10 Film Sequels And Spin-Offs That Should Never Have Happened

Bigger, longer, faster - and not as good.

By Ian Watson /

Universal Pictures

The law of diminishing returns dictates that when Hollywood seizes on a sleeper hit and begins cranking out sequels, prequels and spin-offs, the desire to make money will suck all the life out of the material and produce a film of inferior quality.

Advertisement

Released in 2004, James Wan€™s Saw was a movie for the head, a well thought-out psycho-thriller that didn€™t skimp on character. By the time of Saw 3D, the series had become a parody of its former self, resorting to violence so cartoonish and overdone that it was impossible to take seriously.

Memo to aspiring filmmakers: when you open a movie with 2 alpha males being forced into combat by a tricycle-riding puppet, you€™ve abandoned the source material and lurched into high camp. Sure you can recycle shtick from earlier installments, but as another victim faces another round of torture porn, we€™re reminded that we€™ve seen it all before and simply raising the volume doesn€™t change that.

Advertisement

In a perfect world, every franchise would be The Fast And The Furious, becoming steadily bigger and better until audiences get the scene they€™ve always wanted €“ Dwayne Johnson leaving his hospital bed so he can destroy a city block with a gun bigger than Ol€™ Painless.

Until then, here are 10 movies that followed Saw 3D into Bad Movie Hell.

Advertisement

10. The Lost World: Jurassic Park

Universal

Steven Spielberg€™s first movie since winning Best Director for Schindler€™s List, The Lost World takes place on €œSite B€, another island that just happens to be home to a menagerie of dinosaurs. Faster than you can say €œplot contrivance€, there€™s several potential victims poking around the place.

Advertisement

You see, Jeff Goldblum has a hitherto-unmentioned girlfriend (Julianne Moore) who€™s already there, so when Jeff decides to rescue her, his hitherto-unmentioned daughter decides to stow away. Because what€™s a Jurassic Park movie without a kid being placed in peril?

The rest of the film is a succession of dinosaur attacks, and its €œart€ lies in its contrivances. In order to keep the movie from stalling, screenwriter David Koepp (Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull) throws in all manner of nonsense, including a scene where Goldblum€™s daughter saves him from a dino by performing gymnastics and a moment where the creepy foreign (Peter Stormare €“ who else?) wanders off on his own to his doom.

Advertisement

Clearly saving the best for last, Koepp tosses in a homage to King King in the film€™s final act as a dinosaur runs amok through San Diego, knocking down walls and drinking from swimming pools €“ all without waking up the neighbourhood.

9. Terminator Genisys

Paramount Pictures

By this point in the Terminator franchise, each new installment was attempting to address what everyone hated about the previous sequel, so Genisys makes a deliberate attempt to eschew Salvation€™s po-faced seriousness and lack of time travel paradoxes. Unfortunately, it overcompensates with an attitude that verges on camp and a checklist of scenes recycled from its predecessors. Kyle Reese arriving in 1984? Check. A T-1000 disguised as a cop? Check.

Advertisement

With a timeline so muddy that characters appear to be referencing events that haven€™t happened yet (or have they?), sequel #4 is in such a hurry to prolong the franchise that it lets nothing €“ not the exposition, the clunky humour or the characters who keep explaining their motivation to each other €“ stand in its way.

Weirdest of all (discuss) is how Sarah Connor and Kyle Reese have in this timeline become wisecracking parodies of their former selves, joking with each other that if they never get it on, then the world will be doomed. If you were making an Airplane! type spoof of Cameron€™s original, that€™s exactly the kind of material you€™d use.

Advertisement

8. Halloween: The Curse Of Michael Myers

Dimension Films

Michael Myers no longer resembles John Carpenter€™s creation: having been stabbed, blinded, blown up, run down and hit by 500 rounds of ammunition, he€™s now a comic book super villain with an adamantium skeleton and a unique healing ability €“ Wolverine in a Halloween mask.

Advertisement

Fortunately, The Curse Of Michael Myers has a plausible explanation for this. All along, Mikey was being manipulated by a group of druids who contacted him using a constellation of stars that only appears on Halloween. The constellation is in the shape of a thorn, so the symbol is tattooed on the wrist of every member, including Myers, something every previous and future movie forgets to mention.

Just so we€™re clear, though, these are not the druids of Iron Age Britain but Hollywood Bullsh*t Druids who live in an ultra-secret underground bunker (accessible through an unlocked and unguarded door marked €˜Maximum Security€™), dress like Emperor Palpatine and talk in the solemn manner of low-rent movie villains. By sending Myers to kill teenagers every October 31st, they intend to associate Halloween in everyone€™s mind with a horrific event.

Advertisement

Which they do.

7. Blade: Trinity

New Line Cinema

David S Goyer is a screenwriting legend whose credits (Batman Begins, Dark City) speak for themselves, but every so often his reach will extend his grasp and he'll churn out a movie like Blade: Trinity.

Advertisement

In case you don't remember, this is the one where Dracula is discovered in Iraq and, because it seemed like a good idea at the time, played by Prison Break's Dominic Purcell. Blade gets two new sidekicks in the form of Jessica Biel and Ryan Reynolds but, disappointingly for the writer who brought Batman and Superman into the Twenty-first century, Goyer makes little attempt made to extend the Blade universe. The behind the scenes stories, however, are fascinating.

According to Patton Oswalt, who plays tech guy Hedges, relations between Goyer and Wesley Snipes were so strained that the star attempted to strangle him on set, prompting the filmmaker to hire a biker gang he€™d met in a strip club as bodyguards. Director and star communicated through post-it notes for the rest of the shoot (Wesley signed his €œfrom Blade€), with a stand-in fulfilling the actor€™s duties while Snipes smoked weed in his trailer.

Advertisement

6. A Good Day To Die Hard

20th Century Fox

Rumours persist that Twentieth Century Fox released a sequel that called itself a Die Hard movie and thought it was a Die Hard movie but caused everyone who saw it to call bullsh*t because it didn€™t feel like a Die Hard movie. Such rumours remain unsubstantiated because those viewers have retreated into a state of denial.

Advertisement

Playing more like a very poor man€™s 24 movie than a Die Hard picture, sequel #4 is a ginger-haired stepchild that deserves to be beaten at every available opportunity. There isn€™t a single memorable moment in the entire film, and nothing in Skip Woods€™s screenplay suggests he did anything more than dust off an unproduced script, change the names and ask the studio, €œWill this do?€

You€™re off to a bad start when a character who hates flying has no problem taking a plane to Russia on a moment€™s notice, but why stop there? Randomly throw in an unexciting chase sequence, add a few flat and unremarkable villains, sprinkle with crap one-liners and €“ presto! €“ you€™ve made a worse movie than Under Siege 2: Dark Territory.

Advertisement

5. I Spit On Your Grave 3: Vengeance Is Mine

Anchor Bay Films

According to I Spit On Your Grave 3 €“ or should that be Thrice Spit On Your Grave? €“ all men are monosyllabic slobs capable only of demeaning women, who in turn are €œempowered€ by killing them. There are constant references to abuse that while intended to give the narrative €œdepth€, just become repetitive and give no real insight.

Advertisement

When a friend from her support group is raped and murdered by an ex-boyfriend and the police are unable to help, Jennifer Hill (Sarah Butler) goes all Charles Bronson and tracks down the guy responsible. Like all the men in this movie, you can tell he€™s a vicious sexual predator just by looking at him, so when Jennifer confronts him in a dark alley and he attempts to assault her, she bites his dick off with the zinger, €œJust the tip, Sweetie!€

There€™s more: when a colleague tearfully suggests that a man who€™s been abusing his stepdaughter should be punished by having a metal pipe rammed where the daisies don€™t grow, Jennifer takes him at his word and visits the stepdad.while carrying a sledgehammer and a length of pipe.

Advertisement

Come back, Michael Winner, all is forgiven.

4. One Missed Call: Final

Kadokawa Pictures

This is the second Japanese sequel to One Missed Call, Takashi Miike€™s Ringu rip-off, but don€™t be fooled: it has all the idiot victims, cheesy effects and stupid plotting of American multiplex fodder.

Advertisement

When teenage monkey wrench Asuka commits suicide, her classmates celebrate in time-honoured fashion with a school field trip to Korea, where they€™re picked off one after the other using this franchise€™s modus operandi: they receive a call from their future selves, then die at the date and time of the call. And they don€™t go quietly: one girl is dragged along by a motorcycle, a guy is attacked by electric cables (don€™t ask), a body is found inside an industrial dryer etc.

As a keen student of Ringu knock-offs, you€™ll know that the heroes in these films usually solve the €˜mystery€™ by finding the ghost€™s mortal remains and burying them, but this movie ain€™t having none of that. If you want to defeat Asuka, send her an e-mail. Get your friends and your friends€™ friends to send her an e-mail. If she receives over forty thousand in two minutes, this will of course cause her computer to explode, thus trapping her in limbo for all eternity.

Advertisement

3. Superman Returns

Warner Bros.

In Superman Returns, Lex Luthor€™s diabolical masterplan rests on his ability to distract Superman long enough for him and his henchmen to enter the Metropolis Museum Of Natural History, steal a chunk of Kryptonite and make a clean getaway - which he does in about 5 minutes. His method of distraction? Fixing the brakes on Parker Posey€™s car so that she careers out of control.

Advertisement

Now wait a minute: the title of this movie is Superman Returns, not Easily Distracted Man Fumbles The Ball And Almost Allows Metropolis To Be Destroyed As A Result. If the only thing on earth that can destroy you is being displayed in the local museum, and your old nemesis is on the prowl, would that not cause you to connect the dots? Would you not demand tightened security at the museum, just in case? You€™re Superman, you can do that sort of thing.

Instead, Easily Distracted Man is so slow on the uptake that he just bides his time while Luthor kidnaps Lois Lane and €“ get this €“ uses the Kryptonite to grow a new continental landmass in the ocean. Instead of concluding that landing on Kryptonite Island might be injurious to his health and sending in the Marines, this would-be superhero flies to the rescue.and seems surprised when he loses his powers.

Advertisement

2. Van Helsing

Universal Pictures

When The Mummy Returns made $430 million worldwide, Universal asked director Stephen Sommers to create another franchise based on their classic monster movies €“ which he€™d clearly never seen. Sommers€™ Mummy films owe more to Indiana Jones than Boris Karloff (or even Lon Chaney Jr in bandages), but with Van Helsing, he turns the monsters into comic book villains.

Advertisement

Seen briefly early on, Mr Hyde is the same ridiculous Hulk-like character we saw in The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen, while Dracula and Frankenstein€™s monster have become so nonthreatening that they may as well be advertising breakfast cereal. Then there€™s Van Helsing himself, who in this version becomes a monster hunter employed by the Vatican. He gets corny one-liners and a ton of gadgets, so Hugh Jackman plays him like a suave secret agent, not a bad idea when he€™s acting against Kate Beckinsale€™s glorified Bond girl.

Sommers is a director from the Michael Bay school of filmmaking who thinks that more is more and you can never have too much of .well, everything. The film quickly becomes interminable as Sommers piles one noisy, repetitive action sequence on top of another and, for bad measure, gives the material a camp attitude.

Advertisement

When Dracula gets a comic relief sidekick, you know you€™re watching a movie on the level of Scooby Doo Where are You?

1. Catwoman

Warner Bros.

A movie without a single good idea in its 104 minutes, Catwomangets off to a bad start by €œreimagining€ the lead character as Patience Phillips (Halle Berry), a clumsy graphic designer who makes ads for Beau-Line, a beauty cream that (in theory) reverses the aging process.

Advertisement

In practice, it causes headaches, nausea and disfigurement, and when Halle discovers this, she€™s left for dead by Sharon Stone, who practically has Evil Villain written on her forehead. We€™ve barely reached the 20 minute mark and the film€™s biggest problem is already apparent: a heroine nothing like her comic book counterpart will spend the rest of the movie trying to save America from a skin care product.

You see, Stone knows all about the cream€™s side effects and, having presumably paid off the Food and Drug Administration, plans to launch it anyway, which will.give a lot of people headaches. And a bit of a rash. In order to stop this, Berry gets a superhero costume that covers her face but leaves her midriff exposed, which is enough to shield her identity from everyone, including Stone.

Advertisement

To think Roger Ebert hated this movie.