Nothing grabs people's attention quite like a little controversy, and that's certainly true in the world of cinema. Deviate from the norm and people start paying attention for better or for worse, no doubt earning some free PR for your movie and putting it on people's radars. Like any other year, 2014 has been full of controversial movies that turned people's heads and for one reason or another got them talking. So, what was controversial this past 12 months? Well, one of the most unnecessary movie remakes of all time, a number of long-awaited biopics that apparently minced with reality, watered-down sequels and reboots of classic properties for teenage audiences, actors and directors even disowning their own movies, and a number of projects that made everyone look inward and ask some crucial questions about themselves. That's without even mentioning the comedy that sparked an international incident and stole most of the movie world's headlines last month. Whether or not these 15 films actually ended up being any good, each raised passionate debate with strong arguments on both sides, with the controversy in come cases actually overshadowing the film itself and essentially becoming its own entity. Such is the nature of the world in 2014, again, for both better and worse. Here are the most controversial movies of 2014...
15. RoboCop Is Another Pointless Remake That Flopped
Pointless remakes are a dime a dozen these days, but people got really up in arms when filmmakers decided they'd start remaking classic action films from the late-80s Paul Verhoeven Golden Era of Action. The 2012 Colin Farrell-starring Total Recall remake flopped critically and commercially, and the same was ultimately true of this competently-directed but completely needless reboot of the classic Peter Weller-starring action flick. This is a remake that surrendered pretty much every problem with remakes of classic action films: it was rated PG-13 instead of R, so there's none of the original's incredible gore effects, the satire was toned way down and nowhere near as clever, and despite a great cast, they were all wasted on bland characters. Though this movie might have made the fanboys whine incessantly, it's one instance where they were totally justified: the message to studios is simple, to stop rehashing classics and hoping to make an easy buck.
14. The Imitation Game "Downplays" Alan Turing's Homosexuality
Any movie depicting the life and times of mathematician Alan Turing was bound to be controversial, if only because it was extremely likely that he'd end up being played by a heterosexual actor, which many (albeit misguidedly) believe to be an affront in of itself. Still, before The Imitation Game even came out, there were persistent murmurs that the movie was going to downplay Turing's homosexuality in order to appeal to a wider audience and not "put them off". While the movie paints him as shy and retiring, the real-life Turing was reportedly quite open and eager to come onto men. In addition, the movie has been accused of playing-up Turing's tenuous relationship with Joan Clarke (Keira Knightley), devoting more screen time to it simply because it's heterosexual and more palatable to some audiences. Also, the frame narrative involving a detective investigating Turing's homosexuality has been completely invented for cinematic purposes. Still, does The Imitation Game capture the spirit of Turing's life and make a potent tribute to his legacy? Absolutely. It's far from a great film but it provides a welcome platform for Benedict Cumberbatch, even if it ultimately fell rather short of its initial major awards hopes. It's just a shame the movie wasn't more rigorous about reflecting the truth of the man's life.
13. The Expendables 3 Is PG-13 & Pleases Nobody
Fans of cheesy action flicks everywhere collectively groaned when Sylvester Stallone announced that the third Expendables movie would be getting a PG-13 rating in an attempt to appeal to a wider audience, while also introducing a gang of younger Expendables characters to that end. Expectations as such weren't high from the outset, and unsurprisingly, the results weren't pretty. The final movie, which also leaked online three weeks before release, was disastrous: despite game new actors like Wesley Snipes, Harrison Ford and Antonio Banderas giving it their all, the PG-13 was lame and bloodless (which is stupid when there's so many brutal deaths in the movie), and there's far too much of a focus on the younger characters, most of whom are played by up-and-comers without much acting talent at all. The movie posted the worst reviews and lowest revenues of the series, because a) hardcore action fans aren't interested in PG-13 and b) teenage kids have no interest in watching 65-year-old men running around pretending they're half their age. Thankfully, at least, Stallone has promised that the next Expendables movie will be back to R-rated glory, though they may have already lost a significant portion of their audience for good. Given how Stallone criticised Bruce Willis for being greedy by asking for too much money to star in this movie, it seems rather hypocritical that he and Lionsgate were attempting such a dishonest cash grab with EX3.
12. Wish I Was Here's Kickstarter Campaign Opens A Debate About Crowdfunding
Zach Braff courted plenty of controversy when he went to Kickstarter to get his latest film, Wish I Was Here, funded. His fans raised $3.1 million, an avenue Braff admitted taking after traditional financiers wanted to take final cut privilege away from him and also help decide the cast. Still, it soon enough caused many to ask: why does someone as successful and popular as Braff need to be asking his fans to pay him to make a movie? Could he not self-finance the movie? In fairness, Braff did contribute a small amount of his own money to funding the film, along with a third more traditional financial source, though to many that wasn't good enough: to use a crowd-funding platform that, in spirit, many saw as intended for up-and-coming talent, was a betrayal of the whole funding model. Someone who spent almost a decade on a hit show shouldn't be asking his fans to pay his way without at least offering some potential compensation in return if the movie makes bank. In the end, the movie received mixed reviews and just about broke even, so though nobody got rich off of it, it still seems a bit tacky to ask your own fans to stump up cash and then more money once the movie comes out. To many, this was the definition of exploiting your own fanbase.
11. Inherent Vice...Or Incoherent Vice?
Paul Thomas Anderson's long-awaited adaptation of Thomas Pynchon's 2009 novel opened to some of the year's most divisive reviews, with some critics hailing it as the sort of singular masterpiece only PTA was capable of making, while others dismissed it as self-indulgent, overlong, and much ado about nothing. Even those who praised the film struggled to argue against the fact that it was, with its meandering narrative, a challenge to follow, leading to it earning the popular moniker of "Incoherent Vice". Though it's hard to complain about the brilliant acting, witty script or sharp direction, does the whole amount to the sum of its parts? It's safe to say that those who enjoy straight-forward A-to-B-to-C narratives may well struggle with Anderson's unapologetically deliberate approach here, even if its unfussed pace and twisty narrative seems appropriate given the haze of weed smoke that the entire story takes place in.
10. Dying Of The Light Gets Disowned By Its Cast & Crew
In October of last year, Paul Schrader took to Facebook to tell his fans that his latest movie, Nicolas Cage-starring cop flick Dying of the Light, had been taken away from him by his producers and re-edited, scored, mixed and colour-corrected without his input or permission. While Schrader, Cage, executive producer Nicolas Winding Refn and co-star Anton Yelchin were all barred from publically criticising the film due to non-disparagement clauses in their contracts, they decided on an unusual protest to express their disgust. Each of them posted a picture of themselves wearing a T-shirt quoting said clause, a silent protest of sorts that nevertheless made their disappointment 100% clear. Undeterred, Lionsgate ended up releasing the movie straight-to-VOD on December 5th, a severely neutered 94-minute cut that was unsurprisingly destroyed by critics. While it's difficult to watch the finished product and see the promise of a great film at all, the movie's butchered release was still a loss for freedom of artistic expression, especially as it's unlikely that Schrader will ever be allowed to release his own cut given the movie's critical and commercial failure.
9. Gone Girl Makes Couples Reconsider Their Relationships
While there was plenty of discussion about whether or not Ben Affleck's genitalia makes its screen debut in this movie, the movie's real source of fervent debate is something else entirely. The author of Gone Girl's source material, Gillian Flynn, joked before the movie's release that it's the film that might "break up couples nationwide" and cause married couples to re-evalute their relationships. Labelled by many critics as "the worst date movie of all time", it's safe to say that the film's examination of the potential deceit, lost desire and social pressure that mold many marriages could cause some couples to reconsider what they've signed up for on the drive back home from the cinema. While the movie's narrative is, of course, inherently ridiculous, there is certainly some personal truth hidden beneath the absurd plot twists and outrageous social satire, that even someone as close to you as your spouse can harbour deep, dark secrets and be far from the person you thought you married. If you caught the movie at the cinema, there's a good chance you saw couples vociferously arguing about the movie on the way back to their cars, and one can only imagine that David Fincher would be maniacally grinning at the sight.
8. Dear White People Provokes Racists Everywhere
Dear White People has been marketed as being a movie about "being a black face in a white space" (following black students at a predominantly white university), and though the tone of the trailer was clearly satirical, that hasn't stopped closet racists from emerging from the woodwork and rather glibly declaring that if a movie were made called, "Dear Black People", it would be deemed racist and never granted release. That's to completely ignore the subtleties of race relations in the U.S. in particular, though, where the black man is marginalised, and where a movie like this is enormously relevant. The film has been labelled a "lightning rod for controversy", though it has been extremely well-reviewed for the most part, with many critics noting that most complainers would probably ease up if they actually watched the film: it's not an attack on whites in any way, but simply a send-up of the social institutions which essentially encourage the differences between races. In short, though daringly-premised, the film ultimately is a lot more pragmatic than its detractors will be expecting, if only they'd bother to actually sit down and watch it.
7. The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies (Finally) Ends The Franchise
Expectations were undeniably high for the final entry into Peter Jackson's six-film Middle Earth franchise, even though the previous two Hobbit movies had drawn mixed notices from critics and audiences. Surely the final movie couldn't help but deliver an awe-inspiring finale, right? Well, The Battle of the Five Armies is, in fact, the worst-reviewed of the six movies, for though the battle scenes entertain and it provides a firm lead-in to The Lord of the Rings, it also still feels rather bloated, the CGI is laughably poor, and it further fails to justify the need for a relatively short book to be split into 3 movies. Still, the movie was unsurprisingly a box office juggernaut, as these films are essentially critic-proof, and stand as a towering example of how easily an acclaimed auteur such as Jackson can exploit his and Tolkein's fanbase. Still, nobody put a gun to the audience's heads, so it's not like they're blameless for encouraging this cash-grabbing behaviour either.
6. Selma Is Disallowed From Quoting Martin Luther King's Copyrighted Speeches
Ava DuVernay's massively-acclaimed Oscar hopeful Selma covers a pivotal period of Martin Luther King's (David Oyelowo) life in immaculate, deeply affecting detail, though she and screenwriter Paul Webb faced a massive hurdle when trying to get the film made. The "rights" to King's iconic speeches had already been sold to Steven Spielberg for an unspecified project, and so they were not allowed to use the man's precise words, but had to essentially paraphrase his speeches while attempting to capture the spirit of what the man said. It's truly impressive that the final movie doesn't make this apparent at all, with King's various speech scenes totally capturing the vibe of the moment and slotting in perfectly with some of his real speeches. On the other hand, though, doesn't it seem disgusting that words as inspiring and important as those of Dr. King aren't in the public domain, but can somehow be commoditised and sold off to the highest bidder by his estate? Surely if King were here today, he'd disapprove of such craven money-grabbing by his family.
There was plenty of pre-hate for this movie before it even began shooting, when early scripts for the Turtles reboot leaked online in which the Turtles were depicted as aliens. This script was later scrapped, however, and production pressed on for a live-action reboot which attracted controversy pretty much every time it announced anything, be it that Jonathan Liebesman (Battle Los Angeles, Wrath of the Titans) was directing, or Megan Fox was starring as April O'Neil. The final movie itself proved even more troublesome, though, with fans criticising the decision to give the Turtles huamnoid-esque noses and mouths, as well as ret-conning their backstory (April has now known them since childhood) and introducing an incredibly creepy subplot in which Michelangelo keeps hitting on April. Unsurprisingly, the film was panned by most critics even if it was a significant commercial success, with a sequel already in the works.
4. Noah's Depiction Of Evolution & Noah As A Drunk
Any movie of this biblical magnitude is going to be a magnet for controversy no matter what, and unsurprisingly, Darren Aronofsky's unconventional take on the tale of Noah's Ark attracted plenty of it long before it was even released. For starters, the director clashed with Paramount over the final cut of the movie, as they reportedly developed up to six alternate cuts of the movie (of varying degrees of "friendliness" to Bible Belt Christians), even if they ultimately did concede and allow Aronofsky's cut to be released. Once the film came out, though, the controversy intensified, with two particular scenes proving troubling: the Creation montage which appears to show the Big Bang and the process of evolution, and also the depiction of Noah as a drunk. Also, the movie's re-purposing of the story as an adventure flick complete with battle scenes did draw some ire. Still, on the whole, Aronofsky's film was a daring religious epic that was ultimately pretty pragmatic, broached between adapting the source material and updating it for a modern world. An admirable goal.
3. Interstellar Divides Audiences Down The Middle
One of the most anticipated movies of 2014 also proved to be one of the most divisive, as Christopher Nolan's Interstellar was, depending on your opinion, either a Kubrickian sci-fi masterpiece, a competent yet flawed sci-fi, or a soppy pile of nonsensical garbage. Though the performances and visual splendour of the movie were almost universally praised, criticisms were lobbed at the massive amounts of exposition, poor female characters, and a third act which seemed to completely deviate from the hard science veneer of the previous two hours. Many fell in love with its ambitiousness and its sheer spectacle, however, choosing not to focus on individual moments but the sheer emotional heft of the entire movie. No film in 2014 has been as passionately argued about as this on both sides of the equation, while anyone stuck in between, who liked it with reservations, should just stick their fingers in their ears and walk away.
2. Exodus: Gods & Kings' White-Washed Casting
Ahead of the release of Ridley Scott's biblical epic Exodus, there were naturally concerns about the "white-washing" of the movie's characters, causing an irritated Scott to declare in an interview, "I can't mount a film of this budget...and say that my lead actor is Mohammad so-and-so from such-and-such. I'm just not going to get it financed." Though Scott's response was indelicate and insensitive, he certainly wasn't wrong, yet his brutal honesty totally rubbed people up the wrong way. While the tendency to slather white actors in make-up to give them a more "ethnic" look has always been a bit embarrassing, there's positively no way that this $140 million epic would exist if more "appropriate" actors were cast, because for the most part, white people like watching white people. Christian Bale gave a more tactful and sensible response by declaring that, if everyone were more supportive of North African and Middle Eastern filmmakers and actors, then the financing would also come along with it.
1. The Interview Causes Hacking, Terrorist Threats & An Unexpected VOD Release
And of course, what else was going to be #1 but probably the most controversial film of the decade, The Interview? The Seth Rogen and James Franco-starring comedy courted enormous controversy as soon as the first trailer dropped and North Korea took a look at it, publically denouncing the film months ahead of release. Things intensified when Sony was hacked in late November, apparently by North Korean hackers who demanded that The Interview's release be cancelled. Astoundingly, after threats to attack cinema chains showing the film, Sony allowed the chains to withdraw from screening the movie, causing Sony to eventually cancel the theatrical release altogether. They did relent, however, releasing the movie to a small number of US cinemas on Christmas Day, while making it available on VOD for $6 from Christmas Eve. The unprecedented release has proved relatively successful for a movie that many expected would probably end up shelved and quietly dumped on DVD, grossing $31 million to date on VOD, and while not quite matching the movie's budget, it at least demonstrates the potential viability of day-and-date VOD for additional profits. And as for the movie itself? It's good, silly fun. Hardly a brilliant film, but worthy enough of the controversy, especially considering its outrageous climactic scene, which you really need to see for yourself. Which movies did you find the most controversial and shocking this past year? Shout it out in the comments!