10 Times “Good” Characters Gave Being Evil A Try
Not every good guy stays good all the time. Occasionally, heroes give being evil a try...
“You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.”
Harvey Dent nailed it there: heroes and vigilantes may start out with good intentions, but they don't always stay on the path. The line certainly works for a character like Batman who skirts the law with everything he does, but what about other characters normally considered to be on the side of good?
Not everyone dresses in black and beats up bad guys in the name of what's right; many heroes stand tall and proudly defend the innocent from evil. As time goes on, heroes struggle with loss, pain, and being blamed for collateral damage among other things that take their toll. It can be tough being good when being bad is so much easier and there have been quite a few good guys who decided to dip their toes into the pool of evil.
These forays into the dark side of things generally last only a brief time, but for some, it could be the struggle that finally brings about their downfall. Whatever their reasons, even if they are completely beyond a person’s control, the good guys don’t always stay good.
10. Theon Greyjoy
When it comes to someone like Theon Greyjoy, people either hate him or love that they hate him and it has everything to do with what this guy did. Sure, he was taken hostage as a kid by the Starks, but they treated him like one of their own children. He grew up alongside his “siblings” and even helped wage war in the name of the North… until he flipped the script and betrayed everyone around him.
Possessed by some strange loyalty to his horrid father, Theon captured Winterfell and fake-executed his two little brothers. Granted, he didn't kill his adoptive kin and instead slaughtered a couple of innocent farmboys, but that is only slightly less evil.
Just when it's starting to look like Theon won't reform, he's captured by Ramsay Bolton, who is arguably the most sadistic fiend in all of literature. He picks up the name "Meek," loses the family jewels, and learns the error of his ways via a strict regimen of torture and mental abuse.
Theon eventually redeems himself by helping Sansa escape Bolton, but his foray into evil was pretty costly and horrific, which just goes to show you shouldn't betray your adoptive family for your real one if you're a main character on Game of Thrones.
9. Bucky Barnes
Bucky Barnes began as the little kid sidekick to Captain America during World War II, a time when it seemed appropriate to team a superhero with a child for some reason.
Following the war, Bucky remained dead as far as anyone knew, but was actually picked up and taken to Moscow by the Soviets. He woke up with amnesia so the Soviet scientists hooked him up with a bionic arm, trained him as the Winter Soldier, and sent him on his way.
He was programmed as an assassin for the Soviet Union and went about executing whoever he was told to kill. In the MCU, he tracked down and killed Tony Stark's parents, which is something Tony was somewhat upset about. Granted, he didn’t know who he was and he was operating under the orders of his benefactors, but evil is as evil does and all that.
Eventually, Barnes meets up with Captain America, which helps to jog his memory. Once he realized who he was and what he had done, the regret nearly kills him so he takes off for a while. Eventually, he comes around and fights the good fight, but Bucky never forgave himself for his actions as the Winter Soldier.
8. Walter White
If there’s one thing Breaking Bad taught the world, it’s that a good guy can go bad and make it work. When the series began, Walter White was a meek guy who taught high school chemistry. When he learns he has late-stage lung cancer, he decides to do something about it so his family will be taken care of when he is out of the picture... rather nice, isn't it?
Unfortunately, he doesn't head to the supermarket to buy a bunch of scratchers like most people and instead, he decides to try cooking meth seeing as he has the knowledge and wherewithal to do it better than anyone else around.
White starts calling himself "Heisenberg" and his character transition gets dark fast. Murder, robbery, and general mayhem follow his chaotic fall from grace as his true nature reveals him to be an evil man who will do anything to achieve his goals... unfortunately, those goals shift as he becomes criminally successful.
The entire series run of Breaking Bad is about White's transition from a run-of-the-mill good guy into a truly evil one. By the end of the series, he not only failed to redeem himself, he made no effort to do so.
7. Ozymandias
Ozymandias started out as a superhero who used his incredible intellect to fight crimes alongside his fellow heroes. When the public turned against the superhero community, he turned his intellect to more lucrative matters and built a corporate empire.
In Watchmen’s alternate timeline, the Cold War never ended and continued to ramp up in intensity. Believing the world to be on an inevitable road to nuclear annihilation, Veidt hatched a plan to create an external threat the globe could rally against. Step one in his plan to bring about world peace: brutally murder his old teammate, the Comedian.
One could argue that Veidt's fall into darkness began with his murder of the Comedian, but this was only a single step in a well-established plan he knew would result in the death of millions. Veidt knew he had to kill the Comedian so he felt the death was justified for the "greater good" of world peace... and he may have been right.
When his plan was revealed, he convinced most of his former teammates to go along with it. Ozymandius' actions were evil, but they were done to ensure a positive result, which is why he never felt his actions were wrong.
6. Hal Jordan
Hal Jordan was the Green Lantern of Earth until he turned to evil. For his entire career, Jordan was a good guy. He flew for the U.S. Air Force and found a Green Lantern Ring while trying to save an alien. With the ring, he became the Green Lantern, a member of the Green Lantern Corps who fought to protect the universe from evil, so after decades of comics, DC decided to make him about as evil as possible.
After his hometown is wiped off the face of the planet, a despondent Jordan recreated it and everyone within using his ring. The Guardians of the Universe didn’t approve of this sort of morbid reminiscing and ordered him to stop. Let’s just say, he didn’t take it well.
He flew off into space and crossed the line into evil when he killed a Green Lantern… then another and another until he possessed more rings than anyone. He arrived on OA and slaughtered all but one of the Guardians and destroyed the Central Battery renaming himself Parallax, which is the entity corrupting his actions (he didn't know that at the time).
From that point forward, he was a bad guy, but DC eventually brought him back a few years later and returned him to the Corps.
5. Buddy Pine
Buddy Pine is the perfect example of why kids need to have responsible adults watching out for them. When he was a little boy, Buddy was obsessed with Mr. Incredible, but instead of bugging him for autographs and selfies, he tried to be his sidekick... forcefully.
He wanted to be a good guy, which was probably something Mr. Incredible should have taken into account seeing as Buddy invented all manner of gadgets. Instead of using those gadgets and helping Buddy navigate the dangerous waters of adolescence so he could grow up to become a superhero, he pushed him away.
What could Buddy do, but rebrand himself as the supervillain Syndrome and launch a calculated plot of revenge against his former idol?
He built a criminal empire and even fashioned a headquarters within an active volcano… as one does when they turn to villainy. When his plan is launched, he kills former heroes, kidnaps children, and threatens to destroy a city. Buddy never returned to the cute, hero-worshiping boy we met at the beginning of the film - his transition into evil was irreversible and he ended up dying while trying to kidnap an infant, which, let's face it, that's truly evil.
4. Jason Todd
You know you're not dealing with the best character in the world when a fan vote results in their brutal torture and death at the hands of the Joker. That's exactly what happened to Jason Todd, Batman's second Robin, when DC decided to ask its readers via a telephone poll if the Boy Wonder should survive the Batman: A Death In the Family storyline. He lost by 72 votes.
In the story, the Joker captures Robin and brutally murdered him, which is not something that Batman took well—the death shapes Batman's character and actions for years.
Like most comic book characters, Todd refused to die and after an impressive 17-year span in the coffin, he was resurrected thanks to some time-rippling events. Todd takes a quick dip in the Lazarus Pit and regains his memories, but he loses his mind and blames the Dark Knight for his premature demise, which sets him on a path of evil to get revenge against his former guardian.
Todd picks up the Red Hood moniker and becomes a lethal assassin—completely abandoning Batman's "no killing" policy. This lands him on the Bat's bad side and he becomes a villian, but eventually crosses back over into anti-hero territory.
3. Saruman
When we first meet Saruman, he's dressed all in white and stands as the paragon of virtue and all that is good in the world. As one of the Istari, he was sent to Middle Earth to guard it from evil, but must not have gotten the memo because he turns out to be about as evil as you can get in a Tolkien book. After coming to the conclusion that Sauron's plot to take over all of Middle Earth is impossible to stop, he joins forces with him.
Determined to put the idiom, “if you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em” to work, Saruman turns on everyone who trusted him and sets out to create an army in the most destructive way possible.
He lays waste to Fangorn forest, which is something you should never do when there are giant tree monsters lurking about. He uses the land to breed a new form of deadly orc and begins to lay siege upon Middle Earth.
He is finally defeated when the forest fights back and is imprisoned atop his own tower. He never comes back from his foray into evil and is eventually dispatched after an underling of his, Grima, slits his throat.
2. Superman
Superman is a being of pure good and you would never expect him to turn to evil, but that’s exactly what happened in the Injustice: Gods Among Us video game franchise and comic books. After the Joker destroyed Metropolis, killing Lois Lane, Superman snaps. He thrusts his hand through the clown’s chest killing him, which leaves everyone around him shocked and instantly afraid.
At this point, Superman lost his only tie to humanity, which forced him to conclude that the old way of doing things was no longer working so he became a tyrannical world leader. Superman’s New World Order offends just about every one of his former allies who banded against him in an effort to thwart his newfound evil ways.
Superman’s reign lead to the deaths of countless heroes he formerly stood beside. It was a stark contrast to the Superman we all knew and loved and answered the question, "what would happen if Superman decided one day to become evil?"
As the most powerful character in the DC Universe, he was nearly unstoppable, but was finally removed from power when Batman snagged a still-good Superman from an alternate universe to battle his villainous alter-ego.
1. Anakin Skywalker
Anakin Skywalker stands as the utmost example of a character’s fall from grace. Thanks to George Lucas' starting his magnum opus in the middle, we first met him as Darth Vader, but Anakin began as a cute, little, enslaved tot on the planet Tattoine. Think about it... even if you hated the Prequel Trilogy, Anakin was a cute kid, but grew up to become an aggressive, worrisome, and petulant young man.
All he wanted was to keep his beloved safe from harm, but he went about it in the worst way possible resulting in exactly what he trying to prevent. He killed his wife by breaking her heart (after choking her) and nearly dies fighting his best friend and mentor, which left him a crippled, burnt, husk of a man the Emperor had little trouble converting into his minion: Darth Vader.
Vader sets his sights on the remaining Jedi of the galaxy and slaughters them. He was truly the visage of evil at this point and nothing could stop him... until his son showed up.
Luke was able to redeem his father at the very end, which helped prove that a person who turns to evil can one day return to the side of good.
Which other good characters tried being evil? Let us know down in the comments.