The idea that filmmakers should strive to make their movies timeless may be somewhat passé but remains an appealing notion. Calling a film dated can sometimes be just as damning as calling it awful or unwatchable. But the fact is times change and attitudes change and some films age better than others. Advances in technology are especially inevitable. No matter how well constructed the plot of a film is, technology can theoretically advance to a point that renders certain parts of a film obsolete. Sometimes the entire premise can be undermined if the technological changes are substantial enough. So here are five movies that could not be made today without major alterations to the plot to account for new technologies.
5. Manos: The Hands of Fate
Universally recognized as one of the worst movies ever made, this cinematic train wreck did at least result in a hilarious episode of Mystery Science Theater 3000. A family on a road trip searches for a place to stay called the Valley Lodge. What they find instead is a cult led by the Master and his creepy assistant Torgo. Today. the existence of GPS devices means the family would not have to stop and ask for directions. They would therefore never have become caught up in the cults evil machinations and the film would be even more meaningless than it already is.
4. Time After Time
Jack the Ripper uses H.G. Wells time machine to escape Victorian London and winds up in San Francisco in 1979. Wells follows. Now thats quite a time jump. But forensic science has taken more than a few leaps and bounds of its own in the last thirty years. The final act of the film hinges on the fact that Wells believes his beloved Amy has been murdered by the ripper when her best friend is the real victim. With DNA testing and other modern forensic techniques, its much harder to disguise the identity of a murder victim. Jack the Ripper may have gotten away with his crimes but fortunately science has made it easier to catch the would-be rippers of today.
3. The Wicker Man
When Sgt. Howie makes his fateful trip to the island of Summerisle to search for the missing Rowan Morrison, he has no way of contacting the mainland. This unfortunate fact becomes particularly irritating after his plane is sabotaged. In the modern era, there is no question that he would be able to maintain contact with his fellow officers in case something went wrong. The abysmal Nicolas Cage version makes the excuse that cell phone reception is poor in rural areas but it also put Cage in a bear suit so why should we give it any credit? Theres also the issue of the Child Rescue Alert system now in place throughout the UK. Thanks to that, every concerned citizen would know that young Rowan was missing (even though she really wasnt).
2. Tootsie
Dustin Hoffman is in over his head as a struggling actor forced to dress in drag in order to find work. Once he becomes so popular that his contract with a soap opera is extended for a year, he needs to find a way out. A golden opportunity comes when a crewmember spills a sticky substance on some videotape resulting in a live broadcast of a key scene. He promptly tears off his wig and his career as a woman is over. Now that virtually all TV shows are recorded digitally, there is no need for scenes to be broadcast live. Hoffman could still unmask himself but it would have nowhere near the impact it did in front of a live audience. Plus we wouldnt have gotten the classic Bill Murray line, That is one nutty hospital!
1. The Rocky Horror Picture Show
Its the classic tale of a young couple who need to find a phone because their car has a flat tire. Their search brings them to a castle filled with Transylvanians, only not the kind from eastern Europe. By the end of the night, theyve been transformed into transvestites and have had sex with Tim Curry. Nowadays, Brad Majors (asshole!) could simply whip out his smartphone and call AAA. He and his fiancé Janet Weiss (slut!) wouldnt have to go looking for help and a cult phenomenon would have no reason to exist. It may be the definitive midnight movie but technology-wise, its stuck in a time warp.