15 Terrible Mistakes That Almost Ruined Terminator For Everyone

It's a miracle the series survived these farces.

By Jack Pooley /

The Terminator franchise might not quite be a box office juggernaut on the level of, say, the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but it's impossible to deny the iconic impact the series has had over the last 30 years, especially the first two movies directed by James Cameron. The latter two movies never managed to live up to the first two, but the series has always been a financial success, hence why a fifth movie, with the horrible title Terminator: Genisys, recently wrapped production and is due for release next year. Though the series made Arnold Schwarzenegger a mega-star overnight and kick-started James Cameron's extremely successful career, the franchise has had its share of ups and downs over the years, be it the painfully low budget of the original movie, or the unfortunate creative license the third and fourth movie took with what came before. As you might notice, Terminator 2 doesn't show up in our list because, well, it's pretty damn perfect. These 15 crucial errors in judgement threatened to derail their respective movies and the franchise as a whole, but of course, the series has endured, though we'll probably have a few more complaints to add to the list once Genisys is out in the wild next summer.

15. Nick Stahl Replaces Edward Furlong As John Connor (Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines)

One of the most successful aspects of Terminator 2 was the chemistry between young future resistance leader John Connor (Edward Furlong) and the T-800 (Schwarzenegger), so when Terminator 3 was finally announced, it was presumed that a now-adult Furlong would be returning to reprise his role. However, the actor's well-documented substance abuse problems resulted in him being recast with Nick Stahl, a talented actor who nevertheless just...isn't Furlong. Despite Stahl doing a fine job as Connor, the switch to a new actor was rather jarring considering Stahl's utter lack of resemblance to Furlong, and the fact that fans were so desperate to see an older Furlong interacting with Arnie once again. The role was of course Furlong's to lose, so he has nobody to blame but himself, but one can only imagine that the film would have been all the better had it built on the relationship between the two actors from the previous film.

14. The T-1001 Urinal (Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles)

Garbage lead singer Shirley Manson plays a T-1001 Terminator with ambiguous motives in the second season of Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles, acting as the head of the Zeira Corporation and revealing her liquid metal composition in one incredibly awkward scene. Two of her underlings are going to the toilet when one says of Weaver, "God, that b**ch p**ses me off", at which point the toilet begins to morph into a liquid metal form which eventually transforms into Weaver, who then uses a liquid metal finger (ala the T-1000) to stab the guy through the head. The scene is meant to be shocking and bada**, but really it's more weird than anything: did Weaver have to dismantle the toilet ahead of time and just sit there while this guy (and potentially a bunch of other guys before him) took a leak all over her? Did she really have to set up such an elaborate way to kill the guy rather than forming any other metal object in the room? It's creepy and kinda funny (albeit for the wrong reasons).

13. Arnold's Dong (The Terminator)

In the opening minutes of The Terminator, the malevolent T-800 (Schwarzenegger) arrives in Los Angeles in the middle of the night, and heads out in the nude to acquire some clothes. Just as he heads over to Bill Paxton and his buddies to deprive them of their duds (and their lives), audiences get a wildly unnecessary shot of Arnold walking towards them, his junk clearly visible flapping around for a few seconds. In fairness, this wasn't really especially noticeable until the Blu-ray version of the movie hit stores, but ever since, it's been burned onto the retinas of Terminator fans everywhere. Did Arnie really need to do the scene completely naked? The movie was low budget for sure, but couldn't Cameron have stretched for some artful lighting or one of those anti-nudity coin-purses, or you know, maybe just shoot him from the waist-up?

12. Night Becomes Day Within 5 Minutes (Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines)

The set-pieces in Terminator 3 might not live up to those of the previous two films, but they're still a lot of fun to watch and sharply directed by Jonathan Mostow. However, there's one glaring flaw that sticks out like a sore thumb during John Connor's early effort to escape the Terminatrix (Kristanna Loken), and that's how ridiculously fast the skyline changes from night to day. When John flees the veterinarian clinic in a van, it's pitch black, yet when Arnie heads off in pursuit of him three minutes later, it's starting to get light (as pictured above), and another two minutes after that, when John has his unsavoury interaction with the disgruntled driver, it's totally bright and early. While few will argue that the sun rises quickly, that the skyline goes from pitch black to bright within 5 minutes is just totally ridiculous. Sure, shooting a scene set during sunrise must be an absolute logistical nightmare, but the lighting shift is distractingly abrupt, and there's not really any reason why the scene had to be shot this way. Mostow could have saved himself a lot of hassle by just filming it all at night, and having the sun rise off-screen in subsequent scenes. It might not completely derail the movie, but it's easy to imagine that Cameron wouldn't have let such a glaring oversight slip by on his watch.

11. CGI Arnie (Terminator Salvation)

Due to his role as the Governor of California, when a fourth Terminator film was announced, Arnold Schwarzenegger was only able to have the most limited of roles, which ultimately ended up being a silent CGI cameo rather than a brief walking-on part. Near the end of the movie, John Connor (Christian Bale) faces off against another T-800 model, who was played by Austrian actor Roland Kickinger, with a crude CGI model of Schwarzenengger's face pasted over the top. Though the clear pressure to at least feature Arnie in some fashion was evident, the final results look more awkward and silly than anything else: it's a cool scene in theory, but the distractingly bad, video game-esque CGI Arnold just doesn't measure up to the real thing. Smartly, at least, director McG doesn't linger on Arnold's face for too long, and eventually his skin is burned away, leaving just the endoskeleton behind, leading to a less distracting showdown with Connor. No matter how bad the upcoming Genisys might be, at least it has Arnie in the flesh.

10. "I Hate Machines" (Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines)

Within 10 seconds of meeting future resistance lieutenant Kate Brewster (Claire Danes), she's already annoyed the hell out of everyone thanks to one incredibly heavy-handed line of dialogue. She's in a department store with her fiancee Scott, and when a barcode scanner doesn't work, she declares, "I hate machines." It's such a lazily set-up line to demonstrate that Brewster probably isn't going to get along with the T-800 very well, plus, who in real life ever refers to a barcode scanner as a "machine"? Most people would probably say "I hate technology" or "I hate computers", neither of which sound especially great either, but they don't seem quite as ham-fisted and forced as what they went with. It's classically cringe-worthy dialogue, thrown in simply to reference a word from the movie's title, though it really just plays as patronising and dumb.

9. Giving Away The Twist In The Trailer (Terminator Salvation)

Even ignoring the fact that Terminator Salvation had a ridiculously awesome trailer for an ultimately rather disappointing movie, the most interesting idea it set up was that Marcus Wright (Sam Worthington) was, in fact, part-man, part-machine, much to the horror of himself, John Connor and the whole human resistance. However, though this is a provocative enough idea to bring fans back to the cinema, it ultimately proved to harm the film, because it's actually revealed as something of a big plot twist half-way through the movie, even though just about everyone watching was already aware of this. Had the marketing team co-operated with McG, then perhaps this twist would have been left out of the advertising, but instead, it left viewers bored and anxiously waiting for the reveal to happen so they could see what was to follow.

8. Awful Effects (The Terminator)

One of the more memorable quotes from The Terminator has Kyle Reese (Michael Biehn) explaining the Terminator to Sarah Connor (Linda Hamilton): "The 600 series had rubber skin. We spotted them easy, but these are new. They look human €” sweat, bad breath, everything. Very hard to spot. I had to wait till he moved on you before I could zero him." It's a terrifying idea, it's just a shame that the low budget movie's special effects...aren't so special, and so Reese's comments about the new T-800 being hard to spot just seem kinda ridiculous. Sure, the famous eyeball scene is only a small part of the movie, and the movie's other cheap-looking effects (namely the stop-motion endoskeleton) actually enhance the overall creepiness, but given that the Terminator is supposed to be an immensely convincing infiltration bot, this scene rings hilariously hollow, even if it's relatively easy to forgive given how awesome everything else is.

7. Goofy Humour (Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines)

If there's one universally-despised element of the third Terminator movie, it's the unnecessary addition of goofy humour. What director Mostow clearly misunderstood is that, though the second movie in particular featured plenty of humour, it was dark rather than silly. Here the humour is fully camp, resulting in two infamous scenes, as Arnie heads to a gay bar to acquire clothes and ends up with a pair of sparkly, Elton John-style sunglasses, and later when he shoplifts at a convenience store and tells the attendant to "talk to duh hand". After the more morbid humour of the previous two films, this is just goofy and cringe-inducing: who seriously thought this was something any self-respecting Terminator fan would want to see? Plus, it just tramples all over the dignity of Arnie's character(s). Somebody needs to make a fan edit with these two scenes removed.

6. The Heart Transplant (Terminator Salvation)

At the climax of Terminator Salvation, John Connor is mortally wounded during his battle with the T-800, and despite Kate's (Bryce Dallas Howard) best efforts to save him, his heart has suffered too much damage to be salvaged. However, a saviour comes in the form of Marcus, who offers up his own heart to save John's life and keep the resistance afloat. There are two problems with this idea: a) it's totally ridiculous and impossible to believe that Kate could perform a heart transplant in the totally not-sterile environment of the desert and b) it's extremely rushed through in the final moments of the film, not really giving the audience any time to process it before the credits roll. The originally-planned, much darker ending in which John Connor is killed and his likeness is stretched over Marcus' body to preserve the myth of the resistance leader would have been a much more interesting ending even if the logistical issues of placing Connor's face on a machine are both clunky and incredibly gross.

5. T-850 Overrides Its Programming Because...It Can? (Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines)

After the TX kicks Arnie's head off and changes his programming, he heads out in pursuit of John Connor, and a fight begins. As the T-850 prepares to Terminate John, John asks the machine, "What is your mission?", at which point the T-850 endures a conflict of directives, between its original mission (to keep Connor and Brewster alive) and the new mission given to him by the T-X. Connor manages to appeal to Arnie's "emotional" side, and the T-850 hurls Connor to safety, leading to a corny montage of the machine bashing a car to pieces about 20 times, before he shuts himself down and freezes on the spot with the most hilariously constipated look on his face. It's an extremely tired trope in cinema that the protagonist manages to stop a brainwashed person from killing them by appealing to the deep good inside of them, but this is a machine without any concept of good and bad, and so the whole scene just comes off as lame and silly. If the TX were anywhere near as advanced as it looked, it would have been able to just overwrite his programming without any overlap. Otherwise, if it can be reversed with some manipulative conversation, what's the point?

4. Sarah Connor Dies...Of Leukemia? (Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines)

One of the more unfortunate omissions from T3 was the lack of Sarah Connor, with actress Linda Hamilton turning down the script because she felt that her character was unnecessary and the script was "soulless". This lead to Connor being written out of the franchise, having succumbed to leukemia in 1997, though having seen Judgment Day pass without incident before doing so. However, she had a contingency plan in case Judgment Day had merely been delayed (which it turned out to be), leaving a cache of weapons in her casket, which John and the Terminator retrieve. Still, given how iconic Hamilton made Sarah in the first two movies, and how strong a female character she was, it was a shame to see her bumped off so casually in T3. Seriously, leukemia rather than an epic, bullet-riddled blaze of glory? Still, at least fans got to hear her voice again in Terminator Salvation by way of some tapes she left for John.

3. Not Enough Future War (Terminator Salvation)

The entire selling point of Salvation was that it would finally get to the future war between the resistance and the machines which was previously teased in each Terminator movie with a brief flash-forward sequence. Making Terminator Salvation strictly a war movie should have been an easy choice, yet the end result just isn't focused enough to this end, featuring a curious lack of imagery from the previous movies (such as T-800s en masse crushing human skulls) and nowhere near enough human-machine battle scenes. There's too much of a focus on other ideas which just don't really work (the whole Marcus thing, for one), when a post-apocalyptic Saving Private Ryan would have been exactly what the movie needed to be. Sadly it seems like viewers may have lost their chance to get the ultimate future war movie now, because from what's been seen and heard so far, Genisys is going to be something completely different.

2. It Was On FOX (Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles)

FOX is a TV network frequently criticised for their extremely conservative approach to the content of their shows: the likes of 24 have demonstrated that it's perfectly fine for characters to be violently murdered, but they can't show even one female nipple or have one character shout the F-word, because this is apparently too offensive. This hypocritical philosophy has ruined a number of shows (remember that The Sopranos was originally pitched to FOX), and one can't escape the feeling that Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles was one of them. Though it made a decent effort of tying itself into the labyrinthine Terminator mythos, the TV show was seriously harmed by its lack of violence and adult content, considering the movies were all rated-R except for Salvation, and as such needed a show that reflected this (preferably on a network like Showtime or HBO). From the pilot, it just felt like a generic sci-fi series slapped with the Terminator logo, as well as suffering from by-the-numbers direction and a budget that wasn't large enough to support all the big ideas. On another network, it might not have seemed quite so dull and homogenised.

1. Lack Of Dark Humour (Terminator Salvation)

One of the biggest complaints about Terminator Salvation was its almost total lack of humour. While Terminator 3 had goofiness, Salvation didn't fare much better with its aggressively self-serious approach, which was in stark contrast to the black humour of the first two movies, which nevertheless lightened the emotional load and ensured the movies stayed more fun than grim. Salvation, though, is just a somber slog at the end of the day: everything's lent the import of Shakespeare and Bale is trying to do Serious Acting but sorely needs some levity to work with (undeniably harsh though the apocalyptic scenario is). The previous three films all had one thing in common: they were daft and they knew it, but Salvation doesn't seem quite so keen to accept its own ridiculousness, and as such it's a strangely off-putting outing. Are there any other cringe-worthy moments that nearly ruined Terminator for you? Shout it out in the comments!