Viewers and critics alike have demonstrated their out-and-out disappointment with Peter Jacksons The Hobbit trilogy, claiming it to be all pixels and no pulse. But is this onslaught truly warranted? Maybe the trilogy was prematurely condemned under the curse of prequels, or like The Godfather: Part III (1990), perhaps its just misunderstood? It may also be that audiences arrived at the party with their Lord Of The Rings expectations or maybe, just maybe, if you look close enough, The Hobbit is actually every bit as good as, if not better than The Lord Of The Rings Thats right! Tolkien aficionados expected Jackson to achieve the same level of epic grandeur with the bloating of one novel as he achieved with three entirely separate novels - it would be like setting sail in a paper boat and expecting it to stay afloat it just doesnt happen. But dont be so quick to rule him out. With the reduced source material he had, Jackson nonetheless mapped out a sensational trilogy and theres a definitive beauty in that. The Hobbit trilogy suffers at the hands of relentless criticisms, but if cynics cap their hasty comparisons and consider the trilogy on its own merits, then there's actually much to love and admire about The Lord Of The Rings prequel series. Here are ten reasons why you are wrong about The Hobbit trilogy.
Advertisement
10. The Length Is Entirely Necessary
One of the biggest criticisms suffered by The Hobbit films is that they are too long Seriously? What must be going on in audiences lives that an extra thirty minutes in the company of universally popular characters puts them at risk of exploding into a thousand pieces? Furthermore, no one can pretend that they dont already know what theyre getting in terms of runtime when they make that decision to sit through a Peter Jackson/J.R.R Tolkien movie. In fact, would it not have been strange if the instalments were shorter than two hours in length? If they were, you could bet that they would have been criticised for being too short. The Hobbit trilogy presented Peter Jackson with the perfect opportunity to show Middle-earth in a way that The Lord Of The Rings had no time for. That said, lets be thankful for the undernourished novel, though, eh?
9. The Action Is Not Inferior
Another common criticism of The Hobbit is that its action considerably pales in comparison to the action in Rings. However, there are many standout sequences in this trilogy that in fact give testament to Jacksons prowess when it comes to stimulating set pieces. Boiling since An Unexpected Journey, the clash of two titans, Thorin Oakenshield and Azog The Defiler, gives birth to one of the most haunting moments across all three parts and even all six parts, stylishly surpassing Fellowships clash of Aragorn and Lurtz. Thorin out-wits the knucklehead and sends him plunging into the ice covered lake, leaving the beasts limp body to drift beneath the surface. Just when you think Thorin has triumphed, Azog suddenly opens his eyes and pierces his razor sharp extremity through the sheet of ice and through Thorins foot! Now thats action wizardry that even Gandalf would applaud Furthermore, the dwarves brutal yet elegant escape from Mirkwood, as they charge down stream in barrels, coupled with their earlier escape from Goblin Town, offers a stark reminder that fans are back in Middle Earth and firmly couched in Jacksons and Tolkiens sword-slinging spectacular.
8. You Wanted Something Different To Peter Jackson
What Peter Jackson wanted was to replicate what was in the book and what he learned from Tolkiens notes. Through his cinematic trilogy, Jackson sought to communicate an adventure of epic proportions, remaining consistent with his own modus operandi, whilst also communicating a considered account that was loyal to the source material. However, what audiences wanted was an endless stream of action, or more accurately, what they wanted was The Lord Of The Rings. As a result, audiences expectations clouded their judgment of the trilogy. So with that in mind, The Hobbit films were never going to be what fans wanted them to be. In the same way as Ridley Scotts Prometheus (2012) flopped because it wasnt another Alien (1979), its the ill-advised expectations of The Hobbit trilogy that smothered Jacksons new baby before it had even taken its first steps. Its therefore inequitable to criticise the series for not being something that it never had any intentions of being in the first place.
7. Freeman's Bilbo Beats Wood's Frodo Every Time
Martin Freeman is a far better actor than Elijah Wood, period. And not only that, but Bilbo Baggins characterisation is leaps and bounds better than Frodos: Freemans quirky but loveable turn is extraordinarily layered and his relaxed delivery of speech offers a refreshing distinction to the more stagey dialogue in Rings. Throughout the three consecutive films, Bilbo goes through a very natural change and it works; he represents courage and that is a very visible evolution in him. He grows from this nervous wreck into a pillar of strength and its this superior characterisation that makes it easier for audiences to align with Bilbo and to feel immersed in this fantasy world. The many uninspired performances of the sequel series distance audiences from engaging with the heart of the story. However, helped on considerably by Freemans rendition of Bilbo, audiences of The Hobbit are much easier given to the all-important suspension of disbelief.
6. You Didn't Trust The Master Of Middle-Earth
Tolkiens The Hobbit is commonly considered a tome for children, full of English oddity and accessible language, but it forms, also, the essential sprouting of The Lord Of The Rings trilogy. That said, whilst Jackson juggles such complex stories, one would expect a few narrative loose ends across the transition from sequel to prequel. However, the man at the helm drops not one stitch and pays perfect homage to the world. It is upon this superior narrative that Jackson has undeniably been focused for the fifteen years that he has spent bringing Tolkiens literary creation to life. The fact is, and youll be foolish to think otherwise, that having exhausted nearly a third of his life on the project, Jacksons understanding of Tolkien lore can be presumed to exceed that of anybody else and the way he shot The Hobbit trilogy reveals it unmistakably. The sheer scope of Middle-earth is expertly realised and Jacksons all-encompassing knowledge means that he is able to focus on the individual world of each of the characters, capturing the micro detail of their personalities, whilst also constructing the overall world of the film in order to achieve the illusion of a self-contained fantasy realm.
5. The Hobbit Is A Victim Of Its Time
The Lord Of The Rings is a pronounced series largely because of its time. Audiences feel a greater attraction to the original movies because nothing so epic had been done previously. So when you criticise The Hobbit trilogy, youre essentially punishing the films for arriving at a time when movies of such an ambitious scale are now considered the norm And thats just outright absurd. Is it Hobbits fault then that movies like The Avengers and Avatar, in all their visual glory, have desensitised audiences to cinematic spectacles of such lavish scope? No. In fact, Hobbit deserves additional praise for meeting, upholding and in some cases even surpassing that standard. So in the eyes of the common filmgoer, it of course falls flat. But what people dont realise is the ways in which the trilogy has initiated cinematic innovation. Having pioneer Peter Jackson at the helm meant that audiences were treated to cutting-edge visual effects and a choice of three technical versions: 2D, 3D and High Frame Rate 3D. Although HFR provoked fury amongst critics and cinephiles, as they felt that the new format outputted something that appeared starkly uncinematic, it has to be said that the problem isnt with the technology but with the audience. Given that cinema history has largely been written in 24fps, its no wonder that cinemagoers are likely to feel certain ire at first. However, perhaps opinions of the trilogy might have been different if audiences were already acclimatised to 48fps. The trilogy presented itself in HFR and like Rings nothing so epic has been before. Whether you like it or not, you have to admire Jacksons chutzpah for pushing the boundaries of cinema yet again.
4. The Series Expanded Middle-Earth
If nothing else, The Hobbit trilogy stands as another opportunity to see favourite Tolkien characters in action, both in 3D and in High Frame Rate. In doing so, The Hobbit films not only continued the saga but also gave a new lease of life to The Lord Of The Rings movies, as they renew their stance in popular culture and their shelf life in HMV. So ask yourself something: how bad could it be after all? Not only is it an opportunity to see the same, much admired characters, but fans are also joining them in a profound journey, as they set out to overthrow Smaug and recoup their rightful home. There is a compelling narrative at the heart of The Hobbit trilogy that takes the audience on a ride like no other and that mustnt be taken for granted. Across all three parts, the story has followed this family there and back again and theres an infectious humanity here that pulls you in close. That right there is what makes this trilogy every bit as good as Rings, if not better.
3. You Don't Know The Book
Criticisms come from being unfamiliar with the source material. Those who are versed in the literary counterpart will realise that Peter Jacksons filmic interpretation delivers the true nature of the book, and therein lies its ultimate value. Imagine the outrage of literary fans if what Jacksons trilogy had showcased wasnt what was promised in the novel. Many people protested about not only the length, but the inclusion of the supper scene in the trilogys first installment. However, as one of the weightiest scenes of the novel, spanning several pages and showing-off Tolkiens poetical prowess with Misty Mountains Cold, Journeys sequence was in fact not long enough.Jackson has successfully conveyed the tone and the atmosphere that is anchored within Tolkiens writings and the bottom line is, fans of The Hobbit get The Hobbit. On a similar note, fans of The Lord Of The Rings still get The Hobbit See how it works?
2. This Is Not Rings And You Just Don't Know How To Handle That
Although it is recognised that The Hobbit and The Lord Of The Rings take shape in the same fictional universe and thus, they are bounded to each other, to directly compare the two on an all-encompassing level is simply outrageous. Rings is about saving the world. It is serious and everything depended on these nine characters. The Hobbit is different. Its really just an adventure. It doesnt touch anybody except those connected to Erebor. The Hobbit is much easier; it is about the dwarves and only the dwarves. Whereas Rings starts off as a very murky adventure and grows into an epic war movie, The Hobbit is a homegrown fantasy adventure and is detached from Rings in that fact. Refrain from viewing The Hobbit as an extension of Rings and instead see it as a self-contained film series. The fact that storylines and characters collide should be considered little more than a coincidence.
1. The Hobbit Succeeded In Ways Rings Didn't
Although The Hobbit trilogy reached new levels of cinematic splendor and succeeded in visualising Middle-earth on a scale that is far beyond the reach of Rings, it would be unjust to set the movies visual effects against its much older sequel. But hold on a minute, The Hobbit actually puts right a catalogue of other elements that Rings gets wrong. An important thing to take note of here is that Peter Jackson listened to the fans. He heard the feedback from Rings and implemented it here, most notably not cutting as much content. The insincerity of Rings characterisation was stifling, but The Hobbit succeeded in rectifying these one-dimensional performances. Richard Armitages Thorin and Martin Freemans Bilbo for example represent a break from the plasticity of performance that held back the original trilogy and marks a development in characterisation, each rendered with both inner and outer conflicts. In addition, The Hobbit series also succeeded in ousting the unnecessary melodrama that Rings bathed in. These are just a handful of ways in which The Hobbit bettered and outclassed its much older and falsely better-revered companion. What do you make of The Hobbit trilogy? Are they underrated or do you think theyre a detriment to Middle-earth? Join the discussion down in the comments below.