7 Actors Who Tried To Be Directors (And Totally Failed)

Some people should really just stay in front of the camera...

By Jack Pooley /

There's so much involved with being a film director that it's no surprise how many films end up being irredeemably awful: even the most talented filmmakers have made their terrible films, and it's safe to say that making a great movie is a combination of skill, luck, and just the right circumstances at the right time. Still, actors are probably better-equipped than any other aspect of the filmmaking process (perhaps with the exception of cinematographers) to transition behind the director's chair, and as such it's no surprise that so many end up giving it a shot. Of course, there are countless cases of tremendous success: Clint Eastwood, George Clooney and Ben Affleck are just three examples of actors who have enjoyed significant plaudits as directors, and in the former and latter cases, arguably more so than in their original occupations. But don't be mistaken: directing a movie is a tough ordeal, and there are many more instances of actors who stepped up to the plate, swung hard and missed spectacularly. These 7 actors, whether acclaimed performers in their own right or more dubious prospects, took their talents behind the camera, and in many cases often wrote and even starred in the movie themselves. The results? In these cases, they were (and in some cases continue to be) complete busts. They tried, but alas, they're better off leaving the heavy lifting to a director who has a stronger handle on the craft. Did we miss any calamitous attempts by actors to become directors? Do you disagree with any of our entries? Let us know in the comments!

7. Steven Seagal

Steven Seagal has never exactly been known for his acting prowess, and throughout the years has mostly been limited to undemanding action vehicles such as the Under Siege series. In 1994, however, the action star directed his own starring project, On Deadly Ground, an environmentally-minded actioner that, despite its noble intent, was a flop with both audiences and critics, failing to make back its budget and earning a distinguished 0% on Rotten Tomatoes. Despite the unanimous pasting the movie received from reviewers, some did at least appreciate Seagal's attempts to tell a more thoughtful, considered story than in most of his movies (the bad guys are an oil company), though its noble intentions were offset by the usual array of inane dialogue and gratuitous explosions. The film was nominated for 6 Razzie awards (including Worst Actor, Picture and Director for Seagal), with the actor-director "winning" Worst Director. Unlike some other entries on this list, at least Seagal had the good sense to leave it to the professionals after this single flop.

6. Johnny Depp

The title of Johnny Depp's single attempt at directing to date, The Brave, could easily be a statement about Depp himself, given the picture's grim subject matter: Depp plays a Native American man struggling to make a life for himself, his wife and their two children. In order to fix his situation, he agrees to be the star of a snuff film in exchange for $50,000, hoping that his sacrifice will buy his family a better life. The movie documents the week leading up to the film shoot. Sadly the movie suffers from glacial pacing which undercuts its rather shocking, visceral appeal. Depp, who co-wrote the movie, overstates any apparent philosophical appeal of his narrative, and the result is a bloated, 2-hour-plus meditation which doesn't really go anywhere, even despite some decent work from Marlon Brando in a brief supporting role. On the plus side, it evidently gave Depp his Jack Sparrow look, so there's that... In terms of follow-ups, Depp reportedly completed a documentary about Rolling Stones guitarist Keith Richards last year, though we're still waiting to see that one materialise...

5. Sally Field

Sally Field is one of the most beloved actresses of her generation, and to an entire younger generation of viewers is probably best known as Momma Gump. However, Field has also directed two movies, a little-known TV movie called The Christmas Tree, and then her only theatrical directorial effort to date, 2000's Beautiful. The movie revolves around a young woman's (Minnie Driver) desperate efforts to win a beauty pageant, but was widely lambasted by critics, earning a mere 16% on Rotten Tomatoes. A common criticism of the movie is Field's inability to stick to a clear tone, as the story tries to be both a frothy satire of pageant culture and a more serious-minded coming of age story. What's more, the commentary about an increasingly superficial society felt dated even in 2000, and Mona is a fickle, difficult character to warm to, as much as Driver tries her hardest to make her likeable. Despite seeming like a good fit for Field's sensibilities, she suggests here that she doesn't have the lightness of touch needed for more sensitive dramatic material. She has yet to direct anything since.

4. Jean-Claude Van Damme

Jean-Claude Van Damme proved in his 2008 movie JCVD to be more perceptive than most of us probably expected, though that doesn't mean he's ever been qualified to direct one of his own movies. Nevertheless, he gave it a shot with 1996's The Quest, a typical martial arts flick which, if Van Damme had paid any attention to his previous movies, he might have actually been able to pull off. Sadly, The Muscles from Brussels' directorial debut suffers from poor camerawork and, strangely enough, a distinct lack of action. There are a few perverse delights, like the opening scenes in which Van Damme is dressed up like a clown, and Roger Moore's completely inexplicable presence, but on the whole, this is one of the actor's lesser martial arts vehicles, lacking in energy and even the basic thrill of some fun fight scenes. It scored 14% on Rotten Tomatoes. As for his second feature, known under the titles Full Love, Soldiers and The Eagle Path, it screened at Cannes 4 years ago, but has yet to be released due to additional shooting in 2012. Not the best of indications that he's improved...

3. Forest Whitaker

Forest Whitaker is one of our finest character actors, and so it wouldn't be much of a surprise if he could pull off a great movie from the director's chair, but sadly not to date. Whitaker has directed 5 movies, the obscure TV movies Strapped and Black Jaq, but more prominently the romantic comedies Waiting to Exhale (52% on RT), Hope Floats (24% on RT) and First Daughter (8% on RT). It's certainly unexpected material for Whitaker to take on, though common criticisms throughout his directing oeuvre include his emotional heavy-handedness and a failure to distinguish himself from similar directors making similar movies. It also appears that of the three major movies Whitaker has directed, each subsequent one has been worse than that which came before. Whitaker hasn't directed a movie since First Daughter was a critical and commercial bomb (despite his previous Hollywood features doing good business), though is rumoured to be taking another stab at it by directing an upcoming adaptation of William Paul Young's novel The Shack, possibly starring Idris Elba. We'll have to wait and see...

2. James Franco

James Franco has proven himself time and time again to be an excellent actor, even earning an Academy Award nomination for his work on 127 Hours. In recent years, he's attempted to stretch himself as an artist, not just by pursuing extensive academic work, but also turning his hand at directing, having over a dozen movies either completed or in post-production to date, all in the span of less than a decade. It's unsurprising, then, that Franco's movies tend to be rough-hewn, specialist art-house-flicks-cum-vanity-projects, and his films that critics have even bothered to review rank as such: The Broken Tower (20%), Sal (43%), Interior. Leather Bar. (55%), As I Lay Dying (42%), and Child of God (46%). The guy even has a movie in his filmography called "Francophrenia". Though Franco's adaptations of works from William Faulkner and Cormac McCarthy are a step in the right direction, he has yet to prove himself to be anything more than an aspiring director who just happens to have the money to blow on indulging his artistic whims, whether they're actually any good or not. With four more of his directorial effects awaiting release this year, he's showing no sign of slowing down, in spite of audience apathy.

1. Dolph Lundgren

Completing the tri-fecta of action stars in our list who tried to make movies, we have in our #1 spot Dolph Lundgren. From 2004-to-2010, the Expendables star directed 6 movies starring himself, with as predictably daft titles as you'd expect: The Defender (which has Jerry Springer playing the President of the United States), The Russian Specialist, Diamond Dogs, Missionary Man, Command Performance (which shows off Lundgren's drumming skills, and also features his young daughter Ida in a role), and The Killing Machine. Unsurprisingly, though reviews are pretty difficult to come across, the films appear to range from mediocre-to-terrible, even if his streak of directing these little-known films suggests that someone does enjoy them, and somehow they do in fact turn a profit. As such, perhaps it's a tad unfair to say that Lundgren failed to be a director, as he did, even if they're all seemingly within a wheelhouse so niche and generic that anyone but the most ardent Lundgren die-hards wouldn't go anywhere near them. He's not exactly pulling a Stallone and directing high-budget studio flicks, and he hasn't made a film in 4 years. One has to wonder why not if this is such a lucrative gravy train for the muscle-bound actor. Did we miss any actors who tried their hand at directing and failed? Let us know in the comments!