You know you messed up big time when you have to apologise to audiences for a film you directed. That's exactly what Joel Schumacher ended up doing for Batman & Robin, however, and it's something that the majority of viewers probably thought was a long time coming. To this day there are still outraged fanboys to be found, on social networks and comment sections across the web, accusing him of killing the Dark Knight. Y'know, until Christopher Nolan came back and saved his life (and ours). Batman & Robin did wind up being the least successful of Warner Bros's initial attempt to bring the Caped Crusader to the big screen, but Batman Forever had managed to almost double the gross of Tim Burton's darker, more brooding Batman Returns. When Schumacher came on board he threw out the gothic atmosphere Burton loves and went full camp even more so with his second film, which saw gaudy colours all over the place, visible nipples on all of the heroes' costumes and George Clooney as Bruce Wayne admitting that he played the character gay. The Nolanverse swept all that away in a sea of serious faces and earthy browns, but things could have been very different. Just as a third film by Burton would've changed things immeasurably, so too might've a trilogy by Schumacher. The villains were in place, so was the cast, and it's closer to Nolan than you think...here are ten things you need to know about Batman Triumphant.
10. The Whole Cast Would've Come Back
At least, that was the assumption, based on preproduction work by Joel Schumacher before Batman & Robin came out and spoiled his chances. The Batman Triumphant script by Mark Protosevich (who you might remember from I Am Legend, Thor, and the unnecessary Spike Lee Oldboy remake) brought back all the usual faces. So, Chris O'Donnell was set to reprise his role of Robin for a third time, with Clooney apparently in line to don the cowl once more. Alicia Silverstone was in the mix again as Batgirl, in this case the inquisitive niece of Alfred (who would be Michael Gough again, one of the few carry overs from the Burton films). The over carry over was Pat Hingle as Comissioner Gordon, a piece of inspired casting that none of the Batman films neither Burton's nor Schumacher's did enough with. Despite apparently wanting to take a different tone with Batman Triumphant, all the usual suspects were on board.
9. The Scarecrow Would Have Been The Villain...
Having dealt with Jim Carrey's Riddler and Tommy Lee Jones's Two-Face in Batman Forever, before squaring off with Arnold Schwarzenegger's pun-happy Mr Freeze and Uma Thurman's wilting Poison Ivy in Batman & Robin (the less said about the none-less-Tom-Hardy Bane in that film, the better), Batman Triumphant would've seen the Caped Crusader coming up against a whole other set of villains. In this case The Scarecrow was in the frame as the principal anatgonist. Jonathan Crane wound up being the main villain of Christopher Nolan's Batman Begins years later, albeit in a much different form, in that case played by Cillian Murphy. This Crane was mostly the same: a psychologist who goes a bit nutty himself, and blights Gotham with his fear toxin which causes people to hallucinate their worst nightmares. Murphy wasn't the name he is now, though, and so Warner Bros were considering a trio of four actors to fill the role of The Scarecrow. So, Batman Triumphant could've seen George Clooney's hero facing off with a villain played by either Nicolas Cage, Steve Buscemi, Ewan McGregor or Jeff Goldblum. All of which would've been interesting, in their own ways...
8. ...With Madonna Playing Harley Quinn
As had seemingly become di riguer since The Penguin and Catwoman tore up Gotham in Batman Returns, Triumphant would've seen the heroes coming up against not one but two enemies. Deciding to go with something a little less well known (back then, anyway), Protosevich's script had Harley Quinn in a supporting role. Whilst The Scarecrow hewed pretty close to his comic book incarnation, this Harley Quin would've varied a lot from the source material. There she's Joker's long-suffering girlfriend, his former psychologist at Arkham who falls madly in love with him (and madly insane along with it). In Batman Triumphant she would've been The Joker's daughter, seeking revenge on Batman for killing her dad. If you think that change (and explicitly linking the Schumacher and Burton films for the first time) are weird, then the news that they hoped Madonna might play the character will blow your mind, no?
7. Mad Hatter Might Have Been Involved As Well
Either a sign of what a mess Batman Triumphant was, or else how little they'd gotten into preproduction, was the amount of villains they were considering. Either they hadn't really quite settled on The Scarecrow and Harley Quinn, or else they were gonna have a Spider-Man 3-style too many bad guys spoil the broth situation. Because besides those two principal antagonists for a little while it seemed like there were some more villains in the mix as well. Apparently comedian Martin Short was mooted for the part of Mad Hatter, with Warner Bros presumably hoping to strike gold a second time after casting comedian Jim Carrey as a madcap, manic Riddler in Batman Forever. Given the downturn in the former Saturday Night Live performer's career in recent years perhaps Batman Triumphant would've been a god send. Or possibly not, since the Mad Hatter is an Alice In Wonderland-obsessed criminal who likes kidnapping little girls. Why don't more colourful superhero films involved paedophilia eh?
6. Ditto For Man-Bat
Yet another bad guy they were considering for Batman Triumphant took things in an even more radical direction than The Scarecrow, Harley, or even the Hatter. Things had already moved away from the grounded pretty quickly with Danny de Vito's Penguin in Batman Returns and the big blue Mr Freeze in Batman & Robin, but introducing Dr Kirk Langstrom would've been a whole different ball game. A sort of Jekyll And Hyde-style anti-hero, Man-Bat is kind of exactly what he sounds like. Batman is a human who dresses as a bat; Man-Bat is what happens when Langstrom knocks back an experimental cocktail of chemicals that transforms him into a half-human, half-bat, with fur and wings and a piercing shriek and all. Usually he's an out-of-control menace like the Hulk rather than openly evil. So if Man-Bat did appear in Batman Triumphant it would've probably not have been as the main villain. The rumours at the time had Mark Linn-Baker down as the first choice to play Man-Bat, possibly because he too had a hyphen in his name. Seriously, he's apparently famous for a sitcom called Perfect Strangers. What even is that.
5. Warner Bros Nearly Took It In A Whole New Direction
Of course, Batman Triumphant wasn't the only iron Warner Bros had in the fire back then. Once Batman & Robin turned out to be quite such the colossal disaster it was, both critically and commercially, they decided they were going to take things in a completely different direction to Schumacher's films, both tonally and setting-wise. One of the precursors to Christopher Nolan's grittier, more realistic take on the Batman mythos with his Dark Knight trilogy was an adaptation of Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli's iconic Year One storyline, parts of which did end up being used in Batman Begins. For a moment it even looked like Darren Aronofsky might direct it. The other side of the coin was a totally different story. Where a Year One film would've grounded the Caped Crusader more than Schumacher's more theatrical characterisation, set and costume design ever did, they were also considering turning the Batman Beyond cartoon where a teen living in a Blade Runner-esque future inherits a super Bat suit from elderly Bruce Wayne into a live action feature.
4. They Wanted Jack Nicholson For A Joker Cameo
Besides some similar cast members and the occasional off-handed remark there isn't much sign of connective tissue between Tim Burton's first two Batman films and the two that Joel Schumacher directed after taking over. Despite the wildly differing tones and Michael Keaton swapped for Val Kilmer and George Clooney, though, they're meant to be set in the same universe. A universe where Gotham City goes from decidedly gothic and Art Deco to a gaudy, paint-splattered nightclub interior gone epic, but the same universe nonetheless. Batman Triumphant would've highlighted that further by confirming that the first Batman film where the Dark Knight knocked off Jack Nicholson's Joker happened to this guy who looks like him off of ER. Not only was there the plot line about Harley Quinn as his daughter, but the producers hoped to convince Nicholson back as The Joker, in a cameo role not resurrected, but a hallucination of Batman's brought on by The Scarecrow's fear toxin.
3. George Clooney Nixed The Whole Thing
Speaking of that guy from ER, it's almost certainly George Clooney's lack of interest in another Batman film that was the final nail in the coffin for Triumphant. Besides the scathing reviews and poor box office returns for Batman & Robin, that is. The superstar Hollywood actor has since remained in good humour about his part as Bruce Wayne, but has never been in any doubt as to the film's quality. When questioned about Ben Affleck's casting in the part of the Dark Knight for the upcoming Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice, Clooney responded "I am the least qualified person to comment on anyone playing the role of Batman since I so terribly destroyed the part. Yep, he's under no allusions as to what Batman & Robin did. Presumably that's not something that's been benefited by hindsight. At the time he was almost certainly offered silly money to reprise his role as Batman, but chose instead to maintain some integrity after that absolute turkey and walk away. Apparently losing their leading man was enough to bring Batman Triumphant crashing down.
2. Parts Of The Script Were Used For Batman Begins
One of the most interesting things about Joel Schumacher's tenure on the Batman films is quite how much its legacy is felt amongst Christopher Nolan's take on the Dark Knight. The camp, brightly-coloured, tongue-in-cheek portrayal (and the failure of such) is what caused Warner Bros to take the franchise in a different direction, but that's not all. Schumacher, Clooney, and apparently everyone else involved with Batman & Robin is aware of what an awful mess they were a part of. To Schumacher's credit, he did want to try something different with Batman Triumphant. That's why the larger-than-life villains were replaced by the grotesque Mad Hatter and Man-Bat. That's why the all-too-literal Poison Ivy and Mr Freeze were swapped out for the psychological horror of The Scarecrow. Who ended up being the main villain of Batman Begins years later, putting paid to the rumours that parts of the abandoned Triumphant script were salvaged by Nolan.
1. Schumacher Was Atoning For His Sins (And Still Might)
So yes, apparently Batman Triumphant was a concerted effort on Schumacher's part for disappointing fans of the Tim Burton films by paring back all the OTT camp stuff and focusing on the dark, brooding character the Caped Crusader really is (when he's not being played by Adam West, anyway). Looking back he said he felt he "owe the Batman culture a real Batman movie. I would go back to the basics and make a dark portrayal of the Dark Knight." So yeah, Batman Triumphant would essentially have been Batman Begins, only with Schumacher and Clooney instead of Nolan and Bale. Who knows how that might've turned out? Probably still not great, but better than Batman & Robin, you'd hope. Fans might even get a chance to see what it'd have been like at some point. Last year there was some scuttlebutt that Schumacher was getting the chance to turn the unproduced Triumphant script into a comic book, to be illustrated by industry hot shot Dustin Nguyen. Both Schumacher and Nguyen have pleaded ignorance to any such project, but the rumours persist. Maybe there's still life in the project after all. Maybe Batman Triumphant finally will be...well, triumphant?