8 Reasons Hollywood Will Never Stop Making Sequels
We've hit peak sequel, and it's only going to get worse.
It's Friday, so you want to go to the cinema. What's on at the local multiplex? Oh... a magician sequel, a Tarzan reboot, a movie follow-up to a 90s TV sitcom, an animation plastered with endorsements that it's from the guys who made Minions. You could wait a week and see the Ghostbusters reboot, although people aren't exactly too hot on that. If you don't mind incredibly inconvenient times you may be able to make Nicolas Winding Refn's latest beautiful mess, but for those wanting to get home before midnight there's nothing but franchise films of minimal appeal.
This feeling's hardly new - in 2016 we've very much hit peak sequel. Fourteen of the twenty highest grossing films this year have been sequels, while most of the others are franchise-hopefuls based on existing IPs. It's been this way for a solid decade, and it's only getting more suffocating.
The message is simple: Hollywood just loves its sequels. And while we may get all glass-eyed looking back to an era even twenty years ago when fresh, original ideas could crack into the mainstream and get audience's attention, there's no avoiding that nowadays the franchise reigns king. And, it seems, will forever. Here's eight reasons why the sequel trend isn't going anywhere.
8. For Starters, The Numbers Say It's A Good Idea
Of the ten highest grossing films of each year since 2010 (so a data set of seventy), fifty-one were sequels, five were reboots of existing franchises, six were original animations (half of which were based on pre-existing ideas), three were adaptations of popular works (two books, one video game) and only four were wholly original ideas (two of which came from Christopher Nolan, who is pretty much a brand by himself). Of those latter three categories (which fit the notion of an original movie), six of them either got or are getting sequels, meaning that only seven movies (or 10%) in the Top 10 highest grossing films of each year in the 2010s are non-franchise films.
That's a shocking percentage, and seems to say that audiences actually want sequels and remakes over fresh ideas. So why wouldn't you give them more of that?
Of course, there is the issue of choice; those seven movies are Inception, Inside Out, Gravity, The Martian, Tangled, Interstellar and The Mermaid (the highest grossing Chinese film ever), most of which consistently rank as the most popular of this seventy films. As that's unquantifiable, however, it's not surprising studios listen to the 90%.
7. It Promotes Rewatching
What's the main thing you do before going out to see a new sequel? Why, you rewatch the original. It happens every time - you either missed the film first go around and want to get up to speed or simply need a refresh of where all the characters were when we last saw them. And in doing so you're playing right into the studio's hands.
Even if a sequel performs poorly, it's invariably renewed interest in the original (and if it's worse, then it's paradoxically bolstered its reputation), which is a very good thing for the distributor; the cost of selling the rights to Netflix increase, more people download it or buy it on DVD and it's a talking point probably for the first time since release. For bigger or less recent films, smart studios will even have a special edition released in the weeks leading up to release, which not only serves to promote the sequel, but introduces a further form of revenue.
All of this occurs before the sequel's hit. And even if you don't eventually go check the original out again or see the follow up, it's made an impact and established the series as a mainstay (this worked very well for Fast And Furious in the long term).
6. The "Sequels Are Always Worse" Rule No Longer Holds
There once was a time when the only two great sequels were The Godfather Part II and The Empire Strikes Back. OK, yes, there were always good sequels (Aliens, Mad Max 2, Terminator 2), but I'm talking ones that not only matched the original, but transcended being part of a franchise in a time when being part of a franchise was poison. Back then, sequels tended to be regurgitative and cheap; it's only in the past couple of decades things have really shifted.
The rule that sequels are always worse has been so eroded away by exceptions that it barely holds anymore; pretty much every superhero sequel to a solid first movie (The Dark Knight, Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Spider-Man 2, X-Men 2), follow-ups to animated movies for non-merch-driven series (Toy Story 2, How To Train Your Dragon 2) and even random movies that don't deserve a sequel (I stand by my enjoyment of Magic Mike XXL) can all be great.
Once you have this higher perception, then audiences are going to treat sequels more seriously and be considerably more open to shelling their hard-earned cash on them. Although this then asks the question of why the quality's turned up, which we'll look at next...
5. Much More Money's Invested In Sequels Today (Which Feeds The Whole Thing)
The reason sequels used to be cr*p is because they rarely tried to be anything more. They were quick-and-run attempts to get a little more money from a hit before letting it disappear from public memory. You only need to look at the direct correlation between the drop in budget, quality and audience interest over the likes of Planet Of The Apes and Superman. You had exceptions, like Godfather and Empire, but what was holding them back was the money.
The handful of times a filmmaker convinced a studio to make a sequel with serious backing and vision (see James Cameron) began to show that there was expanded potential here, however, and gradually Hollywood began to push for more. Now series like Planet Of The Apes are treated with real care, with state-of-the-art CGI instead of cheap fancy dress shop masks.
It's a self-fulfilling loop. There's higher investment in sequels, and that's led to a greater care in their production, in turn giving better movies and thus increasing audience expectations, which gives studios a reason to put more into sequels. There's still the same old dreck to sully this, of course, but this has all meant that default expectation of a sequel being sh*t no longer exists.
But why not make original movies with the same care? What makes follow-ups so special? Let's look at that next...
4. In The Mega-Franchise Landscape, Sequels Are More Economical
The big difference between modern sequels and the sequels of decades past is that now franchises are no longer a series of single events linked by characters, but part of a bigger narrative. You obviously have the shared universes of comic book franchises, but this has been a mainstream obsession since the turn of the millennium, when The Lord Of The Rings was produced back-to-back and the ten-years-in-the-making Harry Potter endeavour kicked off.
There's a strong storytelling element to this, of course, but you don't have to look far to see why it's financially beneficial also. So much of the pre-production work (especially on a visual side) can be carried over, as can the specific knowledge of the crew, while casting is a much simpler task if the leads are sorted. In fact, on that casting point, this is where having a multi-picture deal really helps - you can lock talent down for much longer on a set rate (the only problem is when that runs out and the likes of Robert Downey, Jr. demand ridiculous amounts).
So while Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice was one of the highest grossing movies of all time, some of its costs are spent on laying foundation for future projects and thus the whole thing is a lot more stable; once the franchise ball is rolling, it's much easier to go bigger.
Compare this to standalone blockbusters that are vying to become a franchise - they have to hold back because everything needs to be on-screen in this one movie should things not go to plan. Warcraft and Deadpool are two great recent examples, where financial concerns impacted various creative choices, something that is unlikely to be an issue in the sequels.
3. Modern Audiences Stick With What They Know
One thing that stands out from what's been said so far is that even bad sequels that have looked misjudged from conception still make money (some don't, thank goodness, but even "bombs" like Independence Day: Resurgence regularly make their budget back), while a host of original ideas struggle to break through. Why is this? Better the devil you know, of course.
People are much more likely to go see a movie from an IP they're familiar with than chance a cinema ticket on something untested. The sequel may not be better than something original, but you know exactly what you're in for (something that has begun to infect movies in general, with tones and stories that are rigidly laid out in the first ten minutes and not deviated from throughout the runtime); just look at how The Nice Guys struggled at the box office.
The Nice Guys is an original and entertaining film with an intriguing marketing campaign and strong reviews, yet it came behind Angry Birds, Captain America: Civil War (which had already been out a couple of weeks) and Neighbours 2 at the box office on opening weekend. The latter had the biggest audience overlap with Shane Black's detective noir, and that managed to make double (and a similar percentage on lifetime worldwide gross too), something that is predominantly thanks to that massive great "2" in the title.
2. They're A Proven Money-Spinner Because Just Being A Sequel IS A USP
At the end of the day, sequels work. That's why we get them: people will go see them. And even when we get a run of lacklustre follow-ups that fail to set to box office alight - see recent triple-whammy of Alice Through The Looking Glass, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out Of The Shadows and Independence Day: Resurgence - there's always a whole host of successful sequels - Captain America: Civil War, Finding Dory - to show it's something about those particular movies, not the nature of the sequel in general, that's at fault (this is what the stats in the first point really attested to).
Sequels can work. And if something can work it's a safer bet than something that just might work. If you're a movie executive and a producer comes to you with two identical movie pitches, except one is part of a pre-existing series and the other a completely original pitch, they'll go for the former every time (this can be extrapolated for adaptations of books, games, TV shows et al), because it's proven to make money. The selling point is that it's a sequel.
Even big budget movies that are "original" come with a hook like that, usually a named actor or director; of those seven non-franchise movies from recent years, only two aren't part of a pre-existing brand. And that's because brand is the word of the day...
1. It's Really All About Branding
If you think Disney shelled out $4.05 billion on Lucasfilm just so they could make a new Star Wars trilogy, then you're more oblivious than the people who didn't realise Palpatine was Emperor Palptaine. Star Wars: The Force Awakens made $2 billion worldwide, but that's just part of the massive multimedia blitz that they restarted in 2012 and shows no signs of abating - through books, games, merchandising, tie-in deals and other money-making schemes (they're doing a freaking theme park), the money from straight ticket sales is just part of something much bigger.
Star Wars has, of course, been around for almost forty years and is a well-established brand, but that's exactly what studios want; to turn their big names into cross-promotional properties. But while you can have toys and TV shows made about anything if you can put up the money, the real power of a series is new cinema releases, where you can get it in the mainstream eye (this is also why we're seeing non-cinema brands like Angry Birds, Lego and Emojis become movies - it's all about extension). Heck, Ubisoft have just admitted that's their exact plan with Assassin's Creed.
Many are being a bit too brazen about this, talking about trilogies before the first movie's out, seeding a long list of spin-offs in movie number two and treating a franchise like it's iconic well before it's cracked the cultural psyche, but what they're going for is the same thing Star Wars and its ilk has.
And if Disney will never stop making Star Wars, then what else can the rest of Hollywood do?
What're your thoughts on the current sequel epidemic? Share your take down in the comments.