20 Theories That Answer Classic Unexplained Disney Questions

And no, they're not "just cartoons..."

By Sara Weir /

There is nothing worse when you're waiting for a question to be answered in a movie and before you know it, the credits are rolling and you're left feeling absolutely clueless. Why would they do that to you? Even allowing for the inevitable space for a sequel, that's just careless and frustrating. Of course there is a massive difference between wanting more and finding out why Scar and Mufasa look nothing like each other. Are they even related? Are they step brothers? Because you really have to suspect that the milkman has been involved in some way. No matter what your age, you're bound to have at least five Disney films that you are completely in love with despite the huge, gaping questions that Walt seemed to gleefully leave unanswered. But blind love can only cover holes for so long, and sooner or later you're going to start tearing your hair out, writing conspiracy theories on your wall and rocking gently to the thoughts that you'll probably never find out the truth. Or... you could just read this article and be completely satisfied by all the questions you thought weren't answered in classic Disney films...

20. How Can Pocahontas And John Smith Understand Each Other?

The Film: Pocahontas Answer: Grandmother Willow. Grandmother Willow's song "listen with your heart, you will understand" allows Pocahontas and John Smith to understand each other, and the gust of magical wind that surrounds them, breaks down the barriers of communication and turns their foreign tongues into domestic ones. The concept of knowing where a talking tree comes from is also pretty simple; Grandmother Willow is obviously an Ent.

19. How Come WALL-E Is The Only One Left Of His Kind?

The Film: WALL-E Answer: Whilst WALL-E may seem like he is a cute, loving little robot he's actually worse than Patrick Bateman. A complete psychopath. On the surface, it appears that he's been left alone because all of his fellow robots simply stopped working, but it's a lot more sinister than that. The units all had the capacity to self-repair; so as soon as the first ones started to die, the others should have been able to fix themselves. That wasn't really a quirk of WALL-E's programming "malfunction", it's more like commitment to their prime directive. So in reality, it looks more like WALL-E killed off every other robot to harvest them. That's why he's so very blasé about cutting them up and stealing their body parts for himself and despite the fact that he falls in love with another robot he doesn't seem to mind that he is surrounded by death in the first place.

18. Why Doesn't Ariel Just Write To Eric?

The Film: The Little Mermaid Answer: Ariel signs her name on the contract to Ursula so she can clearly write and thus should probably have saved a lot of time and confusion by writing a little note to Eric telling him to kiss her but no. The solution, unfortunately, is that Ariel is clearly an idiot, as evidenced by her willingness to leave her entire friends, family and world whilst changing her whole identity in the process in order to get a boyfriend... She has to change everything about herself so that he will accept her, despite the fact that they have never even spoken to each other before. But at least they both find each other physically attractive, because that's what true love is all about, right?

17. Why Did Mowgli's Parents Abandon Him?

The Film: The Jungle Book Answer: They died completely horrific deaths and you should be ashamed of yourself for doubting them. They were either killed in a tragic canoe incident as that was where Mowgli was found or they were killed by Shere Khan and The Jungle Book is actually a tale of one tiger's desire to eat an entire family. Now go and hang your heads in shame.

16. Is Christopher Robin Imagining His Friends And Why Does Winnie Never Wear Trousers?

The Film: Winnie The Pooh Answer: Most likely. If anything, he's probably dead and Winnie and friends are just his version of Heaven because in reality, hanging around with a bear and a tiger is a mighty good way to get yourself eaten. Also, look at the height difference between Christopher and his friends; he is only a young boy and these are supposedly fully grown animals yet they are such smaller than him. The fact that an Owl is the same size as a Kangaroo suggests they really are just figments of a child's development imagination. Winnie the Pooh does want he wants and if he wants to flash then he's going to flash. Disney have always been quite inconsistent with their characters who wear no trousers but feel the need to always wear a t-shirt, so it's not exactly anything new. The real mystery is what sort of garment Piglet is actually wearing.

15. What Is Scar's Real Name?

The Film: The Lion King If he was born with the scar then fair enough, that would make sense. But if he wasn't born with the scar on his eye then he got into some fisty cuffs and therefore Scar became his nickname? His parents wouldn't have been cruel enough to name him after a facial deformity, would they? And how did he get the scar? He's a notorious scaredy cat. Answer: His real name is Taka and Scar is the nickname that he chose himself after he got in a fight with a herd of buffalo, proving that you really should persist with that nickname you've tried to get everyone to call you. Scar was unavailable for a comment on what really happened between him and the buffalo because he is dead.

14. Did The Genie Create An Entire Empire For Aladdin Just So He Could Have Somewhere To Rule?

The Film: Aladdin Answer: Pretty much. Aladdin asked for the Genie to "make him into a Prince", not to just look like a Prince or act like one but to become one. So, the Genie would have had to have created an entire kingdom for Aladdin to rule otherwise he wouldn't be fulfilling his main duty as a Genie - to grant wishes VERY specifically. The Genie probably just created people out of thin air and told them to follow the guy in parachute pants, and they did. Which is somehow morally less murky than killing people or making people fall in love.

13. Why Wasn't Anna's Heart Unfrozen When Olaf Nearly Melted For Her?

The Film: Frozen Answer: Frozen has proven that Disney is into feminism and that people should not have sex with snowmen, (Disney are in no way endorsing incest either - true love isn't aways that kind). Olaf loved the idea of heat and fire more than his love for Anna and the fact that he runs away from the fire means that he technically doesn't fully melt for her. So his sacrifice isn't quite "true" enough. It would also mean that Olaf's love for Anna was truer than Kristoff's love for her, which would have been a rather sad ending indeed as they would get together knowing that they're not actually soul mates and Anna should be shacked up with a snowman.

12. Why Didn't Cinderella Just Run Away And What Would Have Happened If Someone's Else Foot Fit The Slipper Before Prince Charming Reached Her?

The Film: Cinderella Answer: Cinderella was an orphan with no inheritance, no social connections and she hadn't even come out in society. In what world would she have survived if she had run away? The answer to this question can also be found with Fanny's story in John Cleland's novel Fanny Hill and in Thomas Hardy's Tess of the D'Urbervilles and it isn't pretty. Everything happens for a reason, right? The Prince was meant to find Cinderella at that exact moment so that she would be the first person in the ENTIRE kingdom with that size foot. Imagine if all women had similar sized feet? Cinderella would be a story of chaos and in the real world, when someone cuts their toes off in order to for into the slipper (like the ugly step sister's did), they wouldn't be found out by the amount of blood gushing out of their foot because life isn't fair and they would get the guy.

11. How Did Prince Phillip Know To Kiss Aurora?

The Film: Sleeping Beauty Answer: True love, obviously. In a modern context the fact that the Prince just "knows" to kiss Aurora when she's asleep is pretty creepy. She's not consenting, or even able to be asked, but in the romantic world that Disney created, that doesn't matter. Love is an unstoppable force. And anyway, who goes to sleep with lipstick on? Exactly, poor Phillip wouldn't have passed up on that chance whether she was conscious or not.

10. Why Does Beast Pretend To Never Have Been A Human Before His Transformation?

The Film: Beauty And The Beast Answer: Give the guy a break. Imagine knowing that you and everyone you know has been turned into weird cutlery people because you're a massive d*ckhead who is so consumed with their own selfishness and narcissistic tendencies that you're not even deemed fit to be a human anymore. That fork was too small for his massive Beast hands and even when you pretend to know what you're doing with fancy cutlery in a posh restaurant, don't deny the fact that you'll probably dribble all over yourself and you'll ask which fork is for the salad. Wait... did some of his servants have to become spoons? That seems a particularly cruel punishment.

9. How Come Russell's Parents Allow Him To Keep Hanging Out With The Old Man Who Basically Kidnapped Him?

The Film: Up Answer: In all honestly, if you gave birth to someone as annoying as Russell, you're probably glad to have a bit of a break from him. Besides, he's a boy scout and they are always prepared for anything so he'll be fine with anyone, right? Unfortunately Russell is not blessed with good parents; his father is almost entirely absent thanks to his new life, his stepmother is the stereotypical evil witch, and his mother is so redundant she doesn't even demand mention. The poor kid has to show that he's only going to be worthy of their attention until he achieves every scout badge ever created. And still nobody questions where he went, or why it was with an old, lonely man.

8. Why Did She Never Question Why She Was Locked Up In A Tower?

The Film: Tangled Answer: She's either very trusting or an idiot, or both. It is only until Rapunzel comes of age as it were, that she is able to question an adult's authority because as a child, it is considered a sin - Mother knows best after all - although it's unclear why she didn't. Seriously, what's the worst that could happen? She'd get locked up in a tower? More importantly, how doesn't her hair give her whiplash? Obviously, it's magic, but are her follicles embedded with cement?

7. Where Are Boo's Parents?

The Film: Monster, Inc Answer: Her parent's were alcoholics and forgot that they even had a daughter. Boo was gone for a WHOLE day and they never once came looking for her, but then again, how could they? They were in and out of so many children's bedrooms that they wouldn't have had a chance in finding her. And it's always a rule that time works different in alternate realities. So it might well have been a Narnia situation where she was literally only gone for a few minutes in the human world.

6. How Did Andy Never Hear The Toys Talking?

The Film: Toy Story Answer: In reality, if someone said to you, "my toys become alive when they think I'm not looking and they all talk together. Like... they have meetings," people would think that you were a few fruit loops short of a bowl. So Andy probably just chose not to believe. He really doesn't want anyone picking at the fact that he doesn't have many real friends as he spends most of his time with his toys and his lack of a stable father figure would be blamed for his inability to move on and grow as a person into an adult. All of a sudden, the plot thickens and Woody and his pals would be trying to break Andy out of a mental institution.

5. What if Arthur Was A Rubbish Ruler?

The Film: The Sword In The Stone Answer: Like most children his age, Arthur has the qualities of innocence and seeing the good in people, which fade away as you become older. Arthur has that magic in him that he will still see the good even at the end of all things, which will eventually make him a strong and rational leader. (Hopefully). But what about the years before he learns regality? What if Arthur was completely incompetent as a leader? He was clearly a terrible squire. Would the people still think it was a good idea to base the future leadership of the entire kingdom on anyone who can pull a sword out of a stone? Definitely not, they'd probably have to set up an actual democracy or something...

4. Why Is Anita Friends With Cruella?

The Film: 101 Dalmatians Answer: People question the friendship between Anita and Cruella as being unrealistic and disingenuous when in reality, those are qualities considered to be harvested by Cruella. Anita is gentle, kind and patient, which is probably why Cruella takes advantage of her good nature. She's a bully, it's what they do. Why else would Biff be friends with George McFly? The real question should be how on earth can they afford to look after and feed all of those puppies? Roger isn't exactly making the big bucks. Maybe they'll end up looking for business in the fur industry anyway...

3. What Is Peter Pan's Deal?

The Film: Peter Pan Answer: He's dead. He's also incredibly selfish since he doesn't want Wendy or the Lost Boys to have parents so he wants her to stay in Neverland where she will ultimately die too. Peter Pan is basically an awful person and he even leads on Tinker Bell for all of those years making her the little b*tch she is when her status as number one girl is put under threat. And even his shadow doesn't like him.

2. Does He Get To Stay A Real Boy?

The Film: Pinocchio Answer: Yes, because wishes do come true, even if he has proved himself to be ridiculously easily led and a bit of a bad boy at times. But then that's part of being a human. Except he'll probably wish that they didn't in this case as he now has far more responsibilities than just worrying about how big his wood will get... Or will he? He is human after all.

1. Why Aren't The Dwarves Rich If They Dig Up Diamonds Every Day?

Disney: Snow White And The Seven Dwarves Answer: "It ain't no trick to get rich quick/ If you dig dig dig with a shovel or a pick" They also admit that they have no reason why they do it, they just like to do it, which is very humbling as they're doing it for the love of it and not for the benefits. Clearly Disney dwarves are very different from Tolkien's dwarves. Unless they're just covering the fact that they're really, really bad at trading and someone is taking them to the cleaners when it comes to selling their wares on... Which other distracting Disney questions do you wish had answers? Share yours below in the comments thread below.