10 Problems With Marvel's Phase 4 (And How To Solve Them)
How do you follow the Infinity Saga? Well, probably not like this...
After months and months of the usual Mafia-level secrecy, Disney and Marvel Studios unveiled what Phase 4 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe looks like at this relatively early stage: the projects that will become the next slate of films in a shared universe that’s made $22 billion worldwide over the last eleven years.
And it wasn’t terribly overwhelming. True, the response in Hall H was predictably manic, but at this point Kevin Feige could probably reveal a Rocket Raccoon movie starring an actual raccoon and people would go insane.
The fact is, the vast majority of the projects revealed to us had already been revealed or leaked over the preceding months anyway. The only surprises were the subtitles of some of the films, the casting of Shang-Chi and a few of the Eternals, the revelation of Natalie Portman’s role in the next Thor film, and the last minute, post-credits-style stinger of Mahershala Ali’s casting in a Phase 5 Blade reboot.
It’s not just the predictability of Feige’s presentation, though. There are some issues raised by what we know so far about Marvel’s Phase 4 offering. But it’s not too late to fix them… oh, and spoilers for any and all of the Marvel movies released so far may appear in this article like wild Pokemon. Gotta catch ‘em all.
10. The Black Widow Movie Feels Underwhelming
We now know a little more about the first instalment in Marvel’s Phase 4: the Black Widow movie. Set between Captain America: Civil War and Avengers: Infinity War during the period where Natasha Romanoff was still a fugitive from international justice, it’ll see her face off against former colleagues from Russia and the Red Room.
And yet there’s nothing here that feels especially vital. Unless you’re a Black Widow stan desperate for one last round of high kicks and dry quips, it all just seems a little dull.
The Black Widow movie must have been greenlit after they knew the character would die in Avengers: Endgame. They knew that her character’s arc was coming to a close: so why spend all the time and money on this film in the first place?
Natasha Romanoff is dead: this prequel, the beginning of the vaunted new saga, is set during the saga we’ve just closed the book on. What is there to get invested in?
Well, the obvious answer would be to walk back Endgame’s definitive no-taking-back rule on the Widow’s passing.
In the comics, the Black Widow was killed in battle and resurrected… by the Red Room. They have her memories transferred to a clone artificially grown to maturity, their greatest assassin returned to them at last.
It was made as clear as possible that the Infinity Stones couldn’t bring back a character sacrificed to the Soul Stone - but they found a loophole to bring back Gamora. Why not Romanoff?
9. It Feels Like We’ve Done The Eternals Before
An immortal royal family of superpowered creatures of alien origin living apart from humanity… the high concept for the Eternals feels very, very familiar.
It’s probably because it’s roughly the same high concept of the Inhumans TV series, which featured a royal family of superpowered creatures of alien origin living apart from humanity.
Now, as far as we know, the Eternals have been loitering around Earth posing as gods for us poor benighted mortals for thousands of years - you know, like the Asgardians, who we discovered through three Thor movies and a guest shot on Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. have been loitering around Earth posing as gods for us poor benighted mortals for thousands of years. The Asgardians, ruled by an immortal royal family of superpowered creatures of alien origin living apart from humanity.
Going forward, it’s vital to differentiate the Eternals from the Inhumans and the Asgardians for a cinema-going audience that won't be familiar enough with the original amazing Jack Kirby comics to know the differences.
They’ve already stunt-cast the hell out of it, which is helpful - and the diversity of said cast is a welcome thing to see, especially with what appears to be two female leads.
But let’s have less of the 'classical-gods-amongst-us' thing, and perhaps lean more heavily into the 'immortal warriors' trope: a little bit more Highlander, a little bit less Clash Of The Titans.
8. Wanda Maximoff Is A Completely Unknown Quantity
Four movies in and four years later, we know less about Wanda Maximoff than we did when we first met her as a villain in Avengers: Age Of Ultron.
In that film, she was revealed to have powers that were bestowed upon her by experimentation with the Mind Stone, alongside her twin Pietro. He gained superspeed; she gained… well, the jury’s out on that.
In the comics, her powers haven’t been clearly defined either. Depending on who’s writing her, she can alter probability, alter reality, wield magic, wield chaos magic, or some weird-ass combination of the above.
In the movies, she’s been able to put ‘the whammy’ on the minds of the Avengers and displayed some hellacious telekinetic ability, which as time went on has become her go-to power. The telepathic stuff's been completely forgotten about since Age Of Ultron.
It should also be noted, just in passing, that the MCU has never referred to her as ‘the Scarlet Witch’ (due to the franchise’s ongoing embarrassment at the comic book tropes it’s adapting) and it looks like with WandaVision this will be continuing. Has Carol Danvers ever been referred to as Captain Marvel, by the way?
WandaVision (they should seriously consider changing that title, it’s awful) is apparently going to be ‘weird’, harking back to how Maximoff was first described in Age Of Ultron, so it’s possible we might finally get into the nitty-gritty of the character and the extent of her powers. Not before time.
7. There Aren’t Very Many Movies On This Slate
So Black Widow is out next May, and Eternals is out six months after that, in November next year. That’s only two MCU movies in theatres in 2020, and the one coming up is a full ten months after Spider-Man: Far From Home (and, as mentioned, it’s a prequel set six years or so before the current 2023-set continuity).
It’s not much, is it? Yes, The Falcon And The Winter Soldier is debuting sometime in autumn 2020, but this franchise is called the Marvel Cinematic Universe, not the Marvel Multi-platform Universe. A TV series on a brand new paying digital platform is not the same thing as a major cinema release, no matter how Disney tries to spin it.
From dominating the release schedules, Marvel Studios have stepped back to releasing only two movies in the next year and a half.
The solution is… well, to amend the slate. What’s been announced is subject to change - that’s always been the case. Remember, at one point the Inhumans project was a film, not a TV series.
There’s also no reason in the world why Marvel Studios can’t greenlight lower budget stories for cinema release which could slot in between major tentpole releases. Arguably, some of these Disney+ projects could have been movies that filled these roles.
Look at the two Deadpool films - these were made for a third the cost of the cheapest MCU movies, and you can’t really tell the difference. Lower budgets mean lower expectations, but allow for greater storytelling capacity.
6. We’re Not Getting Any New In-Continuity Stories For A While
At the risk of repetition, the Black Widow movie is set several years in the past. Neither the Eternals nor the Shang-Chi movies have any indication that they’ll reference any current events for other Marvel heroes.
So when do we get to find out what’s happening with our favourite characters?
Spider-Man’s stuck in a nasty cliffhanger - when will that be resolved? No idea. Who took the Wakandan throne when Black Panther died? No clue. Nearly three decades ago, Captain Marvel vowed to the Kree that she would take the fight to them - what happened there? Who can say.
Previously, the waiting time for an MCU sequel was a couple of years - now we’re reliant on Disney+ shows to give us post-Endgame stories for these characters we’ve become so invested in.
Those who can’t get Disney+ when it launches will have to wait nearly two years just to see Doctor Strange and Wanda Maximoff again, and a further six months after that to see Thor and Valkyrie. They're still keeping you guessing about the Guardians and Spider-Man.
Even for those who can get Disney+, two of the projected shows are out-of-continuity: the version of Loki they’re using is one from a branched timeline, and the whole point of What If? is that it’s not part of MCU continuity.
This isn’t just Phase 4. It’s an issue that’s affected the MCU for a while. Because Marvel Studios can only make a certain number of projects at once, everything else is queued for development and production. However, Phase 4 is the worst it’s ever been.
5. Is Disney+ Really Going To Be Integral To The MCU?
Marvel Studios and Disney are making a lot of assumptions if they believe that their Disney+ shows are going to be able to reach the same number of people as their movies.
Morgan Stanley analyst Benjamin Swinburne projected in a recent note to investors that in the short term term, Disney+ 13 million subscribers to sign up by the end of 2020 (ie, by around the end of the first year or so).
It’s tricky to say exactly how many people went to see Spider-Man: Far From Home, but with the average ticket price in the US at around $9.00 and a box office of a billion dollars and climbing, it’s a safe bet that it was a lot more than 13 million households.
That means that it’s equally safe to say that a lot less people will be physically able to watch the Disney+ shows - at least, in the first two years, which happens to cover all of Phase 4 - than will be able to go to the cinemas to watch an MCU movie.
They’ve already said that the events of WandaVision, out on Disney+ sometime in Spring 2021, will tie into the events of Doctor Strange And The Multiverse Of Madness, which is coming out on May 7th 2021. However, less people will be able to see the former than the latter… so let’s hope what happens in WandaVision isn’t too important after all, right?
4. We've Got A Two Year Slate Of Disney+ Marvel Shows... What About The Netflix Shows?
Nowhere is there any mention of the Netflix shows that were recently unexpectedly cancelled - in the Phase 4 announcements, hints about Phase 5 or anywhere else.
Scuttlebutt (like gossip with dodgy small print) is that if Disney+ wants to continue the Netflix street level shows - or even just a couple of them - it’s contractually obligated to wait two years after their cancellation, although it’s not clear whether that’s two years before they can enter production or two years before they can promote and broadcast them.
The fact that in this two year slate there’s no mention of any of the Netflix shows is a bit of a slap in the face for fans who’ve been campaigning for their resurrection, not to mention a continuing gap in the MCU’s treatment of actual crimefighting superheroes. Is Spider-Man the only person stopping bank robberies and organised crime in the whole of this Marvel Universe?
Now, in fairness to Disney et al, they may well have an announcement regarding these properties up their sleeves for Hulu - some of the Netflix shows are too violent to be screened on Disney+. Equally, the Defenders cast may no longer be available: actors get other jobs. People move on.
But enough of being fair! Bring back Daredevil and Punisher, you cowards! Give us a Heroes For Hire show!
And announce Keanu Reeves as Moon Knight. You know you want to.
3. Falcon & Winter Soldier Is Rehashing Bucky’s Brainwashing
Currently, it’s understood that the Falcon And Winter Soldier will feature Helmut Zemo as the villain, returning from his role as the instigator of the Civil War. The Hall H presentation also implied that the Winter Soldier’s brainwashing will again be a significant plot point.
Bucky’s unstable nature was the focus of both the last two Captain America movies. No one has any reason to trust him now that Captain America is no longer in the picture: if he goes AWOL again they’d lock him up and throw away the key.
Meanwhile, the MCU’s version of Zemo is a one-note villain - and as previously discussed, isn’t necessarily even a villain, given that his origin story and motivation is identical to the Punisher’s. Why bring him back?
If it’s still about an obsession with revenge against the Avengers, then Falcon wasn’t on the team when Ultron destroyed the city; Bucky’s not an Avenger at all. Stark’s dead, Rogers is presumed dead by the public at large. What’s the point?
Perhaps if Zemo only appears at the beginning, or if they get the brainwashing issue out of the way early. They could then dedicate the rest of the show to something new and different that establishes Bucky as an actual hero now, making amends for the past.
And bring back Old Man Cap in a cameo as the new head of S.H.I.E.L.D., please. He’s the only person who can provide continuity for the Winter Soldier character on an ongoing basis.
2. Is The Mighty Thor Going To Involve A Transformation?
It’s exciting that Marvel Studios will be bringing a version of the Mighty Thor to the MCU. Jane Foster’s heroic apotheosis has featured in some of Marvel’s best books over the last few years. However, it does raise the question of how they’re going to pull it off.
In the comics, Jane Foster has cancer and physically transforms into an Amazonian Asgardian female when wielding the hammer, in a nod to the way Thor used to transform from Dr Donald Blake into the God of Thunder back in the early days of the character.
Currently, Jane is the Valkyrie in her own series - and there too she transforms physically into an Asgardian form, becoming taller and heavier (and growing her hair out from the I’m-in-remission pixie cut).
The cache of bringing Natalie Portman back to the MCU would be lessened if they had her morph into a different woman when becoming a superhero.
There’s always the possibility that CG imagery and the magic of motion capture could be used to transform Portman in post-production. This would allow her to still play both aspects of the part while changing height, mass and musculature. This isn’t as much of a cop out as it appears: it’s not like Brie Larson glows a fiery yellow through the power of acting alone.
1. Captain Marvel And Black Panther Sequels Are Being Delayed Till At Least 2022
It’s alarming that Marvel Studios claims to understand the importance of representation and diversity; to see how powerful it is to have these hugely successful Captain Marvel and Black Panther properties on their books… and then chose to prioritise literally everything else over their sequels.
Now, Phase 4 is only two years, and it’s almost certain that Phase 5 will feature both a Black Panther sequel and a Captain Marvel sequel… but that’s not good enough.
Assuming that Black Panther 2 arrives early in 2022, that will be a minimum of four years since the first film. How do you have that movie in your back catalogue, have seen the reaction to it… and then put the sequel on the back burner?
Even if you don’t care about representation, Black Panther is the biggest non-Avengers superhero movie of all time. It made more than Avengers: Infinity War in the USA. This is not a difficult decision.
Similarly, the importance of a female character like Captain Marvel to the MCU going forward requires that you prioritise it over less relevant characters. A 2022 sequel would mean three years between movies, and it seems likely that it’ll be later than that.
Now, it’s possible that we’ll see Wakanda before Phase 5. The Vision’s resurrection is likely to be tied to Shuri in some way. However, that’s absolutely not going to cut it. The 2021 slate needs amending to include a Black Panther sequel. Four damned years is too long to wait for something of such cultural relevance.