13 Ways DC Is Attempting To Combat The Marvel Films Model
There's more than one way to build a superhero universe.
Its hard to actually call what DC has built so far a universe, since it consists of only one released film, but make no mistake, the DC Extended Universe is coming. Man Of Steel was a great starting point, and extrapolating from there, coupled with what we know about their upcoming slate, from personnel choices to the tones of trailers, we can make educated guesses as to how theyre handling their material.
Since Marvel essentially paved the way when it comes to both interconnected movie universes and modern superhero movies, its natural that DC is going to look at how they did things. But that does not mean that they will blindly follow in Marvel's footsteps.
Wisely, what DC ultimately seems to be doing is focusing on their own adult style and strengths, instead of just playing copy cat to Marvel. DC conceivably has learned from Marvel's bumps in the road and is trying to avoid those same mistakes. By fighting this established order of how to do things, theyre aiming to make good movies free of some of Marvel's trademark flaws.
From the characters they use to the way they portray them, DC is doing things differently as a means to create their own superhero niche. Not all of their efforts will work, but these are the ways that DC is attempting to counter what Marvel has done so successfully for years.
13. Drafting Competing Scripts
DC has caught a lot of flak for the way theyre developing most of their scripts. Rather than just hire the writer they think is best for the job, as regular movies do, DC is instead hiring multiple writers at once for the same project. Aquamans development started with three writers until a favourite was picked and Wonder Woman had five.
Its not exactly the nicest environment for screenwriters but there are advantages. Plenty of the scripts these guys write wont get filmed anyways, so this process is just a bit more public than usual. Furthermore, the methodology of throwing everything at the wall and seeing what sticks isnt necessarily a bad idea.
Marvel, like most movie studios, has a tendency to re-write movies throughout development. In recent years, James Gunn re-wrote Guardians Of The Galaxy from scratch while Paul Rudd and Adam McKay did a significant re-write of Ant-Man when Edgar Wright left. The point being that if the script is going to get altered anyways, they might as well just get the kinks out early.
This also seems to be a way for them to vet lesser accomplished screenwriters. Not everyone is being subjected to this process as proven talents like Chris Terrio are still being given control of their own scripts.
12. Better Production Values
Whereas Marvel has succeeded in both developing strong characters and creating unbelievable action scenes, many of the technical aspects of their films have left fans wanting. In particular, theyve struggled to cobble together any memorable scores or striking cinematography.
Marvel has undeniably lacked strong soundtracks for most of their movies. With the exceptions of the classic Guardians Of The Galaxy playlist and Henry Jackmans electronic The Winter Soldier, most of their stuff has been Bryan Tyler putting out some serviceable background noise. Even if DCs answer for all things music is Hans Zimmer, thats better than most of what Marvel has already done.
On the visual side of things, for all of his faults as a director, Zack Snyders works have always been visually stunning. Look no further than Amir Mokris beautiful photography from the Man Of Steel trailer to be reminded of that. Now that hes re-teaming with his frequent collaborator Larry Fong, the DC movies are already standing out with how beautiful they look compared to the very ordinarily-shot Marvel fare.
DC certainly hasnt proven themselves enough in this regard yet, but just based on Marvels inability to deliver, this could be a huge area for them to capitalize on.
11. Diversity In Their Superheroes
There will come a time when non-white and non-male superheroes will become commonplace in film. That day is slowly approaching but until it does, every new hero will be scrutinized by the media based on how diverse they are. Just ask Marvel, theyve been fielding complaints about the lack of a Black Widow solo movie since the day she was introduced. Now DC has the chance to learn from their mistakes.
Marvel has Captain Marvel on the go, as well as Wasp about to co-star with Ant-Man, but it might be a case of too little, too late. Despite being five years behind with their development, DC is going to get out of the gate first with Wonder Woman releasing in 2017.
From a racial standpoint, both DC and Marvel are planning to introduce some notable black superheroes next year that will subsequently get their own features. Cyborg and Black Panther are going to be debuting within months of each other, but Black Panther's solo feature will be Marvels 18th film, while Cyborg's will only be DCs 10th.
DCs not really beating Marvel to the punch, but the fact that theyre not waiting around for twelve movies before they decide to diversify already shows good judgment and media management on their part.
10. Giving Their Directors More Control
No one is going to accuse James Wan of being an influential voice in filmmaking, but hes had success across genres. David Ayer has crafted some of the best crime movies of the last 15 years, Patty Jenkins directed Charlize Theron to an Oscar win, and Seth Grahame-Smith... well maybe its best to just forget about him for now. The point is that while these may not be the master directors DC is claiming them to be, they all have individual flair and definitive voices, which is more than what could be said of most Marvel directors going into their movies.
Marvel runs their operation very much like a TV series. The producers are the ones really in charge and the director is only their to execute their will on film. So while their initial efforts included more prolific directors like Jon Favreau and Kenneth Branagh, after their creativity was stifled by the model, Marvel turned to more easily controllable options. Suddenly, TV directors and relative unknowns were getting brought onboard to direct huge blockbusters with little experience.
The results have largely been successful but just look how much better Guardians Of The Galaxy was when they gave control to a more established director with a distinct voice. This is what DC is trying to do every time.
If DC really wants to sell this idea of getting master directors, they should just hire Edgar Wright to direct The Atom as a big middle finger to Marvel.
9. Owning All Of Their Characters
Marvel characters like X-Men and Spider-Man very much led to the creation of the modern superhero genre. Unfortunately, for this to have happened, Marvel had to sell away the rights to the characters. Long before they operated their own studio, Marvel rightly saw optioning their character as a lucrative way to get them on screen.
Ever since, Marvel has been slowly trying to re-acquire their characters, going through a lengthy process to get Spider-Man back and just now being the subject of rumours concerning Fantastic Four. On top of this, though their villain problem isnt directly affected by this issue, not owning the rights to their most famous villains, like Green Goblin, Galactus, Magneto, and Doctor Doom, certainly hasnt helped.
Whereas Marvels ownership of their own characters has become so convoluted that people need diagrams to understand it, DC already has a leg up on the competition. DC owns the film rights to all of their characters and is thus unencumbered by distractions from other studios and bitter public feuds with Fox.
8. Starting With Their Most Famous Heroes
Even though theyre now household names, the likes of Iron Man and the Guardians of the Galaxy are far from A-listers in the comics. They were developed into films largely because Marvel couldnt actually use any of their most famous characters.
As a result of owning all of their characters, DC can immediately showcase all of their biggest heroes, something Marvel could never do. Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman are their three most recognizable characters and theyre not coincidentally the first three were going to see on screen.
There may eventually come a time when DC wants to pursue lesser names from their own library as Marvel has. We could see a B-movie adventure with Booster Gold or a journey through the occult with Zatanna, but the point is that DC dont have to do this if they dont want to. Because they have access to their biggest characters, thats who theyre rolling out first.
DC can stick to its guns and get right into things. Launching with their most iconic characters ought to give their efforts the boost it needs to try and catch up with Marvel.
7. Treating Their Movies As Standalones
DC seems a lot more intent on approaching their films as individuals, wanting to sacrifice continuity for individual quality. This could change greatly as the movies begin to introduce more and more heroes, but for the time being, it looks like each film is meant to offer a complete story without worrying about where the other characters are.
Its almost set up like a comic book, where each film leads into the next adventure, rather than having each one build up multiple subplots to all pay off in one giant team-up movie. That means that Nick Fury wont be there to introduce the Avengers four movies before they actually appear.
Marvel certainly tried to start off this way in Phase 1 but over time have become burdened by the weight of everything thats going on in their movies. The benefit of a nascent universe is that its not overcrowded yet. This means we can get good films without having to worry about plot holes in regards to the universe. Surely thats better than a mediocre film that strenuously adheres to the continuity.
6. Better Villains
Even after twelve movies, each sporting multiple unique and varied villains, Marvel has still struggled to produce even a handful of quality antagonists. With Zod and Faora alone, DC has already topped nearly all of their villainous efforts.
Marvel has received criticism for not devoting enough time to developing their villains, often leaving them to act more like plot devices. Conversely, in Man Of Steel, we understood exactly why Zod was doing what he did, and were invested in whether he would succeed.
Casting certainly isnt the issue. Marvel has scouted a true bevy of talent to enliven their villains with and thats scarcely helped. Instead, it looks like DC is already succeeding at adapting villains because its giving them the requisite screen time to be compellingly developed.
Obviously its too early to call Lex Luthor and the Joker successes, but the controversy surrounding their casting and the initial glimpses of their performances isnt going to lend itself to mediocrity. Theyre either going to fail beautifully or succeed, and so far DC is one for one on the villains front.
5. Not Sharing TV Continuity
A lot of people were unhappy when it became clear that Stephen Amells Green Arrow would never suit up next to Ben Afflecks Batman on the big screen. Unlike how Marvel connects series like Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. and Daredevil with their movies, DC formally announced that they have no plans to do the same. This might be a good thing for them.
Look no further than the recent rumours that Kevin Feige has completely broken off from Marvels TV efforts, wanting nothing to do with the likes of Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. The entire ordeal becomes constantly burdened by continuity and an overflow of different characters that, for the sake of quality, it could just be best to have a Flash for movies and a Flash for TV.
Remember, DC is in a different place than Marvel was, as they already have multiple successful shows on the go. Its much harder to navigate this landscape when their worlds are already so developed. This way, the movies arent burdened by the continuity of the shows and vice-versa.
For what its worth, on the TV side of things, it certainly doesnt harm their brand. Theres communication between the two, after all, DCs COO Geoff Johns is both a lead writer on The Flash and co-writing the new Batman adaptation. Furthermore, Arrow and The Flash dont need the help, and now they dont need to explain why the Justice League doesnt show up every time theres a problem.
4. A More Adult Tone
One of the calling cards of a Marvel film is its humour and sense of fun for the whole family. DC, likely fearing that all of their movies would resemble Marvels if they copied this tone, decided to go in a different direction entirely, one with a self-described intensity and seriousness of purpose.
Remember, we dont actually know that this will work, were merely observing the ways in which DC is trying to differentiate themselves. In this case, they may have gone a tad overboard.
This tone in question probably isnt really the best suited to all of their characters, but its clear that DC is making a concerted effort to distance themselves from Marvel and this is one way to do that. Theyre attempting to create adult dramas that just so happen to star superheroes and its unclear if thats going to work out.
Nevertheless, for all of the acclaim Marvel gets, their tone is likely the biggest thing holding them back come awards season. Were not about to proclaim Suicide Squad the next Dark Knight, but its clear that for those types of accolades, this kind of tone is valued more.
3. Backwards Continuity
Using backwards continuity is a trick to make viewers feel as if characters were always there, lurking in the backgrounds of previous adventures and influencing things from behind the scenes. Even if the initial film hadnt been conceived with this in mind, if executed properly, it makes them feel developed, and re-contextualizes parts of the original film.
DC is specifically attempting to do this around the Battle of Metropolis from the end of Man Of Steel. For one, theres Zods cataclysmic World Engine, which Superman throws into the sea. We now learn that this pissed off Aquaman and hes coming to the surface as a result. Likewise, the Batman V Superman trailers make it very clear that Bruce Wayne was there during the attack, helping rescue people.
While we never actually saw either of these characters in Man Of Steel, retroactively putting them there without obstructing the original films narrative is an ingenious way of ingraining them within the established world.
Fixing characters into this pre-existing moment seems to be a much better route than burdening stories with setting up the future. It means theyre waiting for something to succeed before building off of it, and not wasting time developing future storylines that we may not want or get to see.
2. Team Comes First, Then Spinoffs
Batman V Superman is officially introducing us to the remaining members of the DC Trinity: Batman and Wonder Woman. By the end of the movie, its rumoured that almost all of the Justice League will cameo. This will all directly lead into Justice League Part One which releases in 2017, meaning that DC wants us to glimpse the team first as a means to get to know everyone.
From there, all of the spinoffs will happen, with us already having met the likes of Cyborg and the Flash before they go off on their own. Each solo outing is given a head start since were already acquainted with each character. This also means that whatever conflict they face in the film (rumours peg it as an alien invasion), its sure to shape each of the characters' journeys.
Marvels approach was considerably different, slowly letting us meet their stars in a variety of disparate settings, before bringing them all together. The Avengers built up an unreal amount of hype for one movie, so now DCs trying to invert that same model to build up hype for many movies.
Quite frankly, Marvels method was immensely successful but any effort to mimic that is going to reek as laziness on DCs part. This way, they both avoid too many comparisons to The Avengers, and find a way to help enrich each of their films with pre-existing character depth typically reserved only for sequels.
1. More Than One Person In Charge
Marvel has succeeded under the guidance of Kevin Feige. The producer extraordinaire revolutionized the concept of a shared film universe and has ushered in a slew of captivating films.
But DC is a much different beast than Marvel, and not only do they not have their own Kevin Feige, it appears that they may not want one singular person in charge. Keep in mind that DC is basically a wing of Warner Bros thats been given some autonomy. Conversely, Marvel Studios is its own studio thats simply owned by Disney.
Zack Snyder may be the figurehead of the DCEU but he clearly doesnt have all the pull that Kevin Feige does. In fact, he better resembles a more powerful version of Joss Whedon, with his hand in all of the creative efforts, but without the authority to completely dictate how theyre handled.
Snyder is leveled off by the likes of writer David Goyer and executives and producers like Charles Roven, Deborah Snyder, Greg Silverman and Diane Nelson. Its a collective brain trust that falls in line with DCs mantra of giving their directors more freedom to be creative.
Of course, the real people who should be in charge of the DCEU are the animated universe masterminds Bruce Timm and Paul Dini, but I digress.