10 Upcoming Films That Are Terrible Ideas

When Hollywood decide it's time for a Tetris movie, they've officially ran out of ideas.

By D.M. Anderson /

We€™ve all been there€sitting in a theater, watching a trailer for yet-another creatively-bankrupt Hollywood product and thinking, €œWho gets paid to come up with this crap?€ Endless sequels, origin stories, pointless remakes, movies based on toys, reboots of franchises whose corpses are still warm. There are occasions when you could almost be offended by the apparent contempt major studios seem to have for the intelligence of their audience, that we€™ll lap-up any brand name they vomit onto the screen, no matter how terrible, as long as we€™re already familiar with it. Sure, there are exceptions. On paper, The Lego Movie sounds like one of the dumbest ideas of all time, but it confounded everyone€™s expectations by being creative, clever and ultimately heartwarming, the total opposite of the cynical product we all thought it would be. But for every Lego Movie, there€™s a Battleship, an idiotic attempt to pander to an undemanding audience€™s familiarity with a brand name. For every movie that truly warrants a franchise (like Star Wars or the Marvel Cinematic Universe), we see studios trying to resurrect and reboot old properties (cartoons, games, belated sequels) with the hope of striking box office gold. The following is a list of upcoming films, either in development or in production, that are truly stupid ideas. As one would suspect, all of them are remakes, belated sequels, unnecessary reboots or attempts to make a movie out of a concept which doesn€™t lend itself to cinematic storytelling. In other words, they have flop written all over them€

10. Poltergeist (Remake)

This one€™s already wrapped up and due for release next summer, meaning no one arrived in time to remind producer Sam Raimi and director Gil Kenan that the idea of remaking Poltergeist is only marginally less stupid than Gus Van Sant€™s scene-for-scene reshoot of Psycho. Recent history is rife with updates of classic horror films, but with few exceptions, they€™ve been slick, watered-down products aimed at the mall-rat crowd, devoid of any elements which made the originals groundbreaking. But unlike Halloween or A Nightmare on Elm Street, the original Poltergeist was unique in that it was essentially a family film which just happened to scare the living hell out of everyone. That it managed to do so with absolutely zero body count is a testament to how skilfully it dished out the dread. For an entire generation of kids in the 80s, Poltergeist was their first taste of true terror, and it remains one of the scariest films of all time. Remakes of The Texas Chainsaw Massacre and Friday the 13th were cynically produced to cash in on a brand name as well, but one can (almost) justify their existence because the originals are definitely products of their time and seem rather quaint today. However, like Psycho and The Exorcist, Poltergeist has not only aged remarkably well, it remains required viewing for any serious horror fan, regardless of age, and that hideous clown still makes everyone jump out of their seats. What€™s the point of wasting millions of dollars on a film that doesn€™t have a chance in hell of topping the original? WHAT COULD SAVE THIS FILM: The same undemanding teenagers who flock to see every other pointless remake during its opening weekend. It'll still most-likely suck.

9. Popeye 3-D

With the exception of a horribly misguided 1980 musical starring Robin Williams (directed by Robert Altman, of all people), few have given this spinach-loving sailor much thought over the past several decades. Even Boomerang, Cartoon Network€™s dumping ground for animated relics, largely ignores those old classic shorts, probably because Popeye was never as endearing as other cartoons from that era. So you have to wonder what audience a 3-D computer-animated update of an 80-year-old character would even appeal to. After all, it€™s likely most children€™s parents didn€™t grow up with him either. Even if they did, Popeye€™s overall appeal is similar to Betty Boop€™s€sort of retro-hip if seen on a tee-shirt (or a box of fried chicken), but nothing anyone is pining to see back on the big screen as a full length feature. WHAT COULD SAVE THIS FILM: Mr. Peabody & Sherman, another generations-old property hardly anyone remembered, turned out better than expected and did pretty well at the box-office. It wasn€™t great, but didn€™t rely on nostalgia or brand name familiarity to connect with a new audience. For Popeye to have a chance in the 21st Century, Sony Pictures (the studio producing the film) needs to follow suit.

8. Star Wars (Spin-Offs)

Once they acquired Lucasfilm, we all knew Disney would milk the Star Wars franchise for all it's worth. While that€™s sort of a good thing (we€™re getting Episode VII, directed by J.J. Abrams, who made Star Trek relevant again), it also means nearly half of the products available in Disney Stores are now Star Wars-related. Not content with continuing the Star Wars saga, Disney also announced spin-off films which will presumably be origin stories of beloved characters such as Han Solo and Boba Fett, released in interim years between episodes of the ongoing saga. The threat of over-saturation notwithstanding, this is a bad idea. By their very nature, origin stories are essentially pointless. Case-in-point€the main problem with the Star Wars prequels wasn€™t George Lucas€™ terrible dialogue, clunky performances or over-reliance on CGI. It was the fact that everyone already knows the fates of most of the main characters, stripping these films of any tension or suspense. We€™re simply watching a checklist of events hinted at in the original trilogy, which never really needed further exploration. You also need to ask yourself if you really care about Ford-less Han Solo or the rise of Boba Fett (who may look cool, but isn€™t exactly a dynamic character). WHAT COULD SAVE THESE FILMS: This is probably a moot point. Star Wars continues to be a cash cow, and a slew of spin-offs, no matter how redundant, aren€™t likely to change that.

7. I Am Legend (Reboot)

Richard Matheson€™s classic novel has already been adapted for the screen three times. Though none of the films are without their flaws, none are totally terrible either. Each has qualities which not only distinguish them from each other, but make them worthwhile for any fan of post-apocalyptic stories. 2007€™s I Am Legend (boasted by Will Smith€™s star power at the time) was a blockbuster, so of course Warner Brothers wanted a sequel. Since Smith€™s character, Neville, died at the end, a prequel was suggested. Fortunately, someone wised up and scrapped such a terrible idea. However, someone else came up with an even worse one€ I Am Legend is now getting the dreaded reboot treatment. A spec script, originally titled A Garden at the End of the World, is being re-written as yet-another adaptation of Matheson€™s story with the hopes of finally turning the property into a franchise. Note to Hollywood: Not every hit movie needs to become a goddamn franchise, nor does every franchise need to be rebooted. And if you absolutely can€™t help yourself, would it kill you to at least wait a decade? Surely, you have a few original scripts lying around you could shoot in the meantime, don€™t you? WHAT COULD SAVE THIS FILM: Make a truly bleak and violent horror film that doesn€™t rely on star power, free of any overt heroism, sentimentality and CGI monsters. Make a lower-budgeted film in order to push the R rating to its limit and still turn a profit. It worked with the Evil Dead remake, which everyone once thought was an equally awful idea.

6. Ghostbusters 3

Co-star/co-writer Dan Ackroyd has been trying to get Ghostbusters 3 off the ground for decades, hell-bent on keeping the project alive even without Bill Murray, who€™s the sole reason most of us loved the original film in the first place. Ackroyd apparently learned nothing from Blues Brothers 2000 (a candidate for the most pointless sequel of all time). As recently announced, a third Ghostbusters film is now indeed in the works, but not as Ackroyd envisioned. This one will be a reboot with an all female Ghostbusters team, with Paul Feig directing and co-scripting. No Murray, no Ackroyd, no Bernie Hudson and obviously no Harold Ramis. Looks like a lot of others learned nothing from Blues Brothers 2000 either. This is a desperate and cynical attempt to resurrect a brand name that probably shouldn€™t have been a franchise to begin with. Comedy sequels (Ghostbusters II included) are nearly always inferior to the originals. As for belated sequels, even those with original cast members€name one that was actually worth waiting for. An all-female Ghostbusters is nothing but a parlor trick by its producers, who apparently think you won€™t notice they couldn€™t coax Bill Murray back. Sure, there are a plethora of great comedic female actors out there, such as Melissa McCarthy (who can successfully carry even the most contrived Hollywood product). But being cast in a classic franchise because of your sex is not only demeaning, it doesn€™t change the fact that, without Murray, no one cares about Ghostbusters. WHAT COULD SAVE THIS FILM: If Murray showed up for at-least an unbilled cameo, it might have a chance to lure the older crowd who grew up with the original.

5. The Peanuts Movie 3-D

Charles Schultz€™ Peanuts is one of the most beloved comic strips of all time, and the numerous holiday TV specials are so iconic that you€™d be hard-pressed to meet anyone who didn€™t grow up on this stuff. Part of the comic€™s appeal is its minimalism€simply-rendered characters, low-key observational humor and children serving as a microcosm of life€™s trials & tribulations. The TV shows retained the same look and tone. The fact that most are still an annual part of everyone€™s holiday TV diet is a testament to their timelessness. Is there anyone who truly believes Peanuts needs a CG update, in 3-D no less? This is even a worse idea than Popeye, because these iconic characters (and how they€™re illustrated) are still culturally relevant. When we think of Snoopy lying atop his doghouse or Lucy swiping the football away from Charlie Brown, a specific image immediately comes-to-mind. Who the hell wants to see them rendered any other way? In addition, Peanuts have historically fared better on television than in theatrical features, mainly because the classic TV programs consisted of vignettes loosely tied to a theme, and would often deviate from whatever threadbare plot was presented. While several feature-length Peanuts movies were released in the 70s, none of them were as consistently funny or interesting as the comic or TV shows. The concept of Peanuts doesn€™t lend itself to full-blown features. What€™s charming, amusing and insightful in 30 minute segments becomes somewhat meandering when padded out to 90. WHAT COULD SAVE THIS FILM: It depends on the number of undemanding children still blown away by anything presented in 3-D, with parents willing to pay the inflated admission price, even though this movie will undoubtedly crap all over their own childhood memories.

4. How The Grinch Stole Christmas

There€™s a good reason Dr. Suess€˜ books are wafer-thin. They€™re meant to be read by parents to put their toddlers to bed, or by children themselves once they start learning to read. There€™s also a good reason why 1966€™s How The Grinch Stole Christmas became a beloved holiday TV special: Chuck Jones€™ animation is wonderful, Boris Karloff€™s narration and voice of The Grinch are perfect, and the story encapsulates the true spirit of Christmas in 22 short minutes. It was never conducive to a full-blown feature film, nor are any other Dr. Suess books, for that matter. We€™ve been bombarded by them over the past decade and a half (both CG animated & live-action), and all are nothing more than cynical attempts to cash in on a brand name. The live-action remake, The Grinch, may have made a pile of money (probably because it features Jim Carrey at his most unhinged), but you€™d be hard-pressed to find someone who actually likes this movie. Believe it or not, yet-another feature-length version of How the Grinch Stole Christmas is currently in development. This one will be fully CG-animated, yet doesn€™t change the fact that the original book can be read and enjoyed in a fraction of a movie€™s running time, meaning it will be just as unnecessarily padded-out as the Jim Carrey version. Since CG animation is no longer a novelty, finding a reason for this film€™s existence is a challenge. It€™s hard to imagine anyone improving on the original TV special, which is still aired every year during the holidays. WHAT COULD SAVE THIS FILM: It stands to reason that the only way this film will be successful is if little kids consider traditional animation as irrelevant and archaic as those who poo-poo old movies filmed in black and white. A sad, but potentially true, reality.

3. Skull Island

Yes, kids, this is yet-another origins story (are we sensing a trend here?), focusing on the old stomping grounds of everyone€™s favorite disgruntled gorilla, King Kong. Little is actually known about the plot itself (or if Kong is even the main focus), but when a teaser was shown at this year€™s Comic-Con, it was greeted with some disappointed groans in the audience once they realized it wasn€™t a trailer for the upcoming Jurassic World. Despite the presence of fangirl heartthrob Tom Hiddleston, one must question how many moviegoers actually wish to revisit this island. The highlight of every King Kong film (even the idiotic 1976 version) was always the title creature€™s escape from his captors, his subsequent rampage through New York, followed by his tragic death. One could even argue that King Kong is already an origin story. But even if you don€™t agree, wouldn€™t going back to visit his early days on Skull Island destroy some of the mystique that made him so appealing to begin with? WHAT COULD SAVE THIS FILM: Retain the title for brand name recognition only. Acknowledge it€™s the same island, but avoid featuring Kong at all. Make Skull Island a terrifying place (which Peter Jackson admittedly did very well) where the rules of accepted science do not apply. Make it a survival story with characters we care about.

2. ID Forever (Parts 1 & 2)

Those of a certain age might recall watching the Super Bowl back in 1996, and during a commercial break, witnessing the most jaw-dropping teaser trailer of all time. Who wasn€™t awestricken by the image of a massive fireball rolling up the streets of New York, tossing cars through the air like toys? Or the total annihilation of The White House, rendered to splinters with a single shot fired from a miles-wide alien saucer? The trailer alone arguably sold Independence Day to the world, and it didn€™t matter that the movie itself turned out to be a corny mash-up of 50€™s sci-fi and 70€™s disaster movies. After ID4 (as it€™s affectionately nicknamed), the massive destruction of famous landmarks became a common trope in countless large scale actions & disaster films. Though some of its special effect shots look a bit creaky today, ID4 is fondly remembered as one of the 90€™s definitive summer popcorn pictures. And until just recently, it was one of the few true blockbusters of the past 20 years where, not only were there no serious sequel plans, nobody was pining for one. Most of the civilized world was destroyed in the original film, along with the entire invading alien race. What was left to blow up? But a belated sequel has indeed been announced, to be released as two separate films with the stupidest title ever. There are numerous reasons why this is a terrible idea. First and foremost, the original film€™s concept in-no-way warrants any kind of follow-up. Earth was invaded, then the aliens were defeated, and we were all happy with that. There€™s absolutely no need to revisit any of these characters or rehash yet-another invasion story. Second is the decision to divide the sequel into two separate films (the most blatantly-greedy trend Hollywood has ever conceived), which reeks of overconfidence. While the original ID4 remains undeniable fun, it hasn€™t really aged that well. Producers are being hopelessly optimistic to assume audiences will flock back (twice) to a franchise that€™s a generation old. Finally, part of ID4€™s retro charm lies in its still-impressive use of practical special effects (one of the last mega-budget films to do so). It seems highly unlikely these sequels will revert back to models and miniatures when CGI is more economical. CGI will render these films indistinguishable from any other effects-laden blockbuster. Not only that, the wholesale destruction of famous places is no longer a novelty. WHAT COULD SAVE THIS FILM: New landmarks to destroy, a lead actor as amusing as Will Smith (who opted out of these sequels, even though he could use a hit right now) and one hell of a story to justify two separate movies.

1. Tetris

Tetris is a puzzle-type video game created in 1984 by Alexy Pajitnov. The premise is simple: assorted multi-shaped blocks slowly drop down the screen, and your job is to make them fit with other blocks you€™ve already placed. If you successfully complete a solid line of blocks, it disappears, allowing you additional time and room for more blocks. If not, once the blocks stack to the top of the screen€game over. Until Angry Birds took over everyone€™s phone and tablet, Tetris was the most stupidly-addicting game of all time, hugely popular in the 90s when Nintendo included it in the bundle of its Game Boy system (for you young€™uns, the Game Boy eventually made your precious 3DS possible). The phenomenal success of Tetris was due to its awesomely simple game play. There€™s no plot, no characters, no back story, no cheats and no beating the game; you play as long as you can before you€™re overwhelmed, making its appeal similar to pinball. Its perfect simplicity is why Tetris often listed among as one of the greatest video games of all time, and also why it€™s a totally stupid idea for a movie. Sure, it€™s a brand name people are still somewhat familiar with, but how the hell can anyone write a story or screenplay based on the premise? It€™s just a random series of blocks raining down from the top of the screen. Not only that, it€™s been a couple of decades since Tetris was everyone€™s time-waster of choice. Didn€™t the total failure of Battleship teach anyone that an old game without any characters makes a sh*tty movie, even in the genre of video game adaptations? WHAT COULD SAVE THIS FILM: Nothing. It€™s hard to imagine anyone, nor matter how talented, could piece together a story worth watching. This ranks high among the worst movie ideas of all time. Do you disagree, and are actually willing to admit you're looking forward to any of these films? Speak your piece and try to convince us otherwise.