9 More Actors Who Just Gave Their Worst Performance Ever

2023 was a stellar year for bad performances, but these actors really gave it their worst.

By Alisdair Hodgson /

Looking back over 2023, we have been blessed by surprisingly few out-and-out big-screen hits compared with previous years. Oppenheimer gave moviegoers something to cheer about, but it's hard to imagine anybody will be talking about Expend4bles, Napoleon, Hypnotic or You People in the decades to come.

Advertisement

There are a multitude of reasons as to why those films underwhelmed, but one that they all had in common is that they each featured at least one career-worst performance.

No matter what way the Hollywood winds have blown, big and small hitters from across the A-list have, of late, delivered some listless performances. Granted, it's not always the actor's fault, with tragic technical work, Swiss cheese plots, and dialogue only Tommy Wiseau would sign off on all having a hand in constructing an unsalvageable role. Not that that excuse applies to every lowlight on this list, however, with some actors making an unfortunate habit of bad portrayals across multiple films.

Whatever the cause, no matter the symptom, even the more decent films didn't stand a chance with these actors putting in their worst performances.

9. Chris Evans - Ghosted

Chris Evans and Ana de Armas first set our screens on fire in Rian Johnson's mystery movie Knives Out, despite the fact they were playing enemies. This was followed up by a similarly antagonistic setup in the Russo Brothers' actioner The Gray Man, which, although not an out-and-out success, still showed the pair made good big-screen companions. Therefore, it made sense that producers wanted to get them back together in a more cooperative role.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the film that united them for the third time was the secret agent action-comedy, Ghosted. Failing on both the action and comedy fronts, the film suffers from not really knowing what it is and where it belongs - and this extends to the cast. De Armas is bad, the usually reliable Evans is worse, and the pair don't have enough chemistry to strike a spark, never mind set fires.

Now, much of the blame here can be placed on the script and overall direction of Ghosted, but the rest is on the performances. No two ways about it, Evans is the worst thing about this dull disaster. He falls flat on the banter, and doesn't sell even a moment of the supposedly budding relationship with his co-star. Definitely an all-time worst for the man who led Captain America and Snowpiercer.

8. Brie Larson - The Marvels

When Brie Larson appears in a picture these days, she sometimes has a hard time committing to the bit.

Advertisement

So goes her latest appearance in the MCU, leading the three-hander, miniature ensemble piece The Marvels as alien-superhuman hybrid Carol Danvers/Captain Marvel. It's no small secret that the film has had the worst commercial performance of pretty much any major Marvel movie to date, especially given it cost $275 million to make.

Her performance may not just be her worst in the MCU, but her worst of all. While it wouldn't be fair to say Larson sank the film on her own, she didn't exactly help it float.

All in all, this tepid offering makes it difficult not to yearn for the days when Larson played her full range in supporting roles and retained her edge as something of a cool outsider, a la Scott Pilgrim's Envy Adams. What we really need is for the actor to break free of the MCU and deliver smaller-scale yet more adventurous performances again after being on a pretty lethargic run for some years now.

7. William Fichtner - Hypnotic

Once a director you could comfortably mention in the same breath as Quentin Tarantino, Robert Rodriguez has spent the bulk of his career since the '90s creating a pretty uneven filmography, with highs in Once upon a Time in Mexico and lows in Sin City: A Dame to Kill For.

Advertisement

His recent effort Hypnotic sadly falls into the latter bracket, taking us into a sub-Matrix world where illusion and VR reign supreme. Despite having Ben Affleck in the lead role (who can, if nothing else, definitely put in a performance and pull serious numbers), the film is uninspired, confused, derivative and, well, just really dull.

William Fichter stars opposite the ex-Bat as Dellrayne, a gifted "Hypnotic" who knocks over banks, takes no prisoners, and has something to do with the disappearance of Detective Danny Rourke's (Affleck) son. Fichter is an old hand at this kind of role, but that is precisely what's wrong. He spends the film sleepwalking through a part he's played a hundred times before - but it's not all on him. The script is thin, the dialogue stiff, and every actor on screen suffers as a result.

6. Amy Adams - Disenchanted

Of all the sequels the world didn't need, Disenchanted is definitely up there. Following up Kevin Lima's 2007 fairytale fantasy Enchanted, where the young, animated Giselle (Amy Adams) is blasted into the real world (in a real body) by a piece of sinister magic, and must find her way home before she's trapped there forever. Naturally, she found her handsome prince in the form of divorce attorney Robert Philip (Patrick Dempsey) and opted to stay, signing off with a happily ever after...

Advertisement

Well, almost. Disney has never been afraid of resurrecting an old property to profit off the back of the accompanying name and brand recognition, and so the house of mouse dug up the bones of this moderate success story to put together a jangly sequel it could release straight to streaming: Disenchanted.

The sparkle of the first film is gone, along with its originality, and, though Adams returned (for an as-yet undisclosed sum), Disenchanted finds her at a career low. Almost totally at odds with the role that she's playing, her performance feels weighed down by something, as if she herself has lost the magic. But don't say the title didn't warn you!

5. Phoebe Waller-Bridge - Indiana Jones And The Dial Of Destiny

Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny had fans of the eighties adventurer raring to go, hoping that this - likely Harrison Ford's last outing in the role - would redeem the middling Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, and go out on a high.

Advertisement

While not the worst thing ever, James Mangold's entry into the series doesn't offer a whole lot to get excited about. All the hallmarks are there - the hat, the whip, the Nazis, the dry humour - but none of it feels fresh or essential. Least essential of all, though, is Phoebe Waller-Bridge's Helena Shaw, Indy's goddaughter and a slippery grifter to the core, more interested in getting her own way than sincerely engaging with the history old Dr Jones is interested in.

Having already succeeded on stage and television to a significant degree, a career low for Waller-Bridge isn't as damning as it sounds. Nevertheless, she brings a deep smugness to a two-point-five dimensional part in the Dial of Destiny that only serves to highlight the inadequacies in the plot and character motivations.

No doubt designed to remind us of the savvy and street-smart Marion (Karen Allen) from Indy's first adventure, Waller-Bridge's delivery is instead smarmy to a fault.

4. Shawnee Smith - Saw X

Despite Saw's self-proclaimed Final Chapter coming around in 2010, the splatter franchise has lived on in various spin-offs and prequels since. While the quality of the films has varied wildly, Tobin Bell has been the one stalwart presence, marshaling the role in Saw X - the latest and potentially final installment involving Jigsaw Killer John Kramer - with a gravitas hitherto unseen in the franchise.

Advertisement

His castmate, Shawnee Smith, didn't come quite as prepared. Returning as Jigsaw's protégé Amanda, Smith cleaved away the more tender and conflicted aspects of Amanda's personality, and switched the hysteria up to full gear. This gives Amanda a kind of raw thirst for blood and punishment in Saw X that she rarely if ever openly displayed in the original films.

Perhaps the full blame can't be laid on Smith's shoulders, however, as almost everything about Saw X was constructed to give long-time fans the servicing the studio clearly thinks they needed, only leaving room for Kramer to have any character development. And the less said about that preposterous wig the better.

3. David Duchovny - You People

With the weight of the world's money behind it, Netflix has presided over a raft of sensational films over the past decade, but it has also introduced us to some absolute shockers.

Advertisement

Despite having Jonah Hill and Eddie Murphy on board, You People is of the latter category. The basic premise is geeky white Jewish guy (Hill) falls in love with a hip black woman and the ensuing cultural clash that occurs via her overbearing father (Murphy). Somehow director Kenya Barris manages to bungle this premise and everyone comes out of it worse for wear, with You People's depiction of Jewish characters coming in for heavy criticism following its release.

Murphy and Hill have had plenty of career duds to rival this, but the film's stand-out bad performance is David Duchovny, simply because it's the worst he's turned in yet. The usually humorous and charismatic actor struggles with a straightforward embarrassing dad part, supposedly representing white, Boomer Judaism in a way that never lands.

Again, as is so often the case, the weakness of the dialogue and script in general do a lot of harm here, but an old hand like Duchovny would have been able to work through it better than this.

2. Ashton Kutcher - Your Place Or Mine

From one Netflix disaster to another, Your Place or Mine is another entry in the canon of the middling-to-awful romcoms the streamer churns out on a regular basis. Except, this time, instead of hiring the next up-and-coming nobody to flounder in the surf, they got noughties rom-com darlings Ashton Kutcher and Reese Witherspoon.

Advertisement

The pair play Peter and Debbie, best friends who swap houses for a week, discovering in the process that the lives they think they want may not be what's best for them - and that each other might be the answer.

Like Sleepless in Seattle and You've Got Mail before, the film keeps its romantic leads apart for as long as possible. But, while this worked with Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan, who seem if not made for each other at least comfortable in each other's presence, it doesn't for Kutcher and Witherspoon. Their long-distance interactions and screentime together speak not of two friends of 20 years, but of an awkward couple who have been forced together for someone else's amusement (ours).

This is Kutcher's fault more than anything, as he didn't really turn up for the role, sleepwalking through his scenes, soft-serving the emotional moments, and cruising towards the easy payday at the end of it all. Given he starred in films like Dude, Where's My Car?, he should be embarrassed that this is his worst.

1. Megan Fox - The Expendables 4

With nearly a decade since the previous instalment in Sylvester Stallone's all-action, guns-n-muscles film series, it was high time for another Expendables. The world, and filmmaking, have moved on since 2014, and there was a real opportunity to comment on this, lampooning the eighties action hero in a new light while bringing on some young stars of today and tomorrow.

Advertisement

But, no. Stallone instead brought together the remaining fragments of the old team (or, basically, anyone he could get to still run around dodging bullets and explosions), a host of new martial arts-star villains, and Fifty Cent, Andy Garcia and... Megan Fox.

Inhabiting a similar, yet more physically involved role to the one Charisma Carpenter had in the first couple of films, Fox is Lee Christmas' (Statham) on-again, off-again girlfriend and new leader of the Expendables team. Not known for either her acting or action chops, the decision to bring Fox on board jars with the premise of the series - to bring together action legends in one film.

Delivering lines throughout as if she's reading them for the very first time, the ex-Transformers star stuck out as hammy and unconvincing in a film series that is supposed to thrive on being hammy and unconvincing. The plot and dialogue aren't exactly up to scratch, but she brings the film - and, by extension, the series - to new, perhaps unrecoverable lows.

Advertisement