5 Best And 5 Worst Romances In Science Fiction

By James Ramos /

Romance is a fickle beast. We fall in love, we fall out of love, sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn€™t. It can feel like the easiest thing in the world, but often it just plain doesn€™t make sense at all. Fictional characters aren€™t exempt from the ups and downs that love often brings, or the heartache that it can cause. In fact, many a fictional story is fueled purely by the chaos love can wreak on people (I€™m looking at you, Twilight). The world of science-fiction has its fair share of whirlwind romance. Some work out like a dream, others can best be described as a train wreck, where each individual car is made up of many, smaller train wrecks. Here are 5 of the worst science-fiction romances, followed by 5 of the best...

5 Worst Sci-Fi Romances

5. Cyclops & Jean Grey (X-Men)

Right off the bat, it seems these two have the most joyless relationship ever captured on camera. We don€™t even find out they€™re a couple until she off-handedly mentions it to Wolverine, who by now is dead set on romancing her himself, and who couldn€™t care less. And it€™s hard to blame him, seeing as how, other than a cool warning to €˜stay away from his girl€™, Cyclops does precisely ziltch to discourage his advances. Imagine for a moment, friends, that you are in a committed relationship, when all of a sudden some virile, never-aging, perfect-specimen-of-a-human-body stranger just up and moved in with you and your squeeze, and their room was right €˜down the hall€™. Not only that, but this attractive stranger made no secret of the fact that they were out to steal your sweetheart from under you. Whatever your reaction would be, even if you€™re the most docile of people, Cyclops€™ was, like, a dozen times less than that. Wolverine€™s presence is treated like more of an annoyance than a threat to his relationship. And it isn€™t like Logan€™s intentions are a secret (they do have two mind readers on campus, after all, one of whom is Jean herself). Throughout all three of the original X-Men films, Storm, Jean, Rogue, and freaking Bobby are all aware of the €˜tension€™ between Dr. Grey and the Wolverine. And all the while Cyclops does.... a lot of frowning. Heck, the only time we see an earnest reaction from him is when Logan joins the team. I don€™t know about you, but watching X-Men and X2 I always got the feeling there was some inner animosity a€™brewing between Cyclops and Jean to make him care that little about their relationship. How It Ends: Turns out, of course, that there was! When Phoenix (Jean€™s powerful subconscious) is unleashed, the first thing she does is kill Scott. The second thing she does is make out with Wolverine. Not much room for doubt there.

4. Anakin Skywalker & Padme Amidala (Star Wars I-III)

The relationship between Anakin, Jedi Knight turned Sith Lord, and Padme, former Queen turned senator, was... unorthodox, to say the least. When they first met, he was a nine year old slave while she was a fourteen year old Queen in hiding. Throughout the entire course of their first encounter its more than clear that while Annie plainly admires Padme, she views him as nothing more than a child to be looked after (although not exactly an adult herself). Fast forward ten years, when fate brings them together once more. Anakin is no longer a child, yet Padme assures him that to her, he€™ll always be €˜that little boy she knew on Tatooine€™. Not exactly words that set the heart aflutter. Anakin, though, spends the rest of their second encounter trying to prove himself to her. Which, given his position as the only thing between her and death via assassination courtesy of the Trade Federation, turns out to be pretty easy. Also, he now has a lightsaber, and, as we all know, lightsabers are awesome. This time, they part ways as a married couple. Something I always wonder while watching Attack of the Clones is, at which point did Padme stop seeing him as a child and start seeing him as something else? Blurry line, I suppose. How It Ends: Skip ahead three more years and our not-so-happy couple again reunites, only for Padme to drop the €˜Surprise, I€™m nine months pregnant with your baby€™ bomb. This news is shortly followed by Anakin€™s tragic turn to the dark side, and their last conversation ends with him force-choking her under the belief that she was in cahoots with Obi-Wan, who, incidentally, was by that time trying to kill him. In summary, their first date she was barely a teen and he was still in the single digits age-wise; on their second, they eloped, and their third ends with him indirectly responsible for her death. Star-crossed lovers, indeed.

3. Bruce Banner & Betty Ross (The Incredible Hulk)

Let€™s go with the Marvel Cinematic Universe version here. Our introduction to Bruce and Betty is fairly early on, in the opening sequence to The Incredible Hulk. Unfortunately, about ten seconds into that montage Bruce hulks out and destroys half of Betty€™s face. Not the greatest way to start things off. Throughout the course of the movie, Bruce and Betty rekindle the romance that ended when her father chased him off. Unfortunately for Betty, this involves harboring a fugitive, not to mention putting her life in danger every minute she spends in said fugitive€™s company. Is it worth it? Apparently so, because before Bruce showed up she was dating a neurosurgeon with a nonexistent sense of humor, whom she literally just walked away from to get to Bruce. It seems a little one-sided. Betty gives up everything €“ her career, her belongings, possibly her freedom €“ for Bruce, and in return she gets... the constant threat of death. And yes, he saves her life a few times along the way, but he€™s always saving her from a situation that he is indirectly the cause of to begin with. How It Ends: In the end, they go their separate ways, because keeping regular company with a rage monster is evidently not a good idea. The exact nature of their relationship is left ambiguous, until, of course, we run into Bruce again in The Avengers, where there is an interesting contrast between Banner and Thor. Whereas Thor comes back from a whole different planet and makes it a point to inquire about Jane€™s well-being, Banner €“ who€™s back in the country for the first time in who knows how long €“ doesn€™t even mention Betty. Not even in passing.

2. Batman & Catwoman (The Dark Knight Rises)

I€™m referring to the Dark Knight Rises version of the pair here. Tiny little movie, you may have seen it. Yes? Cool. The first time Bruce Wayne meets Selena Kyle, she introduces herself by ever so graciously robbing him of his mother€™s pearls and scavenging his fingerprints to sell for illegal purposes. Nice to meet you, too, Ms. Kyle. But it gets worse. As we all know by now, within the hour Kyle has sold Wayne out to Bane, and proceeds to watch as he beats him into submission, after which she tries to flee the country. At this point it should be noted that she doesn€™t even know whether Bruce is dead or not, and that doesn€™t seem to bother her all that much. Throughout the film, while Wayne and Kyle maintain a flirtatiousness with each other, it doesn€™t seem that the other is ever a real priority for either of them. This cavalier attitude is demonstrated in full by Bruce when he casually hooks up with Miranda Tate. Selena Kyle, who? How It Ends: Eventually they do seem to come together. Bruce is no longer Batman and Selena is, apparently, no longer a cat burglar. They€™ve given themselves a fresh start, although, even at the very end, neither of them seem to really enjoy being in the other€™s company. Whether or not that relationship crashes and burns shortly after the credits roll is anyone's guess, but I'm inclined to think that it does.

1. Kyle & Amanda (Kyle XY)

Kyle XY was a brilliant series. Don€™t remember much of it? That€™s most likely because it was cancelled after just three seasons, which I recently rewatched on DVD. I must say, while it was airing I dismissed it as the poor man€™s Smallville, upon full viewing I was pleasantly surprised. It really was a great show in its own right. One of its most frustrating aspects, however, was the relationship between Kyle €“ a genetically altered clone with superpowers €“ and Amanda, the literal girl next door who plays a mean piano. For one thing, they really didn€™t have much chemistry. Secondly, around season two we meet Jessie, who is pretty much a girl version of Kyle, with her own powers and abilities. The sparks between these two are much more profound (read, they exist), yet Kyle €“ for reasons that are never really explored €“ continues to choose Amanda over Jessie. Which of course would make sense, if Kyle and Amanda actually seemed to like one another. But it doesn€™t seem that way. Like, at all. What€™s more, fate appears to be firmly set on keeping the two apart. In season one, Amanda has a boyfriend, which by season two is over with, but then, in comes Jessie, who by season three has drummed up so much of Amanda€™s jealousy (not helped by the increasingly compromising situations she and Kyle get caught in) that she actually calls it quits with Kyle. Yet, instead of Amanda and Kyle coming off as star-crossed lovers fighting desperately for the one they care about, it just becomes one of those €˜dude, you€™re obsessing over the wrong girl€™ scenarios, and by the show€™s end I was hoping he€™d get a clue and move on already. How It Ends: As previously noted, Kyle XY was cancelled before its time. Yet, the show-runners created a documentary entitled Future Revealed to wrap up some of the loose ends. Upon watching, I learned that Kyle, in fact was eventually supposed to end up with Jessie, but that in the end, he€™d basically be alone because of the whole I'm-a-superhero thing. So, there€™s that, I guess. Well, that was bleak. Gives one a bad outlook on love, no? Yeah, well let€™s move right into the five best romances now.

5 Best Sci-Fi Romances

5. Peter Parker & Gwen Stacey

When I first heard that Gwen Stacey would feature as Peter€™s love interest in The Amazing Spider-man, I was pretty thrilled. By then the Peter Parker/Mary-Jane rollercoaster had gotten pretty tired and more than a little formulaic. My only hope was that she would have more in common with her comic-book counterpart than the one that was pretty much a glorified cameo in Spider-Man 3. Boy oh boy, was I not disappointed. The Peter/Gwen dynamic was a colossal improvement from the get-go, capturing the wide-eyed wonder of young love, with all its playfulness, angst, and intensity perfectly (especially considering that neither of the leads were really teenagers). The chemistry between the two is undeniable, and the best part? Peter trusts her enough to not bother with all that €˜I can€™t tell you my secret identity because you won€™t be safe€™ stuff. She€™s in on it fairly early on, even protecting her newfound knowledge from her father, who is actively on the Spider-hunt by then. In the end, she isn€™t the damsel needing to be rescued, but an active partner in defeating the Lizard. Spider-Man isn€™t the only amazing thing in this movie. How It Ends: The couple that saves together stays together. While it€™s a happy ending for the duo, we the audience (at least those who are familiar with the comics) are left with a sense of foreboding, seeing as Gwen€™s replacement is officially a part of the sequel, and we all know what will probably end up happening then.

4. Clark Kent & Lois Lane (Smallville)

Generally speaking, Clark and Lois make a pretty good match for each other. Lois is pretty obviously an integral part of Superman€™s identity, and we could be here all day discussing this particular duo in all their various incarnations, but for the sake of brevity we€™ll focus on just one: the Smallville version. From the moment she debuted in season four, Lois€™ dynamic with Clark quickly became one of the highlights of the show, and a welcome change of pace from all the melodrama that was Lana Lang. It wasn€™t a matter of will-they-won€™t-they this time, it was more like how-will-they. Watching their bond blossom was one of the best parts of the series, especially in later seasons. With Lois€™ arrival, we knew we were one step closer to Clark embracing his destiny as the Man of Steel. How It Ends: Things wrapped too soon, in my opinion. As the interaction between the pair grew from barely concealed disdain to mutual respect and finally to full-fledged I-can't-live-without-you-ness, I would have loved to see more of how their relationship would evolve once Clark was in the cape and the two were partners working for the Daily Planet (which we sort of got to see, albeit briefly). But, at least it ended with the knowledge that everything between them was eventually sorted out, and they do finally get married.

3. Dana Scully & Fox Mulder (The X-Files)

You probably knew this one was coming. The couple that basically embodied the will-they-won€™t-they trope, the nature of their relationship was one of the burning questions throughout the X-Files€™ run, which is saying something, considering that it was a show about aliens and conspiracy theories. What made this pair so great was the polarity of their personalities. Here were two people €“ the skeptic and the believer, the stoic and the (relative) goof €“ who by all counts should not have been able to tolerate each other, let alone love one another. And yet, thrown into increasingly bizarre scenarios and forced to fight their way out together, that€™s exactly what ended up happening. It was like Pride and Prejudice, but with aliens. Also, watching Scully shut down Mulder€™s dry attempts at flirting was pretty funny. How It Ends: It€™s abundantly clear that Scully and Mulder are an item before the series ended. When the second movies picks up a few years later, they end up together, boating off to start a new life together. Was I the only one who thought one of them (Mulder) was going to end up dying or something? Pleasant surprises, all the way around.

2. Spock & Uhura (Star Trek)

Sometimes, less is more, and in 2009€™s Star Trek, we got just that, at least when it came to romance. When Uhura shuts down Kirk€™s advances, we at first assume it€™s because he€™s sort of a douche, but later, when the cadets are given their assignments, is when we see that she's already spoken for. We finally glimpse something between her and Spock when she insists on being assigned to the same ship as his. But at this point it could still be merely a close friendship, a passing fancy, anything, really. But then Vulcan is destroyed, and we get the scene between the two in the lift. Friends don€™t kiss each other like that. Case closed. This is followed up with the scene before Kirk and Spock beam aboard Nero€™s ship (when her first name is finally confirmed). But, other than these few occurrences (and all the love-y eyes between them throughout the film) we don€™t know much as to the exact nature of their relationship. How It Ends: How it began, how far and how long it€™s been going on; there are few details known. And it doesn€™t matter, because the two make a surprisingly well-made pair. We can tell that Spock adores her (given the speed with which he reassigned her to the Enterprise and the praise he heaps on her) and it€™s obvious that she feels the same way for him (check out that face as he walks onto the bridge at the end). And in the end, that€™s all that really counts in a relationship, isn€™t it? Also, with Star Trek: Into Darkness now at the movies, we€™ll go ahead and call this one ongoing.

1. The Doctor & River Song (Doctor Who)

Over the course of the near fifty years of Doctor Who, the Doctor has had his share of romances. Weird, is what I would describe most of them as, with the exception of Rose Tyler (just thinking about all that brings a slight tear to my eye). By far the most enjoyable of these to watch has been that between the Doctor and his wife, River Song. The twist (that they keep running into each other in reverse) is what makes theirs a truly unique romance for the show. Unique, humorous, and often heartbreaking. The adorable River Song is a joy to watch in her own right. She€™s smart, mysterious, and kicks all kind of tail. But when she€™s with the Doctor, the best is brought out in both of them. She knows him better than he knows himself at times, and their banter back and forth is hilarious (see the episodes The Time of Angels and Flesh and Stone for a prime example). He, in turn, while initially reluctant to acknowledge that she is his future, comes to realize that she truly is the woman he loves. But theirs is not a love without tragedy. The Doctor€™s first time meeting her is the last time for her, and as she explains to Amy Pond, she never knows at what stage in their relationship they€™re in from one meeting to the next, and oftentimes the Doctor knows her less and less. But regardless, whenever they come together, we the audience are in for a treat. How It Ends: Technically, it ended the first time we saw River. But, fortunately for everyone, there€™s plenty of time between what€™s already happened and what€™s yet to come, so odds are we€™ll see much more of River Song before time comes full circle. How€™d we do? Think of any more great (or not so great) sci-fi romances? Let us know in the comments section.