edge effects would be perfect for 3D. With James Cameron's continued involvement it would be safe to say that the addition of the third dimension would be nothing short of stunning. Of course, seeing as the original movie was a product of its time the political angle would need to be dropped and the team of scientists updated for the modern day seeing as the only woman on-board was an 'assistant'. In the mold of the recent $600m grossing 'Journey' franchise, a remade Fantastic Voyage has the potential to be a 3D adventure movie for all ages to enjoy.

6. Reign Of Fire (2002)

How could a movie with such a simple, yet brilliant, pitch wind up being so dull? Rob Bowman's post-apocalyptic action movie is the very definition of 'great concept, poor execution'. With Pacific Rim, The Desolation of Smaug and early reaction to Godzilla footage proving audiences still haven't tired of watching giant lizards causing havoc on a global scale, an updated Reign of Fire could fulfill the potential the original failed to deliver on. The idea that dragons wiped out the dinosaurs and have been in hibernation for thousands of years, waiting to exterminate the next wave of inhabitants, is as high-concept as it gets. An atmospheric opening scene shows the re-appearance of the first fire-breather, before a montage and voice-over effectively establish that humanity is on its last legs. Sadly, from there we are treated to pitch-black, murky action sequences (although the sky-diving sequence is thrilling) and Christian Bale and his people hiding in a castle, musing on the banalities of life. Even a scenery-chewing Matthew McConaughey can't liven things up, despite his utterly demented performance and glorious death scene. Reign of Fire failed to even deliver on the promise of its concept art, something advances in CGI could easily accomplish. The potential is there to deliver massive-scale destruction, charred cityscapes and terrifying aerial assaults, all balanced against a central human story. The original does have its fans, but the sheer potential of the premise could lend itself to something brilliant.

5. The Running Man (1987)

The Running Man is 1980's sci-fi at its cheesiest; based on a Stephen King novel, directed by Starsky and featuring big muscles, bigger hair, Paula Abdul choreography and Arnold Schwarzenegger in yellow spandex. Over 25 years on the movie has not aged well, but the central concept of convicted criminals fighting for their lives in the titular game show is ripe for an update, especially given the onslaught of reality television in the last decade. Despite being made when The Austrian Oak was at the height of his box office powers, The Running Man was only a mild success and made just over $38m on a $27m budget. The movie is unsure whether it wants to be a standard Schwarzenegger vehicle or corporate satire, and gamely tries to balance both as Arnie dispenses one-liners while also rebelling against 'the network'. There are some notable thematic undertones to the movie that still ring true today, especially Richard Dawson's Damon Killian justifying the murderous game-show as a way to satiate America's love of both television and violence. However, any social commentary is soon made irrelevant when a rocket-powered sled fires him through a billboard. The simplest way to market an updated Running Man would be as the R-rated Hunger Games, which is both a blessing and a curse. Those unfamiliar with the original could possibly see it as being too similar to the Jennifer Lawrence-starring box office juggernaut, as both see people fighting for their lives in a television show broadcast in a totalitarian future America. However, without the boundaries of a PG-13 rating a Running Man remake would be able to incorporate underlying themes on our desensitization to violence, as well as the market saturation of reality television in the guise of an action-packed sci-fi thriller. One thing's for sure; the costumes definitely need to change.

4. Killing Season (2013)

Killing Season was only released less than a year ago, so what it is doing on a list of movies that should be remade? Well, the original script is unique, atmospheric and visceral and would have made for an action movie unlike any other. Unfortunately, the end result bore little resemblance and was woefully miscast, poorly acted and directed with no discernible style, and was released to absolutely no fanfare before grossing a whopping $40,000 at the domestic box office. The plot sees Robert De Niro's military veteran living a quiet existence in the Appalachian Mountains when he encounters a Serbian tourist with ulterior motives played by John Travolta, which quickly evolves into a violent game of cat and mouse. Unfortunately, de Niro doesn't seem to be interested in the slightest and it is difficult to decide which aspect of Travolta's performance is worse; the beard or the accent. There are some squirm-inducing scenes of intense violence, but director Mark Steven Johnson (he of Daredevil and Ghost Rider infamy) shoots the whole thing like it's a three-camera sitcom. Originally titled Shrapnel, the breakthrough script from Evan Daugherty was on the 2008 Black List and at one point had John McTiernan attached to direct. Set in the 70's and featuring two grizzled World War II veterans, the story transposed the 'cabin in the woods' motif from the horror to action genre, and features a much stronger narrative and deeper characterization than the mess that hit cinema screens. If Killing Season had stuck closely to the original setting and script, and chosen better in front and behind of the camera it could have been a lo-fi action masterpiece. Instead, it has most likely already been forgotten by most. Think along the lines of Liam Neeson as the isolated ex-soldier and Gary Oldman as his German adversary bent on revenge and you'd have a hell of a movie.

3. Timecop (1994)

20 years on, Timecop remains the highest-grossing Jean-Claude Van Damme starring vehicle, which is hardly surprising given it was released at the peak of his popularity, before his descent into the straight-to-DVD market during the intervening decades. Despite grossing over $100m at the worldwide box office, the plot is hugely inconsistent and full of holes you could drive a truck through. Nonetheless, the strength of the central premise would lend itself incredibly well to the remake treatment. The opening scene of Timecop sets out the movie's stall in brilliant fashion; Confederate soldiers transporting gold bullion are suddenly attacked by a man in period clothing, who just happens to gun them down with automatic weapons. Boom, audience hooked. Sadly, the rest of the movie fails to deliver on the promise of the first scene and the actual time travel is very limited, with the action mostly taking place in either 1994 or 2004 bar a quick jaunt to the Wall Street of 1929. Still, it remains a serviceable sci-fi actioner. The great thing about the 'time-traveling lawman' concept is that a remake would have so many avenues to explore. Besides keeping a few story beats from the original (lead character's wife is offed in the opening act, villain alters the past to manipulate the future), there would be an entirely blank canvas to play with. The plot could feature uniquely-devised set pieces from across history, with a bad-ass action hero saving the world as well as his woman.

2. The Towering Inferno (1974)

The Towering Inferno is rightly regarded as a classic; Steve McQueen and Paul Newman head an all-star ensemble cast in one of the greatest disaster movies of all-time. Both a critical and commercial smash-hit, it was nominated for 8 Academy Awards including Best Picture and grossed almost $140m worldwide, which is well over $650m adjusted for inflation. 40 years on, the story would be perfect for the big-budget blockbuster treatment. In 1974, the making of The Towering Inferno was a production of epic proportions itself; shepherded to the screen by producer Irwin Allen (known as the 'Master of Disaster') it was the first major co-production between two prominent studios, with 20th Century Fox and Warner Bros. joining forces and footing the bill for the $14m budget, a huge figure at the time. Then of course there was the McQueen/Newman double act; the two megastars were treated as equals and were both given the same salary and number of lines, as well as having their names arranged diagonally on the credits so both could lay claim to first billing. Nobody in Hollywood seems to make disaster movies anymore with the exception of Roland Emmerich, though he should be kept well away from this should it ever come to fruition. Armed with a blockbuster budget, a 21st Century Towering Inferno could stay true to the original and feature a sprawling ensemble cast of fully-developed characters that each get their own moments, as well as upping the ante when it comes to spectacular visuals and claustrophobic set-pieces. Of course, a remake would need two genuine A-list stars to top-line the movie; who would you choose? I'd go for Robert Downey Jr. as the fast-talking architect confident in his design and Hugh Jackman as the no-nonsense fireman.

1. The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (2003)

Alan Moore and Kevin O'Neill's hugely popular graphic novel is the epitome of a great idea being chewed up by the Hollywood machine and spat out as an unrecognizable mess; the tale of a rag-tag bunch of 19th Century literary heroes facing off against a threat to humanity is incredibly cinematic and ripe with franchise potential. Unfortunately, the final product bore little resemblance to the source material and suffered from a notoriously tortured production that ultimately led to Sean Connery's retirement from acting, as well as being director Stephen Norrington's last feature. Despite the perfect casting of Connery as Allan Quartermain, with Naseerudin Shah and Stuart Townsend also excelling as Captain Nemo and Dorian Grey, the rest of the cast are one-dimensional and instantly forgettable. Changing Mina Harker from an integral part of the source material to vampiric eye-candy was bad enough, shoehorning in Shane West's wooden Tom Sawyer for the benefit of American audiences is even worse. The villain is weak, the script clunky and over-reliant on exposition and plot points are randomly picked up and dropped without any explanation. Positives include some gorgeous production design and a couple of decent action scenes, but that's about it. The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen did manage to gross almost $180m at the box office, and had a strong performance on home video. That being said, the whole endeavor was a giant missed opportunity that will hopefully be remade in the future to its fullest potential. If it had stayed truer to the source material, the result could be a spectacular steampunk-influenced blockbuster action movie in the vein of a 19th Century Avengers. We can but hope.