For many, the Razzies represent an antidote to the Oscars' stuffiness and the self-congratulatory smugness of Oscar-bait movies. But the Razzies is still an awards show, and it ends up suffering from many of the same problems as others, stuck in a rut of favourite genres or actors to pick on, no matter the actual quality of their work. If there's a type of film that's Oscar-bait, there is assuredly also a type that's Razzie-bait. Just as there's a 'good movie' bandwagon that can sweep a film to awards success, so too can a 'bad movie' bandwagon condemn a movie to Razzies on reputation and hearsay alone, regardless of the quality of the movie itself. Heaven's Gate, for example, was condemned as a box office bomb during its troubled production and was 'known' to be a disaster by the time it was nominated for five Razzies in 1982. Since then, however, the film's reputation has been somewhat rehabilitated. Sure, there are some who still think it one of the worst films of its time, but others now think of it as an unappreciated classic. Ultimately, just as the Oscars can make some choices that look pretty bad in hindsight (like virtually any Best Picture winner in the 1980s), there are a number of films picked out by the Razzies as the "worst" that have instead been judged by posterity as among the greats. Films like these.
10. Friday The 13th
Nominated for: Worst Picture, Worst Supporting Actress (Betsy Palmer) - 1980 Essentially a low budget knock-off of definitive slasher classic Halloween, Friday The 13th arrived in cinemas with mostly negative reviews. It was panned as derivative, cheap, exploitative and needlessly gory, and Razzie nominations followed. As time passed, though, not only did genre fans take to the film's cheap, efficient slasher business, but Friday The 13th itself became the film that was getting ripped off. All the lesser teens-at-camp-menaced-by-a-serial-killer movies, including Friday's own sequels, wound up making the first film look pretty good by comparison. In a similar sense, the original Annie musical's five Razzie nominations now seem a little harsh when the recent remake was a far worse film that was only nominated twice. For horror lovers, Friday The 13th is now spoken of as one of the classic examples of its time and type. In 2001, the American Film Institute even nominated it for its 100 Years...100 Thrills list.
9. DodgeBall: A True Underdog Story, And Anchorman: The Legend Of Ron Burgundy
Nominated for: Worst Actor (Ben Stiller) - 2005 When the Razzies take against an actor or a film, they often like to show this with overkill - nominations are showered on the object of their hate regardless of any other factor. In the 2005 awards, a Worst Actor nomination for Ben Stiller was no surprise after the complete disaster of Envy, in which the combined talents of Stiller, Jack Black and Barry Levinson made a film that was universally panned. The only thing was, the Razzie committee decided instead to nominate Stiller for every movie that he'd made in the previous year. These included the admittedly sub-par romcom Along Came Polly; a perfectly enjoyable, if utterly forgettable, buddy comedy remake of Starsky & Hutch; and two bona fide 21st century comedy classics, DodgeBall and Anchorman. Both were met with a slightly muted response on release - there were critics who dismissed DodgeBall and Anchorman as puerile, dumb, and crude, and they are, but that is partly what makes them so funny. That The Wall Street Journal initially refused to review DodgeBall as not worthy of attention, before finally calling it "erratic, imbecilic if not completely idiotic, inconsequential in even the small scheme of things, and thoroughly entertaining", should tell you everything you need to know about changing critical opinion of the film. On Time Out's list of the 100 Best Comedy Films, both movies appear. Anchorman, in which Stiller's role is just a cameo, was declared the 6th funniest movie of all time.
8. The Fifth Element
Nominated for: Worst Supporting Actress (Milla Jovovich), Worst New Star (Chris Tucker) - 1998 Deeply divisive on its release, Luc Besson's ultra-stylised Jean-Paul Gaultier designed sci-fi blockbuster was dismissed by many critics as excessively camp, hard to follow and lacking in substance. In particular, people had trouble warming to gibberish-talking ginger Leelo (model Milla Jovovich), the eponymous fifth element, and loud mouthed, in-your-face talk-show host Ruby Rhod (comedian Chris Tucker). While their far-from-naturalistic performances may still alienate some audiences, the film's lavish, pulpy, comic book stylings have made it a popular cult hit. Arguably it is the perfect vehicle for Jovovich's 'talents'. With a 71% from the critics and an 87% from audiences on Rotten Tomatoes, the film is increasingly well regarded - last year, Time Out voted it the 42nd greatest sci-fi move of all time, just above Total Recall, District 9, and Ghostbusters.
7. Batman Returns
Nominated for: Worst Supporting Actor (Danny DeVito) - 1993 Batman Returns saw Tim Burton, off the back of the success of his first Gotham venture, given absolutely free reign to make the movie that he wanted. What he returned was an even more heightened slice of gothic expressionism and dark grotesquery, and nowhere was this more embodied than in Burton's take on classic umbrella-wielding Batman gang boss The Penguin, here reconfigured as a deformed freak living in a creepy sewer lair. Comic book purists objected to this re-imagining of a favourite character, while audiences looking for a family friendly adventure found Burton and Danny DeVito's Oswald Cobblepot simply too dark and disturbing. While the backlash against the film that may have resulted in The Penguin's Razzie nomination dismissed Batman Returns as being creepy and grotesque, this for many people was the main strength of the film. As subsequent Batman movies swapped gothic for camp, Batman Returns and its Penguin only looked better and better.
6. Bring Your Daughter...To The Slaughter
Won: Worst Original Song (from A Nightmare On Elm Street 5: The Dream Child) - 1990 The increasingly rubbish sequels to horror classic A Nightmare On Elm Street developed a tendency towards heavy rock and metal soundtracks. The Razzies responded to this trend with a stack of Worst Original Song awards and nominees. For ropey fifth installment The Dream Child (it's the one where the series tries to ditch camp and go darker again), the studio asked Iron Maiden's Bruce Dickinson for an original contribution. The song that he wrote, Bring Your Daughter...To The Slaughter may have won the Razzie, but what was recorded by Dickinson's band also became an enduring fan favourite hit. Up against Cliff Richard's maudlin festive single Saviour's Day in the British charts, Bring Your Daughter would become Iron Maiden's only UK number 1. Another song that Bring Your Daughter beat to the Razzie, The Ramones' Pet Sematary, written to accompany the mediocre Stephen King adaptation of the same name, also turned out to be that band's biggest hit of the era.
5. Scarface
Nominated for: Worst Director (Brian De Palma) - 1984 Brian De Palma was nominated for Worst Director at the first ever Razzies in 1981 for Dressed To Kill, again in 1985 for Body Double, in 1991 for Bonfire Of The Vanities, and finally in 2000 for Mission To Mars. He hasn't won one yet, but it's clear that the director's ultra-stylised pastiches of better filmmakers are just the kind of thing to excite the Razzie committee's ire. The thing is that De Palma's films are often exciting, slick and engaging and his grandiose camera movements impressive. Scarface met with negative reviews on release for its excess of violence, of bad language, of massive drug use - basically it's a film of nothing but excess - but as a movie of highly charged excess it works very well and its reputation today reflects that. A favourite of Scorsese and the AFI's 10th greatest gangster film, Scarface's classic status has by now overruled any early critical coldness.
4. The Blair Witch Project
Won: Worst Actress (Heather Donahue) - 2000 Nominated for: Worst Picture - 2000 Deeply divisive at the time (and perhaps still today), The Blair Witch Project is a film featuring amateur acting and in which very little happens. Lead actress Heather Donahue panics, shakes the camera around and films up her snotty nose. Nevertheless, the film was pioneering and original, while its influence on the whole horror genre in the 21st century cannot be overstated. Better found footage films have come since, undoubtedly, but it was Blair Witch that kicked the whole thing off. Given that, it's hard to suggest this ultra low budget breakout film is at all equivalently bad as fellow nominee The Haunting, the worst example of lazy, bad-remake-based, expensive mainstream horror. With an 87% from critics on Rotten Tomatoes and a placing at 12th on the Chicago Film Critics Association's 100 Scariest Movies, Blair Witch's classic status is now pretty established.
3. Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, Dumb & Dumber, And The Mask
Nominated for: Worst New Star (Jim Carrey) - 1995 Arguably the biggest film comedy star of the last 20 years, Jim Carrey burst onto the scene in 1994 with a trio of hit comedies that traded off his manic style and rubber-faced gurning. Of course, this style of performance wasn't for everyone, but it's still a surprise that the Razzies considered him a Worst New Star candidate in 1995 on a level with Anna Nicole Smith. For a Worst New Star candidate, Carrey has done pretty well for himself in the long run. The likes of The Truman Show and Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind might be show off better performances as far as most critics are concerned, but Carrey's trio of breakthrough hits are still viewed as some of the most fondly remembered comedies of their time. More importantly, perhaps, they are also held up as examples of just the kind of film that fans would like Carrey to still be making.
2. The Thing
Nominated for: Worst Musical Score (Ennio Morricone) Widely regarded as one of the greatest film composers of his time, Ennio Morricone had established his reputation on Sergio Leone's spaghetti westerns before moving on to more mainstream Hollywood productions, all the time moving from his budget-enforced experimental roots towards more traditional orchestral scores. When collaborating with John Carpenter on tense alien shapeshifter picture The Thing, though, Morricone worked closely with the director to utilise Carpenter's trademark minimalist electronic sound. Like earlier Carpenter scores for Halloween and Assault On Precinct 13, these simple themes perfectly keep the tension up throughout. The Thing was not highly regarded on release with critics viewing it as fuelled by excessive, disgusting effects rather than character and story - it is now, however, established as one of the greats of its type (the Chicago Film Critics Association had it as the 17th scariest movie of all). Morricone's score was caught up in the early criticism of the film, but, like the rest of it, the music has grown in stature and reputation. That the prequel/remake in 2011 reused and remixed so much of Morricone's score is the perfect demonstration of how central it was to the film's success.
1. The Shining
Nominated for: Worst Director (Stanley Kubrick), Worst Actress (Shelley Duvall) - 1981 Eight of Stanley Kubrick's last nine films got Oscar and Golden Globe nominations. The other, The Shining, got Razzie nods. While there are issues with The Shining (and Shelley Duvall's screechy performance is one of them), and though original author Stephen King is famously not a fan, it's hard to see how a film that has since become so acclaimed could be deemed amongst the worst of its time. A 92% rating from critics on Rotten Tomatoes, declared the Best Horror Film of all time by Channel 4, 29th on the AFI's 100 Years...100 Thrills list, the subject of an entire acclaimed documentary (Room 237) purely devoted to theories trying to interpret it, The Shining is almost universally revered by now. The only explanation for its double Razzie nomination can be the fact that it was the first awards and the nominations were drawn up by Razzie founder John Wilson and friends alone (an argument for the wisdom of larger crowds, perhaps). Which other now-classic movies did the Razzies get it wrong about? Let us know in the comments below.