10 Underrated Horror Movie Remakes

Thirteen Ghosts is a lot more fun than you remember...

By Sean Martin Moscardini /

Remaking a film is never easy. You have to find the right balance of picking things to keep from the original entry, and then building upon them to either elevate them to superior levels or reimagine them into something entirely new yet brilliant.

Advertisement

The horror genre is never short of remakes and in the case of series like Friday the 13th, you can argue most of the films in the franchise are merely loose remakes, following the same basic structure with mildly differing assets.

It's a terribly difficult thing to get right as if you change too much you stand to alienate fans of the first entry, and if you change too little then there isn't much point in the final product. With a crowd as passionate as the horror community, you better make it worth their while.

These are movies that were either dismissed as inferior to the originals and as punishment were cast into obscurity or ridicule for all time. Or they irritated people with just how they reimagined things, seemingly for the worse and serves only to frustrate anyone looking forward to a return to their respective series.

However, they have been unfairly maligned by unforgiving audiences that relish failure, and these are 10 severely underrated horror remakes and deserve another look now the heat from their releases have died down and we can judge them with fresh eyes.

Warning: There will be light spoilers ahead...

10. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003)

One of the most infamously hated remakes on the list, the Michael Bay produced Texas Chainsaw' is mostly seen as a less scary, studio ordered version of the much-praised original. However, it does so much different from the 1974 film this comparison is unfair, and in some areas, it really surpasses it in terms of sheer panic.

Advertisement

R. Lee Ermey is unbelievably terrifying in this version as Sheriff Hoyt, being intimidating to a fault and has a chilling backstory of gaining a taste for flesh during the Korean war.

Leatherface is also a force of pure anxiety rather than the clumsy child-like brute from the original, as he charges into the movie randomly and raises hell.

Many complained about this version containing blood when the original was so stripped back, but the violence is actually very carefully done to show just enough disturbing imagery to imbed in your brain without being gratuitous.

It's a very slick looking movie as well, setting it apart from the low-budget original to allow viewers to see every ugly detail of the psychotic hillbilly household and its inhabitants.

The introduction of Leatherface in this remake is still an insane rush of adrenaline no horror fan should miss out on.

It's a film that switched things up to give a reimagined take of Texas Chainsaw' that gets a lot more hate than it deserves, and is the best entry into the franchise besides the original by a mile.

9. Evil Dead (2013)

The Evil Dead series is a franchise that lent itself to a remake so well.

Advertisement

This 2013 film made some huge changes despite the main premise being pretty much a direct copy on paper. There seem to be two main problems that make people unfairly deride this version.

The first problem is that there was no Bruce Campbell returning as original hero Ash Williams, and instead, we get the troubled Mia. They introduce a great subplot about her kicking heroin that causes her to be unpredictable even when not a rampaging demon, and going off the 1st movie as a comparison, it makes her by far the better and more complex character.

The second issue was with the villainous deadites. They are far more intense and open to body modification, but they have zero personality and the trademark fun humor they brought is nowhere to be found.

What the film lacks in personality though, it more than makes up for in crazy pacing and tension. People are mauled in numerous torturous ways and blood is spilled so much the entire last act appears to be filmed entirely in red.

It may have took itself too seriously and the deadites lacked character, but it was one of the most heart-pounding, gruesome horror films of the 2010s and gave fans the gore-soaked thrills they craved.

It's a different style to the classic Sam Raimi original, and to write it off due to it not being exactly the same would mean to miss a gorgeous, horrifying experience.

8. The Hills Have Eyes (2006)

The original Wes Craven helmed Hills Have Eyes is a weird, but fondly remembered a piece of pulp horror that saw a family who gets stranded in the desert after their vehicle crashes attacked by a family of cannibals.

Advertisement

The 2006 remake follows the same plot but with a massive dose of intensity, and transforms the cannibals into hideously deformed nuclear mutants.

The first scene of the mutants attacking is downright horrifying and makes sure the stakes are set high early on. The film also has a lot of guts and isn't afraid of shocking its audience Walking Dead style by making any character fair game to die at any point.

The designs of the mutant are spectacularly gross, brought to life with fantastic special effects and the film as a whole has a sickeningly beautiful yet gritty visual style. The movie also brings some savage kills to the table as the 2nd half becomes a gore-soaked showdown between the survivors and mutants.

With an unpredictable plot that throws the characters straight in the deep end and a unique setting, this is an exhilarating and scary ride that arguably tops the original.

It really deserves better than the mixed reviews it got upon release.

7. Thirteen Ghosts (2000)

Thirteen Ghosts got ravaged by critics upon release but has formed a cult following for a reason. It's a loose remake of the 1960 film that cranked everything up to 11.

Advertisement

A rich collector of all things wacky dies and leaves everything he owns to his nephew. The said collection just so happens to include a house of glass with Latin spells written into the walls, and 12 horrific ghosts. The nephew goes to see the house and predictably haunted shenanigans ensue.

The film's plot moves by so rapidly you are never bored, as the movie's visual style assaults you with fast-paced editing and showcases the sensational production value that really flaunts its $42 million budget.

Each ghost is distinct from a unique, tragic backstory that is undeniably intriguing and their stunning appearances are the highlight of the whole show. They also dispatch the main characters in a variety of gruesome ways that include an infamous scene where a lawyer is split in half unlike anything you've ever seen.

It may not be the least bit scary or believable, but it looks wonderful, moves at an intense pace and the titular ghosts steal the show as some of the most creative specters you'll ever see.

If you don't take it seriously its an incredibly fun, haunted house ride, and really didn't deserve the trashing it got on release.

6. The Crazies (2010)

The original The Crazies wasn't a movie that many were calling for a remake, but when it finally dropped it turned out to be totally worth it. This reimagined story of military chemicals turning folk into violent killers has a lot of great things hidden inside its runtime that shouldn't be overlooked.

Advertisement

For a film shot in a small town in Iowa, the film sure packs a punch visually with a lot of the imagery containing moody shadows that contribute enormously to the visceral style the film goes for.

The horror comes not only from the titular crazy residents, but the government who swoop in and order everyone in the town to be killed too. This leads to some thrilling encounters as our heroes avoid getting gunned down while also surviving infected farmers wielding pitchforks.

The film is almost never brought up in conversation when good horror remakes are mentioned, but it really does elevate the material it is given to work with by adding much more action and style to the proceedings.

It's a mature take on a rather average original film that has great suspense, a slew of creepy visuals and constantly ramps up the stakes to a bombastic finale. Give this 2010 version another viewing and you'll probably be surprised how well it holds up.

5. Black Christmas (2006)

The original Black Christmas is a cherished hidden gem from the '70s that was for a long time one of the only Christmas themed horror films around. It was an unsettling experience as it remains a rather realistic take on a stalker preying on a sorority house, with chilling phone-calls and tension-filled murders.

Advertisement

The 2006 remake could not have been any more different, having nothing resembling scares and throwing almost all logic out the window. This film goes into the background of the now yellow-skinned serial killer, and the plot is hilariously poor at trying to shock the viewer.

Seeing a man make angel cookies out of his mother's flesh while a yuletide jingle innocently plays in the background is so ridiculously over the top you have to laugh. It has plenty of gore for the viewers looking for it, but the real joy is in just how stupid and mad the plot twists become.

It's also a very Christmassy film that makes other Crimbo themed movies look like scrooges. Bright Christmas lights dominate most of the cinematography, candy canes and ice skates are used as weapons and the soundtrack is filled with festive jingles.

It's an incredibly fast-paced and fun ride, and if you shut off your brain and take the film as it is, this is a good flick to grab a bag of popcorn and laugh at the sheer madness that erupts onscreen.

It fits right into the so bad its good category.

4. The Blob (1988)

The original The Blob is hard to take seriously with its insanely campy tone and a villain that could be right at home on a Saturday morning cartoon, but it has its place in history.

Advertisement

The 1988 remake goes the opposite direction to make the blob a genuinely frightening prospect. It's a darker take that constantly escalates up to a stunning climax that has a gigantic bloc squaring off against the entire town and military.

The special effects are out of this world, all done practically as people are absorbed, torn apart and melt in spectacular fashion. The Alien shares a lot in common with John Carpenters The Thing in this version as blobby tentacles latch onto its victims, erupting suddenly and crushing them to their gore-soaked deaths.

It's a disturbing thought being broken down on a molecular level and absorbed into the purple goo, all while still alive and screaming. The film also managed to fit in some wry humor to balance out all the carnage filling the screen.

Critics weren't that impressed with this version and it notoriously bombed hard at the box office, but it really deserves more praise for managing to take such a silly concept and bringing it to another level.

This did exactly what any remake should do, updating the story with modern technology and made what was originally a slow-moving gelatinous mass absolutely terrifying.

3. Night Of The Living Dead (1990)

It's not hard to see why the 1990 Night of the Living Dead gets overlooked so much, because the original film is one of the most remade films to ever exist. It just gets lost in the shuffle of the other cheap knockoffs trying to bank off the original.

Advertisement

This version directed by special effects legend Tom Savini, may follow the original heavily but the changes it does make are enough to make it a great reimagining of the groundbreaking classic.

Whereas the original broke ground with a black protagonist, this version also allows Barbara to shine as the female heroine rather than the catatonic useless lump of zombie chow that she was in the original.

It also rivets up the pace with much tighter editing and a focus on the character's actions at the price of a gloomy atmosphere. However, It does allow the tension between characters in the house to be much more intense and the suspenseful zombie attacks that much scarier.

With Savini at the helm, the violence is also heightened with a focus on practical gore that looks just as good as you'd imagine.

It can't live up to what the first film achieved, but it reimagines just enough to stand apart and offer viewers a severely underappreciated zombie flick.

2. Suspiria (2018)

Remaking Dario Argento's horror masterpiece seemed like sacrilege to many as the hyper-stylized original was so unique and in a league of its own, there didn't seem like you could do anything to top it.

Advertisement

Then Amazon studios announced this remake and it stood no chance against the backlash. Instead of the vibrant colors of the original, viewers were treated to an icy-cold, muted color palette with, at a glance, more standard looking filmmaking.

The film also chooses to root the movie in the realm of the realistic, with much of the terror gleamed from horrific Cronenberg-esque body horror rather than the 1977 version which eschews time and place, and the horror is more supernatural based.

These are large changes, and the plot diverges massively from the original, particularly the last act, but it's all the better for it as it completely owns the undeniably intriguing witch lore and expands on it immensely.

It is a tad too long, a whole hour more than the original, but it needed to be to fit in the extra plot elements and lures viewers in with its hypnotic pace and dreaded tone before shocking you to the core with extremely vile visuals.

Whether you're a fan or not, there was no denying this was a bold film and much better than the middling reviews that followed it would suggest. Give this twisted tale of witchcraft and interpretive dance a go and make your own mind up on its quality.

1. Maniac (2012)

This Elijah Wood starring remake of the 1980 film Maniac appeared completely out of nowhere to shock audiences, then quietly drifted into obscurity which is a shame because it's a beautiful, stylish take on a journey into the mind of a disturbed young man.

Advertisement

It follows a man with schizophrenia who runs a mannequin shop, that routinely stalks and kills women at night. We get to see these grisly scenes direct through his own POV, making sure you can't escape a single detail of the numerous violent incidents.

The stunning synth-heavy soundtrack adds a ton of atmosphere, and the whole film is layered with a thick sense of dread as we watch our main killer slowly go more and more insane. The suspense is always high with such an unstable villain and there are several shocking scenes that will no doubt haunt your dreams for a while after the credits roll.

All the performances are done brilliantly too, with Wood bringing his usual boyish charms to disarm you before going into a rampage and scalping another poor woman.

It's a beautiful look into an ugly mind with a crazy amount of horrifying deaths and a superb visual style to put you directly in the feet of a murderer.

It's sadly underrated but more than worth your time if you have the stomach for it.

Advertisement