Alien: Covenant - 10 Theories That Were Utter Bull
A+ for creativity...
There have been few movies this year as talked about and feverishly dissected as the highly-anticipated Alien: Covenant, with the rumours and fan theories only becoming more elaborate and fascinating as its release drew ever closer.
While it's fair to say that these ten theories ranged from utterly bonkers to almost uncomfortably plausible, they all in fact turned out to miss the mark, to some ends disappointing fans and to others giving them a great feeling of relief.
Of course, with the benefit of hindsight, it's easy to differentiate the wishful fanboy conjecture from those ideas that actually would've worked, but before release, anything seemed possible.
There's no rest for fans, though, because the fan speculation has already begun for the next entry into the franchise, Alien: Awakening...
10. Shaw Is The Proto-Xenomorph
The Theory: The movie's original black xenomorph, aka the protomorph, is in fact a mutation of Elizabeth Shaw, who is experimented upon by David and eventually transformed into the alien creature with the help of the mysterious black goo.
The Truth: Shaw is actually killed by David at some point after their arrival on the Engineer planet, likely as a result of his experiments to create the "perfect organism", but no, she is absolutely not turned into the protomorph.
The protomorph at the end of the movie is in fact spawned from Captain Oram, when David tricks him into interacting with an alien egg and subsequently gets impregnated by a facehugger.
9. James Franco Is Infected At The Start Of The Movie
The Theory: After the Last Supper prologue showed James Franco's Captain Branson going to bed because he was "burning up", it turns out that he has somehow become infected with an alien embryo prior to the start of the journey to the Engineers' homeworld.
The Truth: Surprisingly, Franco actually has more screen time in the prologue than he does in the final movie, his cryo-pod catching fire at the very beginning and burning him to death while he sleeps.
He isn't infected in any way, though, and his implied illness was nothing more than a red herring, though the "burning up" foreshadowing is pretty hilarious in retrospect.
8. Walter Gives Birth To An Android-Alien Hybrid
The Theory: Somehow, David finds a way to impregnate the Covenant's android, Walter, with a protomorph embryo, giving birth to the first ever android-alien hybrid.
The Truth: The movie thankfully doesn't even begin to tackle ideas like this, considering how much it already has to juggle. Instead, David presumably destroys Walter and steals his identity to escape the Engineer planet with Daniels and Tennessee.
It's probably just as well, because it's well-established that the protomorph embryo needs a human host in order to flourish, so explaining how it can thrive inside an android would likely require an incredibly convoluted explanation and risk further angering fans.
7. It Sets Up An Alien-Predator Universe
The Theory: There will be a nod of some kind to Shane Black's upcoming The Predator movie, be it a direct, in-film reference or a more delineated post-credits scene.
The Truth: Aside from the fact that the neomorph aliens make a sound not too dissimilar from the Predator's iconic click vocalisation, there are zero apparent nods to the creature throughout the film.
In honesty, this is actually pretty surprising, considering that both properties are owned by Fox and it would've been incredibly easy to include a playful tip of the hat here.
Then again, perhaps Scott vetoed the idea out of the gate, considering his well-known disdain for the widely-maligned Alien vs. Predator movies.
6. The Engineers' Creator Is Revealed
The Theory: Despite Prometheus implying that the Engineers seeded the human race on Earth, it will in fact be revealed that the Engineers are actually a servant race for another higher power who was truly responsible for humanity's existence.
The Truth: Though Prometheus suggested the next movie would delve deeper into the Engineers' mythology and likely explain why they hated humanity so much, they're largely sidelined in Covenant, and any wider questions about the Engineers' own creation aren't touched on at all.
Hopefully the next movie may return to this question, because it felt like a waste to cast the Engineers aside so blatantly here after Prometheus invested so much in them.
5. Meredith Vickers Returns As An Android
The Theory: Charlize Theron's presumed-dead Weyland Corp rep will return in android form to p*** off the Covenant's crew with her hyper-bureaucratic ways.
The Truth: This was always a dubious rumour that felt more like a wishful fan theory than anything else, and thankfully Vickers gets nowhere near the movie, as great an actress as Theron is.
The closest thing we get is a cameo from her father, Peter Weyland, who appears in flashback form in his younger days, having just created David.
The film does nothing to further the "Vickers is an android" theory. She's dead and that's that.
4. The Trailers Only Showed The First Act
The Theory: The trailers have only shown footage from the movie's first 40 minutes, and the main bulk of the narrative actually follows David and Elizabeth Shaw's investigation of the Engineers' homeworld.
The Truth: The trailers unfortunately went pretty much the opposite way and gave most of the movie away for free, bar some of David's crucial exposition in the middle of the movie and that twist ending.
Basically, the fates of the main Covenant crew and the nature of the final battle were all abundantly clear from trailers released several months ago, likely due to Fox wanting to emphasise the presence of an alien resembling the classic xenomorph after Prometheus let a lot of fans down in that department.
3. The Protomorph Fights The Neomorphs
The Theory: Just when it looks like the neomorphs are going to dismantle the Covenant's surviving crew members in the third act, the protomorph shows up and promptly tears its "lesser" brethren to shreds...before turning its attention to the humans, of course.
The Truth: As incredible as this would've been, sadly the neomorphs are conveniently sidelined pretty quickly and pretty much forgotten about once the protomorph hatches.
It would've been an awesome way to show the "perfect organism" asserting itself over a more crude, basic iteration, and making its presence feel even more threatening, so Scott and co. really missed a trick here.
2. Daniels Is Ripley's Mother
The Theory: Daniels is revealed to be the mother of the series' much-loved original protagonist, Ellen Ripley.
The Truth: This was reported by numerous outlets in the months heading up to the film's release and sounded cynical enough to be believable, but it was a pleasant surprise that Daniels in fact turned out to be a standalone character with no link to Ripley or any other existing Alien character.
Giving her a half-baked relation to Ripley would've felt forced and on-the-nose, not to mention a lazy, desperate attempt to make the character feel more relevant.
Few are going to come away from Covenant thinking of Daniels as a classic sci-fi heroine, but at least she's able to do her own thing without being needlessly tethered to the series' iconic protagonist.
1. Shaw Ordered David To Attack The Engineers' Homeworld
The Theory: With the movie's The Crossing prologue showing David preparing to drop a payload of black goo ampules on the Engineer homeworld, it in fact turns out that Elizabeth Shaw was the mastermind behind it, ordering David to launch the strike in revenge for the black goo killing her lover Holloway and the rest of the Prometheus' crew.
The Truth: It's a mildly amusing idea, but not really in step with Shaw's mindset at the end of Prometheus. She wasn't seething with rage over Holloway's demise, but wanted to visit the Engineer planet because of her prevailing curiosity about their desire to wipe humanity out. She wanted to talk to them, not kill them.
Plus, the prologue made it pretty clear that David was acting off his own back when he prepared the black goo payload, as Shaw had been in cryo-sleep the whole time.
How many of these Alien: Covenant fan theories did you believe? Shout them out in the comments!